Thursday, December 17, 2009

Howard Dean Locks Horns with White House and Dem Senators After Call to 'Kill' Health Compromise

By David Edwards and Daniel Tencer, Raw Story. Posted December 17, 2009.

Dean's call to start from scratch and craft a new health care bill is a cause for frustration for Obama's press secretary and Sen. Rockefeller.

In Special Coverage

Hot, Steamy Mormons: Are the Latter Day Saints Getting Sexy?
Liz Langley

Corporate Accountability and WorkPlace:
Why Shouldn't Paris Hilton Pay Her Fair Share?
Brian Miller

Congress Gets Its Act Together: Repeals Ban on Syringe Exchange Funding, Allows D.C. to Enact Medical Marijuana Program
Bill Piper, Naomi Long

Copenhagen Is Not Just About Climate Change -- It's About the What Kind of People We Want to Be
George Monbiot

Does Aspartame Cause Tumors and Pose Cancer Risks? The Jury Is Still Out
Scott Thill

Health and Wellness:
Howard Dean Locks Horns with White House and Dem Senators After Call to 'Kill' Health Compromise
David Edwards, Daniel Tencer

Businesses and Unions Face the Guest Worker Dilemma
Maribel Hastings

Media and Technology:
Everything You Think About Tiger Woods is Wrong, So Shut the F*** Up!
Michael Bader

Movie Mix:
Matt Damon and Morgan Freeman's Invictus Film Release Kicks Off New Campaign For Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Linda Milazzo

Howard Dean: I Won’t "Vigorously" Support Obama's Re-election
Sahil Kapur

Reproductive Justice and Gender:
Can Boob Jobs Serve the Public Good?
Alexandra Suich

Rights and Liberties:
Politicians Are Portraying 'Gitmo North' as a Terrific Local Jobs Program -- Don't Count On It
Liliana Segura

Sex and Relationships:
Guess What? Casual Sex Won't Make You Go Insane
Ellen Friedrichs

Take Action:
G-20 Meetings: Nothing Much Happened in the Suites, and There Was Too Much Punch in the Streets
Laura Flanders

Al Gore: A Billion People's Water at Risk From Melting Ice

The 9 Surges of Obama's War
Tom Engelhardt

More stories by David Edwards Daniel Tencer

White House press secretary Robert Gibbs on Wednesday became the latest Democrat to offer a sharp rebuttal to Howard Dean over the former Vermont governor's call to "kill" the Senate health care bill now that the bill includes neither a public option nor a Medicare buy-in option.

"I would ask Dr. Dean, how better do you address those who don't have insurance: passing a bill that will cover 30 million who don't currently have it or killing the bill?" Gibbs said, as quoted by Sam Stein at the Huffington Post. "I don't think any rational person would say killing the bill makes a whole lot of sense at this point."

In a sign of a rift within the Democratic Party over the removal of all public health care options from the Senate reform bill, Sen. Jay Rockefeller strongly criticized former Vermont Gov. Howard Dean's call for the bill to be voted down.

"It's nonsense," Rockefeller, Democrat of West Virginia, said of Dean's call to "kill the Senate bill." Added Rockefeller: "It's irresponsible, and coming from him as a physician, it's stunning, and he's wrong."

Rockefeller told MSNBC's Andrea Mitchell on Wednesday that there are still many useful measures in the Senate health care bill that are worth passing. Rockefeller noted that the bill mandated a "medical loss ratio" for health insurers of 85 percent to 90 percent, meaning that insurers would be required to spend that percentage of their revenue on providing health care.

Rockefeller said the bill would extend children's health benefits for 14.1 million children whose benefits were set to expire, and noted the number of children covered under the benefits would be expanded, but did not say how many more children would qualify for the benefits.

The senator from West Virginia noted that he had been a supporter of the public option and Medicare buy-in, "but [we] were shot down, so what do I do? Do I take my football and run home and sulk? ... No, I look at the entire bill and I say, 'What is in the interest of the people of my state and the people of America?' and then I vote. In my case I'm going to vote yes."

Dean, who worked as a physician before his stints as governor of Vermont and then chair of the Democratic National Committee, said earlier this week that the removal of the Medicare buy-in provision represented "the end of health care reform in the United States Senate." He suggested that Democrats should start from scratch and craft a new bill.

While many progressive supporters were alarmed by the announcement earlier this month that the government-run public option would be ditched in the Senate bill in favor of a Medicare buy-in option for people aged 55 to 64, Dean came out in favor of the proposal.

That helped to solidify progressives' support for the idea. And it may have also helped convince Sen. Lieberman to come out against the idea, despite having voiced backing for a Medicare buy-in as recently as three months ago. Some supporters of health care reform have criticized Lieberman's decision to oppose the buy-in because it had the support of progressives as "deeply immoral."

Digg! Share on facebook submit to reddit Bookmark on Delicious Stumble This TweetThis

See more stories tagged with: obama, health care, white house, howard dean, rockefeller

No comments: