Sunday, January 01, 2006

NSA to spy on UN diplomats in New York before the invasion of Iraq.



27 December 2005 -- In early March 2003, journalists at the London-based Observer reported that the National Security Agency (NSA) was secretly participating in the US government's high-pressure campaign for the UN Security Council to approve a pro-war resolution. A few days after the Observer revealed the text of an NSA memo about US spying on Security Council delegations, I asked Daniel Ellsberg to assess the importance of the story. "This leak," he replied, "is more timely and potentially more important than the Pentagon Papers." The key word was "timely."

The US government developed an "aggressive surveillance operation, which involves interception of the home and office telephones and the e-mails of UN delegates." The smoking gun was "a memorandum written by a top official at the NSA and circulated to both senior agents in his organization and to a friendly foreign intelligence agency." The friendly agency was Britain's Government Communications Headquarters.

This fact was exposed nearly three years ago. Back then, after news of the NSA's targeted spying at the United Nations broke in the British press, major US mainstream media outlets gave it only perfunctory coverage - or, in the case of the New York Times, no coverage at all. The New York Times opted not to cover the story at all. From Russia to France to Chile to Japan to Australia, the story was big mainstream news. But not in the United States.

The Observer explained: "The leaked memorandum makes clear that the target of the heightened surveillance efforts are the delegations from Angola, Cameroon, Chile, Mexico, Guinea and Pakistan at the UN headquarters in New York - the so-called 'Middle Six' delegations whose votes are being fought over by the pro-war party, led by the US and Britain, and the party arguing for more time for UN inspections, led by France, China and Russia."

The NSA memo, dated Jan. 31, 2003, outlined the wide scope of the surveillance activities, seeking any information useful to push a war resolution through the Security Council - "the whole gamut of information that could give US policymakers an edge in obtaining results favorable to US goals or to head off surprises."

But within days, any doubt about the NSA memo's "authenticity" was gone. The British press reported that the UK government had arrested an unnamed female employee at a British intelligence agency in connection with the leak. Facing the possibility of a prison sentence, Katharine Gun said that disclosure of the NSA memo was "necessary to prevent an illegal war in which thousands of Iraqi civilians and British soldiers would be killed or maimed." She said: "I have only ever followed my conscience."

After 51 weeks she leaked the memo, British prosecutors dropped charges against whistleblower Katharine Gun,

---

Patrick Radden Keefe in the online magazine Slate, pointedly noted that "the eavesdropping took place in Manhattan and violated the General Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations, the Headquarters Agreement for the United Nations, and the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, all of which the United States has signed."

http://www.truthout.org/docs_2005/122705Y.shtml

It is worth remembering that an abuse of power similar to Bush's NSA wiretapping decision was part of the impeachment charge brought against Richard Nixon in 1974. [This comparison was brought home in the ACLU's powerful full page ad in the NYT of December 22nd.]

Impeachment Bush?

Representatives Johns Conyers and John Lewis and Senator Barbara Boxer are talking, in public, about impeachment now.

  • Former Nixon White House counsel John Dean argued in his aptly-named book Worse than Watergate that Bush's false statements about WMDs in Iraq-used to drum up support for an invasion-deceived the American people and Congress. This constituted "an impeachable offense," Dean told PBS' Bill Moyers in 2004. "I think the case is overwhelming that these people presented false information to the Congress and to the American people." Bush's actions were actually far worse than Watergate, Dean contends, because "no one died for Nixon's so-called Watergate abuses."

    Lending credence to Dean's arguments, the Downing Street Memo revealed that Britain's MI-6 Director Richard Dearlove had told Tony Blair that "the intelligence and facts were being fixed around the policy" by the Bush Administration. John Bonifaz, a Boston-based attorney and constitutional law expert, said that Bush seemingly "concealed important intelligence which he ought to have communicated," and "must certainly be punished for giving false information to the Senate." Bush deceived "the American people as to the basis for taking the nation into war against Iraq," Bonifaz argued-an impeachable offense.

  • By November (2005), a Zogby International poll showed that 53 percent Americans favored impeaching Bush -if it was in fact proven that Bush had lied about the basis for invading Iraq. In the last months, several organizations, including AfterDowningStreet, Impeach Central and ImpeachPAC.org, have formed to urge Bush's impeachment.

  • Rep. John Conyers argued as well that the president committed impeachable offenses" because he and senior administration officials "countenanced torture and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment in Iraq" at Abu Ghraib, and elsewhere, including Guantanamo Bay and the now-notorious "black sites" around the world.

  • The most compelling evidence of Bush's high crimes and misdemeanors is the revelation that he repeatedly authorized NSA spying on US citizens without obtaining the required warrants from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance court. Constitutional experts, politicians and ex-intelligence experts agree that Bush "committed a federal crime by wiretapping Americans." Rep. John Lewis-"the first major House figure to suggest impeaching Bush," said the AP-argued that the president "deliberately, systematically violated the law" in authorizing the wiretapping. Lewis added: "He is not King, he is president."

For anyone with understanding and respect for the Constitution, it is obvious that Bush has violated the Fourth Amendment and federal law. This is the definition of "high crimes and misdemeanors". Clinton lying about sex is nothing compared to this. It is timely and responsible to talk about impeachment. If the Republicans were loyal to the Constitution, they would be discussing impeachment. Bush has declared himself king in an undeclared war. We don't allow kings in this country. The Founding Fathers came here to avoid that.

http://www.truthout.org/docs_2005/122705Q.shtml

25 Reasons to Impeach George W. Bush -- June 6, 2005

http://www.counterpunch.org/corseri06062005.html

Lying to the Sovereign

http://www.thefourreasons.org/

Food crisis feared as fertile land runs out

· Maps show 40% of Earth's land is used for agriculture
· Growing human 'footprint' a risk to the environment

December 6, 2005 -- "The maps show, very strikingly, that a large part of our planet (roughly 40%) is being used for either growing crops or grazing cattle," said Dr Navin Ramankutty, a member of the Wisconsin-Madison team. By comparison, only 7% of the world's land was being used for agriculture in 1700.

The Amazon basin has seen some of the greatest changes in recent times, with huge swaths of the rainforest being felled to grow soya beans.

"One of the major changes we see is the fast expansion of soybeans in Brazil and Argentina, grown for export to China and the EU," said Dr Ramankutty.

This agricultural expansion has come at the expense of tropical forests in both countries.

Meanwhile, intensive farming practices mean that cropland areas have decreased slightly in the US and Europe and the land is being gobbled up by urbanisation.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/food/Story/0,,1659112,00.html

Contrast this growing reality of what FTW has previously reported in stories articles like "Eating Fossil Fuels" with the hucksterism being offered by advocates of ethanol and the use of non-edible plant waste to make fuels. All plant material that is not eaten must be returned to the soil to enrich it. Every bit of plant material comprises nutrients taken from the soil. Not replacing that energy only exacerbates the damage being done to rapidly eroding topsoil which we described two years ago as "little more than a sponge onto which we pour chemicals derived from oil and gas." Unless some kind of intelligent debate is engaged, the crisis which is just beginning will be what fundamentalist Christians are praying for, The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse". It does not have to be that way, or that bad. – Michael Ruppert

http://www.fromthewilderness.com/index.html

The War in Iraq Costs

See this link for up to the minute cost total: $228,764,963,195 and growing

http://nationalpriorities.org/index.php?option=com_wrapper&Itemid=182

DU Gulf Era Veterans now on medical disability, since 1991, number 518,739 Veterans

"The real reason for Veterans Affairs Secretary Anthony Principi's departure was really never given, however a special report published by eminent scientist Leuren Moret naming depleted uranium as the definitive cause of the `Gulf War Syndrome' has fed a growing scandal about the continued use of uranium munitions by the US Military."

Comment: Sounds to mw like AWOL Bush fired Principi.

"This malady (from uranium munitions), that thousands of our military have suffered and died from, has finally been identified as the cause of this sickness, eliminating the guessing. The terrible truth is now being revealed."

He added, "Out of the 580,400 soldiers who served in GW1 (the first Gulf War), of them, 11,000 are now dead! By the year 2000, there were 325,000 on Permanent Medical Disability. This astounding number of `Disabled Vets' means that a decade later, 56% of those soldiers who served have some form of permanent medical problems!" The disability rate for the wars of the last century was 5 percent; it was higher, 10 percent, in Viet Nam.

"The VA Secretary Principi was aware of this fact as far back as 2000." "He, and the Bush administration have been hiding these facts.

http://www.fromthewilderness.com/free/ww3/122005_world_stories.shtml#0

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit for research and educational purposes. MY NEWSLETTER has no affiliation whatsoever with the originator of this article nor is MY NEWSLETTER endorsed or sponsored by the originator.)

War as Spoliation


by Frederic Bastiat

[Posted on Wednesday, December 28, 2005]
To receive the Daily Article in your inbox, go to email services, and tell others too!

[Harmonies of Political Economy, Translated from the 3rd edition of the French by P.J. Stirling, 2nd edition, 1850, London: Simpkin, Marshall, and Co., pp. 458-464. This essay by the great French economist Bastiat is reprinted as a reminder of the dangers to all sides of using military force as a means of securing resources or to bring freedom to foreign peoples.]

A man (and the same thing may be said of a people) may pro­cure the means of existence in two ways,—by creating them, or by stealing them.

Each of these two great sources of acquisition presents a variety of methods.

We may create the means of existence by the chase, by fishing, by agriculture, etc.

We may steal them by breach of trust, by violence, by force, fraud, war, etc.

If, confining ourselves to the circle of one or other of these two categories, we find that the predominance of one of these methods establishes so marked a difference in the character of nations, how much greater must the difference be between a nation which lives by production, and a nation which lives by spoliation?

For it is not one of our faculties only, but all of them, which the necessity of providing for our subsistence brings into exer­cise; and what can be more fitted to modify the social con­dition of nations than what thus modifies all the human facul­ties?

This consideration, important as it is, has been so little regarded, that I must dwell upon it for an instant.

The realization of an enjoyment or satisfaction presupposes labour; whence it follows that spoliation, far from excluding pro­duction, presupposes it and takes it for granted.

This consideration, it seems to me, ought to modify par­tiality which historians, poets, and novel-writers have displayed for those heroic epochs which were not distinguished by what they sneer at under the epithet of industrialism. In these days, as in our own, men lived, subsisted; and labour must have done its office then as now. Only there was this difference, that nations, classes, and individuals succeeded in laying their share of the labour and toil on the shoulders of other nations, other classes, and other in­dividuals.

The characteristic of production is to bring out of nothing, if I may so speak, the satisfactions and enjoyments which sustain and embellish life; so that a man, or a nation, may multiply ad infini­tum these enjoyments, without inflicting privation on any other man, or any other nation. So much is this the case, that a pro­found study of the economic mechanism shows us that the success of one man’s labour opens up a field for the success of another’s exertions.

The characteristic of spoliation, on the contrary, is this, that it cannot confer a satisfaction on one without inflicting a correspond­ing privation on another; for spoliation creates nothing, but dis­places what labour has created. It entails an absolute loss of the exertions of both parties. So far, then, from adding to the enjoy­ments of mankind, it diminishes these enjoyments, and confers them, moreover, on those who have not merited them.

In order to produce, man must direct all his powers and faculties to obtain the mastery over natural laws ; for it is by this means that he accomplishes his object. Hence, iron converted into a ploughshare is the emblem of production.

To steal, on the other hand, man must direct all his powers and faculties to obtain the mastery over his fellow-man; for it is by this means that he attains his end. Hence, iron converted into a sword is the emblem of spoliation.

Between the ploughshare, which brings plenty, and the sword, which brings destruction and death, there is no greater difference than between a nation of industrious workmen and a nation of spoliators. They have, and can have, nothing whatever in com­mon. They have neither the same ideas, nor the same rules of appreciation, nor the same tastes, manners, character, laws, morals, or religion.

No more melancholy spectacle can present itself to the eye of philanthropy than to see an industrial age putting forth all its efforts, in the way of education, to get inoculated with the ideas, the sentiments, the errors, the prejudices, the vices, of an era of spoliation. Our own era is frequently accused of wanting consis­tency, of displaying little accordance between the judgments that are formed and the conduct that is pursued; and I believe that this arises principally from the cause which I have just pointed out.

Spoliation, in the shape of War—that is to say, pure, simple, barefaced spoliation—has its root deep in the human heart, in the organization of man, in the universal motives which actuate the social world, namely, desire of happiness and repugnance to pain,

—in short, in that principle of our nature called self-interest.

I am not sorry to find myself arraigning that principle, for I have been accused of devoting to it an idolatrous worship, of re­presenting its effects as productive only of happiness to mankind, and even of elevating it above the principle of sympathy, of dis­interestedness, and of self-sacrifice. In truth, I have not so esteemed it; I have only proved beyond the possibility of doubt its existence and its omnipotence. I should ill appreciate that omnipotence, and I should do violence to my own convictions, in representing personal interest as the universal actuating motive of the human race, did I fail now to point out the disturbing causes to which it gives rise, just as I formerly pointed out the harmoni­ous laws of the social order winch spring from it.

Man, as we have already said, has an invincible desire to support himself, to improve his condition, and to attain happiness, or what he conceives to be happiness, at least to approximate towards it. For the same reason he shuns pain and toil.

Now labour, or the exertion we make in order to cause nature to co-operate in production, is in itself toil or fatigue. For this rea­son, it is repugnant to man, and he does not submit to it, except for the sake of avoiding a still greater evil.

Some have maintained philosophically that labour is not an evil but a good, and they are right, if we take into account its results. It is a comparative good; or if it be an evil, it is an evil which saves us from greater evils. This is precisely the reason why men have so great a tendency to shun labour when they think that, without having recourse to it, they may be able to reap its results.

Others maintain that labour is in itself a good; and that, inde­pendently of its productive results, it elevates, strengthens, and purifies man’s character, and is to him a source of health and en­joyment. All this is strictly true; and it is an additional evidence to us of the marvelous fertility of those final intentions which the Creator has displayed in all parts of His works. Apart altogether from the productions which are its direct results, labour promises to man, as a supplementary recompense, a sound mind in a sound body; and it is not more true that idleness is the parent of every vice than that labour is the parent of many virtues.

But this does not at all interfere with the natural and uncon­querable inclinations of the human heart, or with that feeling which prompts us not to desire labour for its own sake, but to compare it constantly with its results; not to desire to expend a great effort on what can be accomplished with a smaller effort; not of two efforts to choose the more severe. Nor is our endeavour to diminish the relation which the effort bears to the result inconsistent with our desire, when we have once acquired some leisure, to de­vote that leisure to new labours suited to our tastes, with the prospect of thus securing a new and additional recompense.

With reference to all this, universal facts are decisive. At all times, and everywhere, we find man regarding labour as undesir­able, and satisfaction as the thing in his condition which makes him compensation for his labour. At all times, and everywhere, we find him endeavouring to lighten his toil by calling in the aid, whenever he can obtain it, of animals, of the wind, of water-power, of steam, of natural forces, or, alas! of his fellow creature, when he succeeds in enslaving him. In this last case,—I repeat, for it is too apt to be forgotten,—labour is not diminished, but dis­placed.

Man, being thus placed between two evils, want or labour, and urged on by self-interest, seeks to discover whether, by some means or other, he cannot get rid of both. It is then that spoliation pre­sents itself to him as a solution of the problem.

He says to himself: “I have not, it is true, any means of procuring the things necessary for my subsistence and enjoyments—food, clothing, and lodging—unless these things are previously produced by labour. But it is by no means indispensable that this should be my own labour. It is enough that they should be produced by the labour of some one, provided I can get the mastery.”

Such is the origin of war.

I shall not dwell upon its consequences.

When things come to this, that one man, or one nation, devotes itself to labour, and another man, or another nation, waits on till that labour is accomplished, in order to devote itself to rapine, we can see at a glance how much human power is thrown away.

On the one hand, the spoliator has not succeeded as he desired in getting quit of every kind of labour. Armed robbery exacts efforts, and sometimes very severe efforts. While the producer devotes his time to the creation of products fitted to yield satisfac­tions, the spoliator employs his time in devising the means of robbing him. But when the work of violence has been accom­plished, or attempted, the objects calculated to yield satisfaction are neither more nor less abundant than before. They may minister to the wants of a different set of people, but not of more wants. Thus all the exertions which the spoliator has made with a view to spoliation, and the exertions also which he has failed to make with a view to production, are entirely lost, if not for him, at least for society.

Nor is this all. In most cases an analogous loss takes place on the side of the producer. It is not likely that he will wait for the violence with which he is menaced without taking some pre­caution for his own protection ; and all precautions of this kind—arms, fortifications, munitions, drill—are labour, and labour lost for ever, not to him who expects security from this labour, but to mankind at large.

But should the producer, after undergoing this double labour, not esteem himself able to resist the threatened violence, it is still worse for society, and power is thrown away on a much greater scale; for, in that case labour will be given up altogether, no one being. disposed to produce in order to be plundered.

If we regard the manner in which the human faculties are affected on both sides, the moral consequences of spoliation will be seen to be no less disastrous.

Providence has designed that man should devote himself to pacific combats with natural agents, and should reap directly from nature the fruits of his victory. When he obtains this mastery over natural agents only by obtaining a mastery over his fellow-creatures, his mission is changed, and quite another direction is given to his faculties. It is seen how great the difference is between the producer and the spoliator, as regards foresight—foresight which becomes assimilated in some degree to provi­dence, for to foresee is also to provide against.

The producer sets himself to learn the relation between cause and effect. For this purpose, he studies the laws of the physical world, and seeks to make them more and more useful auxiliaries. If he turns his regards on his fellow-men, it is to foresee their wants, and to provide for them, on condition of reciprocity.

The spoliator does not study nature. If he turns his regards on his fellow-men, it is to watch them as the eagle watches his prey, for the purpose of enfeebling and surprising them.

The same differences are observable in the other faculties, and extend to men’s ideas.

Spoliation by means of war is not an accidental, isolated, and transient fact; it is a fact so general and so constant as not to give place, as regards permanence, to labour itself.

Point me out any country of the world where of two races, conquerors and conquered, the one does not domineer over the other. Show me in Europe, in Asia, or among the islands of the sea, a favoured spot still occupied by the primitive inhabitants. If migrations of population have spared no country, war has been equally widespread.

Its traces are universal. Apart from rapine and bloodshed, public opinion outraged, and faculties and talents perverted, war has everywhere left other traces behind it, among which we must reckon slavery and aristocracy.

Not only has the march of spoliation kept pace with the crea­tion of wealth, but the spoliators have seized upon accumulated riches, upon capital in all its forms; and, in particular, they have fixed their regards upon capital in the shape of landed property. The last step was taking possession of man himself. For human powers and faculties being the instruments of labour, they found it a shorter method to lay hold of these powers and faculties, than to seize upon their products.

It is impossible to calculate to what extent these great events have acted as disturbing causes, and as trammels on the natural progress of the human race. If we take into account the sacrifice of industrial power which war occasions, and the extent to which the diminished results of that power are concentrated in the hands of a limited number of conquerors, we may form to ourselves an idea of the causes of the destitution of the masses,—a destitution which in our days it is impossible to explain on the hypothesis of liberty.

How the warlike spirit is propagated.

Aggressive nations are subject to reprisals. They often attack others; sometimes they defend themselves. When they act on the defensive, they have on their side the feeling of justice, and the sacredness of the cause in which they are engaged. They may then exult in their courage, devotion, and patriotism. But, alas! they carry these same sentiments into their offensive wars—and where is their patriotism then?

Freedom and peace go together: $35
When two races, the one victorious and idle, the other van­quished and humiliated, occupy the same territory, everything calculated to awaken desire or arouse popular sympathies falls to the lot of the conquerors. Theirs are leisure, fêtes, taste for the arts, wealth, military parade, tournaments, grace, elegance, literature, poetry. For the conquered race, nothing remains but ruined huts, squalid garments, the hard hand of labour, or the cold hand of charity.

The consequence is that the ideas and prejudices of the dominant race, always associated with military force, come to constitute public opinion. Men, women, and children, all unite in extolling the soldier’s life in preference to that of the labourer, in preferring war to industry, and spoliation to production. The vanquished race shares the same sentiments, and when, at periods of transi­tion, it succeeds in getting the better of its oppressors, it shows itself disposed to imitate them.

What is this imitation but mad­ness?

How war ends.

Spoliation, like Production, having its source in the human heart, the laws of the social world would not be harmonious, even to the limited extent for which I contend, if the latter did not succeed in the long-run in overcoming the former.

_______________________

Frederic Bastiat (1801-1850) was a French economist, legislator, and writer. Comment on the blog.


TOP TEN FOR 2005 FROM TRUTHOUT

In 2005 TruthOut brought you exclusive coverage of the year's most important stories including much original content. This New Year's edition showcases the top 10 TruthOut stories of 2005.

Browse our continually updating front page at http://www.truthout.org

Join fellow bloggers at the t r u t h o u t Town Meeting. Get perspective on today's important issues from TO's editorial team and prominent guest bloggers.
Join the debate! http://forum.truthout.org/blog

t r u t h o u t | 01.01

t r u t h o u t | Mr. Fitzgerald Calling
http://server1.truthout.org/fitzgeraldcalling.shtml
One of the years biggest stories, federal prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald's dramatic quest to bring White House officials to justice for revealing the name of under cover CIA agent Valerie Plame needed special coverage. TruthOut was there.

Steve Weissman | Dead Messengers: How the US Military Threatens Journalists
http://www.truthout.org/docs_2005/022405A.shtml
2004 was the deadliest year for reporters since 1980. At the time many reporters believed that the military was purposely targeting journalists. As a result TruthOut Director, Marc Ash asked Steve Weissman to investigate this claim. In this award winning five part series that came out early 2005, Steve Weissman reports his findings.

William Rivers Pitt | Nail It to the White House Door
http://server1.truthout.org/docs_2005/061505X.shtml
On the eve of the Conyers hearing on June 16th, William Rivers Pitt writes on the Downing Street Minutes -the document leaked by a British version of Deep Throat that describes in plain language the manner in which the Bush and Blair administrations planned to manipulate their way into an invasion of Iraq. A collection of more than 120 organizations and news outlets came together for the purpose of nailing the facts of the Downing Street Minutes to the White House door.

Marjorie Cohn | Abu Ghraib General Lambastes Bush Administration
http://server1.truthout.org/docs_2005/082405Z.shtml
In this exclusive TruthOut interview Marjorie Cohn talks with Janis Karpinski, the Army Reserve Brigadier General who was in charge of the infamous Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq when the now famous torture photographs were taken in fall of 2003.

t r u t h o u t | MayDay Mississippi Delta
http://www.truthout.org/mayday.shtml
In the wake of Hurricane Katrina the TruthOut staff created a special page to provide our readers with around the clock coverage of the events unfolding. In addition to providing coverage from a variety of sources our page also provided resources and information for prospective donors and hurricane victims in need of help.

t r u t h o u t | One Mother's Stand
http://server1.truthout.org/cindy.shtml
In August and September TruthOut's Managing Editor, Scott Galindez spent three weeks at Camp Casey providing our readers with exclusive coverage. As a result TruthOut created this special page "One Mother's Stand." TruthOut also followed Camp Casey to Washington DC for a historic mobalization against the Iraq war http://truthout.org/campcaseydc.shtml.

Bill Moyers | There Is No Tomorrow
http://www.truthout.org/cgi-bin/artman/exec/view.cgi/38/8664
Bill Moyers looks at what he calls one of the biggest changes in politics in his lifetime: the delusional is no longer marginal. For the first time in our history, ideology and theology hold a monopoly of power in Washington. The offspring of ideology and theology are not always bad but they are always blind. And that is the danger: voters and politicians alike, oblivious to the facts.

Confessions of a Marine
http://server1.truthout.org/docs_2005/110205A.shtml
TruthOut's French correspondent, Leslie Thatcher, translated this piece that appeared in Le Nouvel Observateur. It was the story that no American publisher wanted. In this excerpt, Master-Sergeant Jimmy Massey tells about his mission to recruit for, then fight in, the war in Iraq. He tells why he killed. And cracked.

Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. | We Must Take America Back
http://server1.truthout.org/docs_2005/091705Z.shtml
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. delivered this speech at the Sierra Summit 2005 in San Francisco in acceptance of the William O. Douglas Award. " This is the worst environmental president we’ve had in American history. The White House has used all kinds of ingenious machinations to try to conceal its radical agenda from the American people including Orwellian rhetoric. But most insidiously, they have put polluters in charge of virtually all the agencies that are supposed to protect Americans from pollution."

Harold Pinter | The Nobel Lecture: Art, Truth and Politics
http://server1.truthout.org/docs_2005/120805M.shtml
Harold Pinter gave this lecture when he received the 2005 Nobel prize for literature in early December. "The invasion of Iraq was a bandit act, an act of blatant state terrorism, demonstrating absolute contempt for the concept of international law. The invasion was an arbitrary military action inspired by a series of lies upon lies and gross manipulation of the media and therefore of the public."

_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/

Inner Peace

For those of you who are making New Year's resolutions. Here is something to "inspire" you

PEACE.......................Inner Peace (LOL!!!!!!!!!!)...................Scott

Inner Peace
I am passing this on to you because it definitely worked for me and
we all could use more calm in our lives. By following the simple
advice I heard on a Dr. Phil show, I have finally found inner peace.
Dr. Phil proclaimed the way to achieve inner peace is to finish all
the things you have started. So I looked around my house to see
things I started and hadn't finished; and, before leaving the house
this morning I finished off a bottle of Merlot, a bottle of White
Zinfandel, a bottle of Baileys, a bottle of Kahlua, a package of
Oreos, the remainder of both Prozac and Valim prescriptions, the
rest of the Cheesecake, some Saltines and a box of Chocolates. You
have no idea how freaking good I feel.

Quote Of The Day

Here is another "Quote of the Day" that I found langering in the cyber backwaters of my draft folder. Just thought it was still timely and appropriate.............PEACE...........Scott




Quote Of The Day - "Trying to eliminate Saddam ...would have incurred incalculable human and political costs... We would have been forced to occupy Baghdad and, in effect, rule Iraq ...there was no viable "exit strategy" we could see... Furthermore, we had been self-consciously trying to set a pattern for handling aggression in the post-Cold War world. Going in and occupying Iraq, thus unilaterally exceeding the United Nations' mandate, would have destroyed the precedent of international response to aggression that we hoped to establish. Had we gone the invasion route, the United States could conceivably still be an occupying power in a bitterly hostile land." - President George H.W. Bush on operation Desert Storm.

"Be Very Quiet"

A father and son went hunting together for the first time.

The father said: "Stay here and be very QUIET. I'll be across the field."

A few minutes later the father heard a blood curdling scream and ran
back to his son. "What's wrong?" the father asked. "I told you to be
quiet."

The boy, bless his heart, answered;

"Look, I was quiet when the snake slithered across my feet.
I was quiet when the bear breathed down my neck.
I didn't move a muscle when the skunk climbed over my shoulder.
I closed my eyes and held my breath when the wasp stung me.
I didn't cough when I swallowed the gnat.
I didn't cuss or scratch when the poison oak started itching.

But when the two squirrels crawled up my pant legs and said,

'Should we eat them here or take them with us?'

"Well, I guess I just panicked................"

Misc. News From the Progressive Review

THE PROBLEM WITH APOPHIS: IT MAY RUIN THE EARTH

ALOK JHA, GUARDIAN - In Egyptian myth, Apophis was the ancient spirit of
evil and destruction, a demon that was determined to plunge the world
into eternal darkness. A fitting name, astronomers reasoned, for a
menace now hurtling towards Earth from outer space. Scientists are
monitoring the progress of a 390-metre wide asteroid discovered last
year that is potentially on a collision course with the planet, and are
imploring governments to decide on a strategy for dealing with it.

NASA has estimated that an impact from Apophis, which has an outside
chance of hitting the Earth in 2036, would release more than 100,000
times the energy released in the nuclear blast over Hiroshima. Thousands
of square kilometers would be directly affected by the blast but the
whole of the Earth would see the effects of the dust released into the
atmosphere. And, scientists insist, there is actually very little time
left to decide. At a recent meeting of experts in near-Earth objects in
London, scientists said it could take decades to design, test and build
the required technology to deflect the asteroid. Monica Grady, an expert
in meteorites at the Open University, said: "It's a question of when,
not if, a near Earth object collides with Earth. Many of the smaller
objects break up when they reach the Earth's atmosphere and have no
impact. However, a NEO larger than 1km [wide] will collide with Earth
every few hundred thousand years and a NEO larger than 6km, which could
cause mass extinction, will collide with Earth every hundred million
years. We are overdue for a big one.". . .

Apophis asteroid was placed at four out of 10 on the Torino scale - a
measure of the threat posed by an NEO where 10 is a certain collision
which could cause a global catastrophe. This was the highest of any
asteroid in recorded history and it had a 1 in 37 chance of hitting the
Earth. The threat of a collision in 2029 was eventually ruled out at the
end of last year.

Alan Fitzsimmons, an astronomer from Queen's University Belfast, said:
"When it does pass close to us on April 13 2029, the Earth will deflect
it and change its orbit. There's a small possibility that if it passes
through a particular point in space, the so-called keyhole, ... the
Earth's gravity will change things so that when it comes back around
again in 2036, it will collide with us." The chance of Apophis passing
through the keyhole, a 600-metre patch of space, is 1 in 5,500 based on
current information.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/space/article/0,14493,1660485,00.html


||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
AMERICAN NOTES
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

MORE USES FOR DUCT TAPE

NEWS STAR, MONROE LA - On Christmas night several years ago while at
"Grandma's House" in Shreveport, the festive mood of the evening was
interrupted by our teenage daughter calling from the back porch,
"Daaaaaddy!" What seemed like the whole extended family charged from the
den only to find my husband's beloved Labrador Retriever, HRCH Phoebe,
bleeding profusely from the end of her obviously shortened tail, and our
daughter blubbering that she had accidentally closed the storm door too
quickly when they came in the house together. After a trip the emergency
vet's that night and surgery the next week in West Monroe, Phoebe was
recovering well. But this mishap happened right smack in the middle of
duck season, the time of year for which she and her master live. When
the vet said that Phoebe's tail, which was now 4 inches shorter, had to
be kept dry at all times, there was only one solution. Tommy covered her
bandage with duct tape (now fondly referred to at our house as Duck
Tape) and off to the blind they went. - Norma Johnson, West Monroe

I know of a waitress in a restaurant of a neighboring town who uses duct
tape to enhance her figure. She takes the excess "rolls" of flab around
her waist, rolls them up and tapes them flat to her belly. I guess you
could say it's a "redneck tummy tuck!" -Jason Ashley

When my son was born in 1983, I had to go back to work when he was only
4 weeks old. My husband and I agreed we would take turns at night
getting up with him. . . At 5:30 a.m. when the alarm went off, I could
not believe he had actually slept for an hour and a half. I got up, got
in and out of the shower, and he still had not cried. I then could not
believe I was going to have to wake him up to get him ready for the day.
I walked into my son's room and looked over into the bassinet. There I
saw him lying on his back, eyes wide as marbles, happy as could be,
sucking his pacifier which was duct taped in his mouth from ear-to-ear.
- Melinda Bonnette, West Monroe

About three years ago, I had a peach limb break while full of peaches
that were not quite ripe. I decided to put the duct tape around it. The
peaches ripened, and for the last three years, they make as though it
was never broken. I have a small peach orchard, approximately 100 trees,
and I'm never out of duct tape. - Fred L. Kennedy, Marion

My daddy . . . cut his hand one time and put WD-40 on it and wrapped it
with duct tape. - Sandra Rowton, Jena

I coordinate the girls ministry at Highland Baptist Church. Our ministry
is called G.R.A.C.E. - Girls Reaching and Changing Eternity. Each month,
we have what we call Grace nights - nights where we girls get together
for food, fellowship and fun. Our November Grace night had a duct tape
theme. We called it Duct Tape Fest. All of the games and activities we
played centered on duct tape. The funniest game was the Duct Tape
Challenge. Our girls got into teams of three and I gave each team three
rolls of duct tape. They had to tape the smallest of their team members
to the wall. The team whose taped member held the longest won. It was
pretty funny watching them slowly come untaped, and it was even funnier
to watch them try to get all of that duct tape off of themselves. We
ended our gathering with a Bible study about how Jesus holds all things
together, even when we may feel like everything's falling apart. -
Stefanie Cox, Monroe

Green duct tape was widely used by our unit in Vietnam in l963-64 to
cover up bullet holes in our airplanes. . . Most of our planes were
speckled with green tape by the end of my tour. - Don Hoyem, Monroe

My husband decided that three Friday night visits for stitches (in three
weeks in a row, nonetheless.) to the St. Francis Emergency Room was a
bit much, so when our 5-year-old son (once again) had a cut on his chin
that needed to be "put back together," off I went to retrieve the "skin
super glue" from the office. (My husband and I are both physicians).
Upon arriving back home, glue in hand, my surgeon-husband announced,
"glue and/or stitches not necessary." Lo and behold, that adorable
5-year-old chin was held together by a piece of duct tape. -Tara Mercer,
Monroe

http://www.thenewsstar.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2005512060301

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
ARTS
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

UNCONVENTIONAL JAZZ SCENES

RICHARD WILLIAMS, GUARDIAN - The capital of Norway would seem an
unlikely successor to New Orleans, Chicago and New York. And yet, as
jazz heads into its second century as an international language, it's in
Oslo that its conversation is now at its most animated and productive.
Thirty years ago, when the saxophonist Jan Garbarek and the guitarist
Terje Rypdal became the first Norwegian jazz musicians to make an
international impact, no one could have predicted that their country,
with its population of 4.5 million, would now be enjoying such
pre-eminence. . . "The most characteristic thing about these Norwegian
musicians," [Rune] Kristofferson says, "is their disrespect for genre. .
. The academies in Trondheim and Oslo have been important in that
respect, encouraging musicians to step outside their own fields and
experiment in ways that help them find their own voices."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/arts/features/story/0,11710,1659264,00.html

KENNY MATHIESON, SCOTSMAN - Scottish jazz lovers have never had it so
good - that, at least, is the claim of a new Radio Scotland programe,
All that Jazz. Broadcast next week, the show began life when guitarist
Martin Taylor was in Shetland with an Aberdeen-based producer, Claire
White. The pair were making a documentary about the islands' famous
guitarist, Peerie Willie Johnson, when the conversation turned to jazz.
"Martin got talking about the how vibrant the jazz scene in Scotland
was," White explains. "My main interest is in folk music, but I could
see what he was talking about. The more we thought about it, the more
there seemed to be to going on . . .

http://news.scotsman.com/features.cfm?id=2362572005

SCOTT GOLD, LA TIMES - City officials and artists who call New Orleans
home announced that they would team with Habitat for Humanity to build a
village for musicians chased from their homes by Hurricane Katrina. The
alliance, which includes the Marsalis family and Harry Connick Jr., will
use $1 million in seed money generated by two recent concerts in New
York to launch the development. Plans call for as many as 200 homes
surrounding a cultural center named for Ellis Marsalis - a patriarch of
New Orleans jazz and the father of three accomplished musicians:
saxophonist Branford, trumpeter Wynton and trombonist Delfeayo.

There will be single-family dwellings for younger musicians with
families, and easy-to-care-for condominiums for elderly musicians - many
of whom had lived in poor sections of town before the storm hit. The
cultural center would include a performance hall, rehearsal space and
rooms where the musicians could give lessons to children. The
development is expected to cost about $18 million, said Jim Pate,
executive director of the New Orleans Area Habitat for Humanity.
Additional money would be raised through efforts such as the sale of
DVDs and CDs - including an upcoming compilation called "Our New
Orleans: A Benefit Album for the Gulf Coast."

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/
la-na-village7dec07,1,4551048.story?coll=la-headlines-nation

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
CIVIL LIBERTIES
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

REP SAYS 18 YEAR OLD SOLDIERS SHOULD HAVE RIGHT TO DRINK

[PS: Laws prohibiting 18 year olds from drinking are unconstitutional]

AMANDA MASKER, DAILY IOWAN - Despite the right to sign a lease, vote for
the president, and lay their lives on the line, one thing 18-year-olds
legally cannot do is have a beer. New Hampshire state Rep. Jim Splaine
wants to change that for a special sector of 18-year-olds in his state.
The Democrat has sponsored a bill to lower the legal drinking age for
military personnel to 18, arguing that the United States is
"disrespecting" the young men and women who are sent into harm's way by
not allowing them a glass of wine before they leave for war. . .

Splaine argues that if 18-year-olds are being taught to use a weapon,
they should be able to consume alcohol responsibly. In fact, he believes
all adults should be able to legally drink but said he can only do one
thing at a time.

Setting the drinking age set at 21 "makes alcohol a forbidden fruit," he
said. "We are creating a generation of criminals," he said, adding that
young people drink regardless of the laws on the books.

http://www.uwire.com/content//topnews120605001.html

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
POST CONSTITUTIONAL AMERICA .
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

FCC SAYS INTERNET USE MUST MEET NEEDS OF FBI, NOT FIRST AMENDMENT

DECLAN MCCULLAGH, CNET - The Federal Communications Commission thinks
you have the right to use software on your computer only if the FBI
approves. In an obscure "policy" document released around 9 p.m. ET last
Friday, the FCC announced this remarkable decision. According to the
three-page document, to preserve the openness that characterizes today's
Internet, "consumers are entitled to run applications and use services
of their choice, subject to the needs of law enforcement." Read the last
seven words again.

The FCC didn't offer much in the way of clarification. But the clearest
reading of the pronouncement is that some unelected bureaucrats at the
commission have decreed that Americans don't have the right to use
software such as Skype or PGPfone if it doesn't support mandatory
backdoors for wiretapping. (That interpretation was confirmed by an FCC
spokesman on Monday, who asked not to be identified by name. Also, the
announcement came at the same time as the FCC posted its wiretapping
rules for Internet telephony.)

Nowhere does the commission say how it jibes this official pronouncement
with, say, the First Amendment's right to speak freely, not to mention
the limited powers granted the federal government by the U.S.
Constitution.

http://news.com.com/2061-10804_3-5884130.html

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
OTHER NEWS
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

MORE DANGERS FOUND IN 'GOOD NIGHT MOON'

[After Harper Collins censored a book jacket photo of 'Good Night Moon'
illustrator Clement Hurd to remove the cigarette he was holding, Karen
Karbo got to work on other safety problems in the book]

KAREN KARBO, NY TIMES:

A. Huge gilt picture frames have no place in the nursery, especially
those that are not properly secured. . . Suggested change: digitally
replace with piece of lightweight non-toxic fiber art.

B. The reader has no way of knowing whether Bunny's pj's meet current
flammability standards. Suggested change: digitally alter to include
visible "flame resistant" label. . .

E. Balloons cause more choking deaths among 3- to 6-year-olds than any
other toy. Suggested change: Digitally remove. . .

F. Given proximity and brightness of stars and moon, it's apparent that
Bunny's room is in a high rise. Both windows lack either locks or any
type of window guard or restraining device. . .

H. A fire blazing in the fireplace while Bunny sleeps? Suggested change:
Get rid of it. At the very least, digitally add a fire extinguisher to
the wall. . .

J. Clearly the bookshelf is unanchored to the wall. If an earthquake
hit, Bunny could get squashed flat. . .

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/04/opinion/04karbo.html

[Then a few readers found more]

Bunny's bed has no restraining rails. Bunny could roll out of bed and be
seriously hurt. These should be installed at once. - John Collinge
Bethesda, Md


A close examination of the clock above the fireplace shows that the time
is 7 p.m. at the start of the book. At the end of the book, the time is
8:10 p.m., indicating that it takes Bunny 70 minutes to fall asleep. It
is concerning that the book implies that this length of time is
acceptable. On the contrary, 70 minutes to fall asleep suggests that
Bunny is suffering from undiagnosed and untreated insomnia - Gregory
Zimet & Lynne Sturm Indianapolis

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/07/opinion/l07moon.html

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

MOVIE MAKERS FIND MORE WAYS TO DRIVE AWAY VIEWERS

LAURA PETRECCA AND DAVID LIEBERMAN, USA TODAY - Ad forecasters at Zenith
Optimedia said that spending on in-theater ads, usually shown before the
trailers, rose by 18% this year to $400 million - and likely will go up
by about 15% each year through 2008. . . The forecast was good news for
theater owners depressed by the 6% slide in box office receipts this
year. To attract more ads, they've spent about $150 million in the last
three years to install relatively simple digital projectors just for
ads. That's ahead of the much larger investment just beginning for full
digital conversion to movie-quality projectors. . . "I detest having to
go to a theater and sit through 20 minutes of advertising," says Robert
Bucksbaum, who's president of industry research firm Reel Source - and
owns two theaters that don't show commercials. "But it's definitely the
wave of the future."

http://www.usatoday.com/money/media/2005-12-06-cinema-ads_x.htm

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
WORDS
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

Tenured Teachers Rarely Canned - Bloomington Pantograph

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
FURTHERMORE. . .
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

MORE AMERICANS TAKING COMPUTERS WITH THEM TO THE JOHN

AGENCE FRANCE PRESSE - A new survey of Internet use has found that more
and more people are logging on in the bathroom. The snapshot of how the
Internet has changed American life, concluded that home wireless
connections were allowing people to stay connected everywhere - even in
the smallest room in the house. "A significant number of Americans use
the computer connection in the bathroom," said Jeffrey Cole, of the
University of Southern California Annenberg School Center for the
Digital Future. Since people were unlikely to be surfing in the bath, or
while brushing their teeth, Cole said he had concluded that many of them
went off into cyberspace while on the throne. "Over half of those who
used Wi-fi had used it in the bathroom," said Cole.

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2005\12\07\story_7-12-2005_pg9_1


||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

ASHBURY PARK PRESS - The two-week musicians' strike at Radio City Music
Hall in November ended in a deal hammered out with the help of a
mediator named by New York City Mayor Mike Bloomberg. . . If you've
followed the news accounts, that much of the story is familiar. But
little has been said about the one thing in this strike that really
matters most: the successful, if temporary, replacement of musicians
with prerecorded music. . . Musicians have become an expensive line item
in the New York entertainment industry. With the rise of technological
alternatives, theater owners have been poised with the red pen for much
of the last decade. It is even affecting the culture of Broadway shows,
as several inventive creators have handed investors neat "solutions" for
the musician problem. For instance, a reportedly very exciting,
stripped-down version of "Sweeney Todd" currently on Broadway features
the actors playing all the music themselves on a handful of instruments.

http://app.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20051204/ENT/512040317/1031

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

DOUG HENWOOD, LEFT BUSINESS OBSERVER - For those of us who cut our teeth
on the power-structure studies of William Domhoff, which saw the U.S. as
ruled by an old WASP elite operating through institutions like the Ford
Foundation and the Council on Foreign Relations, it's been quite a
surprise to watch the Bush administration in action. Though it should
have known better, it started a pointless war that's put U.S. power and
prestige at severe risk, and it's driven the government's accounts deep
into the red, and it's financed both reckless adventures with huge gobs
of money borrowed from abroad. A serious ruling class might have reined
them in long ago, but our elite has been too narcoticized by its tax
cuts-your average millionaire got a $60,000 break, more than the pretax
income of the average household-to complain. It's looking more and more
like that elite shares many of the same characteristics often attributed
to the couch-potato demographic: short-sightedness, political
disengagement, distractability, and ignorance of the larger world. And
since the Dems serve a dual role, as the "popular" party and as the
party of an alternative elite, their dithering reflects a crisis at the
upper levels of our society, as well as the disorganization at the lower
levels.

http://www.leftbusinessobserver.com/

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

JOHN CARVEL, GUARDIAN - Black people are three times more likely than
the rest of the population to be admitted to mental hospitals in England
and Wales. They are twice as likely to be sent there by the police or
the courts, and 50% more likely to be placed in seclusion, according to
the first ethnic census of inpatients, published today by the health
inspectorate.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/race/story/0,,1660467,00.html

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

AP - The number of Internet users in India will shoot to 100 million in
two years from the current 38.5 million, an industry study said. The
number of Internet users has soared 54 percent from 25 million users in
2004-2005. The catalyst for this growth was the rise in online shopping
for airline and rail tickets, books and home appliances, Preeti Desai,
president of the Internet and Mobile Association of India, said
Wednesday.

http://www.breitbart.com/news/2005/12/07/D8EBEAN80.html

||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||

AP - A professor whose planned course on creationism and intelligent
design was canceled after he sent e-mails deriding Christian
conservatives was hospitalized Monday after what appeared to be a
roadside beating. University of Kansas religious studies professor Paul
Mirecki said that the two men who beat him made references to the class
that was to be offered for the first time this spring. Originally called
"Special Topics in Religion: Intelligent Design, Creationism and other
Religious Mythologies," the course was canceled last week at Mirecki's
request. The class was added after the Kansas State Board of Education
decided to include more criticism of evolution in science standards for
elementary and secondary students. "I didn't know them," Mirecki said of
his assailants, "but I'm sure they knew me."

http://www.kansas.com/mld/eagle/living/education/13337930.htm

GREAT QUOTES / 12

Well this is the 12th installment of "Great Quotes". I hope that you have been inspired, entertained, perplexed, astounded, etc. Please use them as you will. I'm already working on # 13. I will be posting it shortly.....................PEACE..................Scott



Fifty years ago, a young genius made a classic that
could never be re-told. Now, it must be told again,
because evil never dies, but copyrights expire!
-- Firesign Theatre


Baseball is 90% mental, the other half is physical - Yogi Berra


"It is dangerous for a national candidate to say things that people might remember." - Eugene McCarthy


"Nobody knows the age of the human race, but everybody agrees that it is old enough to know better." - Anonymous


If you want your children to be brilliant, tell them fairy tales. If you
want them to be very brilliant, tell them even more fairy tales. -
Albert Einstein


If you dig a hole that's deep enough,
everyone will want to jump into it.
-- Firesign Theatre


"The scientific name for an animal that doesn't either run from or fight its enemies is lunch." - Michael Friedman


Don't worry about the world coming to an end today. It's already
tomorrow in Australia - Charles Schultz


"To err is human--and to blame it on a computer is even more so." - Robert Orben


War is, at first, the hope that one will be better off; next, the
expectation that the other fellow will be worse off; then, the
satisfaction that he isn't any better off; and, finally, the surprise at
everyone's being worse off - Karl Kaus


"The world is full of willing people; some willing to work, the rest willing to let them." – Robert Frost


"Keep your fears to yourself, but share your inspiration with others." - Robert Louis Stevenson


"Ignorance is preferable to error; and he is less remote from the truth who believes nothing, than he who believes what is wrong."
-- Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia


It is impossible to imagine the universe run by a wise, just, omnipotent
God, but it is quite easy to imagine it run by a board of gods. If such
a board actually exists it operates precisely like the board of a
corporation that is losing money. - HL Mencken


"There's a lot of people starving in this country, and we're spending $60 million on (campaign) ads." - New Jersey coffee shop owner Bill Mirrer


Human kindness has never weakened the stamina or softened the fiber of a
free people. A nation does not have to be cruel to be tough. -Franklin D.Roosevelt


The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always
so certain of themselves, but wiser people so full of doubts. -
Bertrand Russell

Nygaard Notes


Independent Periodic News and Analysis
Number 316, December 30, 2005

On the Web at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/

******

This Week: The Nygaard Notes The Year in Review

1. “Quote” of the Week
2. The Year’s Top (Non) Stories
3. Nygaard Notes Year in Review, 2005 Version

******


Greetings,

The last issue of the year, in Nygaardnotesland, is reserved for the annual “Year in Review,” a look back at the preceding twelve months of the Notes. As I always point out, there are several reasons to do this review.

First of all, I always worry that new readers might think that the first two or three issues of the Notes is “what it is.” For instance, the new readers who have come on board in the past three or four weeks might think that Nygaard Notes is “about” propaganda. Readers who came on board last January might have thought that the Notes is “about” morality politics. So, a review that runs through the variety of things that have been in the Notes over the course of a year might remind people that Nygaard Notes is characterized by nothing if not variety!

Secondly, it is good for yours truly to see what I’ve been up to all year. This year, for instance, was the year I went away from a weekly format to a periodic format. So, instead of the traditional 44-48 issues, I only sent out 34 issues this year. Some people have told me that this is a good thing, as the weekly issue was “too much” for them. I, myself, was a little frustrated at how many things I did not get around to discussing this year. But, when I actually looked at what was in the Notes this year, the scope and depth of what I ran was greater than I had been thinking it was. A reality check!

Finally—shocking though it may be!—it has come to my attention that some subscribers do not read each and every issue of the Notes! For those people, a little summary of what they may have missed can’t be a bad thing. (By the way: There is no tax advantage to doing so, but the end of the year is a great time to make a pledge of support to Nygaard Notes! $5.00, $50.00, $500.00. What a great idea!)

So, there you go: The Year in Review is good for new readers, good for Nygaard, and good for long-time readers. Everyone is happy!

I hope you are happy as we let go of the year 2005 and careen into the year 2006. There’ll be lots to talk about, as always. I can hardly wait, and I’m excited to have you all along for the ride!

Nygaard

******

1.
“Quote” of the Week

Doug Thompson, publisher of Capitol Hill Blue, a political newsletter out of Washington (http://www.capitolhillblue.com/) writes in the December 9th edition about a November meeting between Republican Congressional leaders and “President” George W. Bush in which they talked “about renewing the controversial USA Patriot Act.” (For a brief overview of what this law is about, check out this brief report from the Congressional Research Service: http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/intel/RS22348.pdf)

According to Thompson, some of the Republican lawmakers warned Mr. Bush that he risked alienating some conservatives if he pushed too hard on some of “the more onerous provisions of the act.” At one point, an aide in the meeting is reported to have said: “Mr. President, there is a valid case that the provisions in this law undermine the Constitution.”

Thompson says that “three people present for the meeting that day...all confirm” that the “President” replied to that comment as follows:

“Stop throwing the Constitution in my face. It's just a goddamned piece of paper!”

******

2.
The Year’s Top (Non) Stories

The nation’s major news service, the Associated Press (AP) just came out with their list of the “Top News Stories” of 2005, as they do every year. There are things to be learned—or at least things to ponder—when looking at this list, or any of the various such lists that come out around the end of each year.

It’s not surprising to see that Hurricane Katrina was considered the top story overall. It is surprising—at least to me—that the U.S. occupation of Iraq ranked only third on the list, after the papal transition from John Paul to Benedict. The remaining eight stories on the AP’s list were the Supreme Court vacancies, high oil prices, the London bombings, the massive earthquake in Pakistan, the Terri Schiavo end-of-life drama, the leak of the identity of secret CIA agent Valerie Plame by someone in the Bush administration, and the falling approval ratings of the “President” himself.

Part of what is interesting to me about all these lists of “Top Stories” is the tremendously important things that do NOT make any of the major lists. This year, as always, there were several major, major stories that were not on the AP’s list, nor on any of the other lists that I’ve seen so far.

Perhaps the biggest story not on the list is the ongoing collapse of the U.S. health-care system. It’s an “old” story, but opinion polls consistently show it to be among the top concerns of respondents. There are several “Top Stories” here, actually, ranging from the increase in the number of uninsured to 46 million in 2005 (with another 16 million “underinsured”) to the fact that our country has the highest health-care costs in the world, yet ranks near the bottom in overall health indicators among wealthy countries. Isn’t this a “Top Story?” I don’t see it on the AP’s list.

One major story that was barely reported, let alone put on any “Top Stories” lists, was the President’s defeat on Social Security reform. This fantastic failure made no “Top Stories” lists, and when it was reported in the nation’s press, the approach of USA Today was typical. Their October 10th headline on the subject said, “Bush’s Plan Dies Quietly,” but the complete failure of President Bush’s “top domestic policy priority” is only quiet if the media decides it is, of course. No “Top Stories” list for this top story.

One Top Story that is almost guaranteed to never make any lists of “Top Stories” is the decline in the quality of the media itself. 2005 was filled with stories about the budget cuts and other cost-cutting measures that are being implemented across the board in U.S. news organizations, and the accompanying degeneration in news reporting. This “Top Story” has to do with the changing nature of the nation’s “Top Stories.” Who is going to report these? Not the Associated Press, most likely. Probably Nygaard Notes.

So, as we approach the end of the year, and you begin to see and hear reports of “the Top News Stories of 2005,” ask yourself what is really meant by “top” news stories. Is it the stories that were most important in helping our democracy to flourish? Or is it the stories that got the highest TV ratings? Think about that, then make your own list of the “Top Stories” of the year. I’ll bet it will look a little different.

******

3.
Nygaard Notes Year in Review, 2005 Version

We started off the year of 2005 with the “Fantasy Versus Reality” series, which took a look at the phenomenon known as “morality politics” as it plays out in the realm of teen sex, teen drugs, and teens in “boot camp”-style “correctional” facilities. That series ran in JANUARY and FEBRUARY.

A revised version of this series ran later in the year as a feature article in Z Magazine, with the title “Sex, Drugs, and Teens: Fantasy Versus Reality in Morality Politics.”

(Some people didn’t like the series. In response to the first installment about sex, which I subtitled “The Absolutists Versus the Rest of Us”, one angry reader wrote to tell me that “you’re a rather foul kind of absolutist yourself,” and added suspiciously that “I'm not quite sure what your agenda really is...” So, in issue #288 I wrote “Individual Versus Social: About My Agenda.” No sense keeping these things a secret.)

Immediately following that, in FEBRUARY, I ran a piece called “Social Security: The Fundamental Issue.” In the Nygaard Notes typical “plain-as-the-nose-on-your-face” style, I explained the difference between a program of SOCIAL INSURANCE—which is what Social Security is, and was intended to be—and a program of INDIVIDUAL INVESTMENT—which is what Mr. Bush and his allies would LIKE it to be. And I did it all in 1,200 words!

Also in FEBRUARY, I ran the piece called “Reversing Our Thinking – Learning Empathy,” in which I said that empathy “is the ability—and willingness—to put oneself in another’s place and ACTIVELY imagine what a situation must be like for that other person. The better you are at empathy, the more compassionate and loving you can be.” Then I explained a little bit about how to develop this ability.

In the month of MARCH I talked about the plans of the“President” for the elimination or severe reductions to 154 federal programs, plans that went largely unreported in the nation’s press. I also talked, in MARCH, about Haiti, giving a little background on the current outrageous state of affairs in that country, and the outrageous reporting about it in the U.S. press.

Later in the month of MARCH I did a pair of pieces called “Reporting Lies I” and “Reporting Lies II,” both of which were about the responsibility of the media when newsmakers say things that are (shall we say?) less than factual. Here are my two favorite comments (I’m quoting myself!?) from the pieces. I just have to quote my favorite line from these pieces: “When a public figure utters an amazing falsehood to a reporter from a major newspaper, it’s not the reporter’s job to read his mind, or to make up excuses for him. It’s the reporter’s job to report what people say and how it fits with the facts. Journalism, after all, is journalism, and public relations is supposed to be something else entirely.”

When APRIL rolled around, I reported on the release of what has been called “the biggest review of the planet's life support systems ever,” the Millennium Ecosystems Assessment. This report, put out by the United Nations Environmental Programme, warned of a looming collapse of the global environment over the next 50 years, the averting of which will require “radical changes in the way nature is treated at every level of decision-making.” I pointed out how this genuine crisis went almost unremarked in the U.S., while a false and manufactured “crisis” in Social Security dominated the media.

In the month of MAY I returned to the subject of Social Security, running no fewer than FIVE separate articles on the “crisis” supposedly facing the program. I debunked some of the hysterical myths that have been hyped (unsuccessfully, we now know) by the “President” and other foes of the program. The retirement of the baby boomers, the unfunded liabilities, bankruptcy, the trust fund—I talked about all of those things in MAY, then I took a break to talk about...

Venezuela. And Colombia. I talked about U.S. efforts to subvert democracy in Venezuela, and the phony “war on drugs” in Colombia. I expect I’ll have a lot more to say about both of these countries in 2006. Bolivia, too.

In JUNE I returned again to Social Security, giving some facts about the alleged “successes” of individualized Social Security programs in Chile, England, and Galveston, Texas, all of which are supposed to be “models” for the U.S. The facts say otherwise, and it’s all there in Issue #298.

Late JUNE brought the Nygaard Notes Pledge Drive of 2005, which included a piece on “The Role of the Public Intellectual.” I also talked about the “Damsel in Distress” syndrome that we read about in our daily papers. I mentioned Tamika Huston of Spartanburg, S.C. Never heard of her? That’s the point!

In JULY I wrote about a “lunge for the jugular vein of the welfare state” that has been quietly going forward at the highest levels. That lunge is the effort to do away with the income tax. (The “jugular vein” metaphor was not mine, by the way; I was quoting the Wall Street Journal.) I had thought this was going to be the first of many articles about the income tax, since the right-wing plan for years has been to go after the income tax after their first two priorities were gotten rid of, those being “welfare” and Social Security. Well, welfare has been decimated, but Bush’s attack on Social Security has failed. So I don’t think Part Three of the attack on the “welfare state” is going to go too far. (I could be wrong. We’ll see what the “President” says next month in his State of the Union address. If the income tax is emphasized, I’ll tell you more about it. Deal?)

The first thing I did in AUGUST was to spell out the ominous Return of The Nukes that was hidden in plain sight in the federal Energy Bill that the “President” signed early that month. I also gave some resources for action on energy and the racism that goes with our current energy policy environment.

Later in AUGUST I talked about the so-called “settlements” that Israel continues to construct in the Occupied Territories, and how rare it is for U.S. media reports to mention that they are illegal under international law. Speaking of the law, I also talked about how the Italian courts were thinking about ordering the arrest of some CIA agents for kidnaping a man in Italy. I thought it should have been shocking that the U.S. government has no intention of abiding by the law in this case, but nobody seemed too shocked. (Arrest warrants were, in fact, issued for 22 CIA agents, just last week, an important story barely reported in this country.)

I followed that issue with a special anti-war issue, offering resources and information on various anti-war and anti-recruitment efforts, and some practical “Tips for Staying Informed” on what is happening in Iraq. Also in August, I touched on MN senator Norm Coleman’s “crusade” against the U.N., the oil companies’ ten-year fraud perpetrated against “high octane” fuel buyers, and I explained why so-called “free trade” is not “free.”

SEPTEMBER saw me writing, like everyone else, about Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath. Specifically, I explained “Operation Offset,” which is the horrendous “conservative response” to Katrina. Lots of details; read it and weep. (Then DO something!) I also reported on the theft of $1 billion from the Iraq Defense Ministry (out of a total budget of $1.3 billion). Remarkable. Almost unnoticed in the U.S.

In OCTOBER there was LOTS more about Katrina. And more unreported news, specifically: some surprising facts from the 2006 “World Development Report” from the World Bank; a major report on the costs of the Iraq occupation; and a report showing that the number of genocides and violent conflicts, worldwide, has dropped rapidly in the wake of the Cold War.

NOVEMBER and DECEMBER have been consumed by this big series on Propaganda, which is still in progress, but from which we are taking a break to do this Year in Review.

**********

If you have received this issue of Nygaard Notes from a friend, or by accident, or through some other bizarre quirk of inexplicable fate which leaves you with no useful return address, be aware that you can receive your own free subscription by asking for it in an E-mail sent to Nygaard Notes at Or visit the Nygaard Notes website at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/

I would like to continue to provide this service for free. You could help by making a voluntary contribution (anything you can afford, whether $5.00 or $500.00) You can donate online by going to the Nygaard Notes website at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/ Then just get out your credit card and follow the instructions. Of course, you can always just send a good old check through the mail. Make checks payable to “Nygaard Notes” and send to: Nygaard Notes, P.O. Box 14354, Minneapolis, MN 55414. Thank you!

--
Jeff Nygaard
National Writers Union
Twin Cities Local #13 UAW
Nygaard Notes
http://www.nygaardnotes.org

The World of Labor (December 30, 2005)


By Harry Kelber

Firestone Tappers in Liberia Condemned to Life of Squalor
Firestone rubber tappers, whose hard, productive labor has made the multibillion-dollar company one of the world¹s richest and most successful enterprise, are living in deplorable, dehumanizing conditions. A Daily Observer investigative team that visited the Firestone Plantation Dec. 17, saw windowless mud houses, some of them apparently built since the company started in 1926.

Inhabited by rubber-tree tappers, their wives and children, with no running water, no electricity and disgustingly primitive toilet and bathroom facilities, the conditions attest to the company¹s callous ingratitude for the billions of dollars made by the hands of these Liberian workers. In several of the Firestone camps, there is not a single kindergarten to accommodate the many hundreds of early-age children.

The Firestone workers are organized into a trade union, the Firestone Agriculture Workers¹ Union of Liberia (FAWLA), which is an affiliate of the Liberia Federation of Trade Unions. The union recently concluded a three-year agreement with the company, covering wages, working conditions and essential social services, including education for their children.

18,600 Afghans Lose Jobs as Brick Kilns Are Forced to Close
The non-availability of materials used in the manufacture of bricks has forced 75 brick kilns in Afghanistan¹s eastern Nangarhar province to shut down, depriving 18,600 workers of their jobs. The price of bricks, used as fuel, like coal, for house warming and cooking, has soared 30%, causing hardship among impoverished Afghans.

Mukhtar Ahmad, a worker at one of the brick-manufacturing plants, said the price of one ton of coal has doubled, from 4,000 afghans ($80) to 8.000 afghans ($160). The price for a ton of bricks has also increased, from 2,300 afghans to 3,100 afghans.

A spokesman for the Union of Brick Kilns, Mohammad Arit, said that nearly all the 18,600 workers had earlier been working in Pakistan. After the fall of the Taliban regime, most of the workers returned to Afghanistan, but now the closure of the kilns might force them to cross the border again.

Three Thai Auto Companies Face Strike Threats
More than 2,600 workers at three separate automotive companies that operate along Thai¹s eastern seaboard have threatened to strike if managers do not meet their demands for higher pay and benefits. Production at the Ford¹s Mazda assembly plant and several auto seat and glass factories in the region could be disrupted if the labor dispute cannot be settled.

Among the companies affected are AutoAlliance Thailand, a joint venture between Ford and Mazda; Saint-Gobain-Sekurit. An auto glass manufacturer, and General Seating Thailand, a manufacturer of car seats. Executives at all three companies say they hope to resolve the situations, but are prepared to hire temporary workers to ensure that production is not affected if strikes take place.

Labor leaders say the demands for higher wages are reasonable, given the huge profits of the auto industry, which set a record of more than one million vehicles produced in 2005. They also point to rising inflation and higher interest rates that have increased the cost of living for workers.

New Bolivian President Plans Tax on the Wealthy
The socialist president-elect of Bolivia, Evo Morales, has said he will cut his salary by half when he takes office next month, and he expects his cabinet to do the same. At the moment, Morales, an Aymara Indian born into poverty, rents a single room in a shared house before he moves into the presidential palace. The money saved by the salary cuts will go to social programs, particularly to education.

Morales has confirmed that his government plans to introduce a new tax on the wealthy as soon as possible. His advisers say they are planning to revoke a decree from 1985 which switched Bolivia to a free market economy recommended by Washington.

Morales has won wide support among Bolivian farmers for his pledge to allow them to grow coca plants, a major source of their income. Coca is used in the processing of cocaine. His first foreign trip will be to Cuba, a country he has long admired.

U.S. Mine Operator Gave Millions to Indonesian Military
A U.S. mining company, extracting gold from the largest reserve in the world in Indonesia¹s remote Papua province, has paid millions of dollars to the military and police there, the New York Times reported. From 1998 to 2004, the mining company, Freeport-McMoRan Grasberg, gave nearly $20 million to high-ranking Indonesian military and police and to military units, company records show.

The revelations come amid a corruption crackdown ordered by Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, who took office in October 2004 pledging to clean up a country consistently rated as one of the world¹s most graft-prone. The New Orleans-based company defended itself by saying it had provided a secure working environment for its more than 18,000 employees and contract workers in accordance with the U.S. and Indonesian laws.

The company has been one of the top sources of revenue for the Indonesian government, providing it with $33 billion in benefits from 1992 to 2004. This year it expects to pay the government $1 billion. Given the enormous security problems in Indonesia, the company regards huge payoffs as ³the cost of doing business² in that country.

Argentine Workers Take Control of Bankrupt Glass Factory
The workers of the San Justo glassworks in Buenos Aires never thought about owning their company until it went bankrupt four years ago. The factory is one of more than 100 ³recovered businesses² that are now putting themselves forward as an alternative business model for the country.

When the glassworks went bankrupt, a group of the workers, faced with losing their jobs, barricaded the factory gates for almost a year to stop the machinery from being taken away. They slept under canvas through the worst of the winter, while a lawyer argued their case in court. The workers claimed that because they had not been paid for months, they should have first right to the machinery and factory site. Eventually, a judge gave them permission to restart the furnaces.

Today, the 38 workers are once again making glass car headlights , exporting these as spare parts to other countries in South America. They earn about $500 a month, a good wage for Argentina and one that equals the best period when the factory was in private hands.

Our weekly columns, ³LaborTalk² and ³The World of Labor² can be viewed at our Web site: .

Journalists Should Expose Secrets, Not Keep Them

By Norman Solomon
t r u t h o u t | Perspective

Thursday 28 December 2005

Journalists should be in the business of providing timely information to the public. But some - notably at the top rungs of the profession - have become players in the power games of the nation's capital. And more than a few seem glad to imitate the officeholders who want to decide what the public shouldn't know.

When the New York Times front page broke the story of the National Security Agency's domestic spying, the newspaper's editors had good reason to feel proud. Or so it seemed. But there was a troubling back-story: the Times had kept the scoop under wraps for a long time.

The White House did what it could - including, as a last-ditch move, an early-December presidential meeting that brought Times publisher Arthur Sulzberger and executive editor Bill Keller to the Oval Office - in its efforts to persuade the Times not to report the story. The good news is that those efforts ultimately failed. The bad news is that they were successful for more than a year.

"The decision to hold the story last year was mine," Keller said, according to a Washington Post article that appeared 10 days after the Times's blockbuster December 16 story. He added: "The decision to run the story last week was mine. I'm comfortable with both decisions. Beyond that, there's just no way to have a full discussion of the internal procedural twists that media writers find so fascinating without talking about what we knew, when, and how - and that I can't do."

By all indications, the Times had the basic story in hand before the election in November 2004, when Bush defeated challenger John Kerry. In other words, if those running the New York Times had behaved like journalists instead of political players - if they had exposed this momentous secret instead of keeping it - there are good reasons to believe the outcome of the presidential election might have been different.

Chiseled into the stone facades of some courthouses is the credo "Justice delayed is justice denied." The same might be said of journalism, which derives much of its power from timeliness. When egregiously delayed, journalism is denied - or at least severely diminished.

Yet quite a few prominent journalists have expressed a strange kind of media solidarity with the Times's delay of the NSA story for so long.

Consider how the Washington Post intelligence reporter Dana Priest, for instance, responded to a request for "your opinion on the NY Times holding the domestic spying story for a year," during a December 22 online chat. "Well, first: I don't have a clue why they did so," Priest replied. "But I would give them the benefit of the doubt that it was for a good reason and, as their story said, they do more reporting within that year to satisfy themselves about certain things. Having read the story and the follow-ups, it's unclear why this would damage a valuable capability. Again, if the government doesn't think the bad guys believe their phones are tapped, they underestimate the enemy!"

Also opting to "give them the benefit of the doubt," some usually insightful media critics have gone out of their way to voice support for the Times's news management.

Deferring to the judgment of the executive editor of the New York Times may be akin to deferring to the judgment of the chief executive of the United States government. And as it happens, in this case, the avowed foreign policy goals of each do not appear to be in fundamental conflict - on the meaning of the Iraq war or the wisdom of enshrining a warfare state. Pretenses aside, the operative judgments from the New York Times's executive editor go way beyond the purely journalistic.

"So far, the passion to investigate the integrity of American intelligence-gathering belongs mostly to the doves, whose motives are subject to suspicion and who, in any case, do not set the agenda," Bill Keller wrote in an essay that appeared in the Times on June 14, 2003, shortly before he became executive editor. And Keller concluded: "The truth is that the information-gathering machine designed to guide our leaders in matters of war and peace shows signs of being corrupted. To my mind, this is a worrisome problem, but not because it invalidates the war we won. It is a problem because it weakens us for the wars we still face."

(By the way, Keller's phrase "the war we won" referred to the Iraq war.)

The story of the NSA's illicit domestic spying is not over. More holes are appearing in the Bush administration's damage-control claims. Media critics who affirm how important the story is - but make excuses for the long delay in breaking it - are part of a rationalizing process that has no end.

"The domestic spying controversy is a story of immense importance," Sydney Schanberg writes in the current Village Voice. The long delay before the Times published this "story of immense importance" does not seem to bother him much. "The paper had held the story for a year at the administration's pleading, but decided, after second thoughts and more reporting, that its importance required publication." Such wording should look at least a bit weird to journalistic eyes, but Schanberg doesn't muster any criticism, merely commenting: "From where I stand (I'm a Times alumnus), the paper should get credit for digging it out and publishing it."

Professional loyalties can't explain the extent of such uncritical media criticism from journalists. Many, like Schanberg, want to concentrate on the villainy of the Bush administration - as if it hasn't been aided and abetted by the New York Times's delay. Leading off his December 24 column with a blast at George W. Bush for "asserting the divine right of presidents," the Los Angeles Times media critic Tim Rutten proceeded with an essay that came close to asserting the divine right of executive editors to hold back vital stories for a very long time. Dismissing substantive criticism as the work of "paranoids," Rutten gave only laurels to the sovereign: "The New York Times deserves thanks and admiration for the service it has done the nation."

A cogent rebuttal to such testimonials came on December 26 from Miami Herald columnist Edward Wasserman, who wrote: "One of the more durable fallacies of ethical thought in journalism is the notion that doing right means holding back, that wrong is averted by leaving things out, reporting less or reporting nothing. When in doubt, kill the quote, hold the story - that's the ethical choice. But silence isn't innocent. It has consequences. In this case, it protected those within the government who believe that the law is a nuisance, that they don't have to play by the rules, by any rules, even their own."

While many journalists seem eager to downplay the importance of the Times's refusal to publish what it knew without long delay, Wasserman offers clarity: "Didn't the delay do harm? We know that thousands of people were subject to governmental intrusion that officials thought couldn't be justified even under a highly permissive set of laws. We also know that because knowledge of this illegality was kept confined to a small circle of initiates, the political system's response was postponed more than a year, and its ability to correct a serious abuse of power was thwarted. I don't know what the Times's brass was thinking. Maybe they just lost their nerve. Maybe they didn't want to tangle with a fiercely combative White House right before an election. But I do believe that withholding accurate information of great public importance is the most serious action any news organization can take. The reproach: 'You knew and you didn't tell us?' - reflects a fundamental professional betrayal."

Perhaps in 2007 we will learn that the New York Times had an explosive story about other ongoing government violations of civil liberties or some other crucial issue, but held it until after the November 2006 congressional elections. In that case, quite a few media critics and other journalists could recycle their pieces about giving the Times the benefit of the doubt and appreciating the quality of the crucial story that finally appeared.

--------

Norman Solomon's latest book is War Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep Spinning Us to Death. For information, go to: www.WarMadeEasy.com.