Saturday, April 24, 2010
SEC Watching Porn Instead of Financial Industry
by: Husna Haq Christian Science Monitor
Just when it was beginning to repair its reputation with its high-profile case against Goldman Sachs, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) suffers another major blow: Senior staffers there were surfing Internet pornography – as much as eight hours per day, in one case – when they were supposed to be policing the financial industry.
Perhaps this helps explain why the SEC didn't see the financial collapse coming. Or did nothing to stop Lehman Bros.’ questionable accounting tactics. Or Bernie Madoff’s dubious “investing” strategy."
They were busy with other things.
The information comes by way of a disturbing SEC memo to Sen. Chuck Grassley (R), who requested that the agency’s internal watchdog conduct an investigation. ABC News broke the story on its Thursday evening newscast.
The investigation found 31 serious offenders over the past two-and-a-half years, 17 of whom were senior SEC officers with salaries ranging from $100,000 to $222,000 per year.
The AP reports these highlights –
A senior attorney at the SEC's Washington headquarters spent up to eight hours a day looking at and downloading pornography. When he ran out of hard drive space, he burned the files to CDs or DVDs, which he kept in boxes around his office. He agreed to resign, an earlier watchdog report said.
An accountant was blocked more than 16,000 times in a month from visiting websites classified as "Sex" or "Pornography." Yet, he still managed to amass a collection of "very graphic" material on his hard drive by using Google images to bypass the SEC's internal filter, according to an earlier report from the inspector general. The accountant refused to testify in his defense and received a 14-day suspension.
Seventeen of the employees were "at a senior level," earning salaries of up to $222,418.
Rep. Darrell Issa (R) of California, called the scandal “nothing short of disturbing that high-ranking officials within the SEC were spending more time looking at pornography than taking action to help stave off the events that brought our nation’s economy to the brink of collapse.”
But, as the Washington Post reports, it’s not the first time government workers have been caught accessing pornography on the job. Employees at the National Science Foundation, the National Park Service, and even a chief judge of the US 9th Circuit Court of Appeals have been caught looking at pornography or posting sexually explicit content on personal websites.
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.
Dismantling the 5 Big Talking Points of Marijuana Prohibitionists
Opposition to this reform has crystallized within the drug war establishment, and so has their spin.
April 23, 2010
The war on drugs will be on the ballot in California this November. The nation will watch the state decide whether to tax and regulate marijuana or continue to arrest adults for possession of this plant. The vote on the Regulate, Control and Tax Cannabis Act of 2010 will impact many of the most important issues in the country today. Californians will express how they want police resources used, if adults who consume marijuana should be criminalized, how best to deal with the tragic violence in Mexico, and what our priorities should be in tough economic times. It’s no wonder that seven months out, this issue has already generated thousands of news stories around the world. Opposition to this reform has crystallized within the drug war establishment, and so has their spin. Here are their top five talking points and the truth beyond them:
Drug Warrior Spin #1: Why would we authorize another harmful substance in our society?
The reality is that marijuana is already widely available in our society. Like it or not, it’s a mainstream recreational drug consumed by millions, including one in ten Californians last year, according to federal data. The California ballot initiative simply acknowledges that marijuana is here and that it’s more sensible to regulate this massive market, like we do with even more harmful drugs like cigarettes and alcohol. Prohibition of highly popular substances never works and brings terrible collateral damage. Alcohol prohibition didn’t keep people from drinking, but it did give us Al Capone and gun battles in the streets. No one dies over sales of Budweiser today.
Drug Warrior Spin #2: Regulation will cause marijuana consumption to skyrocket with addiction rates to match.
The truth is rates of marijuana consumption aren’t determined by penalties against it. If they were, the U.S. – which arrests an astounding 750,000 people for marijuana possession every year – wouldn’t have double the consumption rate of The Netherlands, where marijuana sales have been tolerated for decades. That principle holds true across this country as some states that lowered penalties against marijuana possession years ago have among the lowest rates of use while some states that retained harsh marijuana laws have among the highest. As for addiction, the risk of becoming dependent on marijuana is mild compared to most other drugs including alcohol and tobacco. In fact, most people who enter treatment for marijuana addiction in this country today are referred by the criminal justice system, but 65% don’t even meet the standard criteria for dependence.
Drug Warrior Spin #3: Regulating marijuana will aid drug cartels.
It is practically Orwellian to claim that state regulation of marijuana would benefit criminal cartels. More than 20,000 Mexicans have died in the last three years thanks to prohibition. There is nothing inherent about the plant that has caused these brutal murders. Banning marijuana makes it worth more than gold, so valuable that people are willing to kill each other over the right to sell it. By regulating marijuana and beginning to bring its production and distribution under the rule of law, we would eliminate the cartels’ existing monopoly and dramatically siphon their profits. They would be the biggest losers in this reform.
Drug Warrior Spin #4: Regulating marijuana would cost society more than the taxes it generates.
Taxing marijuana like alcohol statewide would generate $1. 4 billion in California alone, according to the state Board of Equalization. Californians will also save hundreds of millions in scarce law enforcement dollars currently devoted to enforcing these futile laws. Yet opponents say that drugged driving, increased health care costs, and lost productivity will end up costing much more than taxes would generate. By that logic, alcohol, which causes nearly 100,000 American deaths annually, should be illegal and warrant life without parole. The bottom line is that marijuana is California’s largest agricultural commodity, freely consumed by millions with no regulations or protections, and with no financial benefit to the state. In this economic climate, this is a reality we literally can’t afford to ignore any longer.
Drug Warrior Spin #5: What kind of message does regulating marijuana send to kids?
The irony is that failed marijuana prohibition does nothing to protect kids. Despite 30 years of “Just Say No,” half of high-school seniors admit to trying marijuana. Students are more likely to smoke marijuana than cigarettes and say it’s easier to buy marijuana than alcohol because drug dealers don’t ask for ID. Even more chilling, of the 78,000 Californians arrested for marijuana offenses in 2008, one in five was a child under 18 and half were under 30. Out of control access and mass arrests are prohibition’s true impact on our youth. State regulation will reduce that access, separate marijuana from harder drugs, and allow us to focus on effective youth drug education programs. We will see these arguments play out repeatedly over the next six months. In the end, California will get to choose between two very different models of dealing with marijuana in our society.
Tony Newman is communications director for the Drug Policy Alliance.
Stephen Gutwillig is the California state director of the Drug Policy Alliance.
Tony Newman is communications director for the Drug Policy Alliance.
Stephen Gutwillig is the California state director of the Drug Policy Alliance.
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
DC Voting Rights
----- Original Message -----From: A. LoikowSent: 4/19/2010 2:34:16 PMSubject: Support Legislative Autonomy (and statehood as the only way for the people of D.C. to get their rights!)The D.C. Voting Rights Act which the House of Representatives may vote on this week is the Senate's bill. It ties giving the District a voting representative in the House with giving Utah another representative and contains the Ensign amendment taking away the D.C. Council's right to regulate firearms in the District of Columbia. As there is a strong likelihood of a constitutional challenge to giving our nonvoting delegate a vote in the House, D.C. residents most likely will get nothing from the bill if it passes but a lawsuit and a loss of the right to regulate firearms that we now have. Instead of really increasing our democratic rights, Utah will get an additional vote (the Republican trade off put in the bill when introduced years ago), which it should get on its own through redistricting due to the 2010 Census.Delegate Norton wants a vote no matter what. Since we are a colony and Congress can take away our rights to home rule and to legislate locally on anything, she says we should support this bill because Congress can pass a separate gun law at any time. That is true, but that is no reason to support a bill that takes away our existing rights and gives us very little in return. Delegate Norton should realize that Congress could take away tomorrow any vote it gave our delegate today. The only way to permanently get our full democratic rights, including full representation in our national legislature, is STATEHOOD.Unfortunately, the "voting rights" advocates have sufficiently muddied the issue and confused many people, including the President and many in Congress, so they think that this partial one vote in the House is progress. We have had 210 years of incremental back and forth in getting and losing our democratic rights. The only solution is full statehood. We should demand and accept nothing less.We need to tell Congress strongly and loudly that we want full statehood for D.C., not a colonial mishmash than can be revoked or changed at any time. Demand that the bill be killed and that a bill for full statehood for D.C. be introduced and passed. Only then will the people of the District reclaim the rights they lost in over two centuries ago.Assistant to the Speaker, Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) 202-225-5341 (Montgomery Ct)Here are the phone numbers:President Obama - 202-456-1111D.C. Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton - 202-225-8050House Judiciary Committee Chairman John Conyers (D-MI) - 202-225-5126Majority Leader, Rep. Steny Hoyer (D-MD) 202-225-4131 (P.G. County)Speaker of House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) 202-225-4965Please call ASAP and please sign Council Member Cheh's online petition (and add a comment supporting statehood!).
Thank you for speaking up for the democratic rights of 600,000 American citizens!
Ann Loikow
From: Cheh, Mary (COUNCIL)Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 11:41 AM
To: Zvenyach, Vladlen David (Council)
Subject: Support Legislative AutonomyNeighbors,As you may know, the DC Voting Rights Act is scheduled to be voted on by the US House of Representatives. I have started a petition opposing the bill, if it forces us to accept the inclusion of a NRA-backed provision depriving the District of the ability to enact reasonable gun-control legislation. To learn more, and to sign the petition, please visit my website (www.marycheh.com) or go directly to the petition at this link (http://www.marycheh.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=132:support-legislative-autonomy).Regards,Mary--------------------------Mary M. Cheh
Councilmember for Ward 3
Council of the District of Columbia1350 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Suite 108
Washington, DC 20004Tel: (202) 724-8062
Sunday, April 11, 2010
New evidence of Secret Service complicity in the JFK assassination
newsviewsnolose@yahoogroups.com on behalf of DickM (dick.mcmanus@yahoo.com)
April 7, 2010 MADISON, Wisconsin -- Douglas Horne, who served as the Senior Analyst for Military Affairs of the Assassination Records Review Board (ARRB), has now published INSIDE THE ARRB (2009), a five-volume study of the efforts of the board to declassify documents and records held by the CIA, the FBI, the Secret Service, and other government organizations related to the assassination of JFK.
Horne -- in Vol. IV of INSIDE THE ARRB (2009), has also demonstrated that the home movie of the assassination known as "the Zapruder film" -- and others that correspond to it, such as the Nix and Muchmore films -- have been massively edited to remove indications of Secret Service complicity in the crime and to add other events to these films in order to sow confusion and conceal evidence of the true causes of death of John F. Kennedy.
There are many proofs that the film has been fabricated—including that the driver brought the limo to a halt to make sure he would be killed and more than 60 witness reports of the limo stop.
Comment: This is the most damning evidence as it proves what I already write about in my online book….the CIA plotted to kill JFK. See: http://groups.
Indeed, in an appendix to Vol. IV, Horne explains that a copy of the film has now been studied by Hollywood exerts, who found that the blow-out to the back of his head had been painted over in black in an amateurish effort to obfuscate the blow out, which can actually be seen in a few later frames, including 372 and 374.
Horne has made a forceful declaration to set the record straight:
I know, from my former role as a government official on the staff of the ARRB (from 1995-1998), that there is overwhelming evidence of a government-directed medical cover-up in the death of JFK, and of wholesale destruction of autopsy photographs, autopsy x-rays, early versions of the autopsy report, and biological materials associated with the autopsy. Furthermore, dishonest autopsy photographs were created; skull x-rays were altered; the contents of the autopsy report changed over time as different versions were produced; and the brain photographs in the National Archives cannot be photographs of President Kennedy's brain -- they are fraudulent, substitute images of someone else's brain.
Comment: Pres. Johnson ordered the cover-up for fear that it would get American's all worked-up if they learned that Oswald had connections with the Soviets and Castro, and therein indicate the Soviets or Castor killed JFK, triggering a nuclear war which hawks in the US military were pushing for. The question I have is, when did the falsification of autopsy photographs, etc. start? Did it start before Hoover told Johnson that the CIA also may have killed JFK the day after the assassination? Yes, Hoover told this to Johnson on the morning following the assassination that either the Soviet or Castro, or the CIA was responsible to the assassination.
http://onlinejourna
NOTICE: Material posted to this mailing list is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and/or educational purposes. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107 of the US Copyright Law. http://www.law.
Help Give Away Supreme Court Protest Bumper Stickers, 8th Analysis Installment, And More
NOT The People" bumper stickers, which we have been sending out
mostly entirely for free, and more are being stuffed into envelopes
even as this alert is going out.
Now we need your help spreading this initiative to reverse the outlaw
Supreme Court even further and wider. We have created a special page
where you can pick up a 25-pack of these dynamic messages stickers,
at a very modest cost, just so we can keep this thing going.
Bulk Bumper Stickers: http://www.usalone.com/bumper_stickers_bulk.php
Please consider being the hero activist in your neighborhood by
distributing these bumpers stickers that EVERYBODY wants. Of all the
issues we have addressed in the last 5 years, this is the one that
has people mobilized the most, for on the issue of control of our
government by the corporations turns the survival of our democracy
itself.
And if you somehow missed the previous alerts and just want a free
sticker for yourself that would be this page.
Free Bumper Stickers: http://www.usalone.com/bumper_stickers.php
Not surprisingly, this is also the top issue at the new Independent
Voters page on Facebook. So again, if you are already on Facebook we
urgently need you to get involved there. We have a totally wide open
vote going on what the "Statement of Priorities" for this new
resource should be, so please go to the link below and participate
making sure YOUR priorities are represented.
[Facebook] Independent Voters page:
http://www.facebook.com/Independent.Voters?v=app_109302975758164
And again, please be patient if you are not a Facebook kind of
person, because we WILL build out an alternate connection page for
you once we get the thing really rolling.
You can even get the free bumper stickers from the Facebook page too!
[Facebook] Free Bumper Stickers:
http://www.facebook.com/Independent.Voters?v=app_106690312695773
The rest of the alert we will dedicate to the next of our much
anticipated installments tearing up into little itsy bitsy pieces the
rogue Supreme Court ruling to declare our country the kingdom of the
corporations. We're not proud, we're not tired. But there are still
yet more fundamental and unforgivable errors in this opinion we have
not yet addressed. This is the eighth, and it is entitled:
First Amendment Absolutism, But Only For Corporations Says The
Supreme Court 5
Here we confront the shameless hypocrisy of creating a super
protected status for the "speech" (amounting to nothing more than the
power to spend vast sums of money) of corporations, by the same
Supreme Court line up that has demonstrated zero tolerance for the
"free" speech of just about anybody else.
In his opinion, Kennedy, writing for The Supreme Court 5 (including
Roberts, Scalia, Thomas and Alito), can find no other reading of the
First Amendment except that the "speech" of corporations cannot be
constrained in any way "beyond all doubt" (opinion p. 19). Even
requiring them to maintain a PAC as a vehicle for their political
speech is too onerous of a paperwork burden he says (opinion pp.
20-21). And though previous courts and Congress have long recognized
a compelling governmental interest making sure ordinary citizens were
not drowned by a flood of corporate money, for Kennedy this was
somehow a new invention of the Austin case that he then arrogates to
overrule (opinion p. 31), specifically a governmental interest in
preventing
"... the corrosive and distorting effects of immense aggregations of
wealth that are accumulated with the help of the corporate form and
that have little or no correlation to the public's support for the
corporation's political ideas."
That quote from Austin actually sounds pretty good to us just as it
was.
And of course his own citations to other cases which he provides for
this very quote proves that this concept in law is nothing new, but
instead backed by a long line of case precedents. On another page
(opinion p. 27) Kennedy cites a minority opinion from 1948, where
they complain that the majority in that case (U.S. vs. CIO) should
not have limited "undue influence" by a speaker's "large
expenditures". The point he was attempting to make was that there has
always been a line of dissent, of course proving nothing more than it
has always been the minority view.
The precept that there is a compelling governmental interest in
limiting undue financial influence over our elections has been long
recognized, long acknowledged, and long accepted, except by this same
grousing, grudge settling minority (indeed two of these same judges
were the dissenters in the Austin case itself), but which by the
unfortunate and ill-advised seating of one final corporatist partisan
has now been empowered to execute their long plotted judicial coup.
So what, you might now be asking yourselves, would be a compelling
governmental interest in limiting free speech? The opinion cites a
handful of some 20-30 plus year old cases, examples of people in the
military, people in prison, etc. (opinion pp. 24-25) But of course we
don't have to look that far to find evidence of Kennedy's hypocrisy.
This same line up of judges has spoken very recently on the free
speech rights of ACTUAL people, and let's just see what they said.
In Garcetti v. Ceballos, 547 U.S. 410 (2006), Kennedy wrote the
opinion that a whistle blower, who was a deputy district attorney,
could be retaliated against for speaking out against wrongdoing by
the police. Somehow defending the free speech of someone charged with
protecting the integrity of our law enforcement agencies was not a
compelling government interest. But making sure multi-national
corporations are not even slightly inconvenienced in buying our
elections? That is, according to this same judge.
In Morse v. Frederick, 551 U.S. 393 (2007), Roberts wrote the opinion
that unfurling a nonsensical joke banner ("Bong Hits For Jesus") off
of school property was such a threat to the foundations of our
society that it must be stamped out with the biggest possible boot, a
dire governmental emergency. But having our policy debate leading up
to an election totally dominated by corporate special interests? For
Roberts, not so much.
Yes, when it comes to actual people or real compelling interests
(like stopping police wrongdoing) the First Amendment is not for us.
Because we now have a majority on our Supreme Court for which only
the rights of corporations are supreme, inviolable, and sacrosanct.
But for more evidence of just how dreadfully bad this decision is,
you will have to wait until the ninth bone chilling installment of
the Night of the Living Dead Dissents.
Please take action NOW, so we can win all victories that are supposed
to be ours, and forward this alert as widely as possible.
If you would like to get alerts like these, you can do so at
http://www.usalone.com/in.htm
usalone389b:340229
Saturday, April 10, 2010
A Quiet Giant
by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t Op-Ed
(Photo: Obama-Biden Transition Project / Flickr)
A Quiet Giant
Ever heard of a guy named William Johnson? How about Ward Hunt? Do the names Frank Murphy, Tom Clark, Stanley Matthews, Samuel Nelson, William Strong, Joseph Bradley, John Catron, David Brewer, Edward White or Horace Lurton ring a bell?
Unless you're a legal scholar or historian, those names are almost certainly not going to be familiar to you. Those men were all Supreme Court Justices at one time or another, and though the decisions they rendered live on within our judicial system, they themselves have been largely forgotten by history.
AudioPlayer.setup("http://www.truthout.org/video123/audio/player.swf", {
width: 290
});
Press play to listen to author William Rivers Pitt read his column, " A Quiet Giant":
AudioPlayer.embed("audioplayer_1", {soundFile: "http://www.truthout.org/video123/audio/WillPitt_04-10-10_Quiet-Giant.mp3"});
Of the 111 people who have served on the high court since its inception, only a relatively small handful are still remembered today.
Those names, of course, are far more familiar. Taney, Chase, Holmes Jr., Brandeis, Cardozo, Black, Frankfurter, Douglas, Warren, Brennan, Stuart, Marshall, Burger, Blackmun - these were the ones who changed the course and nature of this nation from the bench.
It is a sad truth that a great many Americans don't know who these people were - after all, it is an even sadder truth that most people don't know the names of the Justices serving at present - but the lives of every living American have been touched, in one way or another, by the decisions rendered by those individuals, and by the 96 others who have likewise served on the court.
Well, that number is about to go to 112. Justice John Paul Stevens, appointed by President Ford in 1975, has announced he will retire this summer.
Predictably, all hell will be breaking loose in short order as everyone in Washington is going to battle stations. President Obama has to pick a successor, Senate Democrats are going to have to navigate another confirmation process, and to nobody's surprise, the GOP is going to go absolutely bat-poop crazy to thwart and upend the process.
The TV news networks are rejoicing at Stevens' retirement, because they more than anyone else love a good rhubarb. Coverage of this is going to focus largely on who the newest nominee will be, what the lay of the land in the Senate is, and what manner of deranged accusations will be leveled at Obama and his nominee by congressional Republicans, the right-wing media, and the bevy of presidential wanna-bes like Palin and Romney who are scurrying around the countryside attending Tea Party rallies trying to gin up support for their erstwhile campaigns.
A Supreme Court nomination and confirmation is a big, fat, juicy target, and you can bet the entire GOP will be taking some big swings.
That's all well and good, but before we turn our attention to what's coming, we must pause a moment to contemplate the man who has initiated this situation. John Paul Stevens was, very quietly, a giant on the court, and like his famous colleagues, he deserves to be remembered far after he finally steps down.
The New York Times on Friday described him thusly:
A soft-spoken Republican and former antitrust lawyer from Chicago, Justice Stevens has led liberals on a court that has become increasingly conservative. He was appointed by President Gerald Ford in December 1975 to succeed Justice William O. Douglas, who had retired the month before. He is the longest-serving current justice by more than a decade.
He joined the court when it included Thurgood Marshall and William J. Brennan Jr., who along with Justice Douglas had been liberal stalwarts of the Warren court era. Also serving were Lewis F. Powell Jr., a Nixon appointee who voted with the court's conservatives on criminal justice issues but was a strong supporter of abortion rights, and Potter Stewart, the last of President Dwight D. Eisenhower's four Supreme Court appointees, who, like Justice Stevens, was a moderate Republican from the Midwest.
For most of his first two decades on the court, Justice Stevens labored in the shadows of those large figures, and was known to the public, if at all, mainly for the jaunty bow ties that were his sartorial trademark. After 1994, though, when the retirement of Justice Harry A. Blackmun made Justice Stevens the court's senior associate, the language of his dissents started to become noticeably sharper, with a theme running through them: that the Supreme Court had lost touch with fundamental notions of fair play.
Confronted with a court far more conservative than the one he joined, Justice Stevens showed the world what his colleagues already knew: that beneath his amiable manner lay a canny strategist and master tactician, qualities he used to win victories that by a simple liberal-conservative head count would appear to be impossible. A frequent dissenter even in his early years on the court, he now wrote more blunt and passionate opinions, explaining on several occasions that the nation was best served by an open airing of disagreements.
What is perhaps most remarkable about Justice Stevens is the fact that he was a Republican, was nominated by a Republican president, but over time became the most liberal voice on the court. His opinions on abortion, gay rights and affirmative action made a lot of right-wing heads explode over the years, to be sure, and that can be almost entirely be chalked up to the fact that, in the second half of his tenure, the court began filling up with the kind of conservative thinkers who turn Republicans into Democrats.
Confronted by the likes of Renquist, Scalia and Thomas, Justice Stevens tacked steadily to the left and away from the party that nominated him in the first place.
Justice Stevens left his most significant mark with two documents, one a decision and the other a dissent. In Hamdan v. Rumsfeld (2006), Stevens declared the opinion of the court that military commissions set up by the Bush administration to hold tribunals for detainees at Guantanamo Bay violated the Uniform Code of Military Justice and the Geneva Convention, and therefore could not proceed.
This was the first significant blow against the manner in which the Bush administration was pursuing its so-called War on Terror, and against the Unitary Executive Theory, which defined their my-way-or-the-highway approach to policy. This decision is likely to be used by other detainees who bring legal actions regarding their treatment and detention.
The other document, a dissent, was nothing less than a thunderclap, perhaps the most significant dissent of the last 50 years.
In Bush v. Gore (2000), the court leaned on a wildly dubious Equal Protection argument to decide the 2000 presidential election in favor of George W. Bush. The dissent penned by Justice Stevens was as scathing, and as accurate, as anything ever rendered by the high court. It read, in part:
Finally, neither in this case, nor in its earlier opinion in Palm Beach County Canvassing Bd. v. Harris, 2000 WL 1725434 (Fla., Nov. 21, 2000), did the Florida Supreme Court make any substantive change in Florida electoral law. Its decisions were rooted in long-established precedent and were consistent with the relevant statutory provisions, taken as a whole. It did what courts do - it decided the case before it in light of the legislature's intent to leave no legally cast vote uncounted. In so doing, it relied on the sufficiency of the general "intent of the voter" standard articulated by the state legislature, coupled with a procedure for ultimate review by an impartial judge, to resolve the concern about disparate evaluations of contested ballots. If we assume - as I do - that the members of that court and the judges who would have carried out its mandate are impartial, its decision does not even raise a colorable federal question.
What must underlie petitioners' entire federal assault on the Florida election procedures is an unstated lack of confidence in the impartiality and capacity of the state judges who would make the critical decisions if the vote count were to proceed. Otherwise, their position is wholly without merit. The endorsement of that position by the majority of this Court can only lend credence to the most cynical appraisal of the work of judges throughout the land. It is confidence in the men and women who administer the judicial system that is the true backbone of the rule of law. Time will one day heal the wound to that confidence that will be inflicted by today's decision. One thing, however, is certain. Although we may never know with complete certainty the identity of the winner of this year's Presidential election, the identity of the loser is perfectly clear. It is the Nation's confidence in the judge as an impartial guardian of the rule of law.
If nothing else, history will remember Justice Stevens for these words. Had his voice been the majority opinion, as it should have been, we would all have been spared a decade of horror, loss, bloodshed and wanton executive criminality. It's pretty much just exactly that simple.
You were right, Mr. Justice. Thank you for your service, and Godspeed. You will be missed.
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.
Share41
A Quiet Giant
Saturday 10 April 2010
by: William Rivers Pitt, t r u t h o u t Op-Ed
(Photo: Obama-Biden Transition Project / Flickr)
Ever heard of a guy named William Johnson? How about Ward Hunt? Do the names Frank Murphy, Tom Clark, Stanley Matthews, Samuel Nelson, William Strong, Joseph Bradley, John Catron, David Brewer, Edward White or Horace Lurton ring a bell?
Unless you're a legal scholar or historian, those names are almost certainly not going to be familiar to you. Those men were all Supreme Court Justices at one time or another, and though the decisions they rendered live on within our judicial system, they themselves have been largely forgotten by history.
AudioPlayer.setup("http://www.truthout.org/video123/audio/player.swf", {
width: 290
});
Press play to listen to author William Rivers Pitt read his column, " A Quiet Giant":
AudioPlayer.embed("audioplayer_1", {soundFile: "http://www.truthout.org/video123/audio/WillPitt_04-10-10_Quiet-Giant.mp3"});
Of the 111 people who have served on the high court since its inception, only a relatively small handful are still remembered today.
Those names, of course, are far more familiar. Taney, Chase, Holmes Jr., Brandeis, Cardozo, Black, Frankfurter, Douglas, Warren, Brennan, Stuart, Marshall, Burger, Blackmun - these were the ones who changed the course and nature of this nation from the bench.
It is a sad truth that a great many Americans don't know who these people were - after all, it is an even sadder truth that most people don't know the names of the Justices serving at present - but the lives of every living American have been touched, in one way or another, by the decisions rendered by those individuals, and by the 96 others who have likewise served on the court.
Well, that number is about to go to 112. Justice John Paul Stevens, appointed by President Ford in 1975, has announced he will retire this summer.
Predictably, all hell will be breaking loose in short order as everyone in Washington is going to battle stations. President Obama has to pick a successor, Senate Democrats are going to have to navigate another confirmation process, and to nobody's surprise, the GOP is going to go absolutely bat-poop crazy to thwart and upend the process.
The TV news networks are rejoicing at Stevens' retirement, because they more than anyone else love a good rhubarb. Coverage of this is going to focus largely on who the newest nominee will be, what the lay of the land in the Senate is, and what manner of deranged accusations will be leveled at Obama and his nominee by congressional Republicans, the right-wing media, and the bevy of presidential wanna-bes like Palin and Romney who are scurrying around the countryside attending Tea Party rallies trying to gin up support for their erstwhile campaigns.
A Supreme Court nomination and confirmation is a big, fat, juicy target, and you can bet the entire GOP will be taking some big swings.
That's all well and good, but before we turn our attention to what's coming, we must pause a moment to contemplate the man who has initiated this situation. John Paul Stevens was, very quietly, a giant on the court, and like his famous colleagues, he deserves to be remembered far after he finally steps down.
The New York Times on Friday described him thusly:
A soft-spoken Republican and former antitrust lawyer from Chicago, Justice Stevens has led liberals on a court that has become increasingly conservative. He was appointed by President Gerald Ford in December 1975 to succeed Justice William O. Douglas, who had retired the month before. He is the longest-serving current justice by more than a decade.
He joined the court when it included Thurgood Marshall and William J. Brennan Jr., who along with Justice Douglas had been liberal stalwarts of the Warren court era. Also serving were Lewis F. Powell Jr., a Nixon appointee who voted with the court's conservatives on criminal justice issues but was a strong supporter of abortion rights, and Potter Stewart, the last of President Dwight D. Eisenhower's four Supreme Court appointees, who, like Justice Stevens, was a moderate Republican from the Midwest.
For most of his first two decades on the court, Justice Stevens labored in the shadows of those large figures, and was known to the public, if at all, mainly for the jaunty bow ties that were his sartorial trademark. After 1994, though, when the retirement of Justice Harry A. Blackmun made Justice Stevens the court's senior associate, the language of his dissents started to become noticeably sharper, with a theme running through them: that the Supreme Court had lost touch with fundamental notions of fair play.
Confronted with a court far more conservative than the one he joined, Justice Stevens showed the world what his colleagues already knew: that beneath his amiable manner lay a canny strategist and master tactician, qualities he used to win victories that by a simple liberal-conservative head count would appear to be impossible. A frequent dissenter even in his early years on the court, he now wrote more blunt and passionate opinions, explaining on several occasions that the nation was best served by an open airing of disagreements.
What is perhaps most remarkable about Justice Stevens is the fact that he was a Republican, was nominated by a Republican president, but over time became the most liberal voice on the court. His opinions on abortion, gay rights and affirmative action made a lot of right-wing heads explode over the years, to be sure, and that can be almost entirely be chalked up to the fact that, in the second half of his tenure, the court began filling up with the kind of conservative thinkers who turn Republicans into Democrats.
Confronted by the likes of Renquist, Scalia and Thomas, Justice Stevens tacked steadily to the left and away from the party that nominated him in the first place.
Justice Stevens left his most significant mark with two documents, one a decision and the other a dissent. In Hamdan v. Rumsfeld (2006), Stevens declared the opinion of the court that military commissions set up by the Bush administration to hold tribunals for detainees at Guantanamo Bay violated the Uniform Code of Military Justice and the Geneva Convention, and therefore could not proceed.
This was the first significant blow against the manner in which the Bush administration was pursuing its so-called War on Terror, and against the Unitary Executive Theory, which defined their my-way-or-the-highway approach to policy. This decision is likely to be used by other detainees who bring legal actions regarding their treatment and detention.
The other document, a dissent, was nothing less than a thunderclap, perhaps the most significant dissent of the last 50 years.
In Bush v. Gore (2000), the court leaned on a wildly dubious Equal Protection argument to decide the 2000 presidential election in favor of George W. Bush. The dissent penned by Justice Stevens was as scathing, and as accurate, as anything ever rendered by the high court. It read, in part:
Finally, neither in this case, nor in its earlier opinion in Palm Beach County Canvassing Bd. v. Harris, 2000 WL 1725434 (Fla., Nov. 21, 2000), did the Florida Supreme Court make any substantive change in Florida electoral law. Its decisions were rooted in long-established precedent and were consistent with the relevant statutory provisions, taken as a whole. It did what courts do - it decided the case before it in light of the legislature's intent to leave no legally cast vote uncounted. In so doing, it relied on the sufficiency of the general "intent of the voter" standard articulated by the state legislature, coupled with a procedure for ultimate review by an impartial judge, to resolve the concern about disparate evaluations of contested ballots. If we assume - as I do - that the members of that court and the judges who would have carried out its mandate are impartial, its decision does not even raise a colorable federal question.
What must underlie petitioners' entire federal assault on the Florida election procedures is an unstated lack of confidence in the impartiality and capacity of the state judges who would make the critical decisions if the vote count were to proceed. Otherwise, their position is wholly without merit. The endorsement of that position by the majority of this Court can only lend credence to the most cynical appraisal of the work of judges throughout the land. It is confidence in the men and women who administer the judicial system that is the true backbone of the rule of law. Time will one day heal the wound to that confidence that will be inflicted by today's decision. One thing, however, is certain. Although we may never know with complete certainty the identity of the winner of this year's Presidential election, the identity of the loser is perfectly clear. It is the Nation's confidence in the judge as an impartial guardian of the rule of law.
If nothing else, history will remember Justice Stevens for these words. Had his voice been the majority opinion, as it should have been, we would all have been spared a decade of horror, loss, bloodshed and wanton executive criminality. It's pretty much just exactly that simple.
You were right, Mr. Justice. Thank you for your service, and Godspeed. You will be missed.
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.
Last Year's Supreme Court Finalists Rise to Top of Obama's List
Saturday 10 April 2010
by: Michael Doyle McClatchy Newspapers
(Image: Lance Page / t r u t h o u t; Adapted: FaceMePLS, Leo Reynolds)
Last Year's Supreme Court Finalists Rise to Top of Obama's List
Washington - Being the best isn't good enough. President Barack Obama's next Supreme Court nominee could also use a compelling story and, perhaps, a little nudge.
Ivy League pedigrees, Phi Beta Kappa keys and groundbreaking reputations abound among Obama's potential nominees. The Senate has previously confirmed some of them for high-level posts. Raw merit, however, won't easily separate the winner from the also-rans.
Instead, age, gender, religion and racial identities might all help tip the balance now. Personal chemistry counts. So does political viability: How much of a fight does Obama want?
"I will seek someone in the coming weeks with . . . an independent mind, a record of excellence and integrity, a fierce dedication to the rule of law, and a keen understanding of how the law affects the daily lives of the American people," Obama said Friday.
Solicitor General Elena Kagan and Chicago-based appellate judge Diane Wood were seriously considered for the last court vacancy, before Obama opted for Sonia Sotomayor. Kagan and Wood are again presumed top-level contenders, though in the past year their relative chances may have shifted.
Kagan is younger, as she turns 50 on April 28. Wood is 59. The modest-sounding difference could matter, if Obama reasons that the younger the justice, the longer she'll have to become a force on the court.
Sotomayor was 54 when Obama nominated her last year.
"I tend to think of all these people as being in their prime," Princeton University Provost Christopher Eisgruber, author of "The Next Justice," said in an interview, "but there is a school of thinking that the president should look at the youngest nominee."
The former dean of Harvard Law School, Kagan over the past year has extended her experience beyond the ivory tower. By personally arguing half-a-dozen cases before the Supreme Court since September, Kagan could now counter some of last year's criticism.
"I don't send patients to the professors at the university unless they're the expert in the field who have actually practiced rather than just taught," Republican Sen. Tom Coburn of Oklahoma told Kagan in 2009. "(You have) this wonderful resume . . . but yet, you've never been a justice and you've never actually been a litigant. "
Wood, by contrast, has spent 15 years on the Chicago-based Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. She gets uniformly high marks from the lawyers who practice before the circuit, although her long tenure also gives potential opponents more written opinions to chew over.
"She has a very long paper trail," Lee Epstein, a professor at Northwestern University Law School, noted in an interview.
Like Kagan, who graduated from Princeton and Harvard Law School, Wood has a stellar academic record, earning Phi Beta Kappa membership and ranking third in her law school class.
Potential nominee Merrick Garland, a 57-year-old appellate judge who serves in the District of Columbia, is another academic standout, having graduated summa cum laude from Harvard and Harvard Law School.
As a graduate of the University of Texas and its law school, Wood also offers Obama the chance to reach beyond the traditional Ivy League orbit. Tellingly, every remaining justice with Stevens' retirement holds at least one Ivy League degree. The last justice to have graduated from a public university law school, Warren Burger, retired in 1986.
"We have a very East Coast-biased court right now," Epstein said, adding that this perception could prove "helpful" to Wood's prospects.
Like Kagan, the first female solicitor general and first female Harvard Law School dean, Wood has been a groundbreaker.
In 1990, she became the first woman to hold an endowed chair at the University of Chicago Law School. While pregnant with her second child, she helped develop the school's maternity leave and, later, sexual harassment policies.
"Lawyers report that she is both scholarly and practical, thoughtful and decisive," the Chicago Council of Lawyers concluded when she was nominated in 1995.
Both Kagan and Wood would be classified as liberal. Each has taken positions sure to draw GOP attention. Kagan, for instance, opposed military recruiting at Harvard because of the Pentagon's policy that bars openly gay service members.
Wood, while still a full-time law school professor, was a member of groups including Planned Parenthood and the National Organization for Women.
A former federal prosecutor, who oversaw some high-profile criminal cases, Garland has a record more generally classified as moderate. Sotomayor, too, had prior experience as a federal prosecutor that proved helpful in winning Senate converts.
Kagan has never been married, while Wood is now on her third marriage. Garland is married.
Kagan is Jewish, as are two of the current justices. Six of the nine current justices are Roman Catholic.
A little bit of personal chemistry can help, or hinder.
Justice Stephen Breyer famously lost his first shot at the Supreme Court in 1993 because of an awkward initial interview with then-President Bill Clinton. This year, it may or may not help Wood that she knows Obama from their days teaching law at the University of Chicago.
"The president has to be comfortable with this person, who will be part of their legacy," Eisgruber noted.
Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm and Pasadena, Calif., appellate Judge Kim Wardlaw also give Obama the opportunity to add a third woman justice for the first time in the Supreme Court's history. The Canadian-born Granholm, a 51-year-old Harvard Law School graduate, offers Obama a chance to get a seasoned politician on the bench.
The 55-year-old Wardlaw, too, is a bit of a mold-breaker. The daughter of a Mexican-American mother, Wardlaw attended community college in Northern California before graduating with top honors from UCLA.
Still other names will rise and fall in coming days, from Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to Attorney General Eric Holder. Some of these names could be bona fide trial balloons, while others will be rank speculation.
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.
Marijuana Legalization: The Pay-Any-Price Principle
by: David Sirota, t r u t h o u t Op-Ed
(Photo: ilmungo / Flickr)
Marijuana Legalization: The Pay-Any-Price Principle
When choosing between frugality and security, history shows that America almost always selects the latter. To paraphrase President Kennedy, we'll pay any price and bear any burden to protect ourselves.
No doubt this was why the economic case against the Iraq invasion failed. To many, the war debate seemed to pose a binary question: debt or mushroom clouds? And when itís a scuffle between money arguments and security arguments (even dishonest security arguments), security wins every time.
Call this the Pay-Any-Price Principle -- an axiom that has impacted all of America's wars, and now, most poignantly, its War on Drugs. When faced with criticism of budget-busting prosecution and incarceration costs, law enforcement agencies and private prison interests have successfully depicted their cause as a willingness to pay any price to jail dealers of hard narcotics.
Of course, data undermine that story line. In 2008, the FBI reported that 82 percent of drug arrests were for possession -- not sales or manufacturing -- and almost half of those arrests were for marijuana, not hard drugs.
Fortunately, these numbers are seeping into the public consciousness. Gallup's latest survey shows record support for marijuana legalization, as more Americans see the Drug War for what it really is: an ideological and profit-making crusade by the Arrest-and-Incarceration Complex against a substance that is, according to most physicians, less toxic than alcohol.
Considering both the public opinion shift and the facts about marijuana, this should be the moment that drug policy reformers drop their budget attacks and flip the security argument on their opponents -- specifically, by pointing out how safety is actually compromised by the status quo.
The good news is that some activists are making this very case.
Last week, students at 80 colleges asked their schools to reduce penalties for marijuana possession so that they are no greater than penalties for alcohol possession. It's a request with safety in mind: According to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, alcohol use by college kids contributes to roughly 1,700 deaths, 600,000 injuries and 97,000 sexual assaults every year. By contrast, "The use of marijuana itself has not been found to contribute to any deaths, there has never been a single fatal marijuana overdose in history (and) all objective research on marijuana has also concluded that it does not contribute to injuries, assaults, sexual abuse, or violent or aggressive behavior," as the group Safer Alternative For Enjoyable Recreation notes.
"It's time we stop driving students to drink and let them make the rational, safer choice to use marijuana," said one student.
Now the bad news: Not every reformer is on message.
In California, where polls show most citizens support cannabis legalization, The New York Times reports that backers of a legalization ballot measure "will not dwell on assertions of marijuana's harmlessness" but "rather on (the) cold cash" pot can generate for depleted state coffers.
The problem is not these advocates' facts -- California officials confirm that legal marijuana could generate more than $1 billion in tax revenue. The problem goes back to the Pay-Any-Price Principle.
By downplaying the argument about giving society a safer alternative to alcohol, California's legalization advocates are letting drug warriors reclaim the language of security, to the point where even liberal Democratic Sen. Barbara Boxer's campaign now trumpets her opposition to the initiative on the grounds that "she shares the (safety) concerns of police chiefs, sheriffs and other law enforcement officials."
A career politician, Boxer understands that if this battle reverts to the old tax-revenue-versus-safety fight, voters will choose safety. In other words, she gets the Pay-Any-Price Principle.
To maximize this opportune moment for drug policy changes, every reformer must appreciate that principle, too -- and finally confront it head on.
David Sirota is the author of the best-selling books "Hostile Takeover" and "The Uprising." He hosts the morning show on AM760 in Colorado and blogs at OpenLeft.com. E-mail him at ds@davidsirota.com or follow him on Twitter @davidsirota.
Copyright 2010 Creators.com
All republished content that appears on Truthout has been obtained by permission or license.
Thursday, April 08, 2010
Nygaard Notes / Social Security
Independent Periodic News and Analysis
Number 453, April 7, 2010
On the Web at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/
******
This Week: Social Security, Etc
1. “Quote” of the Week
2. Report on Some Recent Social Security Hysteria
3. Debunking the Recent Misinformation on Social Security
4. Military Leader Upset With Peace Movement—Stop the Presses!
5. A Tale of Two Militaries
******
Greetings,
Sorry, no room for an editor’s note in this edition.
It’s too long already!
All I’ll say is that the spell checkers in U.S.-made computers go crazy when I write about Pakistan and Afghanistan. Funny. See you next week,Nygaard
******
1.“Quote” of the WeekWriting about the phenomenon of some people getting very famous and often very wealthy for “inventing” (or at least for patenting) something or other, authors Gar Alperovitz and Lew Daly make an important point about the myth that great inventions and innovations come about solely because of the peculiar gifts of the “geniuses” among us. Writing in the current issue of Dollars & Sense, they say that“Most breakthroughs occur not so much thanks to one “genius,” but because of the longer historical unfolding of knowledge. All of this knowledge—the overwhelming source of all modern wealth—comes to us today through no effort of our own. It is the generous and unearned gift of the past.”
******
2.Report on Some Recent Social Security HysteriaHere are a few selections from recent corporate media, all speaking about Social Security:>From the Star-News, of Wilmington, NC, March 23: “The program's dismal outlook has long been known...”The ever-corporate Investor's Business Daily on March 30th said that “There is no trust fund.”Here’s a headline from New York Newsday, March 25: “Social Security in Red for 2010.”According to the March 15th Associated Press, "there's concern that the looming crisis will lead to reduced benefits.”And, finally, the venerable New York Times on March 25 said that Social Security has reached “a tipping point—the first step of a long, slow march to insolvency...”“Dismal outlook.” “No trust fund.” “In the Red.” “Looming crisis.” “Slow march to insolvency.” Wow! This sounds serious!The only serious thing about all this hysteria is that quite a few people appear to believe it.Since the day it was created in 1935 Social Security has been hated by some people in this country. They hate it because of what it is: A program that redistributes wealth for the purpose of providing security to people in the event of disability, death, or retirement. There are still people who hate the idea of a public program that socializes the concern for security for all (“Social” and “Security” are not random words here) in the form of near-universal taxation and near-universal benefits. “Redistribution” is a dirty word for some people, as it interferes with the workings of “the market.”For this reason the propaganda about Social Security has been non-stop, at least since I started intensively studying the program in 1997. The result of all this propaganda is that more and more people every year, including media people, are prepared to believe the worst about the program, as the quotations above illustrate.Here are a few basic points about Social Security to keep in mind when we are bombarded with Propaganda like that above. In no particular order...1. About that “looming crisis” and the “slow march to insolvency.” Well, the current official projections show a revenue shortfall for the program that will hit in the year 2037, assuming that absolutely nothing is done in the meantime. Two points here: I invite readers to let me know if you are aware of any other large program—public or private—that even attempts to tell you what will be happening with its finances 27 years in the future. I don’t think you can. Social Security is required to project far into the future in order to allow legislators to make changes to the program well in advance in order to assure the solvency and continued viability of the program. And they project really far into the future—they actually look 75 years ahead!—in order to avoid needless disruptions and worry on the part of future recipients.So that’s what’s happening: The Social Security actuaries are telling us that we need to make some changes in the next couple of decades if we don’t want the program to come up short. If some potential problems 27 years in the future add up to a “dismal outlook,” then I wish my personal finances were so dismal.2. “There is no Trust Fund.” Yes there is. This is so stupid that it irritates me to have to keep addressing it. But I do address it in the other article about Social Security in this issue.3. “Social Security is in the red.” No it’s not. Again, see the other article about Social Security in this issue.4. We have reached a “tipping point.” I don’t know what this means, but the fact that some of this year’s Social Security benefits will be paid with funds coming from interest on the Trust Fund instead of coming 100 per cent from this year’s tax revenues is something that has been projected since about 1983. I can’t imagine why it would be considered a “tipping point.” And the Trust Fund, as we reach this “tipping point,” still has approximately $2.6 trillion in it. Yes: Trillion, with a “T.”5. Finally, one thing that is rarely heard in the talk about the government’s role in keeping the current recession from expanding into a full-blown depression is that we have a huge program in place that functions to prop up consumer demand during hard times: Social Security. That’s right, when people are losing their employment income, and home equity is evaporating, and income from investments is shrinking dramatically, there are not too many things that remain constant in terms of providing income to people who will immediately pump that money back into the economy. The “tipping point” of having to draw on the interest in order to pump money into the economy is a function of the recession (which depresses Social Security tax revenues), and has nothing to do with the basic health of the program.Despite the U.S. going through at least ten recessions since the Great Depression, Social Security has never missed a payment in 75 years. The fact that those checks arrive every month, even in hard times, means that we now have a powerful anti-depression medicine built in to our system, medicine that was not available when the Great Depression struck. It could thus be argued that the existence of Social Security has played a role in preventing the Great Recession of the 21st Century from turning into a new Great Depression.Now let’s have a look at the article that seems to have sparked the recent wave of anti-Social Security propaganda.
******
3.Debunking the Recent Misinformation on Social SecurityThe article that seemed to spark the current mini-wave of hysteria about Social Security was a March 15th article put out by the Associated Press (AP) and reprinted widely. Headlined “Social Security to Start Cashing Uncle Sam's IOUs,” the article is a veritable gold mine of disinformation and misleading innuendo, so I’ll make an example of it in this little case study. It is by no means unique.Time to Tap the Nest Egg?The AP says: “For more than two decades, Social Security collected more money in payroll taxes than it paid out in benefits – billions more each year. Not anymore. This year, for the first time since the 1980s, when Congress last overhauled Social Security, the retirement program is projected to pay out more in benefits than it collects in taxes – nearly $29 billion more. Sounds like a good time to start tapping the nest egg.”Actually... That “nest egg” is still growing. As a recent report by the Economic Policy Institute put it, “Social Security will continue to run a surplus for years to come, with the combined old age and disability trust funds projected to grow from $2.5 trillion in 2009 to $3.8 trillion in 2020.” There’s no need to take the EPI’s word for it. The Congressional Budget Office report, which is what apparently got the AP reporter so excited, can be viewed on the CBO website. There we can see that, while Social Security benefits in 2010 will total about $697 billion and taxes collected will only total $642 billion, there is the little matter of the $120 billion in interest on the money already accumulated in the Trust Fund, which means that the size of the overall Trust Fund will actually increase by about $90 in 2010. So no “tapping of the nest egg” is called for.The Gov’mint Spent Our Money!AP: “Too bad the federal government already spent that money [in the Trust Fund] over the years on other programs...” and “For more than two decades, regardless of which political party was in power, Congress has been accused of raiding the Social Security trust funds to pay for other programs, masking the size of the budget deficit.”This is the old familiar “There’s no money in the Trust Fund” complaint. My answer: Of course there’s no money in the Trust Fund. That’s not how it works. Anywhere.As I have explained on several occasions, beginning in 1998 (Nygaard Notes #15 “Economics of Social Security for Beginners.” Still available on the NN website) it is quite true that the government has spent the money in the Trust Fund, and anyone who knows anything about how bonds work knows this. Here’s how bonds work: When you “buy” a bond, what you are doing is loaning money to the bond seller. In return you get a promise to get your money back at a certain time, with interest. That’s the “bond.” Once you have the bond and the seller has your money, the bond seller can do whatever she likes with the money. What she does is irrelevant, as long as she pays off the bonds on time.Since 1983, when the Trust Fund was created by Congress (acting on a proposal by the Greenspan Commission), Social Security has been collecting more in taxes than it needed to pay benefits. That was the plan, and the system was required to set aside the extra money in the safest possible place. The safest possible place for anyone’s money is... U.S. Treasury Bonds. Would you, for example, prefer that Social Security invested its Trust Fund money in, say, Toyota? How about Citigroup? AIG? You get my point. People who want their money to be safe invest it in Treasury Bonds. T-Bonds offer low interest rates, but high security (higher interest rates are only required if a loan has higher risk) And Social Security is all about being secure, y’see.So when someone says “There’s no money in the Trust Fund” or “The government spent your money,” I can only think of two possible explanations. 1. They don’t know what they are talking about, or 2. They are trying to scare you.They're WorthlessAP Says: “In all, [Social Security] has about $2.5 trillion in bonds, all backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. But don't bother trying to steal them; they're nonnegotiable, which means they are worthless on he open market.”Nygaard Says: I can’t imagine any comment that could be less relevant to anything. Of course the Social Security bonds are worthless on the open market. They’re “special issue” bonds, which are more dependable and flexible than marketable securities. Other than implying that the bonds are somehow worth less than they would be if they were “in the market”—which is false, they’re actually worth more for this reason—I honestly can’t think of any meaning in this statement. Why would someone say this? Same two reasons as mentioned above. (You can read about “special issue” securities here: http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/ProgData/fundFAQ.html#n7 )Baby BoomersAP Says: “Social Security's financial problems have been looming for years as the nation's 78 million baby boomers approached retirement age. The oldest are already there. As that huge group of people starts collecting benefits and stops paying payroll taxes Social Security's trust funds will shrink, running out of money by 2037, according to the latest projection from the trustees who oversee the program.”When I wrote about this in 1998, I said this about funding Social Security: “Current projections are that the system will be 100% funded until at least the year 2032.” So the system actually looks to be in a little better shape now than it was 12 years ago. And as far as the “financial problems... looming,” that’s why the decision was made in 1983 to set up a Trust Fund. Everyone knew that the retirement of the baby boom generation would increase the costs of the program, so we’ve been planning for it.The AP article begins by saying that “It's time to start cashing them in.” The reporter is referring here to the bonds held by Social Security, which he calls “IOUs.” He adds that “the government will have to borrow even more money, much of it abroad, to start paying back the IOUs, and the timing couldn’t be worse.”Here I’ll quote a March 19th publication from the Economic Policy Institute entitled “Fact Check: Has Social Security Begun Tapping its Trust Funds?”Referring to the basic idea that Social Security has to start “cashing in” its bonds, EPI says: “This is simply not true. According to the Congressional Budget Office—the source cited in the [AP] article—Social Security will continue to run a surplus for years to come, with the combined old age and disability trust funds projected to grow from $2.5 trillion in 2009 to $3.8 trillion in 2020... Even though outlays will exceed payroll tax revenues, Social Security is not about to become a net seller of Treasury bonds, and is in fact still acquiring them to the tune of $100 billion a year. However, the [cashing in the bonds] story has taken off because it fits with the preconception that Social Security is in crisis and its finances are suspect.”I imagine that similar stories will “take off” as 2010 unfolds, so I’ll plan to continue trying to shoot them down as we go along.
******
4.Military Leader Upset With Peace Movement—Stop the Presses!On page 6 of the February 24th New York Times appeared a small story that told a big story. The headline caught my eye: “Gates Sees Danger in Europe's Anti-Military Views.” Gates is Robert Gates, the U.S. Secretary of “Defense.” Now, would it not be expected that the leader of the military forces of the most heavily-militarized nation on the planet might feel threatened by the idea of peace? Well, indeed he does.The Times article reported that “polls show that the Afghanistan war has grown increasingly unpopular in nearly every European country,” leading Gates to complain that “public and political opposition to the military had grown so great in Europe that it was directly affecting operations in Afghanistan and impeding the alliance’s broader security goals.”There are a couple of remarkable things to note in this news article. Note first of all what it is that is newsworthy for the Times: What is newsworthy is the reaction of a high-level U.S. official to public opinion. What is not newsworthy is the actual public opinion that prompted the reaction. Also not newsworthy is the amazing amount of hard work on the part of untold numbers of peace-loving Europeans that has shaped that opinion. It’s not that difficult to find news about the opposition to imperial violence that so concerns our military establishment. (Check out, for example, the work of the 119-year-old International Peace Bureau based in Geneva: http://ipb.org/ )The second remarkable thing to note about this article is the implication that “operations in Afghanistan” have something to do with “security.” That’s highly debatable, but in this article—as in so many others—the relationship between “security” and military occupation is not up for debate.War Is PeaceAccording to the Times, Gates told NATO officers and officials in a speech at the National Defense University, the Defense Department-financed graduate school for military officers and diplomats:“The demilitarization of Europe—where large swaths of the general public and political class are averse to military force and the risks that go with it—has gone from a blessing in the 20th century to an impediment to achieving real security and lasting peace in the 21st.”A more straightforward paraphrase of George Orwell’s famous “War is Peace” slogan would be hard to find in the public record. Gates also said that the fact that “NATO was facing shortfalls of hundreds of millions of euros” was “a natural consequence of having underinvested in collective defense for over a decade.”Underinvested? Hmmm... Perhaps a better interpretation might be that NATO is an alliance without a purpose, and the people of Europe recognize that. NATO was formed, after all, to defend against the Soviet Union and its allies in the Warsaw Pact. Now there is no Soviet Union—have you heard?—nor is there a Warsaw Pact, and Europeans have come to question the need to maintain an anachronistic, costly, destabilizing and pointless military alliance whose enemy does not exist. How this is evidence of an “underinvestment in collective defense” is a mystery to everyone but the U.S. War Secretary and his audience of fellow military personnel. And, apparently, to the New York Times.The Times reports that “NATO’s problems” have been “greatly magnified by the expansion of its mandate beyond European borders, following 9/11.” I think it would be much more accurate to say that “the expansion of NATO’s mandate beyond European borders” IS the problem. And it’s not “NATO’s problem.” It’s a problem for all of the victims of this military alliance: the ones being killed by it as well as all of those in whose names the killing is being done.As an illustration of how easy it is to use a simple change in perspective to transform a “bad news” story into a “good news” story, let’s invoke the familiar Nygaard Notes Alternative Headline. Instead of “Gates Sees Danger in Europe's Anti-Military Views,” how about reporting the same facts under this headline: “European Peace Movement Increasingly Powerful; U.S. Warmakers on the Defensive.”
******
5.A Tale of Two MilitariesThe modern understanding of democracy at the level of the nation-state assumes that the foreign and domestic policies of a nation are best guided by elected and accountable civilians. Undue influence by unelected military forces is seen as anti-democratic, and rightly so. I’ll have a lot more to say about this in the coming months, but for now I want to give a small example of how undue military influence in the governing of a country is portrayed differently in the U.S. media depending on where a country fits into the imperial scheme of things.Back in February, some remarks about Iran made by U.S. Secretary of State Hilary Clinton were widely reported. She was speaking to students in Doha, Qatar, when she said:“We see that the government of Iran, the supreme leader, the president, the parliament, is being supplanted, and that Iran is moving towards a military dictatorship. Now, that is our view... I fear the rise of the influence and power of the Revolutionary Guard... poses a very direct threat to everyone.”And now for something completely different. About a month later—March 11th, to be precise—the New York Times ran a story with the headline “Spy Chief In Pakistan To Stay On Another Year.” Here’s the lead paragraph, followed by some noteworthy excerpts (emphasis added by Nygaard):“Pakistan's spy chief has been granted an unusual one-year extension in his job, a move that may also pave the way for a longer term for the head of the army, Gen. Ashfaq Parvez Kayani who is scheduled to step down this year.“The announcement extending the tenure of Lt. Gen. Ahmed Shuja Pasha as director of the spy agency, the Inter-Services Intelligence directorate, was formally made Wednesday by Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani. But it had been clear for weeks that General Kayani planned to keep General Pasha at his side, and that the weak civilian government would have little choice but to go along with it.“The two generals have driven Pakistan's strategic decisions in the past two years. The likelihood that they would retain their posts represented continuity, at least, in one of Washington's most complicated, mistrustful and high-stakes relationships with an ally.“Senior American generals have invested enormous amounts of time on frequent visits to Islamabad, Pakistan's capital, in the past year, cultivating both generals... American officials have heaped praise recently on the Pakistani military “As head of Inter-Services Intelligence, General Pasha runs the most feared agency in Pakistan, an institution with tentacles into many spheres of life...”The current “weak civilian government” in Pakistan is not technically a “military dictatorship,” but that doesn’t mean that the U.S. would push for sanctions on this nuclear-armed rogue state if is were a dictatorship. In fact, according to Farooq Tariq, general secretary of Labour Party Pakistan, “Since 1978 the different [Pakistani] governments have all been close US allies. This includes 20 years of military dictatorship under Zia [Ul Haque] (1977-1988) and General Musharaf (1999-2008).”So, there you have a Tale of Two Militaries. One is the military of an “ally” with a “weak civilian government” dominated by “the most feared agency in Pakistan,” run by a General, an agency that appears to play the same role it played under previous “military dictatorships” that were also “allies” of the U.S.The other military is the military of an “enemy” nation, a nation that is not armed with nuclear weapons, that is in fact a signatory to the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, and whose military is under the control of a non-military leader (the unelected “Supreme Leader” Ali Khameini). Qw are told that this military is in a country that “is moving towards a military dictatorship” and thus is “a very direct threat to everyone.” Unlike, presumably, our “allies” in Pakistan.It appears that the criteria deciding who is an “ally” and who is an “enemy” has to do with something other than being a military dictatorship, doesn’t it? And just think: We can see all this simply by reading the corporate media. It just requires a little decoding.
**********
Subscriptions to NYGAARD NOTES are FREE. You can start your free subscription by visiting the NYGAARD NOTES website at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/ Or, just send an email to NYGAARD NOTES at nygaard@nygaardnotes.org All back issues are found there, as well, and are fully searchable.NYGAARD NOTES grows by recommendations and referrals from readers. Please “give” free subscriptions to your friends, family members, and allies. Also, please feel free to forward any issue to anyone, or to reprint anything you read here. All of NYGAARD NOTES is in the public domain, to be used by whosoever can use it.NYGAARD NOTES is completely supported by voluntary donations from readers and friends. That’s how it stays independent, and remains free to those who cannot contribute. If you want to help sustain this experiment in independent journalism—now in its ELEVENTH year!—please consider making a voluntary contribution by going to the NYGAARD NOTES website at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/ Then just get out your credit card and follow the instructions. Or, send a check through the mail, payable to “NYGAARD NOTES” at NYGAARD NOTES, P.O. Box 14354, Minneapolis, MN 55414. Thank you!You can also support Nygaard Notes indirectly, by recommending my small business, River City Buttons, that makes custom, pin-on buttons for all occasions. Find it at http://www.rivercitybuttons.com/ --
Jeff Nygaard
National Writers Union
Twin Cities Local #13 UAW
Nygaard Notes
http://www.nygaardnotes.org/
