Thank you for contacting me in opposition to forestry legislation
introduced by Rep. Greg Walden (R-OR). I appreciated hearing
from you and would like to take a moment to respond.
The Forest Emergency Recovery and Research Act (HR 4200) has
been referred to the House Resources, Agriculture, and
Transportation and Infrastructure Committees. Opponents argue it
incorrectly defines salvage logging as necessary to rehabilitate
forests and diverts scarce resources from proactive forest health
initiatives to reactive ones. I am currently in the process of
evaluating this bill along with alternative forest recovery
legislation (HR 3973) introduced by Rep. Tom Udall (D-NM) and
the approach each takes to ensuring the health of our forests.
Please be assured I will keep your comments in mind should either
of these bills come to the House floor for a vote.
Because of your interest in forest health, you may be interested to
know I have supported funding for the Forest Legacy Program.
This program was created because our nation's forests are faced
with an increasing threat to maintain the integrity of our country's
valuable forest lands. Intact forests supply timber products,
wildlife habitat, soil and watershed protection, aesthetics, and
recreational opportunities. However, as these areas are fragmented
and disappear, so do the benefits they provide. FLP is a federal
program that partners with states to protect environmentally
sensitive forest lands.
Again, thank you for taking the time to contact me. I hope you
will not hesitate to call, write or e-mail me again in the future
anytime you have a comment or concern.
Monday, February 27, 2006
A Message from Congressman Adam Smith
Sunday, February 26, 2006
Uncommon Denominator
Uncommon Denominator
The Newsletter of the Commonweal Institute
www.commonwealinstitute.org
-- William T. Sherman
CONTENTS
Wit and Wisdom: Politics and pop culture
Talking Points II: Sticks and stones....
Check It Out: Democracy in America
Featured Article: "The Battle to Stop Bird Flu"
Happenings: Progressive Roundtable
Endorsements: Jim Hightower
Get Involved: Spread the word; become a contributor
TALKING POINTS
There's been a lot of talk recently about the failure of Democrats, progressives, and the Left in general to take advantage of the metastasizing problems of the Republican establishment. What's needed is a plan, a leader, a program. A strategy! Here's one: seek out those independents, moderates, and centrist conservatives of libertarian sympathies, and make the case that the cherished principle of freedom is better served by the Left. There's an opportunity here to gain a significant political foothold and to exploit an increasingly vulnerable division in the conservative coalition. Neither progressives nor the libertarian-minded, one suspects, realizes how much shared ground actually exists between their philosophies. Certainly, there's not a libertarian right now, in the full possession of his wits, who could be happy with the policy trends that are shaping our country. In this, the sixth year of one of the worst administrations in American history, freedom has never been more visibly in decline.
For more than half a century, American conservatives have trumpeted their commitment to defending "liberty" (a term less self-evident than it might appear). In the long, hard slog against Soviet communism, in which Republicans tended to take a more aggressive stance, this self-congratulation had some merit. But in many other instances -- from the pointless campaign against flag burning to a fanatically expansive reading of the second amendment -- the conservative approach to protecting freedom has ranged from the asinine to the simply destructive. Progressives, who have traditionally emphasized "equality" (ditto) in their vision of the American way, need to explain, sincerely and forcefully, their own commitment to freedom. Without a doubt, the opportunity is there, because the modern conservative coalition, in which the religious right has become ascendant over business conservatives and libertarians, has pushed through an array of policies that have made Americans dramatically less free. Behind the specious argument that lower taxes equate with greater freedom, and using the "war on terror" as a pretext for every imaginable power grab, conservatives now resemble Big Brother more than they ever have, and as a result their coalition is at risk of unravelling. Just consider some of the more obvious liberty-undermining trends now underway:
Interference in personal privacy. Where to begin? The assault on the idea of a Constitutional "right to privacy." Domestic spying. Airport no-fly lists. Intrusion in personal records, from Google searches to library fines. And this describes only what American citizens face, let alone the unnumbered foreign nationals who have been utterly deprived of all due process whatsoever.A major problem for progressives is that they've lost a lot of libertarian-minded people by seeming to advocate "big" government and therefore "intrusive" or "stifling" government. What they need to do is make the case, consistently and powerfully, that a government which helps people also makes people more free. To make that case, progressives need to break the current frame of the debate and shift its terms to more favorable ground.
Disruption of the Constitutional system of checks and balances. At every opportunity, the administration, abetted by conservatives in the judiciary and Congress, has asserted a breathtakingly expansive view of executive power and privilege. The very reason that system exists in the first place was to restrict the ability of the executive to encroach upon individual liberties.
Interference in K-12 education. A recent paragraph in the New York Times says it all: "When Republican senators quietly tucked a major new student aid program into the 774-page budget bill last month, they not only approved a five-year, $3.75 billion initiative. They also set up what could be an important shift in American education: for the first time the federal government will rate the academic rigor of the nation's 18,000 high schools" (Jan. 22, 2006). The law leaves it to the Secretary of Education to define "rigorous," effectively giving her an unprecedented authority in evaluating high school curricula.
Requiring schools to give student information to military recruiters. Under the administration's No Child Left Behind Act, recruiters are entitled to get the names, addresses and phone numbers of high school juniors and seniors, unless parents or students sign a form requesting that the data be withheld. Districts that don't comply stand to lose millions in federal funding.
So far, conservatives have succeeded at portraying regulation and taxation as hostile or antithetical to personal freedom. As long as progressives respond to that charge only by pointing to the general economic or social benefits of government activism, they will fail to speak to one of the American public's core values and, regardless of the outcome of any particular policy dispute, will allow the conservative frame to prevail. The challenge is define liberty in much broader terms than simply the absence of regulation or taxation.
The preamble to the Constitution states that one of the document's purposes is to "secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity." What the word "secure" implies in this context is that liberty is not something that simply happens, that simply thrives on its own, but that it requires protection, cultivation, and, yes, government involvement. One of the central insights of our jurisprudential tradition, dating to Anglo-Saxon times, is that law begets freedom -- enlightened, well-administered law, of course, but law nonetheless -- while the absence of law begets servitude, violence, and tyranny.
The key to making the progressive case for freedom is to talk about liberty in the aggregate. Capitalism is certainly the most "free" of the world's economic systems, but the conservative version of capitalism -- low regulation, low taxation, lax enforcement, and so forth -- simply does not create the most freedom for the most people. Instead, as in a Monopoly game, it creates dramatic imbalances, letting the powerful become more powerful (and therefore more free), while offering up only the illusion of enhanced freedom for everybody else. Liberty in the aggregate is not served by the law of the jungle. It is best served by creating legal structures and systems in which people are properly rewarded for their efforts, can make their way forward, are protected from abuse, and can fully express their personal beliefs and pursue their personal preferences.
After five years of the anti-regulatory, anti-tax, and anti-civil liberties policies of the Bush administration, are Americans really more free, in the truest, deepest sense of the word? Are they freer from pollution? Are they freer to provide their kids a better education? Are they freer from the prying eyes of the government? Are they freer to earn a living wage? Are they freer from the intrusive data collection of corporations? Are they freer to express dissent? Are they freer from the dangers of ill health, old age, or hazardous workplaces? Are they freer to travel abroad without fear of terrorism? Are they freer from threat posed by natural disasters? Are they freer to pursue their own vision of life, and to live up to their highest potential?
As this list of questions suggests, freedom means a lot more than getting a $200 refund check in the mail, a lot more than relatively cheap gas, and a lot more than plenty of frozen food options. And the fact that a majority of Americans think the country is off on the wrong track might suggest that more and more of them are answering "no" to these questions.
The progressive side of American politics has to get over its apparent fear of talking about "liberty" and start speaking a language that resonates more deeply than any other in American culture. They need to have confidence that their policies promote rather than restrict freedom, and they need to share that confidence.
WIT AND WISDOM
"Some of the other Oscar-nominated movies people are talking about, George Clooney's film, 'Good Night, and Good Luck.' If you haven't seen it, it's about the White House's Medicare plan for the elderly." -- Jay Leno
"President Bush met at the White House with Jordan's King Abdullah. Yeah, there was one awkward moment when President Bush asked King Abdullah, 'How's Queen Latifah?'" -- Conan O'Brien
TALKING POINTS II
The latest furor in the so-called "clash of civilizations" involves the publication, in a number of European newspapers, of a cartoon depicting the prophet Muhammad wearing a turban made to resemble a bomb. The cartoon sparked protests, often violent, across the Arab world, and led to a series of apologies by European leaders, along with statements defending the principle of press freedom. In the mainstream media, accordingly, the dominant frame for the story has positioned Western values of free expression against Muslim religious sensitivities.
What has gotten lost in the hubbub is the problem of the viciously anti-semitic cartoons and articles that are standard fare in the Arab press. Before Muslims take to the streets to defend their religious sensitivities, and before European leaders apologize for what gets printed in their country's newspapers, they should pause to read some of the sewage coming out of the Middle East. Here are just two:
On April 29, 2002, the Egyptian government daily newspaper Al-Akhbar published an article title "Accursed Forever and Ever." The Jews, we learn, are "the virus of the generation, doomed to a life of humiliation and wretchedness until Judgment Day." The anonymous writer goes on to deny that the Holocaust took place, and then suggests that it actually would have been a good idea, wishing he could say to Hitler: "If only you had done it, brother, if only it had really happened, so that the world could sigh in relief [without] their evil and sin."
On March 10, 2002, the Saudi government daily published an article on the Jewish holiday Purim, by Dr. Umayma Ahmad Al-Jalahma of King Faisal University. "For this holiday," we learn, "the Jewish people must obtain human blood so that their clerics can prepare the holiday pastries....Before I go into the details, I would like to clarify that the Jews' spilling human blood to prepare pastry for their holidays is a well-established fact, historically and legally, all throughout history&. [D]uring the holiday, the Jews wear carnival-style masks and costumes and overindulge in drinking alcohol, prostitution, and adultery." The list goes on and on. The global Zionist conspiracy; the literal blood-thirstiness of the Jews; the convenient myth of the Holocaust; Jewish avarice; massacres of innocents; and so forth. There are many forms of fundamentalism and bigotry in the world, but vicious anti-semitism is one of the most dangerous and most widespread. It has built up a hideous history, and must be combatted vigorously and consistently.
In response to the outpouring of vitriol the continuing violence against Jews, President Bush in October 2004 signed the Global Antisemitism Review Act, which pledges the United States to "continue to strongly support efforts to combat antisemitism worldwide through bilateral relationships and interaction with international organizations." Among its various provisions, the Act requires the State Department to include in its "country reports" on human rights abuses "instances of propaganda in government and non-government media that attempt to justify or promote racial hatred or incite acts of violence against Jewish people."
The Arab world's reaction to the law has not been favorable. In the article "Arab Reactions to the U.S.'s Global Antisemitism Review Act of 2004," Aluma Dankowitz writes that Arab public opinion shapers "called the act an interference in domestic affairs of states, expressed apprehension that its implementation would harm freedom of expression, and protested against what they saw as the considerable Jewish influence in the U.S."
It's time for those in the West to call the Muslim outrage in this case for what it is: hypocrisy. Whatever feelings of frustration, persecution, and insult prevail in the Arab world, and whatever their legitimate grievances about Israeli and American policy, no one is calling for Muslim countries to be wiped off the face of the earth, no one is saying Muslims should be exterminated, and no one is sending Muslims to the gas chambers. The exploitation of anti-semitism by shady and autocratic Arab governments is an obscenity, and to the degree that regular Muslims buy into such vileness, they are writing themselves out of the mainstream of modernity. Anti-semites need to stop finding scapegoats and start directing their energy toward solving the real problems they face: anti-scientific fundamentalism, political corruption, one-dimensional oil-based economies. If they don't, it's going to be endless misery for everybody concerned, but particularly for themselves.
We might note another irony in the reaction to the cartoons. A central reason that has been given for the outrage is that depicting the prophet Muhammad will encourage idolatry. But what is idolatry if not endowing images with greater power than they deserve? The whole point of the Koranic injunction against idolatry is that people should not place so much importance on images that real matters of spirituality and human life are left behind. This is analogous, incidentally, to the campaign against flag-burning in the United States: protecting the symbol of freedom should never taken precedence over protecting the actual freedoms the flag symbolizes, including the freedom to destroy a symbol.
So, sure, the offensive cartoons can be "condemned." But what really needs to be condemned is the mindset of religious fanaticism and intolerance of free expression that seems to be spreading like the bird flu.
CHECK IT OUT
One wonders why the American public, or perhaps just the American press, seems to respond with a gigantic collective yawn when the subject of electoral shenanigans comes up. Do people really not know or not care that our democratic system has been seriously undermined in recent years? Whether or not you believe the Presidential elections of 2000 or 2004 were "stolen," pils of evidence have accumulated that suggests the hardball tactics of the Right -- from aggressively purging voter rolls to aggressively "questioning" voters at black precincts -- improperly swayed the results by crossing the line from aggressive into illegal. And as long as there's no assertive response, there's not much reason to think that things will change.
That's the subject of an ever-growing roster of books on the last three elections (including 2002) and the current electoral system, including its increasing reliance on insecure electronic "voting machines" and its bizarre, or deliberate, inability to provide a uniform and transparent method of registering the public will. A common theme running through these books has to do with a veritable conspiracy of silence on the part of the media, and a shameful refusal by political figures to get involved in investigating the issue. Together, they give the impression that the conservative movement has seized power illegitimately, that American democracy is truly imperilled, and -- at a minimum -- that the fundamental civic trust between political parties has broken down in a way reminiscent of the 1790s or the 1850s.
Not surprisingly, the Right has come out with its own handful of books charging the Left with improper electioneering: John H. Fund, Stealing Elections: How Voter Fraud Threatens Our Democracy (Encounter Books, 2004); Hugh Hewitt, If It's Not Close, They Can't Cheat: Crushing the Democrats in Every Election and Why Your Life Depends on It (Nelson Books, 2006); and Byron York, The Vast Left Wing Conspiracy: The Untold Story of How Democratic Operatives, Eccentric Billionaires, Liberal Activists, and Assorted Celebrities Tried to Bring Down a President -- and Why They'll Try Even Harder Next Time (Crown Forum, 2005). One should note, incidentally, that these three publishing houses are little more than private subsidiaries of the Right's messaging machine; none of them has a track record of publishing anything other than ideologically motivated books.
The aim, evidently, of these conservative titles is to have the debate kind of wash away in an unresolvable "he-said-she-said" blur of charges and countercharges -- much like the effort to confuse the public about the science of global warming. In the midst of that blur, Americans need to concentrate on two central facts. First, the conservatives are the ones who control all three branches of government, so accusing the Left of "stealing elections" is like accusing a homeless person of embezzlement. Second, the conservative record over the last 5 years amounts to a laundry list of misguided policies whose failure is disputed only by those policies' architects, and sometimes not even then.
They should also check out the following books about the history of electoral fraud, and about the last two Presidential elections in particular:
Mark Crispin Miller, Fooled Again: How the Right Stole the 2004 Election and Why They'll Steal the Next One Too (Unless We Stop Them) (Basic Books, 2005)If you're only able to read one of these books, read Miller's carefully researched and closely argued Fooled Again. Despite his fondness for rhetorical excess (which might not serve his purposes all that well), Miller backs up his disturbing conclusions with mountains of factual and anecdotal evidence. The central claim -- that "the two great corporate entities of government and media have unified against" regular Americans -- and the central call-to-arms -- that "we must start working to reclaim that right [to vote]" -- need to be heard and heeded by anyone who loves freedom.
Bob Fitrakis, Steve Rosenfeld, and Harvey Wasserman, eds., Did George W. Bush Steal America's 2004 Election? Essential Documents (Columbus Alive, 2005)
Anita Miller, What Went Wrong In Ohio? The Conyers Report on the 2004 Presidential Election (Academy Chicago Publishers, 2005)
Steve Freeman and Joel Bleifuss, Was the 2004 Presidential Election Stolen? Exit Polls, Election Fraud, and the Official Count (Seven Stories Press, 2005)
Lance Dehaven-Smith, The Battle for Florida: An Annotated Compendium of Materials from the 2000 Presidential Election (University Press of Florida, 2005)
David North, The Crisis of American Democracy: The Presidential Elections of 2000 and 2004 (Mehring Books, 2004)
Tracy Campbell, Deliver the Vote : A History of Election Fraud, an American Political Tradition-1742-2004 (Carroll & Graf, 2005)
Andrew Gumbel, Steal This Vote: Dirty Elections and the Rotten History of Democracy in America (Nation Books, 2005)
Complacency is the bane of democracy. Staying informed is the bane of complacency.
FEATURED ARTICLE
The following is an excerpt from Thomas Goetz's "The Battle to Stop Bird Flu," which appeared in the January, 2006, edition of Wired magazine.
"The 1976 swine flu scare has become enshrined as 'the epidemic that never was,' one of the great fiascoes of our national health care system. But in truth, government officials performed well enough. In just a few months, they went from isolating a strange new flu virus to delivering a vaccine to every American who wanted one. The problem was, all they had were blunt instruments: crude mathematical models, rough estimates of infection rates, and a vaccine that often packed too strong a punch. They were fairly well equipped to react to a worst-case scenario - they just weren't equipped to determine if one was imminent. Forced to guess, they chose 'to risk money rather than lives,' as Theodore Cooper, an assistant secretary of Health Education and Welfare, said at the time. 'Better to be safe than sorry.'Click here to read the whole article.
"All of which raises a question: With the specter of an actual flu epidemic looming, are we any better equipped today? H5N1, the strain of avian influenza currently festering in Asia, has yet to pull off the mutation that would customize it for human-to-human transmission. But we know it's an especially lethal virus; most health experts expect it will make that jump soon enough. So the task for experts is to devise a plan that pinpoints how the virus might spread through the US population - a plan that draws more from the Soviet approach to disease forecasting than from the CDC's approach in 1976.
"Thirty years on, a new science of epidemiology is at hand. It's based on sophisticated computer models that can get ahead of a virus and, in a sometimes dazzling demonstration of computer science, provide exacting prescriptions for health care policy rather than best guesses. It's an approach pioneered not by physicians but by physicists. And it owes a lot to the nuclear bomb."
HAPPENINGS
Progressive Roundtable -- Plans are moving ahead for the Progressive Roundtable event, scheduled for March 2-5 in the San Francisco Bay area. There, a select working group will decide on priorities for the creation of new capacity in the areas of marketing, communications, strategy, and coordination for the nascent progressive movement. Influential progressive blogger Markos Moulitsas Zuniga (whose Daily Kos blog averages over 700,000 readers per day) will be speaking on the first day of the event about factors hampering the Democratic Party at the national level, and what progressives must do to move forward. As word about the Progressive Roundtable has spread, more and more people have expressed a desire to be included, but all slots are currently filled and there is a growing waiting list. Even though the total number actually in attendance must be restricted in order to carry out the tasks of the meeting, others interested in progressive infrastructure are welcome to visit the Progressive Roundtable website. There they can learn more about the event, read and post articles in the Resource Library, list their own organizations in the Organization Directory, and feed questions to the working group team members. A report on the outcome will be posted on the site following the convening.
New CI Associate -- The Commonweal Institute is proud to welcome Rob Dickinson as a new Associate. Mr. Dickinson is known for his leadership, management, communication, and technical skills in working in grassroots organizing and legislative politics. As Executive Vice President of Californians for Electoral Reform, Mr. Dickinson drafted bill proposals, lined up legislative sponsors, initiated a grassroots lobbying campaign, and set up a houseparty-based public education and recruitment campaign. He is currently an independent consultant with clients in both the political and technical arenas, and was one of the developers of the interactive website for the Commonweal Institute's Progressive Roundtable. Mr. Dickinson has held Vice-Presidential positions at Novation Biosciences and Perspecta, as well as managed software development teams at other Silicon Valley companies, including 3Com, Apple, Taligent, and Excite@Home. He received a Bachelor's degree in Computer Science from the University of California at Berkeley.
ENDORSEMENTS
"It's always good to put your brain in gear before you put your mouth in motion. The folks at the Commonweal Institute do the heavy mental lifting so agitators like me can arm ourselves on the front lines of the ideological battles taking place every day in America. For too long progressives have walked fearful of their shadows, whimpering and whining about what's wrong and fighting amongst themselves over crumbs. With the help of the Commonweal Institute, that time is over." -- Jim Hightower, National radio commentator, writer, public speaker, and author of If the Gods had Meant us to Vote They Would Have Given us Candidates
GET INVOLVED
If you agree with Jim Hightower (see above), there are a number of ways you can help the Commonweal Institute achieve its goals.
Right now, as you read, you can simply forward the Uncommon Denominator to friends and family who might be interested in learning about the Commonweal Institute. Getting the word out is crucial.
You can also join our network of donors building the Commonweal Institute. Your tax-deductible contribution is vital to making the Commonweal Institute an effective organization. $100 would help so much! Even a contribution of $10 or $20 will make a difference because there are so many moderates and progressives. Click here to contribute online. Or call 650-854-9796. Your support is essential.
To subscribe to this free e-newsletter, send a blank message to: ci-newsletter-subscribe@svpal.org.
Tipping Point for the Internet
Our work is paying off: Monday's New York Times editorial page1 echoed Common Cause's call to action on net neutrality2, and legislation may be introduced soon in Congress to protect our freedom on the internet. Here's what the Times had to say:
"When you use the Internet today, your browser glides from one Web site to another, accessing all destinations with equal ease. That could change dramatically, however, if Internet service providers are allowed to tilt the playing field, giving preference to sites that pay them extra and penalizing those that don't. …Congress should protect access to the Internet in its current form."
Please add your name to our petition demanding strong net neutrality legislation. We need our representatives in Congress to know that there is widespread support for legislation that protects the democratic nature of the Internet and prohibits telecom companies from blocking, impeding or prioritizing any online content or services.
http://www.commoncause.org/ProtectNetNeutrality
Earlier this month, Common Cause members sent tens of thousands of letters to the telecom execs and asked them to abide by net neutrality principles. But it's clear now that we need a law to protect the Internet from being privatized by Verizon, AT&T and other greedy media corporations. Here's more from the New York Times:
"The Senate held hearings last week on "network neutrality," the principle that I.S.P.s - the businesses like Verizon or Roadrunner that deliver the Internet to your computer - should not be able to stack the deck in this way. If the Internet is to remain free, and freely evolving, it is important that neutrality legislation be passed. …Some I.S.P.s are phone and cable companies that make large campaign contributions, and are used to getting their way in Washington. But Americans feel strongly about an open and free Internet. Net neutrality is an issue where the public interest can and should trump the special interests."
We need you to tell Congress to protect freedom and openness on the internet.
http://www.commoncause.org/ProtectNetNeutrality
Thanks to each of you who has helped Common Cause become a leader in the fight to preserve internet freedom, and thanks for all you do to hold power accountable.
Sincerely,
The Common Cause Media Reform Team
Celia Wexler, Lauren Coletta & Dawn Holian
P.S. Lobbyists for Verizon, AT&T, Comcast and other telecom giants are heading into the halls of Congress to enshrine their own plans in telecom legislation now being drafted in committee. We need to stop them. Please sign the petition supporting net neutrality: http://www.commoncause.org/ProtectNetNeutrality.
1 New York Times editorial
2 "Net neutrality" is the principle that you should be able to access any content or services on the Internet without interference from your Internet service providers
LaborTalk (February 22, 2006)
Power Struggle Erupts in Construction Trades
As Two Crafts Plan to Organize Rival Group
By Harry Kelber
In an obvious power play, the national presidents of two construction unions--the Laborers and Operating Engineers-- announced on Feb. 14 that they were quitting the AFL-CIO¹s Building and Construction Trades Department and were planning to form a rival organization, the National Construction Alliance, that would include the Carpenters, Bricklayers, Iron Workers and Teamsters.
The two labor leaders--Terence O¹Sullivan of the Laborers and Vincent J. Gitlin of the Operating Engineers--were dissatisfied with the response of Department officials to their four-point ultimatum that called for revising craft jurisdiction, reducing the budget, changing the Governing Board's voting system and replacing all current officers.
In his reply, Edward C. Sullivan, the AFL-CIO's Department president, said: "Neither Mr. Sullivan nor Mr. Gitlin has bothered to attend a Governing Board meeting in many months. Had they done so and presented their case honestly and openly to the general presidents of our affiliated unions, much of what they claim to seek could have been achieved in the best interests of the unionized construction industry and all of our members." Sullivan noted that nine construction crafts, including the electricians, plumbers, painters and boilermakers, supported the present leaders and had refused to quit the Department.
The latest cleavage within the construction industry sets the stage for intense raiding by both sides that can escalate into an all-out jurisdictional war in the construction industry. Contractors will hesitate to sign agreements with one group of unions for fear of being subjected to disruptions and possible strikes by the rival group. Under these circumstances, the non-union sector of the industry is bound to continue its growth rather than submit to unionization.
Sullivan has sent a letter to 350 building trades councils in North America, repeating that "in the summer of 2005, at a high-level meeting of our industry¹s leaders- owners, contractors and unions--the Department promised that the building trades would do everything in our power to prevent internal political disputes from adversely affecting our industry, We remain committed to that principle, and we ask for your continued support in keeping that promise."
Explaining why the Laborers were withdrawing from the Department, O'Sullivan said: 'We can't stand idly by, tied to a past that promises only further decline in construction union membership." Unions represent less than 20 percent of the construction industry, compared with twice that number about 35 years ago. But neither the Laborers, Operating Engineers or any of the other construction crafts has made significant progress in organizing.
One of the major reasons for the weakness of the Department is that the leader of each craft union operates his own union as a private fiefdom, seeking to defend or expand his jurisdiction in the industry. There is more hostility rather than solidarity among the crafts. There are no joint organizing campaigns involving all of the crafts, and, with the latest split, the possibility of unified action has become even more remote.
O'Sullivan and Giblin have not come forward with an organizing plan, but prefer to restrict their criticism to the ineptitude of the Department leadership. It can be predicted that when the National Construction Alliance is established in the near future, it will affiliate with the Change-to-Win Coalition, since the Laborers, Carpenters and Teamsters will belong to both organizations.
Neither O'Sullivan nor Gitlin consulted their own members on the decision to split from the Department. They think they own their union and have no need to ask for members' approval. So while they are playing the game of power politics, construction workers may see more of their jobs go non-union, and they'll lose whatever rights they have as union members.
With so much at stake, what can we do about it? At the very least, union members who are laborers and operating engineers should ask for a referendum on whether their union should or should not quit the Building and Construction Trades Department.
Our weekly "LaborTalk" and "The World of Labor" columns can be viewed at our Web site²
Inventing the wheel and taking it
Posted by Evan Derkacz at 8:05 AM on February 21, 2006.
| First the report, then the action... |
Less than a week later MoveOn has leapt to action with a fix. In The Monday Project, "MoveOn Media Action members watch the Sunday morning political talk shows, report any imbalance they see, and on Monday we push back together against the biggest outrage."
This week's action targets NBC's Meet the Press (sometimes referred to as Press the Meat): "The panel featured conservative columnist Paul Gigot (Wall Street Journal), progressive columnist Maureen Dowd (New York Times), neutral journalist David Gregory (NBC), and Mary Matalin—a Republican operative and top political adviser to Dick Cheney, who was allowed to dominate the discussion."
The media is less Conservative or Liberal than it is Capitalist. If Sunday shows have skewed Right it's probably the result of the Right's knack for organizing and being a squeaky wheel. The networks respond to audience demands. MoveOn's 3 million members, if properly mobilized, can become a formidable progressive squeaky wheel of their own.
This is exactly the kind of coordination that can help build on the work and ideas that are out there instead of just grabbing arguments, messages and actions willy-nilly and tossing them into the ring, waiting for the one that'll stick.
It's not as though progressives keep reinventing the wheel, we just seem to want to walk...
Evan Derkacz is a New York-based writer and contributor to AlterNet.
RadioNation with Laura Flanders: February 22, 2006
By Laura Flanders, Air America Radio. Posted February 22, 2006.
| This week on RadioNation with Laura Flanders: Live from Nevada! State progressives making serious headway with unions, coalition-building and increasing tax revenues. |
|
|
| RadioNation host Laura Flanders |
This week we broadcast live from Nevada, where Silver State progressives have been expanding union power, raising taxes despite GOP opposition and creating new coalitions reaching from immigrants to business. Featuring: Bob Fulkerson of the Progressive Leadership Alliance of Nevada, Ireri Rivas of the Nevada Immigrant Coalition. D. Taylor, Secretary-Treasurer of the Culinary Workers Local 226, Las Vegas, the nation's fastest-growing union and Maggie Carlton, a waitress elected to the State Senate, talk about labor's growing power in the nation's fastest-growing city. Kristina Wilfore, of the Ballot Initiative Strategy Center, and Nevada political consultant Gail Tuzzolo, on how ballot measures can bolster the progressive agenda.
Laura Flanders is author of Bushwomen: Tales of a Cynical Species.
MEDIA SAVVY: PROTESTS PLANNED AGAINST MEDIA WAR COVERAGE
MEDIACHANNEL.ORG -- MEDIA SAVVY
News for the Media Savvy
February 22, 2006
AlterNet's PEEK is your daily cheeky -- and serious -- peek into the progressive blogosphere. Written by AlterNet associate editor Evan Derkacz, PEEK dives into the morass and emerges with the best commentary, analysis and satire so you don't have to. Celebrating its first birthday in February '06, PEEK boasts top-50 traffic and climbing. To stay on top of the progressive blogosphere, subscribe today for free!: http://www.alternet.org/subscribe/ (check the PEEK box).
/ / / / / / / /
PROTESTS PLANNED AGAINST MEDIA WAR COVERAGE
Press to be targeted in national media protest on March 20th. United For Peace and Justice is partnering with MediaChannel.org to focus attention on media complicity in the Iraq war.
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3378
= = = =
NYC EVENT: A LOOK INTO THE MAIL ORDER BRIDE INDUSTRY
Please join Gabriela Network – the largest and oldest US-Philippine Women’s solidarity organization – for a film screening of a documentary depicting what is a controversial aspect of human trafficking: the mail order bride industry. The Imaginasian Theater, 23 February 2006, 6:30 pm.
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3401
= = = =
RUMSFELD REVERSES: PLANTING STORIES UNDER REVIEW
Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld said Tuesday that the Pentagon is reviewing its practice of paying to plant stories in the Iraqi news media, withdrawing his earlier claim that it had been stopped.
By Robert Burns, Associated Press
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3385
= = = =
RUMSFELD DECLARES WAR ON BAD PRESS
Pentagon chief Donald Rumsfeld has signaled that he plans to intensify a campaign to influence global media coverage of the United States, a move that is likely to heighten the debate over press freedom and propaganda-free reporting.
By Emad Mekay, Inter Press Service
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3387
= = = =
THE DEVIL IS IN THE LACK OF DETAILS: THE DEFENSE DEPARTMENT'S MEDIA CONTRACTS
Although they've done their best to keep their spinning from public scrutiny, several major incidents have exposed the Bush administration's manipulation of news media: The "sell job" for the invasion of Iraq. Payola pundits Armstrong Williams, Maggie Gallagher and Michael McManus. Stooge "reporter" Jeff Gannon / James Guckert. Video news releases determined to be covert propaganda by the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office (GAO).
By Diane Farsetta , Center for Media and Democracy
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3390
= = = =
NATIONAL SECURITY WHISTLEBLOWERS
Find illegal activity in the U.S. national security agency you work for. Report it to your superiors. Get rewarded by being demoted or having your security clearance revoked -- tantamount to losing your career – while those whose conduct you’ve reported get promoted.
By William Fisher, MediaChannel
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3383
= = = =
BROADCAST BLUES: OR WHY IRAQ IS NOT ON TV
The Bush administration obviously cannot be trusted to portray events in Iraq in an honest way to the public. That leaves the mass media, and the mass media is doing a lousy job.
By Peter Beinart, The New Republic
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3384
= = = =
ANOTHER INEXPLICABLE SILENCE ON GUANTANAMO
When the UN Human Rights Commission last Thursday released its report on the conditions at the U.S. detention facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, alleging that "torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment" was taking place and that the camp should be shut down, the news was met with a chorus of yawns.
By Gal Beckerman, CJR Daily
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3388
= = = =
The gravest indictment of the American news media is that George W. Bush has gutted the U.S. Constitution, the Bill of Rights, the Geneva Conventions and the United Nations Charter – yet this extraordinary story does not lead the nation’s newspapers and the evening news every day.
By Robert Parry, The Consortium News
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3394
= = = =
Propaganda campaign portrays Iran as a pariah state
By Ghali Hassan, Center for Research on Globalization
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3395
= = = =
FUROR OVER CARTOONS PITS MUSLIM AGAINST MUSLIM
A side of the cartoon conflict little discussed is the intra-Muslim side.
By Michael Slackman and Hassan M. Fattah, NY Times
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3393
= = = =
NEW ANTI US MOVIE STIRS DEBATE
A Turkish movie, "Valley of the Wolves: Iraq,” based in part on a popular TV series, has ignited a global controversy with supporters suggesting it is a “Rambo in Reverse.” The action movie shows US soldiers committing war crimes.
MediaChannel.org
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3382
= = = =
CPJ RELEASES ATTACK ON GAMBIAN PRESS
The tightening of repressive media laws and the failure to solve the December 2004 murder of veteran journalist Deyda Hydara added to the climate of violence and intimidation faced by private media in 2005 in The Gambia.
The Independent (via AllAfrica.com)
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3392
= = = =
MOGULS FORCE DELAY IN AUSTRALIA MEDIA LAW CHANGES
Last minute lobbying by the Packer and Murdoch interests has halted government plans to deregulate Australia media ownership. The communications minister, Helen Coonan, was due to unveil the blueprint for media reform this month.
By Cosima Marriner, The Guardian
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3398
= = = =
CHINA DELAYS TRIAL OF NEW YORK TIMES MAN
The trial of a Chinese researcher charged with revealing state secrets while working for the New York Times is expected to take place before the end of March, following a one-month delay.
By Julia Day and agencies, The Guardian
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3396
= = = =
WOODWARD WARNS OF SECRECY TREND
The greatest threat to America's democracy is not terrorism but governmental secrecy, said Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Bob Woodward, whose reporting 35 years ago pierced the veil of secrecy behind Richard Nixon's presidency.
By Tracy Idell Hamilton, Express-News
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3397
= = = =
REPORTERS SMELL FRESH NARRATIVE, POUNCE
2006 is an election year and already we can detect the rustle of reporters converging on what conventional wisdom tells them is the hot storyline of the campaign: In congressional districts across the country, veterans of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are running for Congress -- as Democrats!
By Paul McLeary, CJR Daily
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3389
= = = =
FRIENDS OF SCOOTER LIBBY LAUNCH WEB SITE, WANT YOUR MONEY
Scooter has come to Web, with the launch of a new site, the Libby Legal Defense Trust.
By E&P Staff, Editor & Publisher
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3391
= = = =
U.S. TECHNOLOGY HAS BEEN USED TO BLOCK, CENSOR NET FOR YEARS
If you think there's something new or unique about Google censoring its Chinese website or Websense helping Yemen filter the Net — well, I hate to disappoint you. Those congressmen acting surprised about this stuff are either grandstanding or ignorant, or maybe both. To varying degrees, U.S. tech companies help repressive regimes around the world sift, block and censor the Net. They've been doing it for years.
USA Today
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3386
= = = =
YAHOO!MAIL BANS ALLAH AND DIRTY HARRY HANDLES
Yahoo! is banning the use of allah in email names - even if the letters are included within another name, like Callahan.
By John Oates, The Register
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3399
= = = =
"Cheney's Got a Gun" has been blanketing the airwaves coast to coast and is being downloaded around the world! Now you can watch the new music video to the funny song parody of Aerosmith's "Janie’s Got a Gun.”
The Bob River’s Show (via Political Humor)
http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/3400
= = = =
4 WOMEN WHO CAN WIN
| | ||||||
| Yesterday was Justice Samuel Alito's first day on the Supreme Court bench. The high court now has a majority hostile to women's reproductive rights -- and their first order of business is hearing a case that could substantially alter the right to choose. We don't know what the Court will decide. But we do know that the best way to protect our rights is to elect a Democratic majority to Congress this November. And that's why I am excited to announce the next DFA-List -- Francine Busby, Christine Cegelis, Mary Jo Kilroy and Lois Murphy for Congress. These four women are running in winnable districts. If we are going to elect a Democratic majority in 2006, we need to fight for victories in these races. Read more and make a contribution to their campaigns today: http://www.democracyforamerica.com/candidates Francine Busby for California's 50th District. Francine is running in an April special election for the seat vacated by disgraced Randy "Duke" Cunningham. This race will be the first Congressional race of 2006, and recent polling shows Busby leading all Republicans. This is a race we can win -- Senator Feinstein has won this district and John Kerry received 45% of the vote in 2004. Francine is running a great campaign and DFA members in southern California are already hard at work knocking on doors and phone banking for her. With your support, we can elect Francine and return integrity to the CA-50th Congressional District. Christine Cegelis for Illinois's 6th District. A long-time resident of Rolling Meadows, Christine Cegelis lives and works in Illinois' 6th Congressional District. As a Dean Dozen candidate in 2004, Christine came within just a few points of toppling 30-year Republican incumbent Rep. Henry Hyde. This year Hyde is retiring and Christine's running again in a tough Democratic primary. The DCCC is behind another candidate, but Christine has earned the support of DFA groups across Illinois. Please do whatever you can to help her win her primary on March 21st. Mary Jo Kilroy for Ohio's 15th District. After winning her 2004 race for Franklin County Commissioner with the support of DFA, Mary Jo is now challenging incumbent Congresswoman Deborah Pryce, the chair of the GOP Conference and the fourth-highest ranking Republican in the House of Representatives. Pryce is a key architect of the Republican policies that have taken our nation so far off course, while Mary Jo embodies the values of DFA: fiscal responsibility, social progress and grassroots activism. This district can be won by a Democrat -- John Kerry did it in 2004 -- and Mary Jo Kilroy can do it this year. Your early contribution to Mary Jo's campaign will help her bring new leadership to the United States Congress. Lois Murphy for Pennsylvania's 6th District. In 2004, Dean Dozen candidate Lois Murphy came within just 2 points of defeating Republican incumbent Jim Gerlach in the closest challenge in the country. Now, she's back for a rematch in Pennsylvania's sixth district. Gerlach has been called one of the most vulnerable members of Congress and is working overtime to try to conceal his strong ties to Tom DeLay. As a mother, lawyer, and activist, Lois understands the importance of dedication and hard work. She is committed to fighting for our priorities and values. With your help we can give Murphy the resources she needs to win in this crucial district. Francine Busby, Christine Cegelis, Mary Jo Kilroy and Lois Murphy are strong candidates fighting for change. Their positive vision will lead us in the right direction and restore the values that are important to all Americans. But they need your help to build early support and develop strong grassroots networks. Please help them today: http://www.democracyforamerica.com/candidates Time and time again, DFA has surprised the pundits, winning in districts where Democrats have feared to tread for far too long. Today, I urge you to get involved in these critical races so we can take our country back in 2006! Sincerely, Jim Dean P.S. Last week you raised over $40,000 for former Congressman Ciro Rodriguez's campaign against DINO (Democrat in Name Only) Henry Cuellar. Thank You! | ||||||
What the Hell Happened, Sir?
t r u t h o u t | Perspective
Wednesday 22 February 2006
Liberal Democrats, these days, are mad about a lot of things. They think that the Democrats in Congress haven't done enough to oppose the Republican agenda. They're mad about the prescription drug plan and they're mad about the Patriot Act.
But mostly, they're mad about The War. Not the one in which we went after al-Qaeda in Afghanistan and quit too early. The other one. The stupid one.
They look at the Democratic leadership in Washington and they consider that they are every bit as responsible, via their complicity, for the devastation and war crimes and abject travesty that this invasion has become as the Bush administration.
It's a tough point to argue. I think we've got some fantastic, brilliant Democratic leaders in Congress, in both houses. But the fact is, they did sort of roll over and die and let what was such an obvious boondoggle go ahead, with their support.
Why did we fall for it? How in the world could so many otherwise coherent liberals get so fooled? I count myself among them. At the same time I felt it was bogus, I didn't hit the streets in protest over invading Iraq at first. Why?
My little brain keeps spinning around and I keep coming back to the same answer and I don't like it. It's unnerving, uncomfortable, and the kind of idea that the mind just wants to reject out of hand because it's just too difficult to grasp.
It wasn't Bush's 16 words, and it wasn't any connection to 9/11. I think that the main reason Bush was able to get away with getting us into this war was that Colin Powell said that we had to.
Powell's presentation to the UN was not intended to impress the UN (It didn't, by the way.). That speech was for us. That speech was to sell this war to Americans, and it worked.
Powell had become such an icon, the closest thing to a hero that our country had seen in a long time, that it was simply not possible to not believe him. He was so respected and admired on both sides of the aisle that it was patently inconceivable that he could sit up there and lie to us.
Could Colin Powell have lied to us?
Making Powell Secretary of State was the most important thing that Bush did to legitimize his administration. In spite of all the party hacks and cronies and ex-Senators who had lost to dead people, the General was there, and he had that magic effect. He made you feel like somehow, in the end, everything would be all right.
Powell's name had been bandied about as a Presidential candidate with bipartisan support. When's the last time that happened? He had a dignity, an aura of integrity, a sort of a moral righteousness (the real kind, not the fake Pat Robertson kind) that literally glowed around him.
So when he spoke that day, even if you didn't really buy all the evidence, the creative part of the brain would kick in and fill in the blanks. Surely he knows more information that he can't tell us. It's top secret, right? That's Colin Powell up there, for Pete's sake! If he says we need to invade Iraq, then who am I to disagree?
And so we went to war.
Even today, it's hard for people to wrap their heads around this. We want to believe that Powell was fooled, too. We want so badly to believe that he really didn't know that the Italian Intelligence documents about the yellowcake sale from Niger were forged. We want to believe that he wasn't told that German Intelligence had already discredited "Curveball" and his story about the mobile biological weapons factories. We want to believe that he actually thought that that meeting between an al-Qaeda operative and an Iraqi official was somehow significant.
We need to believe. This is painful.
It is time for the General to talk to us. His ex-Chief of Staff has been all over the place, dissing the Rumsfeld-Cheney-Rove "cabal," but the General has been very quiet. If his Chief of Staff had reason to suspect that intelligence might be being manipulated to fit a political agenda, might not he have as well? If they suspected something was amiss as far away as Downing Street, could he have been that far out of the loop?
Colin Powell has had an incredible and very distinguished career. If ever someone in this country, in modern times, who isn't Jimmy Carter, had achieved the status of almost being completely above reproach, it is him.
But it would be tragic if his legacy were largely those stupid aluminum pipes he went on and on about (which is right up there with duct tape, now). There is no doubt in my mind that that speech was the single most important event in putting the pieces of the puzzle together toward leading us into the invasion of Iraq.
The country bought it. The Democrats bought it. I bought it.
But it wasn't true, and there are some questions to be asked that only the General himself can answer. This is not about letting anybody off the hook, on either side of the aisle. It's just about setting the record straight.
Is it possible that Powell, being the good soldier that he has always been, may have had reservations but followed the orders of his Commander in Chief? Is it possible that the "cabal" was able to keep him in the dark? Is it remotely possible (and I cringe, too) that he was in on it?
Colin Powell has always been one of those people who has always been there for his country when we needed him.
Well, Sir, this is one of those times. With all due respect, what the hell happened?
We need to hear it from you.
Warren Whipple is a freelance writer in Austin, Texas, a little blue island in a big red sea.
