Monday, November 03, 2008

Green Jobs Plans Could Solve 'Twin Crises'

Green Jobs Plans Could Solve 'Twin Crises'

by Haider Rizvi

NEW YORK - Worldwide efforts to overcome the current economic crisis will require more spending on green industry, which will also help slow and possibly reverse the impending climate crisis, say two new studies released this week.

[Green jobs at the crossroads. Worldwide efforts to overcome the current economic crisis will require more spending on green industry, which will also help slow and possibly reverse the impending climate crisis, say two new studies released this week. (Image: treehugger.com)]Green jobs at the crossroads. Worldwide efforts to overcome the current economic crisis will require more spending on green industry, which will also help slow and possibly reverse the impending climate crisis, say two new studies released this week. (Image: treehugger.com)
"It's time for a bailout for the environment: one that creates jobs, is global in scope, and can help rebuild communities amidst the ashes of the current economic crisis," said Michael Renner, co-author of the latest report, entitled "Green Jobs: Working for People and the Environment."

Statistical analysis in the report released Wednesday shows that currently nearly 200 million people in the world have no work to make their ends meet. These numbers are likely to increase further if governments fail to adopt innovative ways to tackle the current economic crisis.

"Green jobs are not only about renewable energy," said Sean Sweeney and Jill Kubit of Cornell University's Global Labor Institute, who co-authored the study commissioned by the nonprofit Worldwatch Institute, an environmental think tank.

The report's authors say that, in China alone, renewable energy technologies employ no less than 1 million people in the wind, solar, and biomass industries. But several other economic sectors, such as construction businesses, transportation systems, agriculture, and basic industry also have the potential to create many jobs that would help reduce carbon emissions to protect the environment.

Retrofitting Europe's residential buildings in order to cut carbon emissions by 75 percent, for example, could lead to more than 2 million new jobs in the next two decades, according to the report, which notes that the construction sector currently employs about 111 million people worldwide.

The report's authors also see "huge potential" for green jobs in efforts to grow public transportation systems. The report's findings show that in the United States and Europe, there are already about 1.2 million people employed in this sector.

According to the report, worldwide, more than 40 percent of steel output and one-quarter of aluminum production is based on recycled scrap, rendering the estimated quarter million jobs in these two sectors at least "a shade of green."

The researchers also note that recycling programs create as many as 15 million jobs worldwide, but they often entail "dirty, undesirable, poorly paid, and even dangerous work, particularly in developing countries." In Brazil, however, over 90 percent of recyclable material is collected by scrap collectors who have organized themselves into a national movement with 500 cooperatives and 60,000 collectors, the researchers said.

Researchers cite a study on more than 1,000 organic farms in Britain and Ireland showing that organic farms employed on average one-third more employees per farm than conventional counterparts.

The authors note that over 1 billion people depend on agro-forestry for subsistence and income, particularly in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. They hold that planting trees on agricultural land provides multiple environmental benefits and can raise farm incomes.

A study released by the environmental group Greenpeace International and the European Renewable Energy Council (EREC) early this week offered similar conclusions.

The report, entitled, "Energy [R]evolution: A Sustainable World Energy Outlook," shows that aggressive investment in renewable power and energy efficiency can create a $360-billion-a-year industry, provide half of the world's electricity, and slash $18 trillion in future fuel expenditures -- while protecting the climate.

"Unlike other energy scenarios that promote energy futures at the cost of the climate, our energy revolution scenario shows how to save money and maintain global economic development without fuelling catastrophic climate change," said Sven Teske, co-author of the report. "All we need to kick start this plan is bold energy policy from world leaders."

Energy efficiency will have to be a major component of those policies, he said, if carbon emissions are to decrease while global energy use inevitably increases. In Teske's view, strict energy efficiency standards make "sound economic sense" because they can help slow down rising global energy demand.

"The energy saved in industrialized countries will make space for increased energy use in developing economies," he said. "With renewable energy growing four-fold not only in the electricity sector, but also in the heating and transport sectors, we can still cut the average carbon emissions per person from today's four tons to around one ton by 2050."

The Greenpeace report suggests that the cost of continued reliance on coal will remain as high as $15.9 trillion until 2030, which is more than what would be required to pay for the renewable solutions proposed in the plan. The authors conclude that these clean energy sources will produce electricity without any additional fuel costs after 2030, while creating millions of jobs and stimulating the global economy.

"The global market for renewable energy can grow at double-digit rates until 2050, and overtake the size of today's fossil fuel industry. Currently, the renewable energy market is worth $70 billion and doubling in size every three years," said Oliver Schafer, EREC policy director. "Because of economies of scale, renewable energies, such as wind power at good sites, are already competitive with conventional power."

Schafer thinks that after 2015, renewable sources across all sectors will be the most cost effective. "The renewable industry is ready and able to deliver the needed capacity to make the energy revolution a reality," he added in a statement. "There is no technical impediment, but a political barrier to rebuild the global energy sector."

John Passacantando, executive director of the Greenpeace chapter in the United States, agrees.

"Countries like China and India are well placed to take the enormous investment opportunity presented by the energy revolution," he said. "It would be short-sighted for them to focus on fossil fuels to power their rapid economic growth. The energy revolution is key to them climate proofing their development."

While there is significant untapped economic potential in the green jobs sector, not all news is good.

According to the Worldwatch report, green jobs are "still an exception" in most developing countries, which account for some 80 percent of the world's workforce, and where nearly 500 million people still earn no more than $1 a day.

Other issues that concerned researchers include the rising level of informality in the global economy, a lack of rules and standards to help ensure decent jobs, and the fact that environmental costs are too often externalized, making it harder for green enterprises to compete.

"Given all of the uncertainties in today's world, it's time for a bold commitment and international cooperation to promote green economies that support conservation, low carbon technologies, recycling, and local communities," said Renner. "I can't see how we'll escape our twin economic and environmental crises if we don't."

Many Voters Caught Unawares by Florida's 'No-Match' ID Law

Many Voters Caught Unawares by Florida's 'No-Match' ID Law

by Curtis Morgan and Charles Rabin

What do a promising rookie for the Miami Heat, a systems analyst from Bulgaria, the wife of a Republican congressional candidate and Fidel Castro have in common?

[Critics say the law adds unneeded steps for minor ID problems and is skewed against minorities. Hispanics and blacks outnumbered non-Hispanics by more than six to one on the list in South Florida, and three to one statewide. (Image: Miller-McCune)]Critics say the law adds unneeded steps for minor ID problems and is skewed against minorities. Hispanics and blacks outnumbered non-Hispanics by more than six to one on the list in South Florida, and three to one statewide. (Image: Miller-McCune)
They can't just show up Nov. 4 and fill out a regular ballot. Theirs are among 12,000 names statewide flagged under Florida's Voter Verification Law, a ''no match'' screening process embroiled in legal and political controversy.

The ID check spits out voter registrations that don't match driver's license or social security records. It has left voters on a list dominated by blacks, Hispanics and Democrats in a legal limbo -- unless they supply elections officials with additional proof they are who they say they are.

More than one-third of the people on the ''no match'' list live in Miami-Dade or Broward counties -- most notably Mario Chalmers, a Heat guard who starred in last year's Final Four college basketball championships.

Chalmers, who grew up in Alaska and played in Kansas, said his father successfully sorted out the ID mess.

''All I have to do is go vote,'' he said, ``so that made it easier for me.''

The process has not been such a breeze for everyone. A Miami Herald survey of 50 no-match voters showed that more than a third didn't know the list, or law, even existed.

The 2006 law, created by a Republican-led Legislature, was put on hold after civil rights groups filed a federal lawsuit last year. Florida Secretary of State Kurt Browning, a Republican, imposed a new version on Sept. 8 over objections from Democratic and voter activists who contend it targets minorities.

The screening snagged dubious registrations among 437,638 new filers statewide, including some 600 who were under-age and two people who told The Herald they weren't citizens.

The address given for one Fidel Castro, registered as a 53-year-old Republican, also was suspect: the Camillus House homeless shelter in Miami. A woman who answered a phone number provided on Castro's form replied in Spanish, ''Fidel lives in Cuba,'' then hung up.

But the law also flagged plenty of regular people -- particularly in South Florida, where Miami-Dade ranked No. 1 with 2,944 names and Broward No. 3 with 1,602.

A Herald phone survey of 50 no-match voters in the two counties suggests many don't know they are on the list or how to get off. More than a third reported either not receiving or overlooking letters from elections offices.

ID REQUIRED

Under state law, counties are supposed to send ''no match'' voters notice that they need to provide elections offices with a driver's license or Social Security card to receive a regular ballot. Otherwise, they could be forced to cast a ''provisional'' ballot subject to additional scrutiny and higher rates of rejection.

Kavin Walden, 23, who registered Oct. 6 when an activist approached him at a park in Liberty City, didn't know the screening snared him as ''Kevin,'' not Kavin.

''I've been waiting for my voter registration card,'' said Walden, a lifeguard at Jose Martí Park worried about health insurance for his 4-year-old daughter and newborn son. ``I don't want to miss this election.''

For people who were notified, the time and effort to resolve identification discrepancies varied. Some reported doing it with a single fax or e-mail, while others found the process slow and frustrating.

Angela Graham-West, wife of Allen West, a Broward Republican congressional candidate, was surprised she was flagged after she registered at the main elections office in Fort Lauderdale.

''Of all people, that I would get caught up in this little web,'' Graham-West said.

Though black and Republican, she discounted race and party as a factor. She guessed the problem was either a middle initial or her identification. She used a military ID because her husband is a recently retired Army lieutenant colonel.

Still, she didn't view the ''hassle'' as an obstacle and supported the scrutiny. ``I think my temporary discomfort is far less important than having an accurate election.''

Husband Allen laughed that he'd like his wife's vote, but he likened the law to a guard gate at a military base.

''Security is a good thing, especially when you think about some of the things going on right now,'' he said.

MINORITIES 6-1 ON LIST

Democrats and other critics argue the state already has a strict ID requirement to vote. They say the law adds unneeded steps for minor ID problems and is skewed against minorities. Hispanics and blacks outnumbered non-Hispanics by more than six to one on the list in South Florida, and three to one statewide. Democrats outnumbered Republicans about four to one both locally and statewide.

Elizabeth Westfall, senior attorney for the Washington, D.C.-based Advancement Project, one of the groups challenging the law, said a law touted as anti-fraud is instead snaring ``sports figures and people who are in the public eye.''

On Thursday, 15 activist groups, including ACORN and the Brennan Center for Justice, wrote Gov. Charlie Crist asking for more flexibility with a law they said ``only prevents valid votes from counting.''

They want the state to relax a standard set by Browning requiring no-match voters to cast provisional ballots. Miami-Dade and some other counties already are providing regular ballots if no-match voters come to the polls with copies of ID documents.

The Republican Party of Florida has backed Browning, arguing the standard ensures illegitimate votes don't cancel out legitimate ones.

`PHOTOCOPY IS KEY'

Jennifer Krell Davis, a spokeswoman for Browning, said the state had slightly ''refined'' its stance to allow no-match voters to present copies of ID papers at polls, rather than the elections office. But the state still wants counties to use a provisional ballot with the ID papers attached -- the standard Broward is using.

''The photocopy is the key,'' Davis said. ``If we're trying so hard to keep accurate voter rolls, we want to make sure we have an audit trail to follow.''

Any no-match voters without copies of ID must use a provisional ballot -- and resolve discrepancies by 5 p.m. Nov. 6 for their vote to count.

Davis said voters still have time to straighten out the issues. For some, getting off the list has been easy.

Jonathan Gonzalez, a 27-year-old who registered by mail in September, faxed a copy of his Social Security card after he got a no-match notice. He early voted at the North Miami Library this week with a regular ballot.

''I guess everything is OK because I didn't hear back,'' he said, ``and I voted."

Others have had to work a little harder.

Davie's Michael McIntosh, 20, said repeated busy signals thwarted attempts to fax his driver's license to the Broward elections office.

''Finally it went through and now I can't talk to anyone to verify they got it,'' said McIntosh, a student at Southeastern University in Lakeland. He has hung up after lengthy waits on hold but he said he has not given up.

''I'm patient enough not to get worked up about it,'' he said.

Others were shocked to find their registrations in question less than a week from Election Day.

''I've been in this country for 12 years and I was excited to be able to do this,'' said Katina Iyer, a systems analyst from Planation. Iyer, originally from Bulgaria, signed up the day of her citizenship ceremony in Miami in September. ``They said just wait for your card in the mail, and almost every day I have been waiting.''

Miami Herald staff writers Diana Moskovitz, Adam Beasley, Dan Chang, Kirstin Maguire, Susannah A. Nesmith and Mike Wallace contributed to this report.

McCain's Shameless Halloween Trick‏

RAW: Uncooked Truth, Beyond Belief

Issue #272
Oct 31, 2008
McCain's Shameless Halloween Trick
Josh Dorner

John McCain's campaign has been marked by one dirty trick after another, but he pulled out an extra special one in honor of Halloween. It may not be the dirtiest trick yet, but it is certainly among the most disingenuous and desperate of the campaign.

McCain dusted off archival footage of Barack Obama praising the McCain-Lieberman global warming bill and cut it into an ad that promises "the truth about global warming." Too bad that McCain never updated his plan after it was first introduced, leaving its targets way behind what scientists tell us we need to do. Plus, it gives away tens of billions to polluters. Meanwhile, Obama's plan is the gold standard -- 80 percent reductions in global warming pollution by 2050 and 100 percent auction of pollution permits to make polluters pay.

What's even more outrageous is that just days ago McCain's chief economic adviser denounced the landmark 2007 Supreme Court ruling that the government must take action on global warming -- making the ridiculous claim that upholding the High Court's ruling would result in Soviet-style central economic planning. This is the same argument cooked up by polluters and ceaselessly advanced by the Bush administration, which has now unlawfully defied the High Court for over a year.

(We also learned today that the Bush administration is furiously working on numerous other eleventh-hour shenanigans to weaken environmental rules and other protections.)

The John McCain of yesterday -- the one Barack Obama is shown referring to in this ad -- would undoubtedly be ashamed of the John McCain of today for aligning himself with the richest polluting companies and the radical anti-science agenda of the Bush administration.

The ad also continues the shameful and deceptive hoax that John McCain has perpetrated on voters all year long: Tthat he supports clean energy. While the ad claims John McCain supports renewable energy, he has actually said that clean energy technologies "don't work." More importantly, McCain has consistently voted against renewable energy whenever he's taken the opportunity to vote, and his failure to support clean energy tax incentives earlier this year put more than 116,000 hardworking Americans in the wind and solar industries on the brink of layoffs.

Fortunately, looks like this Halloween American voters are over McCain's tricks -- which should give us all a nice treat come Tuesday

==================================================
Paid for by the Sierra Club Political Committee, http://www.sierraclub.org/, and not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee.
=================================================

Hell to Pay

»

by: Elliot Cohen, Truthdig

photo
Dick Cheney and John McCain. (Photo: 3.bp.blogspot.com)

Sen. John McCain's ideological ties to the Bush-Cheney administration have mostly passed beneath the radar of the mainstream media, but if McCain loses the presidential race to Barack Obama, his neoconservative legacy could erupt into the open with a force that should not be underestimated.

In a little discussed speech titled "A Period of Consequences," given at The Citadel military college in South Carolina on Sept. 23, 1999, then-Texas Gov. George W. Bush laid out his plan for America. Bush's speech succinctly reflected the ideology of the Project for the New American Century (PNAC), a neoconservative institute initiated in 1997 by The New Citizenship Project, under the direction of its president, Sen. John McCain.

Bush's Citadel speech was mirrored by a report that PNAC produced in September 2000, "Rebuilding America's Defenses: Strategy, Forces, and Resources for a New Century" ("RAD"). As noted by the authors of "RAD," PNAC was based on the defense strategy outlined by Dick Cheney's Defense Department in the 1992 Defense Policy Guidance (DPG) at the end of the George H.W. Bush administration.

The DPG (also known as the Wolfowitz Report) provided a "blueprint for maintaining U.S. preeminence, precluding the rise of a great power rival, and shaping the international security order in line with American principles and interests." The PNAC directors had lamented the fact that the DPG was "leaked [by The New York Times and The Washington Post] before it had been formally approved." It was criticized as "an effort by 'cold warriors' to keep defense spending high ... despite the collapse of the Soviet Union," and was subsequently "buried by the new [Clinton] administration." PNAC was accordingly organized to resurrect Cheney's defunct plan. [The quotations are from the "RAD" document.]

PNAC's plan was a long-term project to be accomplished over decades. It sought to transform the military through research and the development of advanced warfare technologies. The approach included a global anti-ballistic missile system (the so-called Strategic Defense Initiative), a more effective nuclear capability, modernization of conventional weapons and development of biological and chemical weapons. The proposed biological weapons included ones that could " 'target' specific genotypes" and thereby "transform biological warfare from the realm of terror to a politically useful tool." The PNAC plan shunned arms control and the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty as obstacles to U.S. pre-eminence and ability to thwart the rise of other great geopolitical powers. Thus it sought to cultivate and use military superiority "to preserve an international security environment conducive to American interests and ideals." [All quotations from "RAD."]

In his Citadel speech, Bush proclaimed: "… if elected, I will set three goals: I will renew the bond of trust between the American president and the American military. I will defend the American people against missiles and terror. And I will begin creating the military of the next century." But he was very clear that the project would not be completed by the time his administration ended. "Even if I am elected," he said, "I will not command the new military we create. That will be left to a president who comes after me. The results of our effort will not be seen for many years."

Obviously, to carry out the PNAC vision, Bush's successor would have to be dedicated to the vision. This individual could not, as did Bill Clinton, present a conflicting ideology. Currently, the only candidate who appears to satisfy this requirement is John McCain - who, as mentioned, was a principal founder of PNAC. In addition, his campaign advisers and likely members of a McCain administration largely consist of former PNAC officials and signatories, including William Kristol, Robert Kagan, Randy Scheunemann, James Woolsey, John R. Bolton, Robert B. Zollick, Gary Schmitt, Richard Armitage, Max Boot and Michael Goldfarb.

There are two important considerations. First, the Bush/PNAC administration has a decade of planning and implementation at stake on the upcoming election. Second, a McCain presidency would assuredly mean another four years of militaristic Bush/PNAC policies.

So what, in particular, could we expect from a McCain administration? President Bush's Citadel speech gives us some answers, as does PNAC's "RAD." Following are (1) statements from the 2000 PNAC "RAD," (2) parallel remarks made by Bush in his 1999 Citadel speech and (3) what we might expect from John McCain as president and a PNAC supporter.

Strategic Defense Initiative:

PNAC: "Creating a system of global missile defenses is but the first task of transformation."

Bush: "At the earliest possible date, my administration will deploy anti-ballistic missile systems, both theater and national, to guard against attack and blackmail."

In line with this PNAC/Bush transformative priority, McCain has indicated his support of global missile defenses, a project that was scrapped under Clinton because of its costliness, destabilizing effects and failure to provide a bulletproof missile defense system.

Control of the Internet:

PNAC: "… divine [find] ways to control the new 'international commons' of … cyberspace."

Bush: "Yet today our military is still organized more for Cold War threats than for the challenges of a new century - for industrial age operations, rather than for information age battles."

Internet freedom has already been compromised by recent changes to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. These changes fail to provide the necessary judicial oversight to prevent warrantless, mass spying on American citizens' Internet activities and e-mail exchanges. Bush's illegal warrantless surveillance program conducted between 2001 and 2007 appears to be a part of PNAC's concept of controlling cyberspace. In the name of national defense, the National Security Agency has engaged in copying, parsing and downloading millions of American citizens' computerized records into a central government database (so-called Total Information Awareness).

Defense Research and Development

PNAC: build new kinds of conventional forces for different strategic challenges and a new technological environment.

Bush: "The real goal is to move beyond marginal improvements - to replace existing programs with new technologies and strategies."

It is obvious that the economy, health care, education and social services would be sacrificed in order to finance the research and development of such high-tech weaponry under a Bush/PNAC plan. An administration that placed a premium on defense R&D, as McCain's commitment to the PNAC ideology requires, could not realistically address these other concerns. Indeed, the thrust of the PNAC plan has been toward vastly increased R&D defense spending:

PNAC: "… increase defense spending gradually to a minimum level of 3.5 to 3.8 percent of gross domestic product, adding $15 billion to $20 billion to total defense spending annually."

Bush: "The transformation of our military will require a new and greater emphasis on research and development. So I will also commit an additional $20 billion to defense R&D between the time I take office and 2006."

As you can see, Bush's figure of a $20-billion increase in R&D did not come out of thin air. It is the high end of the figure that PNAC had recommended in its 2000 "RAD." In fact, according to the Department of Defense, between 2001 and 2004 Bush "steadfastly increased R&D investments" from $41.1 billion to $64.3 billion, an increase of $23.2 billion, "in order to skip a generation of weapons and transform the military into the 21st Century fighting force it must become."

Using a "New Pearl Harbor" to Propel the PNAC/Bush Plan

In a post-9/11 world where fear of another attack on the U.S. homeland had reached concert pitch, PNAC/Bush was able to exploit the situation to attain the massive increases in defense spending. Bush appears to have been aware of this "homeland" advantage in 1999 before he took office and two years before the tragic attacks took place. And in 2000, one year before the attacks, PNAC lucidly conjectured about the utility of such an attack as a "catalyst" for financing its transformative objective:

PNAC: "… the process of transformation, even if it brings revolutionary change, is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalyzing event - like a new Pearl Harbor."

Bush: "Not since the years before Pearl Harbor has our investment in national defense been so low as a percentage of GNP."

Fighting Multiple Simultaneous Preemptive Wars

On the surface, the PNAC/Bush case for a massive increase in defense R&D can be made on the grounds that it is needed to defend the U.S. homeland from terrorist attacks. However, when seen in the broader context of the PNAC/Bush objective of maintaining the geopolitical pre-eminence of the U.S., this concern becomes only a corollary. It is a truism that we would be safer if we could defend ourselves more effectively; however, the PNAC/Bush mission was never purely defensive; it was and is essentially offensive - to threaten and if necessary militaristically defeat any potential competitors for the title of pre-eminent world power. Indeed, advancing U.S. economic (oil) interests in the Persian Gulf, not defending our turf from a terrorist attack, appears to have been the real reason for the PNAC/Bush invasion of Iraq and its present preoccupation with Iran:

PNAC: "Over the long term, Iran may well prove as large a threat to U.S. interests in the Gulf as Iraq has."

Bush: "Iran has made rapid strides in its missile program, and Iraq persists in a race to do the same."

While PNAC was more upfront than Bush about U.S. economic interests in the Gulf as the main motive for establishing permanent bases there, the targeting of Iran and Iraq is clearly part of the geopolitical play for power that PNAC/Bush envisioned all along. Notice that the PNAC/Bush plan had Iraq in its scope well before the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. The 2000 "RAD" did not mince words about this. "While the unresolved conflict with Iraq provides the immediate justification," it stated, "the need for a substantial American force presence in the Gulf transcends the issue of the regime of Saddam Hussein."

PNAC/Bush Brigade Cannot Afford to Lose Power in Midstream

PNAC: "Over the first seven years of the Clinton administration, approximately $426 billion in defense investments have been deferred, creating a weapons procurement 'bow wave' of immense proportions."

Bush: "The last seven years have been wasted in inertia and idle talk. Now we must shape the future with new concepts, new strategies, new resolve."

It is obvious that the PNAC/Bush administration does not want to hand over power to an administration that does not share its ideology. How far it will go to stop an Obama administration from coming to fruition remains to be seen, but clearly it is strongly motivated and has already gone too far to graciously bow out.

The situation is therefore a precarious one. Logistically, the PNAC/Bush brigade's "plan A" is undoubtedly for McCain to be elected. Just how he is "elected" may be less important than whether he is. For example, widespread election fraud such as inserting malicious code into voting machines in battleground states, throwing out ballots, "caging" and other illegal election practices may be sufficient to tip the vote tally in favor of McCain. Such actions aren't unlikely given the high stakes and the irregularities that occurred in the past two presidential elections.

But what will happen if McCain loses?

This is a power-craving administration that will do what it can to retain power. It has invested billions of dollars in R&D and in building the infrastructure to carry out its mandate to militaristically "preserve an international security environment conducive to American interests and ideals." It has invested billions of dollars and sacrificed thousands of lives in fighting a war to fulfill its mandate of setting up permanent bases in Iraq, and it deems the Democratic option of setting a timeline for troop withdrawal antipathetic to this goal. It has not yet capitalized on its efforts to further U.S. economic interests in the Persian Gulf, and it still aims to thwart any efforts by Iran to counter such schemes. It has already had eight years of interruption by the Clinton administration in actualizing its "military revolution" and has good reason to believe that the old guard which began this incredibly complex ideologically driven venture may fall out of favor and thereby lose the opportunity to finish what it started. It has weapons systems currently in limbo such as the Strategic Defenses, which is a major budget item in defense appropriations and would probably be cut by an Obama administration just as it was by the Clinton administration. Such a cut in defense spending would also have effects on powerful corporate interests such as Lockheed Martin, which is a major supplier of components for the missile defenses involved in the Strategic Defense Initiative.

Consider, also, that the PNAC/Bush administration greatly enhanced the powers of the executive branch, which can now spy on and imprison Americans at will. The architects of such powers are unlikely to want to hand them over to the opposition.

Add to these reasons the frustration at perhaps seeing an ideological vision dashed after almost two decades, and it is clear that the PNAC/Bush administration is not likely to simply swallow an electoral loss.

The consequences of such defeat are and should be a matter of deep concern to us all. Much will depend on the resolve of the American people and their collective commitment to democracy and the rule of law. We must stand firm against fear mongering, propagandizing, bogus legal challenges, attempts to declare the election invalid by fiat, and other tactics aimed at interrupting the constitutional transfer of power.

This shall indeed be a period of consequences.

»

Vote Watchdogs Warn of Troubles on Election Day

»

by: Carol J. Williams and Noam N. Levey, The Los Angeles Times

photo
A federal court has ruled that Colorado must allow thousands of voters removed from voter rolls by the Colorado secretary of state a chance to cast their ballot in next week's election. (Photo: David Zalubowski / AP)

Lawsuits have already been filed over efforts to purge rolls and challenging voter identification laws. "This one is the meltdown scenario," one activist says.

Washington and Los Angeles - Counting down to an election day expected to draw a record-shattering turnout, voting-rights watchdogs are sounding the alarm that a repeat of the Florida fiasco of 2000 could occur in any of a dozen battleground states.

Lawsuits are already flying in many of these states.

Voting rights advocates in Colorado, to take just one example, told a federal judge Wednesday that the names of nearly 30,000 voters were recently purged from the state registry in violation of federal law and ought to be restored by election day. In a compromise, those voters will be allowed to cast provisional ballots.

Across the battleground states, where Democrats had a 2-1 advantage in new registrations, voting-rights groups contend the eleventh-hour verifications demanded by Republican officials are attempts to disenfranchise the new voters.

The flood of millions of first-time voters could lead to crowded and contentious polling places across the country, triggering last-minute identity checks that could deny ballots to those whose names or addresses don't match other government records.

"This one is the meltdown scenario," said Judith Browne-Dianis, co-director of the Ad vancement Project founded by civil rights lawyers to pursue racial justice.

Common Cause, the American Bar Assn., the League of Women Voters and a phalanx of other public interest groups are urging states to ensure that the polls are adequately staffed to handle an onslaught bolstered by millions of newly registered voters.

Voting advocates are worried about its effect in states like Virginia, which has one of the lowest ratios of voting machines to registered voters.

"Voters will simply walk away if the lines are too long," warned Susannah Goodman, who directs the election reform program at Common Cause, a campaign reform group based in Washington. "They don't want to, but they may have a job they have to get to, and they have to go."

Congress enacted the Help America Vote Act in 2002 in response to the Florida debacle two years earlier. The law provided $3 billion for new equipment and statewide registries, but the sheer volume of new voters has overwhelmed efforts to verify their eligibility.

Litigation brought in recent weeks in Ohio, Georgia, Florida and Colorado may serve to alert voters that they may be challenged. But in many states, the verification methods have created more obstacles than they have removed.

In Florida, an aggressive "no match, no vote" standard has been applied to question whether more than 10,000 of those who have registered since Jan. 1 should be given ballots despite discrepancies between their registration information and other government records, said Tova Wang, vice president for research at Common Cause.

Voting rights groups, both nonpartisan and Democrat-aligned, have compiled lists of vulnerable voters and tried to track them down.

"We're engaged in protecting voters from being disenfranchised by virtue of typos and clerical errors," said Adam Skaggs, an attorney with New York University's Brennan Center for Justice.

He said that the likelihood of fraud has been "vastly inflated" and that discrepancies are overwhelmingly the result of innocent mistakes or outdated voter registries.

In Montana, authorities recently sought to drop 6,000 voters from the rolls because of address changes, including soldiers deployed to Iraq, Skaggs noted.

A Brennan Center study of ballot designs found problems in North Carolina, where voters who choose a one-touch straight-party option on voting machines may not notice that the presidential race isn't included and requires a separate vote. In Ohio, the candidates for the top office are split between two pages, which could lead some voters to invalidate their ballots by choosing one on each.

In Georgia, the voter registry has been scrutinized for potential noncitizen entries, and thousands of people -- most with Latino names -- have been flagged for identity checks if they seek to cast a ballot.

Lawsuits challenging election officials' plans to deny ballots in cases of mismatches in at least six states have been shot down by the courts. But appeals are in the works, and concerns over access persist in most of the states analysts consider a toss-up.

"I think we're still going to see a lot of problems, in part because some voters aren't going to find out until election day that they've been dropped from the rolls," said Rick Hasen, a professor of election law at Loyola Law School. "I expect this to happen in Florida, where they had a very aggressive no match, no vote policy."

Citing news reports from Michigan, Ohio, Indiana and Florida, the community activist group ACORN warned last week that Republican officials in those states had hinted at intentions to scan foreclosure filings to identify voters who are no longer living at the address on their registration.

"This shameless challenge adds insult to injury to those who have been hit hardest by the economic crisis," said ACORN, which itself has been accused of fraudulent registrations.

In response to the flood of early voting problems, the Obama campaign, Cable News Network and the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law have set up hotlines, with CNN fielding more than 15,000 calls since opening its phone bank on Oct. 15.

While legal challenges loom over denied ballots and voting machine breakdowns, legal experts said they doubted the electoral vote count would hinge on a single state this time, as occurred in Florida in 2000, when 537 votes separated George W. Bush and Al Gore.

"The good news story is that it's very unlikely in any given year that you're going to have such a close outcome," said Edward B. Foley, an Ohio State University law professor. Just in case, he has developed a proposal for a nonpartisan arbitration tribunal that could be an alternative to ceding that role to the Supreme Court.

The two presidential campaigns are also preparing to deal with lawsuits over the outcome by joining nonprofit and pro bono attorneys who are fanning out by the thousands to monitor the polls.

The Obama campaign has been urging supporters to vote early as a way to avoid problems. "We think for the most part local election officials have done a good job," said Jenny Backus, a campaign spokeswoman.

The McCain campaign has focused in recent weeks on attacking ACORN's voter registration efforts. But spokesman Ben Porritt said the campaign had confidence in most local election officials. "For the most part, these things are handled properly," he said.

While attention has zeroed in on perceived attempts to deny ballots to certain voters, seasoned election monitors point out that such infringement is rare and usually the result of unintentional human error in a system reliant on lay volunteers.

More pleased than apprehensive over predictions of historic turnout, League of Women Voters President Mary Wilson said the nonprofit was concentrating in the final days on ensuring polls have enough workers and equipment, and was seeking to downplay the obstacles so as not to discourage voters.

"It does no good to be talking about barriers to voting when we're this close to the election," she said.

Wilson hailed the improvements in voter registration procedures mandated by the Help America Vote Act but lamented the unanticipated complications imposed by the verification regime.

"A person can leave off a digit from his driver's license, or a woman who gets married and uses her maiden name as a middle initial -- they're not going to match," she said. "Couple that with the fact that the Social Security Administration itself says 28% of the time there's not going to be a match with its data entry and you can see that some of the things HAVA brought to us turn out to be barriers in their implementation."

One benefit of the voting reform law, she added, has been the provisional ballot for voters who show up at the polls only to learn their eligibility is in question. These ballots will be counted if voters confirm their identity within 48 hours, whereas many of those challenged in previous elections were turned away.

Courts including the U.S. Supreme Court have so far ruled against screening efforts that could deny access, allaying activists' worst fears.

"I was really scared," said Wendy Weiser, who heads the Brennan Center's voting rights project. "Now, I am cautiously optimistic, or maybe just mildly apprehensive."

---------

Williams and Levey are Times staff writers.

»

A Last Push to Deregulate

»

by: R. Jeffrey Smith, The Washington Post

photo
In its final months in the White House, the Bush administration is preparing to eliminate federal regulations designed to protect the environment and human health. (Photo: Ron Edmonds / AP)

White House to ease many rules.

The White House is working to enact a wide array of federal regulations, many of which would weaken government rules aimed at protecting consumers and the environment, before President Bush leaves office in January.

The new rules would be among the most controversial deregulatory steps of the Bush era and could be difficult for his successor to undo. Some would ease or lift constraints on private industry, including power plants, mines and farms.

Those and other regulations would help clear obstacles to some commercial ocean-fishing activities, ease controls on emissions of pollutants that contribute to global warming, relax drinking-water standards and lift a key restriction on mountaintop coal mining.

Once such rules take effect, they typically can be undone only through a laborious new regulatory proceeding, including lengthy periods of public comment, drafting and mandated reanalysis.

"They want these rules to continue to have an impact long after they leave office," said Matthew Madia, a regulatory expert at OMB Watch, a nonprofit group critical of what it calls the Bush administration's penchant for deregulating in areas where industry wants more freedom. He called the coming deluge "a last-minute assault on the public . . . happening on multiple fronts."

White House spokesman Tony Fratto said: "This administration has taken extraordinary measures to avoid rushing regulations at the end of the term. And yes, we'd prefer our regulations stand for a very long time -- they're well reasoned and are being considered with the best interests of the nation in mind."

As many as 90 new regulations are in the works, and at least nine of them are considered "economically significant" because they impose costs or promote societal benefits that exceed $100 million annually. They include new rules governing employees who take family- and medical-related leaves, new standards for preventing or containing oil spills, and a simplified process for settling real estate transactions.

While it remains unclear how much the administration will be able to accomplish in the coming weeks, the last-minute rush appears to involve fewer regulations than Bush's predecessor, Bill Clinton, approved at the end of his tenure.

In some cases, Bush's regulations reflect new interpretations of language in federal laws. In other cases, such as several new counterterrorism initiatives, they reflect new executive branch decisions in areas where Congress -- now out of session and focused on the elections -- left the president considerable discretion.

The burst of activity has made this a busy period for lobbyists who fear that industry views will hold less sway after the elections. The doors at the New Executive Office Building have been whirling with corporate officials and advisers pleading for relief or, in many cases, for hastened decision making.

According to the Office of Management and Budget's regulatory calendar, the commercial scallop-fishing industry came in two weeks ago to urge that proposed catch limits be eased, nearly bumping into National Mining Association officials making the case for easing rules meant to keep coal slurry waste out of Appalachian streams. A few days earlier, lawyers for kidney dialysis and biotechnology companies registered their complaints at the OMB about new Medicare reimbursement rules. Lobbyists for customs brokers complained about proposed counterterrorism rules that require the advance reporting of shipping data.

Bush's aides are acutely aware of the political risks of completing their regulatory work too late. On the afternoon of Bush's inauguration, Jan. 20, 2001, his chief of staff issued a government-wide memo that blocked the completion or implementation of regulations drafted in the waning days of the Clinton administration that had not yet taken legal effect.

"Through the end of the Clinton administration, we were working like crazy to get as many regulations out as possible," said Donald R. Arbuckle, who retired in 2006 after 25 years as an OMB official. "Then on Sunday, the day after the inauguration, OMB Director Mitch Daniels called me in and said, 'Let's pull back as many of these as we can.' "

Clinton's appointees wound up paying a heavy price for procrastination. Bush's team was able to withdraw 254 regulations that covered such matters as drug and airline safety, immigration and indoor air pollutants. After further review, many of the proposals were modified to reflect Republican policy ideals or scrapped altogether.

Seeking to avoid falling victim to such partisan tactics, White House Chief of Staff Joshua B. Bolten in May imposed a Nov. 1 government-wide deadline to finish major new regulations, "except in extraordinary circumstances."

That gives officials just a few more weeks to meet an effective Nov. 20 deadline for the publication of economically significant rules, which take legal effect only after a 60-day congressional comment period. Less important rules take effect after a 30-day period, creating a second deadline of Dec. 20.

OMB spokeswoman Jane Lee said that Bolten's memo was meant to emphasize the importance of "due diligence" in ensuring that late-term regulations are sound. "We will continue to embrace the thorough and high standards of the regulatory review process," she said.

As the deadlines near, the administration has begun to issue regulations of great interest to industry, including, in recent days, a rule that allows natural gas pipelines to operate at higher pressures and new Homeland Security rules that shift passenger security screening responsibilities from airlines to the federal government. The OMB also approved a new limit on airborne emissions of lead this month, acting under a court-imposed deadline.

Many of the rules that could be issued over the next few weeks would ease environmental regulations, according to sources familiar with administration deliberations.

A rule put forward by the National Marine Fisheries Service and now under final review by the OMB would lift a requirement that environmental impact statements be prepared for certain fisheries-management decisions and would give review authority to regional councils dominated by commercial and recreational fishing interests.

An Alaska commercial fishing source, granted anonymity so he could speak candidly about private conversations, said that senior administration officials promised to "get the rule done by the end of this month" and that the outcome would be a big improvement.

Lee Crockett of the Pew Charitable Trusts' Environment Group said the administration has received 194,000 public comments on the rule and protests from 80 members of Congress as well as 160 conservation groups. "This thing is fatally flawed" as well as "wildly unpopular," Crockett said.

Two other rules nearing completion would ease limits on pollution from power plants, a major energy industry goal for the past eight years that is strenuously opposed by Democratic lawmakers and environmental groups.

One rule, being pursued over some opposition within the Environmental Protection Agency, would allow current emissions at a power plant to match the highest levels produced by that plant, overturning a rule that more strictly limits such emission increases. According to the EPA's estimate, it would allow millions of tons of additional carbon dioxide into the atmosphere annually, worsening global warming.

A related regulation would ease limits on emissions from coal-fired power plants near national parks.

A third rule would allow increased emissions from oil refineries, chemical factories and other industrial plants with complex manufacturing operations.

These rules "will force Americans to choke on dirtier air for years to come, unless Congress or the new administration reverses these eleventh-hour abuses," said lawyer John Walke of the Natural Resources Defense Council.

But Scott H. Segal, a Washington lawyer and chief spokesman for the Electric Reliability Coordinating Council, said that "bringing common sense to the Clean Air Act is the best way to enhance energy efficiency and pollution control." He said he is optimistic that the new rule will help keep citizens' lawsuits from obstructing new technologies.

Jonathan Shradar, an EPA spokesman, said that he could not discuss specifics but added that "we strive to protect human health and the environment." Any rule the agency completes, he said, "is more stringent than the previous one."

»

The Whole World is Watching‏

The election is upon us. More than 20% of Americans have already voted and Election Day is only four days away. True Vote's report on the election so far shows lots of problems from registration through voting, but U.S. election integrity advocates are mobilized and the whole world is watching. Many organizations and individuals are working to ensure an election result that voters can trust.

This week I met with two international election observers from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe. OSCE's Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights is engaged in an election observation mission in the United States in 40 states. True Vote provided them with a breadth of examples of election issues that they should be monitoring.

Yesterday, I went with two colleagues to seven embassies in Washington, DC to deliver a "Petition for International Observers for the U.S. Presidential Elections 2008." The petition was submitted by TrueVote.US, No More Stolen Elections, the Economic Human Rights Project, Chesapeake Citizens and Global Exchange. Today, the petition is being delivered to the United Nations. We want to make sure that if the election results are contested steps have been taken so that the U.N. is able to participate in ensuring the integrity of the U.S. election. You can see a summary of the petition here, and the full petition here. Watch a video of our delivery of the petition in Washington, DC.

Our international actions are to let American officials know that the whole world is watching. Please sign the petition to support our call for international involvement in a disputed election. Click here to sign the petition.

TrueVote.US's action alerts, joined in by the No More Stolen Elections Campaign, have let election administrators know that there are thousands of eyes watching, their actions will be monitored and reported on so that they can be held accountable. We hope to applaud a smoothly run honest election, but if not we will work for a 2008 election Americans can trust.

While there is more work to do to ensure the integrity of U.S. elections, in recent years Democracy advocates had an impact. This year, a majority of Americans will be voting with a paper record, a shrinking number are voting on touch screen machines and there is more flexibility in when people can vote. Early voting has already shown the need for more reform and True Vote will advocate for a democracy agenda in the next Congress.

Thank you for your support. When we have called on you to take action many of you have. We appreciate it. If you are able to support our work with a donation that would be helpful at this critical time. Click here to donate.

Sincerely,

Kevin Zeese

Executive Director


2842 N. Calvert St.
Baltimore, MD 21218
443-708-8360
TrueVote.US is a project of the
Campaign for Fresh Air & Clean Politics


The NewStandard: A ParEcon Workplace is Possible


By Jessica Azulay

[Excerpted from the book Real Utopia (AK Press, June 2008)]


A parecon workplace is possible. I have experienced one, and now I believe we can overcome capitalism.

The hierarchical workplace is an insidious institution. It is a powerful mechanism through which capitalism imposes and normalizes some of its most vicious values: It thrives on competition. It encourages authoritarianism and subservience. It rewards workers for their race, gender, education, output, age, conformity, and their ability to "work the system." It is dangerous for individual empowerment and democracy, yet it is embraced even by most social-change organizations. It must be subverted.

The theory of Participatory Economics provides a framework for creating a new kind of workplace in present-day market economies. It shows us how to organize our work around a different set of values: equity, solidarity, democracy, and diversity.

Unlike some facets of the parecon vision, which may seem lofty and futuristic, the workplace model can to a great extent be immediately implemented. I say this with confidence because I have done it.

For four years, I, along with several co-workers, labored in a parecon-based workplace to produce a daily, online news publication called The NewStandard. TNS, as we called it, was 100 percent reader funded and not-for-profit. It upheld the highest ethical standards in the news industry and focused on the perspectives of people most affected by current events and government and corporate policy.

Our particular project was a less-than-ideal laboratory for parecon. At its peak, when there were six of us, we worked from four different locations, which made communication challenging. We worked grueling hours to meet daily publishing deadlines, leaving little time and energy for other aspects of our organization. And the funding pressures of the news and alternative-media industries kept our publication on the financial brink.

Yet we found even this to be a rich environment in which to stave off hierarchy. Using the parecon fundamentals---balanced job complexes, participatory decision-making, and payment for effort and sacrifice---we were able to experiment, invent, and reinvent until we found ways of operating that were increasingly efficient and fair.

The workplace structure we created for ourselves was unlike any other parecon-based organization we have ever heard of. Parecon's emphasis on diversity, self-management and solidarity allowed each of us to participate in the development of our organization and to help it work for each and all of us. So here is how this exciting economic vision was put into practice by Megan Tady, Shreema Mehta, Catherine Komp, Brian Dominick, Brendan Coyne, Michelle Chen, Simone Baribeau and myself.

Jill of All Trades

There are many ways to implement balanced job complexes. Some groups have rotated tasks, giving everyone a turn at each to-do. I know of at least one organization that tried to assign an empowerment ranking to each chore. At TNS, we didn't have the time to get very scientific about it and we also needed each staffer to work on things she was good at.

We divided our work into four categories: managerial, content, administrative, and something we called "conmin." Had we all been working in the same physical space, there would have been a janitorial category, but since we each worked from home, the messiness of our respective workplaces was not a collective concern.

The managerial category covered work related to decision-making. It included attending collective meetings, participating in email discussions, serving on decision-making committees, and other forms of coordination and management that involved policy-related decision-making.

The content category included tasks associated with creating and publishing: reporting, editing, website development, etc. Since this work became the public face of our organization and required a high skill level, we considered it very empowering.

Administrative work included most of the behind-the-scenes tasks: bookkeeping, answering email, providing technical support to website users, opening the snail mail, answering the phone, cutting and pasting website text or computer code, taking meeting notes, etc.

Finally, the conmin category was something we created to encompass tasks that were less desirable than most content work, but more empowering than most administrative work. This was not one of our original categories, but we created it out of necessity to acknowledge that some tasks carry empowerment with them, but are nonetheless tedious. This category included activities like writing text for our fundraising drives, fact checking, and putting together our member newsletter.

When we divided up the work, we tried to make sure that each staffer was assigned roughly the same number of hours of each kind of work. It didn't always come out equal, but we tried to address inequities by rotating tasks when possible and assigning new or temporary tasks according to who was low on certain types of work. We also audited ourselves periodically by keeping track of who spent how much time on what.

Some aspects of our jobs were very similar. For instance, participation in collective meetings and email discussions were part of everyone's balanced job complex. We also took turns acting as facilitator and note-taker at meetings.

The rest of our workdays were fairly specialized. My own balanced job complex during the last year of publication consisted mostly of editing work (content) and an occasional writing assignment (content). I was also the main fact-checker (conmin), the article coordinator (managerial) and the bookkeeper (administrative). And I posted content to the website most mornings (administrative).

Brian Dominick's job complex included website development (content), copy editing (content) and writing/editing short news bulletins (content). He also posted content to the website (administrative), answered the mail and phones (administrative), performed website upkeep (administrative) and provided technical support (administrative). And he coordinated our In Other News section (managerial).

Another co-worker, Megan Tady, spent most of her time writing articles (content) as well as doing some editing (content). She was a member of the fundraising/promotion and accountability committees (both a mix of managerial and conmin). And she managed all member email (administrative). Most of the other "managing reporters" like Megan had similar job complexes.

Organized Anarchy

At TNS it wasn't that no one was in charge; everyone was in charge. But we did not make decisions in isolation, which would have lead to chaos. Instead, we developed a sophisticated structure to facilitate quick group decisions, self-management and accountability. This was based on a formal policy we called the Participatory Decision-Making Process.

The goal of the decision-making process was to engage all participants in order to account for diverse views and opinions and arrive at the most widely agreeable or acceptable outcomes. The greater the impact a decision would have on the organization, the more agreement it needed.

We arrived at decisions using a variety of democratic methods, including consensus and voting. When a decision had a large impact on our organization, we required consensus, which to us meant that everyone actively accepted the decision. We also limited the circumstances in which members could block consensus to those in which a member felt a decision constituted a radical departure from the mission or core values of the organization or the decision would pose a moral dilemma unacceptable to the blocker.

When impact on the organization was smaller and removed from the realm of morality and core values, we employed a voting method. Sometimes we used simple majority (four out of six votes, for instance), and sometimes we required a super majority (five out of six votes).

Regardless of which method was used, a formal discussion process always preceded a decision so that staffers could weigh in, ask questions, modify proposals, or express dissent. Dissent was always recorded in our meeting notes, even when dissenters eventually accepted an outcome.

To better comply with the principles of parecon, we also sometimes used other, more-unorthodox methods, in conjunction with consensus or voting.

One such method was called "proportional input." We used this to account for the disparate impact a decision might have on one or more staff members. When using a voting method, like simple or super majority, individual staffers were assigned additional votes based on how much the decision would impact them.

When using proportional input with consensus, a person who stood to be disproportionately affected by a decision could block consensus, even if the decision posed no departure from the organizational mission and presented no moral dilemma.�

Another unorthodox method we used was called "proportional outcome." This method was designed to increase the diversity of our decision-making outcomes. For instance, we used proportional outcome to decide which of several possible new features to implement on our website. We each ranked the possibilities from favorite to least favorite, added up the scores assigned to each item and then used the items with the top three scores.

Proportional-output voting was invaluable in cases where we were seeking the "best" solutions, rather than trying to determine right and wrong ways of moving forward. We often used this method when deciding how much to buy or how much to spend on something. Instead of trying to gain majority support for a specific number, we would each propose a number, average the proposals and use that average as our final decision.

This Participatory Decision-Making Process probably sounds complicated, but over time it became pretty intuitive. For most day-to-day decisions we reached unanimity very easily, even when a voting procedure could have been used. Most of us found it easy to reach compromises and stay relatively unattached to our own preferences because no one wanted to sit in meetings longer than necessary. Staffers had to agree to the decision-making process before joining, and experienced staffers helped newer collective members navigate the process until they were comfortable with it.

Speaking of meetings, we did have a lot of them. We held short morning meetings (about 20 minutes) most weekdays to decide which stories TNS would pursue. These meetings took place at the same time every morning and were conducted over a free conference-calling system. Other day-to-day decisions were made over email, instant message, or an occasional emergency conference call.

Decisions that could not be made with these methods or that needed longer discussion were saved for our weekly meetings, which were also held by conference call. These lasted about one to two hours. Facilitation for these meetings rotated among all staff members. The facilitator was also in charge of putting an agenda together and sending it out to all collective members ahead of time. Note taking for these meetings also rotated.

We also held board meetings a few times a year. For these, everyone traveled to one location for a "retreat," which involved a series of meetings over two or three days. Whenever possible, we saved major organizational decisions for these face-to-face discussions. The task of creating the agenda for these retreats rotated among staff as well.

Before you think the TNS workplace was utopian, let me assure you that we did have problems. Sometimes people habitually missed their deadlines. Sometimes staffers violated our policies. Sometimes they abused power. Eventually, we realized that we needed a way to hold each other accountable for such transgressions.

The main goals of our accountability process, developed over several months, were (1) to provide a fair and quick way to address problematic behavior, (2) to focus on restitution instead of punishment, (3) to provide staff members with support or resources they needed to change their behavior, (4) to allow transgressing staff members to own up to their mistakes and self-manage their remedies.

Any staff member could ask for an accountability meeting about another staffer. At the meeting, the problematic behavior would be described in detail and the negative impacts on individuals or the organization would be listed. Staffers would then decide if the violation was mild, medium or severe. Severity of violations would determine which remedies staffers would have at their disposal.

For mild violations, staffers could ask the violator to write an "owning up letter" to the rest of the collective in which she would describe her own problematic behavior and apologize for it. For medium violations, there were several options, including asking the transgressor to come up with her own plan for restitution, prescribing a course of restitution (like extra work to make up for the extra work she caused someone else), corrective instruction (like re-reading the journalist handbook or read a tutorial about the specific area she messed up with).

For situations in which decision-making power or other forms of empowerment were abused, the collective might temporarily shift the transgressor's balanced job complex to include more rote work and less content or management work.

For the most severe violations, the collective could decide to take away decision-making power specific to the offense. The collective could also decide to downgrade a staffer's status from full collective member back to trial collective member. This was a severe step that would strip the transgressor of blocking power for six months at the end of which all other collective members would have to reach consensus to restore full membership.

Payment for Effort and Sacrifice

All full-time staff members at The NewStandard were paid the same salary, regardless of seniority. Though we started off having receive pay in the form of promised "sweat equity," by the end, we were paying $21,600 per year, a living wage in most of the cities from which we worked. We also provided health insurance and eleven days paid vacation.

Our sick-day policy was a little less traditional. We wanted to recognize that some people get sick more often or have more family emergencies than others through no fault of their own. So we gave each collective member three personal days that they could use in the event of sickness or personal emergency. And then we created a collective "pot" in which we put four days for each staffer. (For instance, when there were six of us, there were 24 days in the pot at the beginning of each year.) Anyone could use days in the pot if they ran out of personal days. But if the pot had ever run out of days (which it never did), anyone who used more than four from the pot, might have to start paying days back. This just meant that some of the days they took would revert from paid to unpaid days.

The result of this policy was that people had a disincentive to take more days than they needed because they knew that leaving days in the pot would help other collective members. Staffers also knew that if they took more than seven days, they might have to pay some of them back if the pot ran out. This policy helped foster solidarity among the staff, as well as accommodate a diversity of needs.

Aside from employing a full-time staff, TNS also paid several dozen freelance journalists over the years. We knew that coming up with a system for paying reporters based on their effort and sacrifice would be difficult, but we tried anyway. I think we got pretty close.

We made a list of the different kinds of work entailed in writing news articles and then we assigned a dollar value to each. For instance, conducting a full interview with a source was worth $20, while reading a document (like a court transcript or a scientific study) was valued at $10. Calling a source for comment chalked up $5. There was a base fee for all articles on top of which fees for these specific types of work were added.

We set up an online system so that after publication of an article, a journalist could log on through our website and fill out an invoice. She would list all the interviews conducted, calls for comment made, documents read, etc. She could also note any extra effort that went into the article. For instance, sometimes journalists had to read documents that were hundreds of pages long or sometimes sources were particularly difficult to interview. When she was done, her editor would review the invoice and adjust amounts accordingly. The editor could also add bonuses for clean copy (which saved others labor time), a quick turnaround (which implied sacrifice) or other extra efforts.

The Capitalist Intersection

Many people think that our nonprofit, reader-driven funding model killed TNS. I think it would be more accurate to say that capitalism killed TNS. Our funding strategy, which was to ask readers to donate a small amount each month, proved successful in many ways. Per reader, we raised an extraordinary amount of money, much more than we could have if we had tried selling our readers' eyeballs to advertisers.

Our main funding problem was that we never gained enough readers. I believe that is because our news-making model incorporated gobs of hard work and ethics, and we were competing in a greed-driven marketplace that generally rewards exactly the opposite.

Aside from funding, the toughest challenge our collective faced was hiring. The U.S. education system and capitalist economy do not prepare people for working in a parecon workplace. We needed people who were skilled journalists, but willing to work for low pay while putting in the extra effort our high standards required. We also needed people who were ready and able to take on the challenges involved in managing a struggling nonprofit organization, but who were willing to share that power collectively.

We found that many skilled journalists did not always have the desire to manage an organization or enthusiasm for collective decision-making. And people with enthusiasm for our workplace values often lacked the reporting or editing skills we required. On top of that, almost everyone qualified for the job could find better pay elsewhere.

For those of us who did end up working at TNS, it was life-changing. Those who had never even heard of parecon before joining our collective quickly adapted to it and became devotees. The very things that made hiring hard, made working on TNS rewarding. Each of us was able to learn and grow in many different directions at once and develop diverse aspects of our professional lives. Although our adventure did not last forever, the four-year experience that we created for ourselves and the example that we provided to those who came into contact with us still reverberates.

We discovered the parecon workplace to be an inspirational institution. I believe it could be a powerful mechanism through which a movement for radical economic change could facilitate and normalize its most vital values: equity, solidarity, self-management and diversity. It encourages individual empowerment and democracy, yet it is rejected by most social-change institutions. They see it not as a threat to capitalism, but as a threat to their internal status quo. But, if we must become now what we wish to see in a better society, resistance to true workplace equity and democracy must give way, and nonhierarchical workplaces must be implemented.

�

Here is the second piece as promised...

Greenspan: The Torments of Contrition
By Frederic F. Clairmont

I was stunned like many on hearing the news on the BBC at 22:00hrs on the 23 October that Greenspan had confessed in his lugubrious mea culpa to Congress that he was ‘shocked in disbelief' by the sheer velocity and propagation of the demolition of the edifice of finance capitalism. His confession of contrition, whose transcript I have now read in its entirety, was not the act of a desperate shell-shocked shriveled creature that had seen the ravages wrought by his policies at the Federal Reserve, i.e. the central bank of the U S caste oligarchy. In those decades of public office, shuttling from Wall Street to Washington D C. as a transplant of Goldman Sachs, (the world's largest investment bank), he had deployed his exalted tenure for the collective enrichment of his discredited caste of financial cronies. Not to be excluded was his massively successful individual accumulation.
�
It was not fortuitous that these spasms of contrition transpired at a moment when the worlds' stock markets, from New York to Tokyo, recorded triple digit declines. The rout of equity and commodity markets remains unstoppable. The despicable hedge funds in a state of disarray are selling (deleveraging is the ugly buzz word) every piece of office furniture they can grab to meet the payments of their lenders. Their paradisiacal days of short-selling and the carry-on trade and other unbridled speculative plunder of the big casino money machine have run into the mud. Even Federal backed government mortgages, hawked by blue-chip corporations, have joined the tumble; no banks, insurance companies, mutual and pension funds are immune from ruin; most of the quasi colonial so-called emergent markets are poised to default on their rocketing levels of debt; the scrambling of every rickety capitalist government to save its skin is on the top of the agenda. In this cesspool of panic and collapse there is no haven for the bourgeois order to seek cover. Non-stop capital infusions (i.e. taxpayers money) by the manipulators of finance capital to the tune of trillions of dollars are impotent to resuscitate the semblance of a bygone era of normality. The dogmas and rotting institutional underpinnings of the bourgeois order that bamboozled many into believing that their creations were things of fixity and permanence have been irreversibly flung into the abyss of a deep black slump. What we are seeing in effect is the spectacle of the kingdom of swindledom run amuck.
�
Greenspan was the impresario of an El Dorado of incomparable pickings that would have made even Warren Hastings and the East India Company, and their subsequent emulators in occupied India, (that escalated into the mass genocide in the subsequent century) appear like a bunch of miserable petty pickpockets. A theme that I elaborated in my researches on The Rise and Fall Economic Liberalism: The Making of the Economic Gulag.
�
�His mea culpa is an act of immense historical significance, yet in perspective it is nothing but a morsel of trivial apologetics. The criminal tale of his abject confessions of the system's delirium tremens told us nothing that we had not known before. What was startling, however, was that this death rattle came from a stricken soul that could no longer coexist with his burden of guilt. What we have witnessed is the unfolding of the personal tragedy of a sordidly bankrupt and corrupt human being who sees the approaching finality of finance capitalism and its failures as the system meandered from upheaval to upheaval during his reign.
�
His confessions came at that propitious moment when the world stock markets without exception were wallowing in the excrement of the most ignoble economic collapse that our planet has ever seen, easily surpassing in its horrors and intensity that of 1929. Trillions of dollars were scrubbed from the world's panic stricken bourses in days and hours - a movement that shows no signs of abating . The revulsion that millions experienced on seeing this debacle on their television screens and reading the agonizing media headlines also demonstrated to the world that the savings and assets of tens of millions of working peoples - the creators of wealth - had been blatantly swindled at the throw of a gambler's toss.
�
Greenspan was the criminal prime mover that abetted the lethal rise and rise of derivative markets presently topping $155 trillion dollars, almost four times the size of our planet's wealth. The criminality of his policies was matched by his intellectual impoverishment perceived in his tortured lingo that " the whole intellectual edifice collapsed in the summer of last year [ August 2007] because the data inputted (sic)into the risk management models generally covered only the past two decades, a period of euphoria.".
�
Stripped of its jargon this meant that sub-prime loans were chopped, diced and packaged into toxic mortgage-backed securities and other derivatives that were marketed at prodigious profits the world over. The trough was brimming. It was the grand extravaganza of capitalist internationalism. This gimcrack house of cards ignominiously crumbled as US borrowers defaulted on mortgage payments in droves, and as house prices slumped. Never mind that his utterance is ambiguous - markets thrive on ambiguity and double talk. Of which Greenspan is an unrivaled practitioner.
�
�Note the conjuror's hand of this financial swindler; it is deemed an intellectual edifice. We are sedulously invited to believe that we are not dealing with the pitiless world of class power and exploitation. What transpired in the markets was all an immense error of the intellect. Capitalism's destructive convulsion generated by the juggernaut of capital itself is thus reduced to a crisis of the intellect. The swindlers that hawked these death-dealing derivatives do not really exist. It is a fantasy. All of this was nothing more than an intellectual shortfall. This brings us to the pivotal issue: capitalism is not an exploitative engine; there is nothing within it that is engineered to exploit any one. It transcends social classes. Competitive markets and the law of supply and demand ensure that there are neither winners or losers. Markets are thus the grand equalizers. Capitalism and the market forces through which it functions thus becomes the supreme expression of democratic choice ; its raison d'etre is rooted in the infallible concatenation of social change. All that matters, as Greenspan teaches, is that we were misguided by the wrong models.. In sum, by the powers of intellect that were fleetingly irrational.
�
Listen again to this bit of sanctimonious babbling that reveals his propensity for the soothing nostrum of models. " I found a flaw in the model that I perceived is the critical functioning structure that defines how the world works. That's precisely the reason I was shocked...I still do not fully understand why it happened, and obviously to the extent that I figure where it happened and why, I will change my views." It would not be a waste of our time to remind him that his dogmas , like his persona, have already been torn to shreds. In much the same manner as the shattered fortunes of his political master in the White House he served so obsequiously.
�
�No doubt by the choice of the appropriate model he means the selection of the sharpest butcher's knife. To be sure, Greenspan's cold blooded policies were deliberately designed to enrich a specific parasitical class, knowing full well that prices do not soar infinitely into the celestial spheres.; ultimately their descent is precipitous. The boom is metamorphosed into a bubble and the bubble implodes into a bust. The rich and the mega rich would not be affected by what he designates as the Tsunami.
�
The world's biggest bubble had burst in August 2007. And its horrendous reverberations on the lives of millions who had been bulldozed out of their homes - the American Dream - were merely one facet of capital's self-inflicted agony. His maudlin prattle unmasks, however, the extent of his impotence and indubitably, I daresay, the magnitude of the criminality of international capitalism in its period of irreversible putrescence. This is what Saramago, the combative Nobel prize laureate, no doubt means when he trenchantly said that the crash , and the ensuing economic and social holocaust that trailed in its wake, is one of the greatest crimes against humanity ever recorded.
�
�It is well to let Greenspan, now wriggling in his state of apoplexy, babble on: "Those of us who have who looked to the self-interest of lending institutions to protect shareholder's equity - myself especially - are now a state of shocked disbelief". Why should he be shocked? He has lost nothing but his wretched illusions. His fortunes are unimpaired. His officially estimated net worth is $15 billion , and presumably that does not include his treasure ensconced in Caribbean tax havens and of which he is one of its most ferocious protagonists. Those who are traumatized to the marrow are the workers in Pittsburg and Detroit and Cleveland and the nation's industrial heartland now transmogrified into a toxic wasteland. On this misery is superimposed the outsourcing of millions of jobs.
�
�During his stewardship the soaring inequalities that his caste and his policies spawned had surpassed those of the Gilded Age [1890-1914], and the abysmally corrupt regimes of Harding, Coolidge and Hoover in the twenties. As for his bellicose support for the $3 trillion colonial war in Mesopotamia comment is superfluous. As the once sanctified apparatchik of world money and credit markets he framed monetary and fiscal policy that enriched the cronies of his irredeemably debased caste oligarchy. He did what his class interests dictated he should have done. In this respect, his ideology and his policies were flawlessly meshed.
�
�Greenspan enshrined the reality and aspirational drives of the ruling caste oligarchy in The Fortune 500. He remains its prime exemplar. Capital must never be understood as an impersonal force; it is embedded in the complex workings of accumulation. Here was the divinity worshipped by the profiteers of the world's money engines in every niche and cranny of big-moneyed finance the world over for decades; the paltriest of his pronouncements were sifted and scrutinized , as in the mutterings of the Delphic Oracle, for the rich offerings they were assumed to possess.
�
�He incarnated the triumphalism of neo-liberalism,; he extolled the intoxicating magic of the market place, the glories of privatization, the Washington consensus , the conquests and ruthless pillage of foreign markets masquerading under the innocuous alibi of globalization whose ultimate quest, as Greenspan sees it, is the pursuit of life, liberty and happiness. The American economy that he presided was dependent however on the world's savings. By its very nature this jerry-built structure proved ephemeral, jacked up by borrowed money and borrowed time.
�
�The driving force of imperialism and the laws of its causality found no home in his desiccated ideological apparatus. He was at once a master of corporate capitalism that had amassed his fortune in Goldman Sachs subsequently catapulting his carcass to the highest reaches of the corporate Gulag's state apparatus where his thrust for personal enrichment sustained its remorseless strides. In his view, the goals of the public and private sectors could not be grasped as autonomous entities; they were interpenetrative and his ideological praxis confirmed it.
�
I shall say no more at this juncture but let me add , in conclusion, that we must be grateful for the trivia that he has bequeathed us. A sewer needs no advertisement and the personal class trajectory of his advance lucidly exemplifies this truth. His tearful contrition delivered in that Sanctum Sanctorum of capital's entrenched power has served to smash the foundations of the empire's ruling class economics, preached by such servile sycophants as Samuelson and his tribe of neo-liberals. His mumblings in the sanctuary of the caste oligarchy have undermined the institutional foundations of corporate capitalism and its works. His mea culpa was not part of this design. Yet irrespective of the forces that impelled him to perform his act of contrition we must render him our thanks infinite.
�
Frederic F. Clairmont

�