Friday, January 06, 2006

Dems and Privacy Politics


By Cliff Schecter, AlterNet. Posted January 6, 2006.



Do you want Karl Rove rummaging through your personal files? The NSA perusing printed copies of debates with friends abroad over who is most likely to emerge victorious in this summer's World Cup in Germany? As the enormous scope of the National Security Agency's wiretapping scandal and the ongoing saga of Karl Rove's double supersecret background conversation with reporter Matt Cooper keep the pundits merrily pontificating about the future of this republic, the Democratic Party, often accused of not forging a coherent message stating its core principles, has been presented with a historic opportunity.

Rove and the indicted Scooter Libby's blunder, which was worthy of "Animal House" hero Bluto Blutarsky, George Bush's burgeoning Republican police state and growing corporate abuse of private records provides Democrats with an opportunity to define themselves. They should support a thematic concept that, ironically, has been a central philosophy Democrats have embraced for years to protect the rights of women: a Constitutional right to privacy. Only now, Democrats should not only support this idea in the abstract but push for it to be codified as an amendment to the Constitution.

Why privacy? Because Rove's loose lips aside, a combination of the big government conservatism and corporate cronyism displayed by Washington Republicans has rightfully made the public, including those on the right and left of the spectrum, wary of a group of ideologues and grafters who seek to stick their collective noses into every aspect of their lives. This, in turn, has given Democrats the chance to not only define themselves but also tap into the growing populist indignation of moderates, independents, libertarians and even many traditional conservatives for the current GOP matrix.

Election results over the past year, and both elite and public reaction to GOP policy and rhetoric, provide ample evidence that privacy is a burgeoning concern across ideological lines. The special election that almost saw the election of Iraqi Freedom veteran Paul Hackett in a cherry-red Republican part of Ohio was nothing short of staggering. Hackett's compelling biography and deficient opponent were certainly a large part of his winning 48.3 percent of the vote in a district President Bush won with a 63 percent average in 2000 and 2004, and former Rep. Rob Portman won in 2004 by 44 percent. Yet, equally as important was Hackett's message, summed up neatly in one of his campaign advertisements:

I'm for limited government. I don't need Washington to tell me how to live my personal life, or how to pray to my God. And I don't need Washington to dictate to my wife the decisions that she makes with her doctor, any more than I need Washington to tell me which guns I can keep in my gun safe.

Hackett is not alone in speaking the language of privacy, however. A newly minted Democratic celebrity, Gov. Brian Schweitzer of Montana, won the governorship in that blood-red state in 2004 by stressing that people should be protected from the vagaries of government and business. In speaking about abortion as early as his 2000 U.S. Senate race against Republican incumbent Conrad Burns, Schweitzer said, "The government should not intervene in a woman's right to make health care decisions. Those decisions should be left up to the woman and her doctor." According to David Sirota, a Schweitzer campaign strategist who wrote a piece on the governor for Washington Monthly magazine, this theme extended to personal land rights:

Schweitzer drafted a nine-point plan to protect cherished hunting and fishing access rights on public and private lands. Among other things, Schweitzer called for keeping public lands in the state's hands, for spending more money to maintain them for hunters and anglers, and for using fees from hunting licenses to buy easements from private property owners to give sportsmen easier access to fields and streams.

The right of hunters, anglers and fishermen to land usage without the interference of government or corporations looking to buy public lands from cash-strapped local governments goes to the heart of the issue of privacy. In fact, property rights landed on the front burner after the Kelo v. New London, Connecticut court decision, with many reasonable Americans resenting the possibility of being forced off their land for mall rats searching for that perfect slushy. With 89 percent of Connecticut residents opposing the use of eminent domain to confiscate their land, you could say we have a bipartisan issue here.

The public reaction against invasive legislation and maneuvering by the GOP has been equally as enthusiastic. The hastily passed post-9/11 Patriot Act is a useful example. The president and a Republican Congress moved quickly to thwart early attempts by U.S. Rep. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., to permit the sun to set on Patriot Act provisions currently allowing the Justice Department to browse through your Amazon preferred list, sans judicial warrant. Yet, the public clearly finds these extrajudicial searches troubling. An ABC News poll on June 9, 2005, showed that, by a 68 percent to 31 percent margin, Americans oppose the FBI's right to demand records without prior judicial approval. Only 42 percent of Republicans and 32 percent of independents not opposed.

This may have something to do with the fact that a bipartisan group of lawmakers, including Democratic Sen. Russell Feingold on the left and NRA board member and Republican Sen. Larry Craig on the right, recently blocked the permanent reauthorization of most Patriot Act provisions. They also blocked temporary permission (2009) to continue two more controversial measures, roving wiretaps and secret warrants for books, records and other items from businesses, hospitals and libraries. The news that the FBI had been spying on such known Al Qaeda front groups as the Quakers and PETA may not have strengthened the administration's position.

Public wariness over the Bush administration's intentions should only increase with the recent revelations by New York Times reporter James Risen that the National Security Agency (NSA) has been running a covert program of spying on Americans who choose to be so bold as to speak with someone not living in this country. While the president has trotted out the usual sycophant defenders, the uproar over this abuse of power has been quite bipartisan. The administration has been admonished by Republican senators such as Chuck Hagel and Olympia Snowe. Sen. Arlen Specter has called for hearings when Congress reconvenes.

Add ardent conservatives such as former House impeachment manager Bob Barr, Reagan Justice Department official Bruce Fein and former Nixon speechwriter and New York Times columnist William Safire to those who have called the program "dangerous" and/or "illegal." An institution on the right, the libertarian CATO Institute has used similarly critical language, and now it has become clear that the deputy attorney general under John Ashcroft, James Comey, refused to endorse its continuation in 2004 because of questions about its "legality." The people have spoken about this issue in the past as well, as shown in a September 2003 Gallup Poll, where 67 percent of Americans opposed having their basic civil liberties violated, even to prevent terrorism.

While it almost seems to have occurred a life ago when surrounded by the current firestorm over the NSA spying on Americans, the decision of the fire and brimstone crowd to insert themselves into the personal tragedy of Terry Schiavo's family was less menacing to many Americans. From the ominous threats of Tom DeLay to the pronouncements of telesurgeon Bill Frist that Mrs. Shiavo was essentially in perfect health to sit up, eat cookies and play scrabble with James Dobson, if her husband would only let her, the public saw this episode for what it was: government intrusion into the personal decisions of a grieving family. According to an ABC News Poll taken at the time, 70 percent of respondents opposed Congressional involvement in this issue, including 67 percent of moderates, 61 percent of independents and 57 percent of conservatives.

Last fall, with Democrat Tim Kaine's stunning 6-point defeat of Republican Jerry Kilgore to become the next governor of Virginia, I know of efforts by at least one unaffiliated group, through the use of direct mail, to directly link Kilgore to the Shiavo affair by reminding voters of his support for Congress's decision to intervene. These efforts were concentrated on the Washington, D.C., suburbs, and while other issues came into play, most notably public education and transportation, it is worth noting that this particular group determined that the Schiavo case merited top-three issue attention. On election day, furthermore, Tim Kaine won one of the fastest-growing suburbs in the country, Loudoun County, by 51 percent to 46 percent, a feat the outgoing and very popular Gov. Mark Warner failed to achieve. He also ran up a huge margin of 60,000 votes in Fairfax County, far outpacing either Mark Warner or John Kerry.

Finally, no invasion of privacy party would be complete if big business didn't show up with a Bordeaux. So not surprisingly, when it comes to gleaning personal information for magisterial profits, big business has acted like a rapacious tiger on the Serengeti plain, yet once obtaining these records, has often resembled nothing so much as Inspector Clouseau. According to a June 18, 2005, account by the New York Times, more than 40 million credit card accounts were exposed to potential identity theft because of a computer security breach at a payment processing company. Bank of America also got into the act, losing data tapes containing the personal information of 1.2 million federal employees. The public is clearly anxious about this issue, with constant reports on major news outlets and Newsweek deeming it worthy of a cover story. Yet, when Senator Bill Nelson, D-Fla., sponsored a bill to protect consumers whose financial woes were caused by identity theft, he was voted down largely along party lines by Republicans protecting the interests of you guessed it -- big business.

There are numerous additional concerns that can fit neatly under the rubric of privacy. In fact, if Democrats would only remind them, many voters would also be none too pleased about the effort of Rep. Ernest Istook, R-Okla., to use hidden legislation to access their IRS records or House Majority Leader Tom DeLay's use of the Homeland Security Department as his own personal police force.

In his great work "American Populism: A Social History 1877-1898," historian Robert C. McMath, Jr., discussed how populist reformers "understood that old rules and values were crumbling, and that powerful new economic institutions buttressed by the state threatened their independence." There could be no more apt description of the way many Americans feel today about big government, big business and its new co-equal partner, big faith.

The ability to build a new coalition of the more-than-willing-to-be-left-alone may not be a panacea, but for Democrats it certainly would be one step towards defining themselves and appealing to swaths of the electorate already disgusted with the heavy hand and corruption of the GOP and waiting for a reason to abandon them. Recent elections and public opinion have provided a shining path to success for Democrats.

It is time to take out the issue of privacy as a constitutional guarantee for a spin, as the perfect storm has created an atmosphere ripe for protecting the rights of a diverse group of Americans from a group of authoritarian and profits-at-any-cost-minded Republicans. They might even want to get Samuel Alito on the record as to what he thinks about codifying privacy rights. Should they pursue this issue, they will most likely find themselves emulating the success of the aforementioned "Animal House" hero Bluto Blutarsky, who as you may remember, reached the hallowed halls of the U.S. Senate once his days at Faber College were over.

Clifford D. Schecter is Graduate Honors Fellow at American University, receiving his doctorate in American History. He writes a periodic political debate column for Knight-Ridder News Service, blogs for The Gadflyer and writes a satirical weekly roundup of political events for Americablog.

Prosperity in George Bush's Economy


By Joshua Holland, AlterNet. Posted January 6, 2006.




010606_story

The economy the cable news networks gush about is going gangbusters. We're hearing about 10 straight quarters of strong growth in gross domestic product, and jobs being created at a clip of over 2 million per year. Unemployment is down, and more Americans own their homes than ever before. And don't forget, Americans' net worth is at an all-time high! And all this prosperity, the corporate media will tell you, is thanks to five years of President George Bush.

But that's an economic picture you won't find hanging on the wall of any normal American house. Most of us know that we're not doing as well today as we were a few years ago. According to a recent Gallup Poll, almost two-thirds of those asked said the economy was "fair" or "poor," and almost six in 10 thought it was getting worse.

That disconnect has left many commentators -- especially on the right -- either scratching their heads with befuddlement or raging apoplectically at the bias of the "liberal media."

National Review author Victor Davis Hanson scolded those who read the New York Times for living "in an alternate universe where everything is supposedly going to hell." In "the real adult world," Hanson wrote, "the economy is red-hot, not mired in joblessness or relegating millions to poverty." But in fact, there are 5 million more Americans living in poverty today than there were four years ago.

Gerard Baker, the U.S. editor for Rupert Murdoch's Times of London wrote, "when it comes to economics, all but America's most fervent critics can still only marvel."

"Everything in the American garden is lovely," Baker continued, "So why the long face, buddy?"

I'll tell you why the long face: The economy most of us experience from day to day has been nothing short of painful over the past five years.

Consider these numbers from the Economic Policy Institute -- a left-leaning think-tank (this essay leans heavily on EPI's excellent research):

  • Salaries are still below where they were at the start of the recovery in November 2001. That, while productivity -- the growth of the economic pie -- is up by almost 15 percent. Meaning we're working harder, producing more, for the same money as five years ago.
  • Since the recession ended in 2001, 50 percent more of the growth in corporate income was sucked up as profits than after past recessions. That's left less for those of us who work for a living.
  • As a result, median household income has now fallen for five years in a row. It was 4 percent, or $2,000, lower in 2004 than it was in 1999.

That last figure means that Joe and Jane Average American -- the household smack in the middle of the booming go-go American economy -- have gotten a pay cut for five years in a row. Small wonder they're sporting long faces.

And that hasn't occurred in a bubble; health care costs for that same family (with kids) rose over 40 percent -- yeah, 40 percent --between 2000 and 2003.

Here's a brief guide for sorting out the economy we live in versus the one we're supposed to feel fuzzy and warm about.

Go-go GDP

It's not just that the growth in GDP over the past four years has been skewed towards investors -- it has -- it's that much of it is a chimera. Defense spending, consumer spending -- financed largely by debt -- and rising home values have been the growth engines for the current recovery. Author James Howard Kunstler estimates that from "2001 through 2005, consumer spending and residential construction had together accounted for 90 percent of the total growth in GDP." [italics mine]

That growth hasn't been free and isn't sustainable. U.S. household debt, adjusted for inflation, rose by more than a third over the last four years. Mortgage and consumer debt equals 115 percent of after-tax income, and the amount American families spend paying off those debts is at an all-time high of almost 14 percent of their paychecks. In other words Americans are all paying a hefty monthly debt tax to banks and creditors on top of what we already pay the government.

Wealth, wealth everywhere

The National Review's Jerry Bowyer blames the "mainstream media" for "obsessing over the level of debt of the average American family, which they only look at in a vacuum, [and] completely ignoring the growth of family net worth." If they were honest, he argues, they'd have to acknowledge "the highest level of household wealth in our nation's history."

But much of that newfound wealth is in our homes, and all signs point to a bubble in the sky-high housing market (although it varies widely by region). According to the Center for Economic Policy Research [PDF] -- a progressive think tank -- the current market "has created more than $5 trillion in bubble wealth, the equivalent of $70,000 per average family of four." Housing prices are way above their historic pattern when you look at demand, population and earnings. What's more, the price for home sales has been way out of step with the rental market -- something one wouldn't expect to see if the high prices were based on economic fundamentals. The estate might be real, but its value isn't.

Unemployment

The headline is that the unemployment rate is low and holding steady at around 5 percent. But it's a tricky statistic: people who give up trying to find a job aren't counted, nor are people who are underemployed. Private sector jobs have increased by only about 1 percent since the start of the current economic recovery. Four years into previous recoveries, private sector job growth had averaged almost 9 percent and it's never been less than 6 percent. According to EPI, "The percent of the population that has a job has never recovered since the recession and is still 1.3 percent lower than in March 2001."

The data tell the tale. While one can spin all day long according to his or her worldview and offer up grand theories about Americans' pessimism, the truth is that for about eight out of 10 people on American payrolls, the economy sucks.

Add in high fuel costs and large, highly visible rounds of layoffs in some of America's leading firms, especially in the auto industry. Then consider the latest tactic sweeping across corporate America: using bankruptcy to "seek relief" from pension and health care obligations. As the Wall Street Journal reported:

Whether an assembly-line worker or middle manager, an employee can no longer assume that promises made earlier -- health benefits or fully funded pensions -- will be there when he or she retires. The loss of security arising from Chapter 11 reorganizations has introduced a new element of anxiety into the lives of baby boomers who are approaching 60, not to mention younger workers just starting out in their careers.

That's just part of a growing trend. Of course, last year's bankruptcy reform bill will prevent most working families from enjoying similar "relief."

None of these issues are of any concern to people earning a couple of hundred grand to discuss the economy on Fox or MSNBC. Contra the right's liberal media conspiracy theories, the major media from across the spectrum are reporting the good news about America's booming economy with zeal.

That endless drumbeat comes with social costs.

First, it fuels the bubble mentality. If the economy's going gangbusters but you're struggling, of course you want to get in on the latest billionaire-creating wealth machine. That mentality infected anyone who bought tech stocks in 1999 hoping to become a "dot-com millionaire," just as it has them running around today buying houses at any price with the expectation that they'll get a 10 percent annual return. Alan Greenspan characterized the mindset as being one of "irrational exuberance." But what could be more rational than piling onto the latest bandwagon after watching a half-hour of CNBC's economic triumphalism?

Less easy to quantify is the psychic cost this has on us. The message we get all the time is that our unrivalled, dynamic economy affords opportunities for us all. So, if you're one of the majority who is not doing so well, it must be your fault. It is you, and not any external economic factor, that is keeping you from profiting from the Ownership Society. You are a loser.

A while back, I wrote an article about how the job outsourcing trend has happened at the same time, as deep cuts in transitional training and assistance came down from Washington. A reader sent me an email about how her middle-aged brother had been laid off by the aircraft parts manufacturer where he had worked for 20 years. "You know the hardest part," she wrote, "has been how he's internalized everything. He has such a low sense of self-worth."

Despite our great wealth, we're an unhappy people; we lead the world in mental health problems year in and year out. It's impossible to know to what degree that results from failing to live up to the economic expectations drummed into our heads every time we hear about the wonders of the American economy. But the message to all those families struggling to get by should be: You're not alone, it's all of us.

Joshua Holland is an AlterNet staff writer.

Thursday, January 05, 2006

Congress petitioned for return of Geronimo's remains


December 25, 2005
Indian Country Today
SAN CARLOS, Ariz. - American Indians are petitioning Congress to investigate the elite Skull and Bones society at Yale University and return the remains of Chiricahua Apache warrior Geronimo to Apaches for reburial.
The online petition describes the desecration of Geronimo's grave in 1918 by members of the society, including President George W. Bush's grandfather, Sen. Prescott Bush. The men removed Geronimo's head and a prized silver bridle, which had been buried with him.
''Using acid and amid laughter, they stripped Geronimo's head of hair and flesh. They then took their 'trophies' back to Yale University and put them on display in the clubhouse of the secret fraternity 'Skull and Bones,''' states the petition.
Outraged American Indian tribal members from across the nation and indigenous people from around the world are signing the petition with plans to pressure Congress to act.
Apache leaders want Geronimo to be buried, as he requested, in tribal lands in the mountains of San Carlos.
''Geronimo left his rifle and peace pipe here when they took him away,'' Thompson said. ''When Geronimo was taken from this land, he wanted to come back and be buried on San Carlos in the Triplet Mountains.''
Skull and Bones admitted to San Carlos Apache leaders almost 20 years ago that it was in possession of a skull it called Geronimo's in its secret ''museum'' in New Haven, Conn.
Raleigh Thompson, who served as San Carlos Apache tribal councilman for 16 years, told Indian Country Today that he was among the Apache tribal leaders with whom Skull and Bones officials met in New York in a series of meetings beginning in 1986. He said the society, of which Bush and his father, former President George H.W. Bush, are members, admitted that it held Geronimo's remains.
San Carlos Apache Chairman Ned Anderson and tribal attorney Joe Sparks were also members of the Apache delegation that met with the society in New York. Anderson and Thompson said the delegation met with Skull and Bones officials and Jonathan Bush, brother of George H.W. Bush.
Thompson said Prescott Bush was among a group of six Army soldiers who dug up Geronimo's remains at Fort Sill, Okla., in 1918. The San Carlos Apache Tribe received a copy of a logbook describing the grave-robbing and a photograph of a skull on display before meeting with the board in New York.
Thompson said the society attempted to return a skull - that of a child - which the Apache delegation rejected. Skull and Bones members subsequently threatened legal action if the photograph were not returned.
Attorney Endicott Davison, representing Skull and Bones, denied that the society had Geronimo's skull. He claimed the logbook was a hoax.
Alexandra Robbins, a former staff member of The New Yorker magazine and author of ''Secrets of the Tomb: Skull and Bones, the Ivy League and the Hidden Paths of Power,'' told ICT that her research supports the Apache leaders' statements. Robbins believes that Geronimo's skull is in the society's tomb.
The petition for the return and reburial of Geronimo's skull states that Skull and Bones is a secret society founded at Yale in 1832. Its history is intertwined with that of the German Illuminati and the Nazi Party, according to the petition.
''They maintain a windowless building called 'The Tomb' at 64 High Street, New Haven, Connecticut. The club's assets are controlled by a front company, The Russell Trust Association Inc. Every year, 15 Yale juniors are 'tapped' for Skull & Bones membership. They are indoctrinated into the cultish society with elaborate rituals steeped in satanic theatricism and latent homosexuality.
''The goal of this fraternity is to create the ultimate network of 'good ole boys' around the world. Their alumni include Prescott Bush's son [George H.W.] and grandson [George W.] as well as heads of state and leaders of numerous intelligence agencies, trading companies, business empires and law firms,'' according to the petition.
Since the initial leak of information to the Apache leaders, other sources have confirmed that Geronimo's skull is, as asserted in the petition, indeed on display in The Tomb and considered the ''mascot'' of this ''club'' on High Street.
The petition further states that the ''undersigned are horrified with this display of elitist, racist witchcraft'' and asks Congress, with the assistance of whatever law enforcement necessary, to launch an immediate investigation into the theft and possession of human remains by Skull and Bones, Russell Trust Association Inc. and any members of the U.S. government involved, past or present.
Stephen Flute, Crow Creek Sioux Tribe, signed the petition and said, ''If the situation were reversed, someone would be in jail or would have been executed. It wouldn't even matter to them if the right person were in jail, as long as one of 'us' paid the price.''
Sheri Big Back Bement, Northern Cheyenne/Apache, said Geronimo remains respected. ''You will never see an Indian dig up the bones of the dead. We know what respect is. Their ignorance and stupidity will come back on them and their families.''
Mohawk Sakaronhiotane Ricky Diabo signed with this message: ''When you mess with the spirits, you shall be punished by the spirits.''
View the petition and signatures online at www.petitiononline.com/Geronimo/petition.html

ChiricahuaApachewarrior_Geronimo_.jpg

The Unrestrained President


By Tom Engelhardt
TomDispatch.com

Wednesday 04 January 2006

As 2006 begins, we seem to be at a not-completely-unfamiliar crossroads in the long history of the American imperial presidency. It grew up, shedding presidential constraints, in the post-World War II years as part of the rise of the national security state and the military-industrial complex. It reached its constraint-less apogee with Richard Nixon's presidency and what became known as the Watergate scandal - an event marked by Nixon's attempt to create his own private national security apparatus which he directed to secretly commit various high crimes and misdemeanors for him. It was as close as we came - until now - to a presidential coup d'etat that might functionally have abrogated the Constitution. In those years, the potential dangers of an unfettered presidency (so apparent to the nation's founding fathers) became obvious to a great many Americans. As now, a failed war helped drag the President's plans down and, in the case of Nixon, ended in personal disgrace and resignation, as well as in a brief resurgence of congressional oversight activity. All this mitigated, and modestly deflected, the growth trajectory of the imperial presidency - for a time.

The "cabal," as Lawrence Wilkerson, Colin Powell's chief of staff at the State Department, has called Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, and various of their neoconish pals, stewed over this for years, along with a group of lawyers who were prepared, once the moment came, to give a sheen of legality to any presidential act. The group of them used the post-9/11 moment to launch a wholesale campaign to recapture the "lost" powers of the imperial presidency, attempting not, as in the case of Nixon, to create an alternate national security apparatus but to purge and capture the existing one for their private purposes. Under George Bush, Dick Cheney, and their assorted advisers, acolytes, and zealots, a virtual cult of unconstrained presidential power has been constructed, centered around the figure of Bush himself. While much has been made of feverish Christian fundamentalist support for the President, the real religious fervor in this administration has been almost singularly focused on the quite un-Christian attribute of total earthly power. Typical of the fierce ideologues and cultists now in the White House is Cheney's new Chief of Staff David Addington. The Washington Post's Dana Milbank described him this way back in 2004 (when he was still Cheney's "top lawyer"):

"[A] principal author of the White House memo justifying torture of terrorism suspects... a prime advocate of arguments supporting the holding of terrorism suspects without access to courts[,] Addington also led the fight with Congress and environmentalists over access to information about corporations that advised the White House on energy policy. He was instrumental in the series of fights with the Sept. 11 commission and its requests for information... Even in a White House known for its dedication to conservative philosophy, Addington is known as an ideologue, an adherent of an obscure philosophy called the unitary executive theory that favors an extraordinarily powerful president."

For these cultists of an all-powerful presidency, the holy war, the "crusade" to be embarked upon was, above all, aimed at creating a President accountable to no one, overseen by no one, and restricted by no other force or power in his will to act as he saw fit. And so, in this White House, all roads have led back to one issue: How to press ever harder at the weakening boundaries of presidential power. This is why, when critics concentrate on any specific issue or set of administration acts, no matter how egregious or significant, they invariably miss the point. The issue, it turns out, is never primarily - to take just two areas of potentially illegal administration activity - torture or warrantless surveillance. Though each of them had value and importance to top administration officials, they were nonetheless primarily the means to an end.

This is why the announcement of (and definition of) the "global war on terror" almost immediately after the 9/11 attacks was so important. It was to be a "war" without end. No one ever attempted to define what "victory" might actually consist of, though we were assured that the war itself would, like the Cold War, last generations. Even the recent sudden presidential announcement that we will now settle only for "complete victory" in Iraq is, in this context, a distinctly limited goal because Iraq has already been defined as but a single "theater" (though a "central" one) in a larger war on terror. A war without end, of course, left the President as a commander-in-chief-without-end and it was in such a guise that the acolytes of that "obscure philosophy" of total presidential power planned to claim their "inherent" constitutional right to do essentially anything. (Imagine what might have happened if their invasion of Iraq had been a success!)

Having established their global war on terror, and so their "war powers," in the fall of 2001, top administration officials then moved remarkably quickly to the outer limits of power - by plunging into the issue of torture. After all, if you can establish a presidential right to order torture (no matter how you manage to redefine it) as well as to hold captives under a category of warfare dredged up from the legal dustbin of history in prisons especially established to be beyond the reach of the law or the oversight of anyone but those under your command, you've established a presidential right to do just about anything imaginable. While the get-tough aura of torture may indeed have appealed to some of these worshippers of power, what undoubtedly appealed to them most was the moving of the presidential goalposts, the changing of the rules. From Abu Ghraib on, the results of all this have been obvious enough, but one crucial aspect of such unfettered presidential power goes regularly unmentioned.

As you push the limits, wherever they may be, to create a situation in which all control rests in your hands, the odds are that you will create an uncontrollable situation as well. From torture to spying, such acts, however contained they may initially appear to be, involve a deep plunge into a dark and perverse pool of human emotions. Torture in particular, but also unlimited forms of surveillance and any other acts which invest individuals secretly with something like the powers of gods, invariably lead to humanity's darkest side. The permission to commit such acts, once released into the world, mutates and spreads like wildfire from top to bottom in any command structure and across all boundaries. You may start out with a relatively small program of secret imprisonment, torture, spying or whatever, meant to achieve limited goals while establishing certain prerogatives of power, but in no case is the situation likely to remain that way for long. This was, perhaps, the true genius of the American system as imagined by its founders - the understanding that any form of state power left unchecked in the hands of a single person or group of people was likely to degenerate into despotism (or worse), whatever the initial desires of the individuals involved.

Sooner or later, the hubris of taking all such powers up as your own is likely to prove overwhelming and then many things begin to slip out of control. Consider the developing scandal over the National Security Agency's wiretapping and surveillance on presidential order and without the necessary (and easily obtained) FISA court warrants. In this case, the President has proudly admitted to everything. He has essentially said: I did it. I did it many times over. We are continuing to do it now. I would do it again. ("I've reauthorized this program more than 30 times since the September the 11th attacks, and I intend to do so for so long as our nation is - for so long as the nation faces the continuing threat of an enemy that wants to kill American citizens.") In the process, however, he has been caught in a curious, potentially devastating Presidential lie, now being used against him by Democratic pols and other critics.

While in Buffalo, New York, for his reelection campaign in April 2004, in one of those chatty "conversations" - this one about the Patriot Act - that he had with various well-vetted groups of voters, the President said the following:

"There are such things as roving wiretaps. Now, by the way, any time you hear the United States government talking about wiretap, it requires - a wiretap requires a court order. Nothing has changed, by the way. When we're talking about chasing down terrorists, we're talking about getting a court order before we do so. It's important for our fellow citizens to understand, when you think Patriot Act, constitutional guarantees are in place when it comes to doing what is necessary to protect our homeland, because we value the Constitution."

By that time, as he has since admitted, the President had not only ordered the warrantless NSA wiretapping and surveillance program and recommitted to it many times over, despite resistance from officials in the Justice Department and even, possibly, from then-Attorney General John Ashcroft, but had been deeply, intimately involved in it. (No desire for classic presidential "plausible deniability" can be found here.) So this, as many critics have pointed out, was a lie. But what's more interesting - and less noted - is that it was a lie of choice. He clearly did not make the statement on the spur of the moment or in response to media questioning (despite the claims in some reports). He wasn't even "in conversation" in any normal sense. He was simply on stage expounding in a prepared fashion to an audience of citizens. So it was a lie that, given the nature of the event (and you can check it out yourself on-line), had to be preplanned. It was a lie told with forethought, in full knowledge of the actual situation, and designed to deceive the American people about the nature of what this administration was doing. And it wasn't even a lie the President was in any way forced to commit. No one had asked. It was a voluntary act of deception. Now, he is claiming that these comments were meant to be "limited" to the Patriot act as the NSA spying program he launched was "limited" to only a few Americans - both surely absurd claims. ("I was talking about roving wiretaps, I believe, involved in the Patriot Act. This is different from the N.S.A. program. The N.S.A. program is a necessary program. I was elected to protect the American people from harm. And on Sept. 11, 2001, our nation was attacked. And after that day, I vowed to use all the resources at my disposal, within the law, to protect the American people, which is what I have been doing, and will continue to do.")

In other words, by his own definition of what is "legal" based on that "obscure philosophy" (and with the concordance of a chorus of in-house lawyers), but not on any otherwise accepted definition of how our Constitution is supposed to work, the President has admitted to something that, on the face of it, seems to be an impeachable act - and he has been caught as well in the willful further act of lying to the American people about his course of action. Here, however, is where - though so many of the issues of the moment may bring the Nixon era to mind - things have changed considerably. Our domestic politics are now far more conservative; Congress is in the hands of Republicans, many of whom share the President's fervor for unconstrained party as well as presidential power; and the will to impeach is, as yet, hardly in sight.

In his news conference defending his NSA program, the President took umbrage when a reporter asked:

"I wonder if you can tell us today, sir, what, if any, limits you believe there are or should be on the powers of a President during a war, at wartime? And if the global war on terror is going to last for decades, as has been forecast, does that mean that we're going to see, therefore, a more or less permanent expansion of the unchecked power of the executive in American society?"

"To say 'unchecked power,'" responded an irritated Bush, "basically is ascribing some kind of dictatorial position to the President, which I strongly reject."

How the nation handles this crossroads presidential moment will tell us much about whether or not "some kind of dictatorial position" for our imperial, imperious, and impervious President will be in the American grain for a long, long time to come.


Tom Engelhardt, who runs the Nation Institute's Tomdispatch.com ("a regular antidote to the mainstream media"), is the co-founder of the American Empire Project and the author of The End of Victory Culture, a history of American triumphalism in the Cold War. His novel, The Last Days of Publishing, has just come out in paperback.

A Woman's Place Is in the Presidential Mansion


By Alexandra Starr
Slate.com

Wednesday 04 January 2006

What's behind the rise of female politicians in Latin America?

For now, the ABC show Commander in Chief, which chronicles the rise of the United States' first female president, is pure fantasy. But a real-life version could soon materialize in the most unlikely of places: Latin America. On Dec. 10, Chile's former defense minister, Michelle Bachelet, came close to becoming the country's first female president, and she's expected to land the job after a runoff this month. That would make Bachelet the sole woman commander in chief in the hemisphere - and the first to rise to that lofty position strictly on her own merits. Unlike the three women who have previously been elected president in Latin America - Violeta Chamorro in Nicaragua, Janet Rosenberg Jagan in Guyana, and Mireya Moscoso in Panama - Bachelet's political rise was not facilitated by a politically powerful husband.

As it turns out, Bachelet isn't the only woman who is ascending the political hierarchy south of the border. In neighboring Peru, Congresswoman Lourdes Flores is favored to win April's presidential election, and Argentina's first lady, Cristina Kirchner, isn't just serving in the Senate, she's also touted as a potential successor to her husband. There is a sizable contingent of women serving in the region's legislatures, too. Since 1991, 12 Latin American countries have enacted quota laws that in some cases have doubled the number of female congressional representatives. (Click here to see which countries have quotas.) While in the United States women make up just 15 percent of the House of Representatives and 14 percent of the Senate, in Argentina and Costa Rica, women comprise fully one-third of the national congresses.

Given Latin America's well-deserved reputation for machismo, the rise of these leaders might seem like an extraordinary power shift. But when you look beyond sheer numbers, feminists will find less to celebrate. Whereas, for example, Bolivian President-elect Evo Morales has made his indigenous heritage a guiding principle of his political career, these female politicians tend to be conventional leaders. Political parties have been their gateways to power, and partly driven by a desire to preserve their relationships with powerful party patrons, they've done little to disturb the status quo. In effect, their gender hasn't had much impact on how they govern.

Ironically, the fact that female candidates look different from the traditional pol has helped propel them forward. Peru's Flores, for example, has benefited from the notion that women are less prone to corruption. (Given Peru's long history of on-the-take male chief executives, being tagged as an honest politician is a huge advantage.) Cristina Kirchner surrounded herself with images of Eva Perón when she was on the senatorial campaign trail last year; obviously, her gender made it easier to claim the mantle of Argentina's immensely popular former first lady. And Bachelet's rise to presidential front-runner can be at least partly attributed to the new face she brings to a political coalition that has ruled Chile since 1990. While voters often begin agitating for change after a decade and a half of the same leadership, Bachelet's status as a single mother who has never held elected office made the ruling Concertación coalition look innovative.

While these candidates do capitalize on their status as women, they don't generally place women-friendly issues at the forefront of their agendas. Cristina Kirchner plays up her feminine side on the campaign trail - she has a predilection for short skirts, kinky boots, and immaculately coiffed hair - but she has never expressed interest in advancing issues like equal pay. Flores, meanwhile, is an economic conservative and a staunch supporter of the Catholic Church; she's unlikely to lead the charge for abortion rights or family planning services. Bachelet - a former pediatrician and mother of three - is more women-focused than most of her powerful female counterparts: As health minister she approved sales of the morning-after pill, and on the presidential hustings she has called for generous child-care subsidies. But given Bachelet's pledge to continue the fiscally conservative economic policies of the current administration, a large-scale social program is unlikely to come to fruition. "She'll take one or two signature issues to mark her as different," says Mark P. Jones, an associate professor of political science at Rice University. "But it will be more media-related than anything else."

Kirchner and Flores were first elected to office a decade and a half ago, before the number of women in their countries' legislatures spiked with the introduction of quota laws. But the women who benefited from the set-asides haven't passed much female-friendly legislation, either. That's in part because of the way they are elected. Many Latin American countries use a proportional representation system where the electorate votes for parties rather than directly for candidates. Seats are allocated to parties based on the proportion of votes they receive. Who gets to fill the coveted slots in Congress often depends on party chieftains. So, women not only owe the (primarily male) bosses for their presence in the legislature, they also need to keep them happy if they want to stay there. Advocating on behalf of women often doesn't sit well with the higher-ups. Take former Argentine national deputy Marcela Durrieu, who was elected after the creation of quotas in the early 1990s and proceeded to push hard for women's rights and increased access to contraception. After she refused to be brought to heel, Eduardo Duhalde - a Buenos Aires political mandarin who subsequently became president - struck Durrieu from the list of candidates. For good measure, he also blacklisted her allies.

While quotas haven't yet produced big shifts in governance, the increased diversity of political leadership is itself a significant breakthrough. Current Chilean President Ricardo Lagos appointed Bachelet to his Cabinet in part because he had pledged that five of the country's ministries would be headed by women. (Lagos and Bachelet are also friends.) Once installed in the executive branch, she became so popular with voters that the ruling party realized their best shot at retaining power was to run her for president. In other words, a quota system provided the opportunity, and Bachelet capitalized on it. A similar dynamic can be discerned in the United States. The two women who are most frequently mentioned as presidential contenders - Sen. Hillary Clinton and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice - both came to public prominence through their relationships to US presidents. Once in the spotlight, they attracted supporters (and detractors) of their own. For now, the closest thing the United States has to a female president is a fictional TV character, but if Bachelet wins her runoff this month as expected, her tenure as the sole woman commander in chief in the hemisphere could be relatively short-lived.


Alexandra Starr is a former political correspondent at Business Week.

Love, Labor, Loss


By Lynne Duke
The
Washington Post

Tuesday 03 January 2006

A child's death stirred Andrew Stern to challenge himself - and unionism.

A daughter's death left an unexpected gift. After the sorrow ripped his heart and the confusion left him dazed, Andrew Stern began to discover it - began to see what Cassie, his 13-year-old, had passed on to him.

She had been so fragile, even confined by a back brace for a time, yet so very much alive. Frail but fearless - that was Cassie. And that was her gift to her father.

It is but one facet of a man's life - certainly not his sum total. Stern, 55, president of the powerful Service Employees International Union, has been a labor activist and innovator for more than 30 years and, in fact, had been fomenting rebellion in big labor for years.

And, yet, after Cassie passed away 3 1/2 years ago of complications from spinal surgery, and after he cried in the shower every day for months, torn apart by the memories, such as jumping little waves at the beach with his daughter in his arms - after all that, Stern realized that something in him had awakened.

"Cassie gave me the courage to have the voice," he explains carefully. He's talking about the voice to articulate his controversial vision.

He began speaking more stridently, and sometimes unwisely, he says. "I lost a lot of my concern about what people thought of me," he says.

He's seated in his office, calming in its monotone whiteness, overlooking a snow-covered Dupont Circle. Cassie is a smiling sprite of a girl in an array of photos on Stern's credenza, along with her big brother Matt, now 19.

"My greatest fear," Stern is saying, "is not having the courage" to take on a fight, "whether it's the labor movement, the Democratic Party or anybody else who stands in the way of workers doing well."

After Cassie, the question taunted him: "What am I so scared about?"

Last summer, he stunned the American labor movement when he led the SEIU and six other unions to defect from the AFL-CIO. He had effectively split the "house of labor" in two, peeling off about 40 percent of its membership.

History one day will record Stern as the impetuous, power-hungry man who accelerated the decline of the American union movement. That is one view, taken by some of his embittered former colleagues at the AFL-CIO.

Or, his supporters say, Stern will go down in history as the courageous, visionary leader who charted a bold new course for American unionism just in time and helped spark a labor movement to fight for workers in the world economy.

Stern, of course, would pick the kinder rendering, for he believes firmly that he is right. Labor needed to be shaken up, and no more harm could come from an AFL-CIO breakup than from the inertia that gripped it, Stern says.

Low numbers speak of the high stakes: Only 12 percent of the American labor force is unionized these days, down from 35 percent three decades ago. Surveys show that Americans want unions but are afraid of how bosses will react, because organizers often are fired illegally for their activities. Workers, Stern says, are devalued, and he is trying to change the way Americans view labor and the economy as a whole.

In the world according to Stern, low-wage workers too often succumb to a form of economic Darwinism. Stern travels the country delivering that message in speeches and rallies. He talks about how the global economy has made things worse, with multinationals competing to find the cheapest labor, minus unions - the Wal-Mart effect. For workers to thrive, big labor has to act as big business does: Go global, recruit without borders, unionize workers across entire economic sectors.

He has rankled many by calling big labor a "lap dog" for the Democratic Party. Labor, he says, should follow a political agenda that's good for workers, regardless of party.

And he caused a firestorm at the 2004 Democratic National Convention when he said a John Kerry victory would be bad for big labor, would give it a false sense of power, and paper over its fundamental problem of flagging union membership. As it turned out, of course, Kerry lost. Big labor could not muster enough troops - a fact that also sparked a rethinking in the movement.

Beyond such macro issues, though, Stern has even drawn suspicion just for being who he is. Some old-line, blue-collar unionists are annoyed with his white-collar, Ivy League background. Tom Buffenbarger, leader of the machinists and aerospace workers, virtually spat out the words "Wharton School" in deriding Stern's educational background.

And yet Stern has pushed big labor, challenged it, lined up some of its big names behind him. He has taken the labor movement to the brink of a new era, for better or worse, while an interior dialogue of grief and loss has shaped his leadership, adding volume to an already voluble voice.

'Male, Pale and Stale'

He's in Philadelphia one November day, at the ornate Union League building on Broad Street, about to address the nabobs of the local chapter of the World Affairs Council and introduce them to his vision of the world of labor.

He's come home, in a way, for he attended college here, the University of Pennsylvania. He first joined a union here, back in 1972. And Cassie died here, over at Children's Hospital, which he'd passed on the train ride up from Washington.

"Lot of memories," he's saying in a corridor before his speech. "I actually couldn't ride the train for a while [after Cassie] because it passed right by the hospital."

But that is his internal landscape. Onstage, before a sea of well-appointed Philadelphia business and civic leaders, he is telling the crowd of his life's work, of the question that has vexed him for years and years.

"How is hard work valued and rewarded in America?" He is speaking, as he so often does, for the blue-collar American workers, those folks whose plight outrages him.

He's telling of a woman named Flora Aguilar. She's a janitor in Houston, among the janitors that Stern's SEIU has just recently organized. She works four hours a day for one of the largest cleaning firms in the country, he says, cleaning "30 offices, two hallways, 29 toilets. And she goes home with 20 bucks. That's Flora Aguilar's life."

And yet workers like Aguilar - increasingly the backbone of the service economy - have been overlooked, deemed too hard to organize by a labor movement whose mentality is stuck in an industrial, manufacturing past that has been exported and globalized.

That's why he calls the labor movement "male, pale and stale."

"We thought we could go into the future by looking into the rear-view mirror, but it just doesn't work," Stern is saying, using one of his oft-repeated images of labor stuck in the past.

The largely white male crowd applauds politely.

An hour later, Stern is down in South Philly peeling off his suit jacket and tie, pulling on a purple SEIU windbreaker and marching across a rain-swept parking lot to join a sea of purple-clad protesters converging on a local Wal-Mart.

He loves this, loves the fray. He used to take Cassie and Matt to protests once in a while, as well as labor conventions, when Cassie was well enough to go.

Here, he is with a family of a different kind. He is chairman of the Wal-Mart Watch advocacy group, and these protesters - white, black and brown home-care workers and janitors - are from SEIU Local 668, where Stern got his start. Now he's plunging into the crowd to show his solidarity, chanting "Hey-hey! Ho-ho! Wal-Mart has got to go!"

From Success, Criticism

Stern wanted to overhaul the AFL-CIO and its more than 60 affiliated unions. And as the leader of the largest and fastest growing union in the group, his voice was heard.

He wanted the federation to merge some of its small unions with larger ones. He wanted it to recruit more aggressively and across entire sectors (all janitors, home-care workers, security guards, etc.), not just at individual workplaces. And he wanted to bring businesses on board by dispelling their fears, in labor negotiations, of being undercut by competing workplaces.

It could be done, he believed, for his own union has done it. In the SEIU, membership has tripled since the 1980s to 1.8 million. The union represents health care workers, janitors, security guards and other service workers often deemed difficult to organize because many are part-time or contract workers.

By gathering the support of local political and religious leaders, the SEIU recently unionized 5,000 janitors in Houston across several workplaces. It also won a recent battle to organize 49,000 child-care workers in Illinois.

The SEIU's successes have not gone unnoticed.

"Houston's tough turf," says Kate Bronfenbrenner, director of labor education research at Cornell University. "Houston sends a very good message - that you can win in the South and you can win big."

And that is the rub.

Ruth Milkman, a professor and director of the UCLA Institute of Industrial Relations, says the SEIU's success has made it the target of resentment by some in the labor movement.

"They're so much better than everybody else that the hubris that might go with that is dangerous," Milkman says.

Indeed, there's a soaring self-assuredness that infuses Stern's work. Get him talking and he launches into a rapid-fire stream of consciousness, very high-concept, and it all makes sense, you think, but then he's turning a sharp intellectual corner, racing up a hill, rounding a bend in the logic and challenging the listener to keep up.

Stern's leadership is "both exciting, wonderful and sometimes a little terrifying," says Stephen Lerner, a SEIU division director and leader of the Justice for Janitors campaign begun in the 1980s. "You can be working with Andy Stern hand in hand with a great idea and there'll be a series of discussions and he'll have a brand-new idea and gears will change incredibly quickly," says Lerner. "So part of what happens is there's very little orthodox. It's an environment that is constantly challenging you and saying you can't sit on your laurels."

In a broad brush, Stern likens himself to John L. Lewis, the mine workers leader who broke with the AFL back in the 1930s when he founded the CIO to represent industrial and manufacturing workers.

"He had the guts to take the money of the mine workers and invest it in building a new organization based on a fundamentally different principle," Stern says. "This guy really created the modern industrial labor movement." Minus Lewis's infamous megalomania, Stern sees himself as leading a similar sea change in big labor.

His detractors - surprise - don't see it that way at all.

When he put forward a set of comprehensive proposals to the AFL-CIO in December 2004, John Sweeney, the AFL-CIO president and Stern's onetime mentor, and other labor leaders rejected most of them.

But even some of Stern's main allies didn't share his far-reaching vision.

James P. Hoffa, president of the 1.4-million-member International Brotherhood of Teamsters and son of the late and legendary Jimmy Hoffa, said his union does not support mergers and strict sectorial organizing. But Hoffa shares Stern's frustration with the AFL-CIO's failure to arrest labor's decline, as well as annoyance at its administrative size.

"You go to meetings there, it's like going to a U.N. meeting," Hoffa said. The Teamsters made some radical organizing proposals of their own. But Sweeney's team was not receptive. (Sweeney declined to be interviewed for this article.)

In June, the SEIU, the Teamsters and other disaffected unions formed the Change to Win Coalition. The next month, while the AFL-CIO was holding its 50th anniversary convention in Chicago, the SEIU and Teamsters announced they were leaving. Soon thereafter, they were joined by the United Food and Commercial Workers, the Laborers International Union, the United Farm Workers of America, the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners, and the apparel and hospitality workers of the Unite Here union.

They left behind an AFL-CIO embittered by the breakup.

The AFL-CIO executive committee had tried to satisfy Stern by proposing that a commission be established to recommend union mergers. Stern voted against it. He saw it as a feint, an AFL-CIO tactic to "fake change rather than make change."

"Nobody ever understood exactly what they wanted," says Denise Mitchell, spokeswoman for the AFL-CIO. "It was maddening."

Some observers suggested that it was all a power play by Stern.

"For all the talk about fundamentally different principles, different strategic approaches, differing organizing principles, that's all really [expletive]," says a labor official familiar with the SEIU who spoke anonymously because he works with both labor federations.

"He'd decided he had outgrown the federation," the source says. "His union was growing. Too many other unions weren't."

Stern dismisses such criticism as "insulting," saying it merely attempts to "diminish" the reformist agenda. Yes, he does want power, he says - "but for workers."

Aiding the Underdog

Almost all the men in Stern's family are lawyers. His late father was. His brothers are. A grandfather was. (The other grandfather was a butcher.)

Ken Stern, 53, Andrew's brother, says they were raised in the Judaic tradition of tikkun olam , "sort of a duty and responsibility to heal the world, make the world a better place."

"He's always cared about people," Ken Stern says of his big brother. "He always liked to help the underdog."

As a teen in West Orange, N.J., Andrew Stern raised money for poor children around the world by throwing backyard carnivals, complete with a baton-twirling neighbor and songs lip-synched by Tom Stern, his youngest brother, who was terrified but did it because Andy was persuasive that way.

In high school, Stern managed a political campaign for a class-president candidate. That role, in the background, was typical of his high school career, except when he played on the tennis team. He was never the high achiever of parental expectations.

"My mom wanted me to be the most likely to succeed or win an academic prize," Stern says, "so in ninth grade, me and my girlfriend were class couple." He laughs. "And then in 12th grade, I was best personality or runner-up in best personality. My mom was hoping for the best biology award."

At the University of Pennsylvania, he enrolled in the Wharton School for a year. But it was a mistake. He didn't plan on going into business.

"You had to wear a tie and jacket to get into the dining hall, and you were served by students in uniforms wearing white gloves," he says, laughing at the spectacle.

He switched to urban studies. He threw himself into campus activism. He helped organize and manage a food co-op. He protested a university plan to turn Penn's version of a "people's park" into a parking lot.

After graduating, he went into welfare, becoming a caseworker for the state. That led him to join the SEIU, which hired him as a union organizer in 1973.

He rose steadily through its ranks - as a local president, then a state president, all the while challenging the status quo, making allies and enemies with whom he would contend for years to come.

Transcending the Grief

Cassie had surgery to correct scoliosis, a curvature of the spine, in May 2002. She also was chronically weak from hypotonia, abnormally low muscle tone that plagued her from birth. Later that month, father and daughter visited his stepmother in Ocean City, N.J. Stern slept in the same room as Cassie to make sure she was all right through the night.

He heard the silence when she stopped breathing.

He tried to resuscitate her. His stepmother called 911. A chopper medevaced Cassie to the hospital. But she slipped into a coma. Several days later, it was over.

His memories became a form of torture - their trip to Venice and the Vatican, their safari in Botswana, the way she bossed her cats, Patrick and Olivia, and did her pottery and had her dad and everyone else lovingly wrapped around her finger.

There was grief counseling. He had a hard time coping. So did Matt, who found it troubling that his father would lose it and start crying in public. And Stern's marriage to Cassie's mom, A. Jane Perkins, did not survive the trauma.

One day, Stern just walked out of a union meeting and wandered the streets.

"I wasn't sure I could continue doing my job after she died," he says.

This year, for the first time, he watched a video montage that a friend had made for him of Cassie's life. It was hard. He watched it in segments over three weeks.

And slowly, it happened. The balance began to take shape. There was and will always be the horror of the loss, he says, but bursting through the pain was also the joy of remembrance.

He had discovered and claimed Cassie's gift.

GW Wins US Okay for Pivotal Cannabis Drug Study


By Ben Hirschler
Reuters


Wednesday 04 January 2005

London - GW Pharmaceuticals has won approval from US regulators to conduct a pivotal Phase III study into its cannabis-based medicine Sativex as a treatment for cancer pain, the drug company said on Wednesday.

GW expects to start testing the product, which is sprayed into the mouth, in US patients with advanced cancer later this year and said it was raising $15 million (8.6 million pounds) in a discounted share placing to help fund the trial while it seeks a US partner.

The US randomised clinical trial will involve 250 people and is likely to last between 24 and 36 months, suggesting Sativex will not be ready for launch in the US marketplace until towards the end of the decade.

GW shares, which had risen 7.4 percent on Tuesday on rumours of positive news about Sativex, hit a 20-month high in early trade before retreating to stand 7.5 percent down on the day at 148 pence in late trade.

GW said it had agreed with Polygon Investment Partners of New York to raise 8.6 million pounds ($15 million), or 8.1 million after expenses, by placing 6.2 million new shares at 139.61p each, giving Polygon a 5.4 percent stake in the company.

Canada became the first country in the world to approve Sativex in April 2005 for the relief of neuropathic pain in patients with multiple sclerosis.

GW suffered a setback three weeks ago, however, when an inquest found the death of a patient taking Sativex in an earlier clinical study was probably linked to the medicine.

Sativex is GW's leading product and the source of most of the company's value.

The group grows thousands of marijuana plants at a secret location in the English countryside, having been granted a dispensation by the government to use the plant for medical research.

Stronger Hand in Talks

Geoffrey Guy, GW's executive chairman, said the acceptance of the Phase III study application by the Food and Drug Administration was a significant achievement for the company that would compress the overall length of time needed to win US approval by avoiding the need for earlier-stage trials.

Having the product in final tests should also strengthen GW's hand in negotiations with potential partners in the United States, where it has yet to sign up a marketing ally.

Germany's Bayer AG is GW's marketing partner in Canada and Britain, while Almirall of Spain recently agreed to market the drug in European countries excluding Britain.

Following the deal with Polygon, GW now has 30 million pounds in the bank, which industry analysts should remove the risk of further fundraising.

Cannabis has a long history of medicinal use dating back to ancient Chinese times. Queen Victoria, whose physician described it as "one of the most valuable medicines we possess", is said to have taken cannabis tincture for her menstrual pains.

It fell out of favour in the 20th century because of a lack of standardised preparations and the development of more potent synthetic painkillers.

GW says it has got round those standardisation problems with its spray-based product, which also avoids the damaging effects of smoking the drug.

Go to Original

Rhode Island Legalizes Medical Marijuana
By M. L. Johnson
The Associated Press

Tuesday 03 January 2006

Providence, RI - Rhode Island on Tuesday became the 11th state to legalize medical marijuana and the first since the US Supreme Court ruled in June that patients who use the drug can still be prosecuted under federal law.

The House overrode a veto by Gov. Don Carcieri, 59-13, allowing people with illnesses such as cancer and AIDS to grow up to 12 marijuana plants or buy 2.5 ounces of marijuana to relieve their symptoms. Those who do are required to register with the state and get an identification card.

Federal law prohibits any use of marijuana, but Maine, Vermont, Alaska, California, Colorado, Hawaii, Montana, Nevada, Oregon and Washington allow it to be grown and used for medicinal purposes.

The US high court ruled June 6 that people who smoke marijuana because their doctors recommend it can still be prosecuted under federal drug laws, even if their states allow it.

Federal authorities, however, have conceded they are unlikely to prosecute many medicinal marijuana users.

"I'm sure everybody in this room knows at least one person who would have benefited from medical marijuana," Rep. Thomas Slater, who has cancer, told fellow lawmakers before the vote. Slater said he does not use marijuana now, but it could become part of his treatment in the future.

Carcieri, unhappy with the override, said the law fails to provide ways for users to buy marijuana legally and leaves Rhode Islanders open to federal prosecution.

"Users will be forced to purchase marijuana in the illegal street market, putting them at risk and complicating the difficult jobs that our law enforcement personnel must do every day," the governor said.

Tom Riley, a spokesman for the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy, said the vote showed "misguided and out-of-touch" views on the harms of marijuana.

"There's this notion from the '60s or the '70s that marijuana is a harmless drug," Riley said. "It's not."