Thursday, January 05, 2006

Oil Boom a Bust for Us, Villagers Say in Court


The Associated Press

Tuesday 03 January 2006

Ecuadorian, Nigerian cases seek compensation from Chevron.

San Francisco - A young boy holds out a deformed hand. A woman is missing a lower leg that was amputated to remove a tumor. A gaunt middle-aged man lays in a hammock dying of stomach cancer.

The haunting images displayed in a photo exhibit at San Francisco City Hall claim to document the devastating effects of more than three decades of oil extraction in Ecuador's Amazon rainforest.

Humberto Piaguaje came to help launch the exhibit and seek justice from the powerful petroleum company he blames for sickening his people and poisoning his homeland. He's one of 30,000 plaintiffs in a class-action lawsuit that alleges San Ramon-based Chevron Corp. failed to clean up billions of gallons of toxic waste dumped in pristine rainforest in Ecuador, where a lengthy trial is under way.

"We've lived there for thousands of years, and we've never had diseases like this before," Piaguaje, a leader of Ecuador's Secoya tribe, said in Spanish. "We want Chevron to do a true cleanup of the areas they contaminated."

Chevron, one of the world's largest oil companies, has denied human rights and environmental violations in the 180 countries where it operates, but allegations of abuse threaten its public image around the world. Critics claim such abuses are increasing as the global scarcity of petroleum drives oil companies into countries with rich reserves but poor protections for human rights and the environment.

"It's the resource curse," said Steve Kretzmann, executive director of Oil Change International. "Unfortunately, the rule around the world is that where you have oil extraction, you see increasing rates of poverty, human rights abuses and environmental destruction."

In Ecuador, the plaintiffs estimate it will cost $6 billion to clean up 18.5 billion gallons of oily wastewater that Texaco, which merged with Chevron in 2001, dumped into more than 600 unlined pits and streams between 1972 and 1990.

Chevron is also fighting lawsuits filed in San Francisco by Nigerian villagers who claim the company's subsidiary supported military attacks on protesters in the oil-rich Niger Delta. A federal lawsuit is scheduled to go to trial next fall, and a trial for a state class-action lawsuit is set to start in 2007.

Chevron lawyers deny the plaintiffs' claims in both Nigeria and Ecuador and believe they will prevail in court.

Chevron Responds

Company officials say Chevron has a long record of protecting human rights and the environment, pointing to its annual reports that detail goals and accomplishments in areas such as environmental management, human rights, AIDS, climate change, energy efficiency, health and safety.

"Wherever we operate, we strive to be a good example through our employment policies, our support for universal human rights as well as obeying domestic and host country laws," said Maria Pica, Chevron's corporate responsibility manager.

Investors don't appear to be worried. Like the rest of the oil industry, Chevron has reported robust profits from soaring worldwide demand.

Fadel Gheit, a senior energy analyst at Oppenheimer & Co., believes the company will likely win both cases, and if they are forced to compensate victims, the payments won't be big enough to affect the bottom line.

"It's nothing but background noise," Gheit said.

But critics say the company's troubles in Nigeria and Ecuador are part of a deeper problem.

"Both ultimately arise out of the corporation's disregard for basic human rights and environmental protection," said Marco Simons, legal director of EarthRights International. "It is part of a pattern that's pervasive in the oil industry."

Simons and other industry critics say the extraction of oil doesn't create many jobs or distribute wealth but props up repressive regimes, leading to widespread social unrest and ecological damage in oil-rich regions.

Sudan, Myanmar Cases

Chevron is hardly the only petroleum company fighting lawsuits alleging abuse. Talisman Energy Inc., for example, is being sued in US courts by Sudanese villagers who allege the Canadian oil company provided money, vehicles and logistics to Sudanese soldiers who sought to depopulate 142 villages near oil fields from 1999 to 2002. Company lawyers have denied the allegations.

As abuse reports have risen, so has the ability of victims to hold corporations accountable. Thanks to the Internet and an increasingly global network of activists, victims are drawing more attention to their plight, and more lawyers are taking on cases.

In an undisclosed settlement in 2005, El Segundo-based Unocal agreed to compensate 15 Myanmar villagers who held the company liable for forced labor, murder and rape allegedly carried out by government soldiers during construction of the $1.2 billion Yadana pipeline.

Chevron, which acquired Unocal in August, now faces criticism for doing business in the Southeast Asian nation formerly known as Burma, where the US government has banned new investment due to human rights concerns.

"Our position is that no one should be investing in Burma right now," said EarthRights' Simons. "It's impossible to do business in Burma without being complicit in serious human rights abuses."

Chevron officials would not comment on the Myanmar operations because the company is still evaluating its new assets, according to spokesman Jeff Moore.

Allegations in Nigeria

The Nigerian plaintiffs accuse Chevron's subsidiary of supporting attacks by Nigerian soldiers that destroyed homes and killed or injured dozens of people. A federal judge ruled in 2004 that Chevron could be held responsible if Chevron Nigeria was involved.

The lawsuits, which seek unspecified damages, claim the subsidiary provided helicopters, boats and planes to Nigerian soldiers who fired at demonstrators in 1998 on an offshore oil platform and in 1999 at two villages where protesters lived.

"Chevron used the Nigerian military as their security force and that resulted in gross human rights violations," said Cindy Cohn, an attorney for the plaintiffs.

Chevron attorneys say the platform protesters were armed youths who demanded money, took more than 200 workers hostage and were shot during a rescue attempt. The company also argues the case belongs in African courts.

"We don't think it's fair or appropriate for Nigerians to bring lawsuits in the United States where they're challenging what the Nigerian government did to them in Nigeria," said Chevron attorney Bob Mittelstadt.

Allegations in the Amazon

The rainforest case spent a decade in US courts before being transferred to Ecuador. The trial, which began two years ago, has proceeded slowly as the judge takes testimony and inspects more than 120 alleged dump sites.

Plaintiffs claim toxic chemicals contaminated rivers, streams and soil in a region the size of Rhode Island, leading to unusually high rates of cancer, birth defects, skin diseases and other health problems. They want the company to pay for their medical care and a thorough cleanup.

"This is rainforest Chernobyl," said Leila Salazar-Lopez of San Francisco-based Amazon Watch. "Before Texaco arrived, this was pristine Amazon rainforest where five indigenous tribes depended on a clean, healthy environment to survive. Now they're basically living in a giant Superfund site."

Chevron has resisted calls for further remediation, saying Texaco already complied with a $40 million government-ordered cleanup from 1995 to 1998 and auditors found no lasting environmental impact.

"So far in the inspections the evidence clearly indicates the remediation was done properly and any residual there doesn't pose a risk to human health," said Chevron environmental scientist Sara McMillen. Samples met drinking water standards of Ecuador, the US and the World Health Organization, she said.

Chevron Blames Ecuadorian Partner

Texaco was only a minority partner in a joint venture with state-owned PetroEcuador, and was released from responsibility for any further remediation when the joint venture ended in 1992, said Ricardo Veiga, the Chevron attorney working on the Ecuador case. He blamed the environmental damage on PetroEcuador and on government policies that encouraged haphazard migration to the area.

"We cannot be blamed for the lack of infrastructure, education and sanitation," Veiga said. "We are sympathetic to the people that live in the area, but we don't think it's accurate or fair to accuse us of creating this situation."

But Amazon natives like Piaguaje don't buy Chevron's arguments.

"We're bringing this case because we do not want to continue living in the disaster left by Chevron," Piaguaje said. "We want this case to be a lesson to the world that companies can act better."


By Audrey Bilger, Bitch Magazine. Posted January 5, 2006.



Once upon a time, politics was serious business.

These days, however, presidential merit is measured as much by frat-house standards as by traditional approval ratings (apparently, American voters would rather have a beer with Bush than with Kerry), and a well-timed joke can sometimes sway public opinion more effectively than a reasoned argument.

Thanks to the advent of television as a force in politics -- not to mention the rise of 24-hour news channels and the internet -- politicians now work closely with comedy writers to add laugh lines to their speeches and, in the process, improve their images.

But when it comes to women in politics, the rise of humor as a campaign requirement only makes their efforts more difficult. Former Texas governor Ann Richards may have gotten laughs at the 1988 Democratic National Convention when she described George H.W. Bush as having been born "with a silver foot in his mouth," but she also made enemies. A few years later, when George the Younger defeated Richards for the governorship, his supporters cited that very line as a particular offense.

Syndicated columnist Molly Ivins, in an interview with political analysts Sue Tolleson-Rinehart and Jeanie R. Stanley for their 1994 book Claytie and the Lady, said of Richards: "I think…[one] thing that men find very threatening is funny women. I mean, with Ann it was a real problem…. They just did not know what to make of her…. If they realize that a woman can be funny, I think men are afraid that that tone can be used against them. And they don't like it."

In 19th- and early 20th-century America, women were generally viewed as entirely lacking in a sense of humor, and witty women were deemed not only aberrant but most likely sexually promiscuous. It's arguable whether things have changed much since then: While there are certainly more female humorists now, the shibboleth "women just aren't funny" persists everywhere from comedy clubs to TV networks to high schools.

None of this has ever kept women from being funny, of course, but the substance of their humor continues to be subject to the judgment of men, who have historically deemed themselves arbiters of what's funny, not to mention who's funny.

Simply put, a woman who makes jokes -- much like a woman who seeks public office -- steps outside the bounds of traditional femininity. So when it comes to women using humor in the realm of politics, they're damned if they do and damned if they don't.

Ann Richards herself recognized that having a flair for the witty remark was a mixed blessing. Early in her career, she received numerous invitations to speak at roasts, and even though she enjoyed these appearances, she realized the potential pitfalls. As she wrote in her 1989 autobiography Straight from the Heart:

I was always worried because there is a general feeling that if you're funny you're not serious. People don't know how many brain cells it takes to be funny…. Humor is a powerful tool. It clears the air. Once you laugh, your mind is opened and then you are able to hear the other things that are being said to you.

Richards's statement encapsulates a primary issue facing women in politics: Humor can be an extremely effective political tool, but a woman who wields it risks appearing frivolous or ditzy. Rather than denoting confidence and power, a woman's sense of humor can also be radically misunderstood, and even used against her.

Experts on humor have long recognized its power to put people at ease and to make them more receptive to the humorist's point of view. In recent elections, candidates perceived as stiff and too cerebral (hi, John and Al!) came under media attack for lacking personality. Every candidate knows it's important to smile for the cameras because frowns and serious looks don't go over well.

Toss gender into the mix and things get more complicated. A woman who is perceived as too serious, like Hillary Rodham Clinton, gets called a ballbreaker; a woman who is too funny, as Ann Richards worried, might not be taken seriously. Male politicians have to strike a balance between the comic and the serious, but women, as the saying about Ginger Rogers's dancing goes, have to do it backwards and in high heels.

For those seeking the highest political office in this country, a sense of humor is essential for currying public favor. Gerald Gardner, who collects examples of presidential humor, asks in his 1986 book All the Presidents' Wits: The Power of Presidential Humor, "Why is it that if a man [sic] wishes to hold the most demanding position on the face of the earth, he must be able to tell a joke?"

He cites Ronald Reagan's comedic ability as one of the reasons for the Gipper's enormous popularity, and underscores the tendency of American voters to choose personality over substance. "A sense of humor," according to Dwight D. Eisenhower, "is part of the art of leadership, of getting along with people, of getting things done."

Former senator and presidential candidate Bob Dole, in his 1998 collection Great Political Wit: Laughing (Almost) All the Way to the White House, recounts how in his political life, "there were countless occasions…when a timely one-liner broke the tension at a tough negotiation and got everyone moving toward a solution."

Many female politicians have been equally adept at using wit to frame key issues. Frances "Cissy" Farenthold, who served two terms in the Texas legislature in the early '70s, summed up her position on affirmative action thus: "I am working for the time when unqualified blacks, browns, and women join the unqualified men in running our government."

Bella Abzug, the first Jewish congresswoman, whose 1970 campaign slogan was "This Woman's Place Is in the House -- the House of Representatives," made a similar point about gender equity: "Real equity is going to come not when a female Einstein is recognized as quickly as a male Einstein, but when a female schlemiel is promoted as quickly as a male schlemiel."

The noted feminist and civil rights activist/attorney Florynce Kennedy had a knack for condensing important issues into one-liners and for staving off opposition with laughter -- a talent her colleague Gloria Steinem called "verbal karate." In a memorial piece on Kennedy's life in a 2001 issue of Revolutionary Worker, Steinem recalls that when she and Kennedy were on the lecture circuit together, they were often asked by men in the audience if they were lesbians ("Why else," Steinem speculates on the views of the questioners, "would a white and black woman be colleagues?"). Kennedy was quick to respond with the oft-quoted line: "Are you my alternative?"

Other Kennedy quips are equally memorable: "If men could get pregnant, abortion would be a sacrament"; "Freedom is like taking a bath: You got to keep doing it every day"; "If you're not living on the edge, then you're taking up space." Although she never held a political office, People magazine called her "radicalism's rudest mouth."

The staying power of Kennedy's wit points out that material like this can help fuel revolutions. But as increasing numbers of women enter the mainstream of political life (and as women seek ever higher office), it's well worth taking a closer look at what happens when political women get funny. The wry former vice-presidential candidate Geraldine Ferraro, in a 1990 interview with Jim Lehrer, described how she appeared to the public during the early stages of the 1984 campaign: "I was on television virtually every night of the week. But if you watched what I was on doing, it was 15 seconds, 30 seconds -- Gerry Ferraro with a zinger that hit either President Reagan or…Vice President Bush.

The sad part of it was that the American public was getting the impression that's all that I was capable of doing. I didn't look very sensitive and they didn't know me very well. The polls indicated that I was feisty, that I was tough, that I had a sense of humor, but [voters] weren't quite sure if they liked me."

The question of how to be tough (as politicians ought to be) yet remain sensitive (as women are required to be) is a dilemma for female politicians even without taking into account their ability to crack jokes. For every vote Ferraro might have earned with a witty remark like "I'd call [Reaganomics] a new version of voodoo economics, but I'm afraid that would give witch doctors a bad name," she may very well have lost supporters who disapproved of her levity. She was on safer ground when she stuck to non-tendentious subjects like technology ("It was not so very long ago that people thought that semiconductors were part-time orchestra leaders and microchips were very, very small snack foods").

As first lady, Barbara Bush, the quintessential strong-yet-properly-feminine matron, could get by with an overtly feminist joke in a commencement address at Wellesley College: "Somewhere out in this audience may even be someone who will one day follow in my footsteps and preside over the White House as the president's spouse. I wish him well."

Less palatable was her earlier, widely circulated jab at Ferraro, whom she called something she "couldn't say" that "rhymed with rich." In her subsequent apology for a joke critics perceived to be inappropriately hostile -- hardly ladylike -- she underscored the original laugh line by saying she was sorry to have called Ferraro a "witch."

But it turns out the first Bush first lady was no match for her daughter-in-law. At April 2005's annual White House Correspondents' Dinner, Laura Bush became an overnight success as a stand-up comedian, in a performance showcasing the one place women's humor is welcome -- firmly within the status quo. In a departure from the tradition of having the president give a comic speech -- possibly because W. seems to find things like the search for wmds funny -- the Bushes offered up a scripted scene that opened with Laura pretending to heckle her husband's feeble attempts at humor. "Not that old joke -- not again," she "protested." She then proceeded to push him aside and claim the podium, launching into a speech of her own.

In fact, the speech was written by Landon Parvin, whom reporter Elisabeth Bumiller has dubbed "joke writer to the stars of Washington." Nevertheless, reporters were falling over themselves in giddy delight at just how funny Laura was. The Washington Post called it "Laura Bush's Coming-Out Party," and the Associated Press trumpeted "First Lady Steals Show." No one came close to saying that her humor seemed threatening, even though her primary target was the nation's Commander-in-Chief. Maybe that was because in reaction shot after reaction shot, George could be seen chuckling good-naturedly at his wife's remarks and basking in the reflected glory of the audience's exuberant response.

Laura's opening salvo intentionally evoked the rhetoric of liberal feminism. She declared, "I've been attending these dinners for years and just quietly sitting there. Well, I've got a few things I want to say for a change."

In the extensive and almost universally favorable press coverage of her speech, reporters enthused about how good it was to see Laura stepping out of her husband's shadow and overcoming her natural shyness. By simultaneously letting viewers in on the joke and encouraging them to accept its fictional premise, reporters accentuated the conservative thrust of the first lady's "desperate housewife" routine.

Everyone could see that she had her husband's permission to say what she did; some reports even said the whole thing was his idea. In this sense, Laura could come off as not fully owning what she said.

Mark Katz, who has written jokes for Bill Clinton, Hillary Rodham Clinton, and Al Gore, among others, talked in a 2000 New York Times column about the importance of recognizing "the line" when writing humor for politicians. Landon Parvin clearly identified that elusive line, and the first lady was in no danger of crossing it in her "impromptu" speech.

For example, she could describe a trip to Chippendales with Lynne "Dollar Bill" Cheney, Condi Rice, and Karen Hughes (noting that Ruth Bader Ginsberg and Sandra Day O'Connor were in the audience, Laura quickly implicated them in the action as well), and the incongruity of such highly placed girls gone wild -- coupled with her own mild-mannered delivery of the punch line -- could generate not outrage but hilarity. The only line that incited a mild degree of controversy concerned George's city-slicker ways: "He's learned a lot about ranching since that first year when he tried to milk the horse," Laura told her audience, adding sweetly, "What's worse, it was a male horse."

The Daily Show's Stephen Colbert took this joke to its logical conclusion the next night, spelling out in a lurid parody exactly what it means to "milk" a male horse, culminating in a description of W. "bathing in a bucket of horse [bleep!]." The comedy in both Laura's initial delivery and Colbert's lewd send-up turned on the notion that the first lady knew not what she said.

While those on the left pondered whether right-wing fundamentalists ought to find Laura's blue humor funny, those on the right sprang to her defense and accused critics of making too much of a lighthearted joke. Ultimately, even off-color humor from the first lady could be assimilated into her traditional feminine role, and her sentimental concluding remarks defused the entire performance: "So in the future, when you see me just quietly sitting up here, I want you to know that I'm happy to be here for a reason: I love, and enjoy being with, the man who usually speaks to you on these occasions."

What the Bush team cleverly recognized is that humor would allow them to capitalize on Laura's popularity, which at the time was almost double that of her husband, and that the sheer surprise value of her remarks would guarantee media attention. In the weeks following the dinner, the first lady was repeatedly asked if she would consider running for office. Her use of humor was perceived as a sign of strength, even though -- and perhaps because -- it hinged on assumptions about her subordination to her spouse.

The first lady's remarks fit into the long-standing category of self-deprecating humor, with Laura offering up the first family as a target in a gesture intended to reassure the audience that they're "just like us."

Gerald Gardner notes that self-deprecating jokes are particularly good choices for presidents: "However arrogant or egomaniacal a president may be, let him laugh at his age, his wealth, or his golf game, and we are ready to turn over the keys of the kingdom."

Our current president isn't particularly good at this type of humor, however: He seems to have a hard time making fun of himself, and his attempts to do so come across as forced and unnatural. In his speech at last year's White House Correspondents' Dinner, Bush led off with a joke about this very subject: "I was going to start off tonight by telling some self-deprecating jokes, but then I couldn't think of any mistakes I've made to be self-deprecating about."

Naturally, his wife's speech shied away from using humor to needle Bush on substantive grounds, despite the rich supply of material other comedians have found in his all-too-numerous errors and gaffes.

From Lucille Ball to Roseanne Barr, female comedians have relied on self-deprecating humor as their staple. Self-annihilating stories of physical shortcomings, domestic inadequacy, and sexual frigidity or promiscuity invite an audience to relate to and laugh with female comedians, but few funny ladies who use these tools achieve the same results that male humorists do, especially since so much of this kind of comedy, served straight, simply reinforces gender stereotypes.

It's hard not to wince, for example, at two of the rare examples of women's political wit that Bob Dole includes in his collection. Margaret Chase Smith, who served four terms in the Senate and 32 years in Congress, was asked by a constituent, "What would you do if you woke up one morning and found yourself in the White House?" She replied, "I would go to the President's wife and apologize, and then leave at once."

Equally painful is Eleanor Roosevelt's joking statement on "campaign behavior for wives": "Always be on time. Do as little talking as humanly possible. Lean back in the parade car so everybody can see the President." Women's self-deprecation can mirror too closely stereotypical assumptions about women's inferiority to men.

Yet as much as female politicians need to be wary of being perceived as too aggressive, they can't be seen as weak either. Authors Tolleson-Rinehart and Stanley argue that "political women…have had to walk a careful line: they must present themselves as at least 'feminine' enough not to raise any fears that they are not 'womanly'; but at the same time they cannot be too stereotypically feminine or they will not be strong enough to lead."

It's hard to walk that line, though, as the case of Geraldine Ferraro illustrates. Critics of Ferraro simultaneously accused her of being "strident" and questioned whether she would be tough enough to push the nuclear button. Gender stereotypes may be even harder to combat in wartime. The first George Bush could pay lip service to a "kinder and gentler nation," but his son deliberately cast his own image in opposition to the "wimp factor" that allegedly worked against his dad.

If Hillary Rodham Clinton makes a bid for the presidency, all eyes will be on her as she grapples with how best to deploy humor. Often depicted either as a dragon lady or as a long-suffering martyr who stood by her man in spite of his infidelities, Rodham Clinton doesn't have a reputation for being funny.

She stepped out on a limb this summer when she mocked the president, saying, "I sometimes feel that Alfred E. Neuman is in charge in Washington." Her immediate audience laughed at the comparison between Bush's leadership and the Mad

Attack humor, however, won't be Rodham Clinton's best friend, since it feeds into the image of her as a castrating bitch. Uncontroversial humor, or humor that attemps to deflate the negative stereotypes about her, will go a longer way toward refurbishing her image. But whatever choices Rodham Clinton makes, she -- like other influential feminists, female politicians, and public intellectuals -- has to avoid being viewed as humorless.

Laugh lines make terrific soundbites for politicians to feed the media. They have to be finely calibrated, however, in order to achieve their desired effect. For the foreseeable future, political women's humor will have to be carefully wielded in order to dispel voter anxieties about powerful women while convincing voters that women have the confidence and competence to do the job.

Getting voters to laugh with them may not be the only path to victory for women in politics, but if they can do this well, their audience is more likely to listen to what they have to say about matters of substance.

Audrey Bilger researches and writes on women's humor. She lives in California.

Abramoff's Crimes Sign of Deeper Cesspool


By Robert Scheer, AlterNet. Posted January 4, 2006.


Top Republican lobbyist Jack Abramoff is set to sing, and his long list of former buddies in Congress and the Bush Administration are quaking in anticipation of possible indictments stemming from the consummate Beltway hustler's crass reign as the king of K Street.

"Casino Jack," a former head of the College Republicans and a "Pioneer"-grade fundraiser for the Bush 2000 campaign, pleaded guilty to three felony counts of conspiracy, mail fraud and tax evasion in D.C. yesterday and is set to appear in Florida today to plead guilty to fraud and conspiracy on separate charges. Abramoff and other defendants also must repay over $25 million to defrauded clients and $1.7 million to the IRS.

But most important for the nation is that Abramoff is now detailing the massive web of corruption he spun inside the Beltway which has already snared a top Bush official, procurement chief David H. Safavian, on charges of lying and obstructing a criminal investigation, and reportedly threatens dozens of other D.C. players.

"When this is all over, this will be bigger than any [government scandal] in the last 50 years, both in the amount of people involved and the breadth to it," Stan Brand, a former U.S. House counsel who specializes in representing public officials accused of wrongdoing, told Bloomberg News. "It will include high-ranking members of Congress and executive branch officials."

Some of the Wild West feel of this Beltway corruption was captured in Saturday's Washington Post expose, "The DeLay-Abramoff Money Trail." It documents in chilling detail how, among other scams, Abramoff funneled a portion of the millions he had been skimming from Indian casino operators with a cool million from two Russian energy moguls through a shell organization called the U.S. Family Network -- and from there into the coffers of politicians in a position to help his clients.

Ironically touting its commitment to "moral fitness" for the nation, the front group with the multi-million dollar budget had a single staff member housed in the backroom of a capital townhouse it owned and rented out to other organizations linked to Abramoff and Tom DeLay -- the latter's staffers called it, ominously, DeLay's "safe house." This is apparently why DeLay felt the need to tout the U.S. Family Network in a 1999 fundraising letter as "a powerful nationwide organization dedicated to restoring our government to citizen control."

It was run by Edwin A. Buckham, DeLay's former chief of staff, whose lobbying firm, the Alexander Strategy Group, carried Delay's wife Christine on its payroll. But the moral "fitness" of such cronyism pales in comparison to the scandal of how Abramoff drummed up support for his varied clients under the cover of conservative morality.

For example, in order to block the ambitions of a rival tribe to the Choctaw Indians who had paid Abramoff millions, the U.S. Family Network sent a mailing to Alabama residents warning shrilly that, "The American family is under attack from all sides: crime, drugs, pornography, and one of the least talked about but equally as destructive -- gambling. We need your help today to prevent the Poarch Creek Indians from building casinos in Alabama." The letter conveniently failed to mention, however, that the U.S. Family Network had received at least $250,000 from the gambling proceeds of the Choctaws.

In another scam detailed in the Post story (which could be quickly optioned by Hollywood for a thriller), players in the mafia-dominated Russian energy industry slid a cool $1 million payment through a now-defunct London law firm into the U.S. Family Network's account -- which was, de facto, a slush fund for the Abramoff-DeLay network.

Citing the Rev. Christopher Geeslin, who served as a titular leader of the U.S. Family Network, the Post reported that Buckham told the reverend the payment was intended to secure Delay's support on legislation forcing the International Monetary Fund to bail out the faltering Russian economy without demanding the country raise taxes on its energy and other profitable industries. Right on cue, DeLay found his way onto Fox News Sunday to take up the Russian's viewpoint: "They are trying to force Russia to raise taxes at a time when they ought to be cutting taxes in order to get a loan from the IMF," he said. "That's just outrageous." The IMF backed down.

This is just an initial peek into the sordid world being revealed by Abramoff and two of his key cronies now spilling the beans to federal investigators. But in the bigger picture, what we are witnessing is the death throes of the GOP "revolution" which once promised to restore morality to Washington but instead sank far deeper into the cesspool of corruption.

Robert Scheer is the co-author of The Five Biggest Lies Bush Told Us About Iraq.

Sun Tzu and the Art of Spying


By Noah Leavitt, AlterNet. Posted January 5, 2006.




010506_story

Last week, White House spokeperson Trent Duffy provided the Bush administration's rationale for its extralegal program to spy on United States citizens. Duffy quipped: "The fact is that Al Quaida's play book is not printed on Page 1, and when America's is, it has serious ramifications. You don't need to be Sun Tzu to understand that."

Duffy was referencing the "big idea" of Sun Tzu's seminal work, "The Art of War," which could be stated as "the ideal strategy is to win without fighting -- to defeat the enemy before combat becomes necessary."

It was an odd but telling comment, and worth exploring for the critical insights it provides about Bush's views on spying and executive branch power.

It may at first seem strange to hear the White House praising an ancient Chinese Taoist thinker to justify a secret Executive Order that allows the National Security Agency to eavesdrop on phone conversations, email and other electronic communications without a court warrant. After all, this is the president who said in a December 1999 presidential debate that Jesus was his favorite political philosopher. And it is ironic, at the very least, for the born-again leader of the free world to be lauding a general from a despotic land who commanded his troops during a time of intense internal conflict.

Yet, Sun Tzu's work has been a staple of Asian business leaders for years, and has recently caught on with American CEOs. Dozens of management handbooks -- the kind you might half-heartedly thumb through in an airport bookstore when your flight has been delayed -- have drawn on Sun Tzu's military philosophy to find lessons for the corporate world. In the supercynical 1987 film "Wall Street," Gordon Gekko, the corporate raider, boasts: "I don't throw darts at a board. I bet on sure things. Read Sun Tzu."

Sun Tzu was a Chinese general who lived in the 6th century BCE, when the powerful Zhou Dynasty was in decline. Many regional feudal lords were competing with the king, and China was in a period of intense and prolonged civil war. Regarded as barbarians by other Chinese, the Zhou leaders appointed their own kinsmen -- or the kinsmen of their most trusted allies -- to rule over the various city-states. In order to convince their subjects of the legitimacy of their power, the Zhou invented a system of authority which they called the "Mandate of Heaven."

Sun Tzu was desperately worried about his nation becoming exhausted by war. He warned that "when you do battle, even if you are winning, if you continue for a long time it will dull your forces and blunt your edge. When your forces are dulled, your edge is blunted, your strength is exhausted, and your supplies are gone, then the other side will take advantage of your debility and rise up."

In order to avoid this national burnout, a leader should strive to keep the enemy off balance through extensive trickery -- "a military operation involves deception." Deception must be ongoing, and unpredictable: "Even though you are competent, appear to be incompetent. Though effective, appear to be ineffective."

Not surprisingly, Sun Tzu believed in the critical importance of spying. In his final chapter, "On the Use of Spies," Sun Tzu relates the importance of foreknowledge, which must come from people who intimately know the conditions of the enemy. He identifies five specific kinds of spies: the local, the inside, the reverse, the dead and the living. Because of their importance, "No one is given rewards as rich as those given to spies."

Yet, a deep current of Taoist moderation runs through Sun Tzu's advice, demanding clear limits and extraordinary discipline before undertaking serious campaigns such as war. In his own way, he was calling for a system of checks and balances. Thus, he warned, "One cannot use spies without sagacity and knowledge, one cannot use spies without humanity and justice"

In its dealings with the extralegal program to spy on U.S. citizens and others living in America -- or to extract information from them -- the White House has shown no sagacity, humanity or justice. Rather, the administration has done exactly the opposite of what Sun Tzu instructed.

Take sagacity. When Bush was unable to obtain top-level clearance for the wiretaps from then-Deputy Attorney General James Comey, two aides -- Andrew Card, White House chief of staff, and Alberto Gonzales, then-White House counsel -- went to George Washington University Hospital in a bizarre after-hours effort to get then-Attorney General John Ashcroft, who was recovering from gallbladder surgery, to sign off on it.

Humanity? This is the White House that supports extraordinary rendition of possible suspects to countries that torture freely in order to extract often inconsequential or fabricated information. Extraordinary rendition is when the CIA sends terror suspects to foreign intelligence agents without extradition proceedings. Suspects have been sent to Syria, Morocco, Egypt and Jordan, countries whose violent practices have been documented and condemned by the U.S. State Department's annual human rights report.

Like Nixon more than 35 years ago, Bush has ordered the NSA to conduct electronic snooping on communications of hundreds of people, including U.S. citizens. Unlike Nixon, however, this president has fully admitted spying and shown no remorse. Watergate settled Fourth Amendment law that the Executive Branch may not engage in wiretapping or other forms of electronic surveillance of the contents of private communications without probable cause and a warrant. Moreover, since the 1950s, the U.S. Supreme Court has clearly held that the president's power as commander in chief provides authority over the military and its battlefield operations but does not provide any comparable authority on matters at home.

Duffy, in quoting Sun Tzu, cavalierly told the American people that deception is the name of the game these days. In effect, he told the American people that they may as well distrust the administration, since the administration clearly distrusts them.

The American public recognizes the problems of applying corporate espionage strategies to the administration of the open democratic society of the United States. In the past few weeks, hundreds of letters to newspaper editors calling for impeachment proceedings have been published and posted online. Academics and lawyers are now openly assessing legal arguments to support impeachment proceedings.

And watchdog organizations are beginning to act. NGOs like Human Rights Watch have also advanced arguments that the alleged torture and other mistreatment of detainees, if proven, would amount to serious violations of U.S. criminal law, such as the War Crimes Act and the Anti-Torture Statute, and have called for a special prosecutor to investigate alleged mistreatment of detainees in U.S.-controlled detention facilities abroad.

And in late December, the ACLU sent a detailed letter to Gonzales calling for the appointment of an outside special counsel to investigate and prosecute criminal acts committed by any member of the Executive Branch in the NSA's warrantless surveillance of people in the United States over the past four years.

In the coming weeks, Congress plans to exercise its oversight role by holding hearings on the question of the legality of the Bush administration's eavesdropping program. Sen. Arlen Specter, R-Pa., chairman of the Judiciary Committee, has pledged to make hearings into this program one of his highest priorities.

In a recent letter to Specter, Sen. Schumer, D-N.Y., also on the Judiciary Committee, said the Senate should also explore "significant concern about the legality of the program even at the very highest levels of the Department of Justice." Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind., the chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, also supports hearings.

Rep. John Conyers has also argued that the president committed impeachable offenses because he and senior administration officials "countenanced torture and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment in Iraq" at Abu Ghraib and other locations, as well as at Guantanamo Bay and the now-notorious "black sites" around the world, including those in Eastern Europe and Afghanistan.

Congress must act to put the brakes on Bush's Cold War-era projects before even larger spying programs are approved. The hearings on Samuel Alito -- no friend to civil liberties and individual rights -- are about to begin, and President Bush just kicked off a barnstorming tour to drum up support for the USA PATRIOT Act, many key provisions of which were set to expire Saturday.

Indeed, we can read Sun Tzu to know where Bush is heading. It is best, Sun Tzu said, when citizens are not involved in military campaigns. It is best, he said, to throw a blanket of silence, of darkness, over the nation on whose behalf the military is working.

That might have been great during a period of civil war 2,500 years ago. However, it is not relevant to a modern society with a system of checks and balances based on a written constitution -- a constitution the president has sworn to uphold, and whose violation can be grounds for impeachment.

Noah Leavitt is an attorney. He can be contacted at nsleavitt@hotmail.com.

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

Women Tool Up for Independence with DIY Parties


By Jonathan Brown
The Independent
UK

Tuesday 03 January 2006

A cold night in an affluent suburb in Denver, Colorado. Inside a well-appointed, detached home a dozen women are gathered.

Aged mainly in their mid-forties, the excited talk among this group of female graduate professionals is of only one thing: tools. They have come here to debate the relative virtues of the V-notch trowel against that of its square-notched rival. Then there is the question of whether to stock up on a few more rolls of waterproof tarp, splash out on a new eight-inch adjustable wrench or invest in that state-of-the art, easy-action caulking gun they have set their hearts on.

Once upon a time their mothers may have come together with friends in just such a manner to purchase Tupperware, or cosmetics. But, as the astounding success of the US-based company Tomboy Tools testifies, this new generation is happily colonising a market that was traditionally the preserve of their husbands.

Such is the success of "tool parties" among women in the United States that Tomboy Tools is exporting the concept across the Atlantic. From March, British women will be invited to break open the nibbles, pour out the wine and get to grips with the latest innovations in DIY design.

Janet Rickstrew founded Tomboy Tools along with two friends in 2000 after attending a Pampered Chef party in their home town of Denver. "We had a lot of fun, but it wasn't enough. We thought we should do something else," the 42-year-old former university maintenance department worker said.

Now the company has 500 party consultants in the United States and a further 150 in Canada. They expect to double the number of party planners this year as well as rolling out in the UK.

Recent research has suggested that 80 per cent of home improvement decisions and 60 per cent of DIY purchases are now made by women, according to the business consultancy the Proficiency Group, which organised the first Rethink Pink Marketing to Women Award this year.

And this new breed of consumers are not just painting cupboard doors and putting up new curtains. More than half say they have repaired a faulty lavatory, while 46 per cent say that they have fixed a leaking tap.

In the United States, retailers were quick to get on board the female DIY revolution, although it was often women themselves who pioneered the change. Barbara Kavovit, who was the former head of a New York construction company, has launched her own range of tools for women. And that does not just mean painting them pink. Specially designed to fit a woman's hand, slightly smaller and lighter to make them easier to handle, they are also stylish and not a little chic. "Every woman should be self-sufficient," the 36-year-old single mother said recently. "I didn't want to reinvent the hammer, which has been around since the caveman era, but I wanted to create tools that felt a little bit softer and a touch lighter and came with an empowerment message." British companies are catching on too.

And British consumers are also being spurred by the appeal of female-friendly shows such as House Invaders and the success of stars such as Linda Barker, Anna Ryder Richardson and Property Ladder's Sarah Beeny.

Ms Rickstrew is confident that tool parties will take off in the UK, which has similar rates of women owning their own homes. Single women account for 21 per cent of all households, while divorce and widowhood is steadily swelling these numbers.

"In the past, women thought that it wasn't their job and that it was down to their husbands. Now it is a question of fostering confidence and empowerment. Women just need the education so we teach them a few simple things like patching or tiling in a non-threatening atmosphere where they are not in fear of being made to look foolish."

So women, who in Virginia Woolf's memorable phrase, once aspired to owning a room of one's own as the apotheosis of independence, could soon be rewiring and plumbing it themselves too.

Jews vs. Darwin? | The Growing NSA Storm | Meat Workers' Misery

Top Stories from AlterNet for January 4, 2006
http://www.alternet.org/
_____________________________________________________

FOWL PLAY IN THE SLAUGHTERHOUSE
Stan Cox, AlterNet
How America is failing the workers who put beef, chicken and
pork on our dinner tables.
http://www.alternet.org/story/30348/

JEWS SAY 'FEH' TO DARWIN
Mariah Blake, Miami New Times
The Orthodox Jewish community clashes over intelligent
design.
http://www.alternet.org/story/30335/
_____________________________________________________

Dont miss AlterNet's coverage of the intensifying NSA
outrage -- and why we should care:

AN ABUSE OF POWER
Jan Frel, AlterNet
The NSA wiretapping scandal is an object lesson in how the
American presidency -- not just this president -- has gained
too much power.
http://www.alternet.org/story/30350/

SOMETHING TO HIDE
Onnesha Roychoudhuri, AlterNet
As the Bush administration downplays its illegal
wiretapping, the New York Times' chiefs keep quiet about
their role in the scandal.
http://www.alternet.org/story/30352/

CONGRESSIONAL OVERSIGHT 2006
Arianna Huffington, AlterNet
With neutered watchdogs like Mitch McConnell in the Senate,
it's easy to see why Bush believed he could do as he
pleased.
http://www.alternet.org/columnists/story/30344/
_____________________________________________________

MILLER'S MOMENT
Garance Franke-Ruta, The American Prospect
This is how George Miller, an effective but largely unsung
congressman, beat the president.
http://www.alternet.org/story/30349/

SAY IT AIN'T SO, SERGEY
Douglas Rushkoff, AlterNet
Google's decision to purchase 5 percent of AOL marks a dramatic
shift in strategy for a company that, frankly, never had to
bother with strategy before.
http://www.alternet.org/mediaculture/30338/

MEDIA NEW YEAR'S RESOLUTIONS
Norman Solomon, AlterNet
No one is in greater need of forthright 2006
resolutions than America's major media outlets.
http://www.alternet.org/columnists/story/30330/
_____________________________________________________

Out of Iraq Events Planned in Over 70 Cities



Out of Iraq Events Planned in Over 70 Cities
Local organizations have planned over 70 Out of Iraq events around the country on or about January 7th. (See list at bottom.) Most of the events are town hall forums, and several will feature members of Congress, including Bobby Scott, Diane Watson, Jim McDermott, Adam Smith, Bob Filner, Martin Sabo, Jim Moran, and John Murtha. Several other events will feature congressional staff, congressional and senatorial candidates, local elected officials, and leaders of the peace movement, including Gold Star Families for Peace founder Cindy Sheehan, and After Downing Street Co-Founder John Bonifaz.

While all of these events will focus on ending the war, many of them will also address Congressman John Conyers' new resolutions to censure President Bush and Vice President Cheney and to create a select committee to investigate and make recommendations on impeachment.

To sign up for an event near you, go to:
http://www.afterdowningstreet.org/event

National Call-In Day on Accountability January 9th
Tens of thousands of members of Progressive Democrats of America and other organizational members of the After Downing Street Coalition will phone Members of Congress in their district offices on January 9, urging them to cosponsor three bills: H.Res.635 to create a select committee to investigate and to make recommendations on grounds for impeachment, H.Res.636 to censure Bush, and H.Res.637 to censure Cheney. More about these bills:
http://www.afterdowningstreet.org/?q=node/5768

Congress Members' phone numbers:
http://capwiz.com/pdamerica/dbq/officials/?lvl=C

International Commission Taking "Indictments" to White House January 9th
On January 9, the International Commission of Inquiry on Crimes Against Humanity By the Bush Administration will serve indictments on the White House for its wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, its actions and policies on torture and illegal detention, its promotion of abstinence-only in the midst of the HIV/AIDS pandemic, its fueling of global warming, and its response to Hurricane Katrina. This is in preparation for its January 20-22 hearings at Riverside Church and Columbia Law School in New York City (where the Administration will be invited to present a defense). For more details, see:
http://www.bushcommission.org

ImpeachPAC Forms Citizens Impeachment Commission
On Monday, ImpeachPAC announced the formation of a Citizens Impeachment Commission to make 2006 the "Year of Impeachment."

Members of the commission include distinguished national activists, business leaders, elected officials, former government officials, historians and legal scholars, and talk show hosts, editors, bloggers, pundits, and authors.
http://www.impeachpac.org/citizens

Get "Enraged & Engaged" to Stop Alito
The National Organization for Women needs your help to keep abortion safe & legal. There is work to be done, both in Washington, DC and throughout the country. As a part of Freedom Winter 2006, NOW and Feminist Majority Foundation are working together to bring grassroots activists to DC between January 3 and January 20. We're also encouraging activists to organize in their communities.
http://www.now.org/defeatalito

Demand Strict Inspection of Diebold Software
It has been proven that Diebold electronic voting machines use code that is prohibited by federal law, but that hasn't stopped them from selling their machines and states from using them!

Please let Federal Election Commissioners know that citizens want the FEC to uphold the law and insist Diebold comply. You can use this one link to send an email to all commissioners. Please let them know that we are paying
attention!

http://www.congressweb.com/cweb4/index.cfm?orgcode=VTUSA&hotissue=4

FORWARD THIS EMAIL

#####

If you received this from a friend, you can subscribe at:
http://afterdowningstreet.org

To unsubscribe from AfterDowningStreet Updates, click here:
http://archive.democrats.com/unsub.cfm?email=tsb713@hotmail.com&fieldname=L16

To unsubscribe from all Democrats.com mailings, click here:
http://archive.democrats.com/unsub.cfm?email=tsb713@hotmail.com&fieldname=L1

MEDIAOCRACY 2006: OUT WITH THE OLD, IN WITH THE NEW

NEW

http://www.buzzflash.com/contributors/06/01/con06003.html

http://www.mediachannel.org/

MEDIAOCRACY 2006: OUT WITH THE OLD, IN WITH THE NEW

By Danny Schechter
Mediachannel.org

New York, Jan 1 2006: A new year always starts with hope and many unfulfilled resolutions. And then, it is often downhill from there. My mother was born on a January 2 so I know that the first month of the year can be a time of promise. As a media critic who spends much of his intellectual energy in media combat, a few words of refection are in order, with a nod to some promising trends.

A pre-new year's conversation with Gerald Calente, director of the Trends Research Institute (you may have seen him on CNN) confirmed that I am not off in my prognostications and that the media system we have grown to first love and then hate is on the way out.

TV is converging with the web, he says, offering a new opportunity for progressives who are tired of being frozen out of the media matrix.

Over the weekend I also noticed that the always innovative but apparently poorly promoted (and hence viewed) TRIO channel is moving from digital cable in New York to broadband, a sign of changing times. Here's their online announcement:

"NBC UNIVERSAL TO LAUNCH TRIO BROADBAND INITIATIVE UNDER BRAVOTV.COM BANNER WITH CONTENT PEGGED TO UNIQUE 'TRIO' BRAND AND POP CULTURE SENSIBILITY ON JANUARY 1, 2006

'TRIO' TO DISCONTINUE AS A STAND-ALONE DIGITAL CABLE TELEVISION SERVICE"

The flight from our traditional viewing platforms has begun. The old media is dying and the new media order is on the way-although not here yet. It is a larger trend I write about in my just published "manifesto," The Death of the Media and the Fight for Democracy (Melville House):

'Ten years ago, the writer Michael Crichton predicted it would happen in an introduction to the 1995 edition of Project Censored, an annual collection of downplayed and suppressed stories. The author of Jurassic Park said he wanted to focus on another "dinosaur" on the "road to extinction":

"I am referring to the American media. And I use the term extinction literally. To my mind, it is likely that what we now understand as the mass media will be gone within the next ten years. Vanished without a trace."

While his prediction may have been off by a few years, he saw what others didn't - perhaps because it takes a novelist to understand reality in a deeper way.

He wrote before all the changes we are witnessing -- more viewers watching cable than network, the growth of satellite channels, a dramatic decline of newspaper circulation, the rise of the internet and the proliferation of diverse content, the search engines and the bloggers and the new digital technologies.

A writer Bruce Sterling has been tracking the death of media. He wrote his own manifesto about it also drawing on dinosaur metaphors. "Our culture is experiencing a profound radiation of new species of media. The centralized, dinosaurian one- to-many media that roared and trampled through the 20th century are poorly adapted to the postmodern technological environment. The new media environment is aswarm with lumbering toothy digital mammals. It's all lynxes here, and gophers there, plus big fat venomous webcrawlers, appearing in Pleistocene profusion."

He adds, "It's a rather rare phenomenon for an established medium to die. If media make it past their Golden Vaporware stage, they usually expand wildly in their early days and then shrink back to some protective niche as they are challenged by later and more highly evolved competitors. Radio didn't kill newspapers, TV didn't kill radio or movies, video and cable didn't kill broadcast network TV; they just all jostled around seeking a more perfect app."

The media consuming public seems to have an unlimited appetite for new media, but it is not just technologies that die but people's relationships to them. With more to watch and more to experience, attention spans shrink with more distractions designed to divert our attentions away from programming that asks us to care about our society in one way or another.

Increasingly, even as it gets slicker, the public that is supposed to like what they see, is turning it off and tuning it out. Our media is being confronted by a public that isn't very happy with its output. We know this from surveys that span the political spectrum that be reported but are rarely dwelt on. The last thing media outlets want to report is why the public is turning against them. In a media designed for "tune-in," tune-out seems to be the trend. Opinion surveys report wide spread dissatisfaction--see recent reports by the Pew Center in American Life--but other statistics are more compelling--the statistics that report fewer viewers watching network news programs and readers buying newspapers.

Match that up with the comparatively low voter turnout in The US and you find that in ours, the most media rich nation on earth, democratic participation is shrinking. Many critics have criticized the media for actually depoliticizing politics and in the process undermining democracy.

Media scandals seem to be erupting more frequently than political scandals, and the credibility of major media continues to decline. One Pew Center public opinion poll in one of those rare moments when members of the public were asked for their views -- found that as many as 70% of the people asked expressed dissatisfaction with the media.

Nearly 70 percent were angry, but for different reasons. Nearly half think the media is too left wing -not surprising after years of the Republican Party's punditocracy trashing the so-called "liberal media." The other half blames the right wing for souring them on media, pointing to Fox News and a tendency for big media to defer to big government.

In the general public, there is a growing consensus of complaint as media insiders puzzle over slipping ratings or more young people abandoning news networks for comedy channels for their news. There seems to be a growing anti-media consensus at the very time that media institutions seem to be more powerful than ever.

Linda Foley, who runs the Newspaper Guild, sees hostility to big media growing. She writes: "Across all states and nearly all states of mind, "the media" have replaced "politicians" as one of our most reviled institutions. This united disdain and distrust of commercial media has been fomenting for several decades. The days when Woodward and Bernstein were folk heroes and Walter Cronkite was the most trusted man in America are long gone.

What happened? For one thing, media-particularly local media-got bigger and more distant. In an effort to homogenize content to make it appeal to broader swaths of audiences across multiple communities and lifestyles, U.S. media have dumbed down the news and sexed up the entertainment to minimize costs and increase sales and profits. (Sex sells; news doesn't.)"

Part of the reason is the blurring of lines between facts and opinion, news and entertainment; reality on TV is being replaced by "reality-based" programming. Many of our elections are now viewed mostly through the window of manipulative political commercials not held to standards of truthfulness. There are more pundits on the air than journalists. A trend towards sillier and sillier programming results in a lack of respect for media outlets.

How can this system be changed, or can it?

That's the question on the agenda in this news year, and change is all around us.

One way to renew a failing system is to bring new players into it. Mega web portals like Yahoo and Google are newcomers making deals every day with the old brands. Google buys into AOL; Yahoo buys into photo-sharing site Flickr, and now it has acquired bookmarking phenomenon Delicious to expand its new search software.

It's hard to keep up with all the technical innovation. It's technically feasible right now to watch TV and use the Web interchangeably on the same screen.

There is a promise here of a break up of the old monopoly structures and in it, an opportunity for those of us dissatisfied with the old to create something new. Some see a chance to cash in-not just bitch, but also get rich.

Others recognize that more diversity on the airwaves is possible. And that will be a good thing for allowing real media choice to help renew our democracy.

At the very end of last year, one of America's great media critics, George Gerber, died. His mantra was that we need a media with more to tell, not just sell. He called for activism and movements to protect and expand our cultural environment.

He may be gone, but that time may be coming-not necessarily in the way he imagined.

News Dissector Danny Schechter is blogger-in-chief of Mediachannel.org. For more on The Death of The Media and When News Lies, his book on Iraq war coverage, see Newsdissector.org/store.htm. Comments to dissector@mediachannel.org



--

Jackie Newberry
Outreach Coordinator, Mediachannel.org
jackie@mediachannel.org

MediaChannel is responding to the crisis of our times. We are adding news from diverse sources to demonstrate that the world can be covered in a better, more democratic way.

To link to The News Dissector: http://www.newsdissector.org/blog
To link to Media is a Plural: http://www.roryoconnor.org


Read the following blogs on the Web or subscribe to them for free: http://www.mediachannel.org/email/

o News Dissector Daily Weblog: http://www.newsdissector.org/blog/
o Media is a Plural Weblog by Rory O'Connor: http://www.roryoconnor.org
o Media Savvy - MediaChannel's daily news roundup http://mediachannel.org/blog/taxonomy/term/5/9

Join us in the "Tell the Truth About the War" Campaign. http://mediachannel.org/blog/node/1555

We welcome your comments and stories; use our contact form: http://www.mediachannel.org/about/.

Your donations will help us survive. Please consider becoming a sponsor of MediaChannel's Global Movement: http://tinyurl.com/9h8vd





Tuesday, January 03, 2006

Friends Don't Let Friends Commit War Crimes

By Cindy Sheehan
t r u t h o u t | Perspective

Monday 02 January 2006

"You're like an ambassador for peace," a Spanish journalist told me as we finished one of the dozens of interviews I gave in Europe. I did this interview right before I went to meet with the Spanish Deputy Minister for Foreign Affairs.

In reality, I did feel like an ambassador for peace as I traveled around Europe for 16 days in December.

The Mayor of London held a reception in honor of our peace efforts at the new and very modern City Hall, near the impressive and intimidating Tower Bridge and the Tower of London. Mayor Ken Livingstone has always been an outspoken critic of the Iraq war and the war crimes of Tweedledum and Tweedledee ... Bush and Blair ... the corrupt, yet sadly comical, mis-leaders of two of the most powerful countries on the planet. I believe Bush and Blair are too far gone for redemption. They both need to be removed from their power and tried for their war crimes and betrayals. Until they are removed, the murder and the mayhem will continue.

In Ireland, I met with that country's equivalent of Condi Rice, the dignified Foreign Minister Dermot Ahern. As a matter of fact, he had just met with the "steely" Condi the week before. Incredibly, he accepted assurances from her that the CIA airplanes (up to 60 documented by peace activists) that are landing in Shannon airport are not transporting prisoners for extraordinary rendition ( i.e., torture). That's like accepting a pirate's assurance that he's not going to steal your boat as he's boarding it with a drawn sword! I tried to impress on Mr. Ahern that the leaders of my government are known pathological liars, and can't be believed on this or anything. The torture planes are landing on Irish soil, so Ireland should inspect them for human rights violations. If Condi and her "husband" George aren't doing anything wrong, they have nothing to be concerned with.

Ireland declined to send troops as part of the Coalition of the Killing, but they do allow US planes to re-fuel at Shannon airport (Mr. Ahern: We did it during Vietnam!). I delivered a stack of petitions to Mr. Ahern of 10,000 signatures from pro-peace, anti-killing citizens of Ireland demanding that their government stop allowing my government to land torture planes and troop transport planes at Shannon airport. My own son, Casey, went through Shannon. I urged Mr. Ahern to please make the US refuel their planes elsewhere. The occupation of Iraq is illegal by most standards and immoral by all standards. Being accomplices to war crimes makes one culpable for these war crimes. I can say he listened and I believe he genuinely wants to do what's right for Ireland. The people of Ireland need to keep the pressure on their government to act rationally and responsibly in this matter.

Scotland is the birth place of impeachment and also the birthplace of both of my great-grandmas. I met with many Scottish MPs who are very anti-war and anti-Bush and anti-Blair. They are doing all they can to end the Scottish involvement in the war. The First Minister wouldn't meet with me. But my friend, Rose Gentle, has been trying to meet with him since her son, Gordon, was tragically killed in Iraq. When leaders of countries are co-conspirators in lies and corruption and don't even have the courage or integrity to meet with the people whose lives their unpunished felonies have damaged beyond full repair, that is a scandal.

The Spanish government is relatively new and they did bring their troops home from Iraq after the old government was kicked out in 2004 because the people of Spain had it with the lies and corruption of their Bushite regime.

The recurring theme when I met with Spanish government officials, including the Vice President of Spain, Manuel Marin, and the deputy foreign minister and heads of some of their parties, was "shared values." We the peoples of both countries need to find common ground on which to stand. We urged the Spanish government to loudly denounce what the US is doing because the US government has no positive, life-affirming values. The US government has negative, life-ruining values such as the use of WMDs and torture as means to satisfy its ends of greed for power and mammon.

The Spanish officials, like the other government officials we met, told me and the other Gold Star Families for Peace members and local peace activists who attended the meetings, that their countries are "great friends and allies of the USA."

We want friends and allies of the American people, but not of the current regime. The government is not identical with the people, despite what the right-wing hatemongerers say. Indeed, that is fascist notion. Not only do we not need to love our government's policies. When they are evil, we have a patriotic obligation to oppose them with all our strength. When the Bush administration uses white phosphorous on innocent men, women, children, and babies, when it uses illegal imprisonment and immoral torture on fellow members of the human race, when it invades and occupies another country that is no threat to the USA, we must say No. BushCo is an out of control entity which needs to be reined in by us! The longer the horror of Iraq continues, the more war crimes are committed and the more innocent lives ruined!

During my visit to Europe, I was invited to other countries as a peace emissary. People in Italy and Australia are particularly anxious to have me visit, because their governments are accomplices to BushCo in Iraq. I will be speaking to the European Union Parliament twice in 2006 to urge them to pressure our administration to stop its killing policies in Iraq and try something new: diplomacy and peace. Heads up, Condi: peace is NOT spread by killing and war.

Although, our visits to the various governmental officials in Europe did not have an immediate effect, perhaps seeds were planted. The international peace community is energized and refocused. However, by just meeting with me, the officials of each country are showing a minor tear in the fabric of support with the illegitimate residents of the "Casa Blanca." Each little sign gives hope.

As Dermot Ahern told me: "It's going to get back to Washington that I met with you. They won't be happy. But I don't care. It was the right thing to do."

The Greening of Goldman Sachs


By Traci Hukill, AlterNet. Posted January 3, 2006.



Also in Top Stories

2005 Wasn't All Bad
Katha Pollitt, The Nation

Chicago vs. Hugo Chávez
Jessica Pupovac, The NewStandard

Solving the Immigration Dilemma
Neil Peirce, Stateline.org

'Strapped' for Adulthood
Jodie Janella Horn, PopMatters


More stories by Traci Hukill

010205_story

Last year the investment bank Goldman Sachs acquired a portfolio of mortgages in default that involved a remarkable piece of land in Tierra del Fuego, Chile. The wild, starkly beautiful island on the far tip of South America is a haven of biodiversity, home to old-growth beech forests and a unique network of peat bogs. So when the bank donated all 680,000 acres of the property -- an area about a third the size of Yellowstone -- to the Wildlife Conservation Society in trust to the people of Chile, it was a boon to ecological preservation.

It was also a source of perplexity in some quarters. While Goldman Sachs explained that it had simply acted on a "rare opportunity for the firm to benefit global conservation," many people found it hard to trust such a gesture of generosity from a financial institution.

But there is reason to think that skeptics can relax their vigilance on this one and maybe even entertain some hope. In November Goldman Sachs, a financial sector leader worth $60 billion, rolled out a new environmental policy that goes further, and is smarter, than any comparable policy in the corporate world.

The unveiling of the framework to address environmental degradation and climate change capped 18 months of consultations with environmental groups. Among them were Rainforest Action Network (RAN), Rainforest Alliance, World Resources Institute and Friends of the Earth.

Only eight pages long, the plan (PDF) contains some fairly typical stuff, such as a vow to use more recycled paper in Goldman's offices. But it also contains a promise to reject projects in environmental no-go zones, and to institute further changes in the way it does business--all with an eye on ethics and the environment.

According to the framework, Goldman Sachs will:

  • disclose the greenhouse gas emissions of all its operations;
  • make $1 billion available for investments in renewable energy;
  • set up a think tank to identify other lucrative green markets;
  • work on public policy measures relating to climate change;
  • conduct more rigorous assessments of its new projects' impacts on the environment and on indigenous people;
  • refuse to finance extractive projects in World Heritage sites or any projects that violate the environmental laws of the host country.

This is not a case of Goldman pretending its job is to save the world, or forsaking its primary mission to make money for its investors. Self-interest is in full effect here. Goldman Sachs is positioning itself to be a leader in the green energy sector.

It's also averting risk. The policy says so in so many strangulated, jargoney words: "We believe that companies' management of environmental and related social risks and opportunities may affect corporate performance."

Translation: there are real financial costs to ignoring the environment and the people who depend on it for their survival, and we don't intend to get stuck paying them.

Gold standard

If Goldman Sachs winds up doing well by doing good, that's fine with Ilyse Hogue, coordinator of Rainforest Action Network's Global Finance Campaign. To her, Goldman's new policy is genuine cause for excitement for three reasons, starting with the investment firm's reputation.

"It's largely regarded, in a way that I'm just coming to understand, as the gold standard in the market," Hogue says. "So simply by making the commitment to these values, Goldman sends strong signals through the marketplace that are heard in corners of the economic system that we've yet to reach."

Second, Goldman Sachs CEO Hank Paulson, who also chairs the board of The Nature Conservancy, showed an avid interest in the policy from the start of the process. In other successful corporate campaigns undertaken by RAN -- with JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America and Citigroup -- the boss's buy-in has been critical to follow-through. Hogue believes that Paulson's commitment bodes well for Goldman's putting its money where its mouth is in coming years.

Third is the policy itself. It's the first corporate environmental policy to hinge on the newly minted idea of "ecosystem services," which is a way of looking at the environment in terms of what it provides for humans. Ecosystem services might include the storm buffer provided by healthy mangrove forests lacing tropical coastlines, or the water filtration furnished by intact wetlands. A healthy forest provides multiple ecosystem services: It cleanses the air by providing a carbon sink, it produces clean water, it may contain habitat for spawning fish that in turn feed humans, and it provides the intangible service of recreation and spiritual renewal.

All of these "services" have value, and their disruption exacts a price. Deforestation in Haiti made the 2004 flooding and mudslides truly disastrous. The warming of Caribbean waters fueled Hurricane Katrina, and when the surge hit, the damaged Louisiana wetlands were unable to slow it.

If it seems mercenary to make the case that nature should be protected so humans may be spared the cost of failed natural systems -- in lives, resources and dollars -- it's also true that the formula translates effortlessly into financespeak. This is something banks get.

It may result in better policy, too.

"It may seem like a little thing, but in terms of the way these policies are absorbed, it's actually very important," Hogue says. "What the banks are actually understanding with this breakthrough language is that you have to look beyond the forest to understand the value of the forest."

Nature's capital

The term "ecosystem services" burst on the scene last spring with the release of the United Nations-backed Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, a $24 million global health check that combined the expertise of 1,360 scientists in 95 countries.

The concept had been around -- in 1997 a group of economists and biologists had calculated that the earth's ecosystems provide $33 trillion worth of services each year -- but the Millennium Assessment was the first major report to be built around the idea. It did not attempt to assign dollar figures to ecosystem services, but it did present its findings in economic terms. Concluding that two-thirds of the earth's ecosystem services are being used up faster than they can replenish themselves, the report stated the finding thusly: Humans are running down nature's capital.

Walt Reid, who directed the seven-year project and now heads Stanford University's Institute for the Environment, says this is a matter of economic sense. "If you have $10,000 in the bank and you're spending it, you're living well and times are great -- but you're not replenishing it," he says. "If you factor in the real cost of changing systems, we're often making the wrong choices."

The report made front-page news around the world -- everywhere except in the United States, where it barely registered. In other countries, governments and businesses have been awakening to the idea that degraded environments inflict serious costs. Last March British finance minister Gordon Brown told a gathering of 20 of his international counterparts that climate change posed a major threat to economic growth. This is slowly dawning on U.S. companies too.

"I think the bean counters have come running to corporate leaders in a cold panting sweat saying, 'This is how much global warming is gonna cost you,'" says RAN spokesman Paul West. "We've been saying that [it's good business to factor in environmental costs] for a long time, but they just didn't want to hear it from environmentalists."

Weasel words or lawyerspeak?

It remains to be seen how Goldman balances its stated convictions with its commitment to its shareholders. Its new policy states very clearly that it "will not stray from [its] central business objective of creating long-term value" for shareholders and clients. But is Goldman prepared to take some financial hits in the short term to stand behind its promises?

It's hard to tell by reading the framework. The document is stuffed with weak verbs like "prefer" and "encourage." Example: "We will encourage clients conducting industrial and agricultural activity in environmentally sensitive areas to do so with the appropriate safeguards."

Hogue says that's what happens after lawyers get a hold of a document, that it doesn't necessarily mean Goldman is backing toward the door. Lucas van Praag, spokesman for Goldman Sachs, says that "if your view is world-weary and very cynical, then you might say, 'Well, these are weasel words and they haven't said anything substantive at all.' But I can tell you from our perspective these are taken very seriously indeed."

Van Praag is candid when pressed. "Does that mean we would never do business with a company that has been accused of engaging in illegal logging? No, it doesn't. What it does mean is we would hope to do business with that company on the basis of encouraging them to change."

Hogue agrees. "There are steps in between," she says, "like saying to these high-impact clients, 'We want to do business with you but you need to do A, B and C.' That actually moves industrial sectors."

Ultimately it comes down to enlightened self-interest, as it must in order to work for business. Says van Praag : "What we say about our business is that it's composed of three elements -- people, capital and reputation. And of the three the one that's most difficult to repair or replace if it's damaged is reputation. So we don't want to do things that are going to affect our reputation, because that speaks directly to our license to operate."

So there it is. If environmental responsibility is good for Goldman Sachs' reputation, it's good for the long-term bottom line. Maybe someday corporate reverence for nature will be unsullied by filthy lucre, but for now it may be appropriate to stop and gratefully reflect on a minor miracle that has taken place: a leader in the financial world has begun to consider that what is in the interest of the environment is in the interest of business.

"For so long when you thought about any of these banks, you never would have thought they would change their lending practices around these criteria," says RAN's West. "What we're seeing is the race to the top may be underway, for a change."

Traci Hukill is a freelance journalist based in Monterey, Calif.