Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Patenting Life


by Michael Crichton

You, or someone you love, may die because of a gene patent that should never have been granted in the first place. Sound far-fetched? Unfortunately, it’s only too real.

Gene patents are now used to halt research, prevent medical testing and keep vital information from you and your doctor. Gene patents slow the pace of medical advance on deadly diseases. And they raise costs exorbitantly: a test for breast cancer that could be done for $1,000 now costs $3,000.

Why? Because the holder of the gene patent can charge whatever he wants, and does. Couldn’t somebody make a cheaper test? Sure, but the patent holder blocks any competitor’s test. He owns the gene. Nobody else can test for it. In fact, you can’t even donate your own breast cancer gene to another scientist without permission. The gene may exist in your body, but it’s now private property.

This bizarre situation has come to pass because of a mistake by an underfinanced and understaffed government agency. The United States Patent Office misinterpreted previous Supreme Court rulings and some years ago began — to the surprise of everyone, including scientists decoding the genome — to issue patents on genes.

Humans share mostly the same genes. The same genes are found in other animals as well. Our genetic makeup represents the common heritage of all life on earth. You can’t patent snow, eagles or gravity, and you shouldn’t be able to patent genes, either. Yet by now one-fifth of the genes in your body are privately owned.

The results have been disastrous. Ordinarily, we imagine patents promote innovation, but that’s because most patents are granted for human inventions. Genes aren’t human inventions, they are features of the natural world. As a result these patents can be used to block innovation, and hurt patient care.

For example, Canavan disease is an inherited disorder that affects children starting at 3 months; they cannot crawl or walk, they suffer seizures and eventually become paralyzed and die by adolescence. Formerly there was no test to tell parents if they were at risk. Families enduring the heartbreak of caring for these children engaged a researcher to identify the gene and produce a test. Canavan families around the world donated tissue and money to help this cause.

When the gene was identified in 1993, the families got the commitment of a New York hospital to offer a free test to anyone who wanted it. But the researcher’s employer, Miami Children’s Hospital Research Institute, patented the gene and refused to allow any health care provider to offer the test without paying a royalty. The parents did not believe genes should be patented and so did not put their names on the patent. Consequently, they had no control over the outcome.

In addition, a gene’s owner can in some instances also own the mutations of that gene, and these mutations can be markers for disease. Countries that don’t have gene patents actually offer better gene testing than we do, because when multiple labs are allowed to do testing, more mutations are discovered, leading to higher-quality tests.

Apologists for gene patents argue that the issue is a tempest in a teapot, that patent licenses are readily available at minimal cost. That’s simply untrue. The owner of the genome for Hepatitis C is paid millions by researchers to study this disease. Not surprisingly, many other researchers choose to study something less expensive.

But forget the costs: why should people or companies own a disease in the first place? They didn’t invent it. Yet today, more than 20 human pathogens are privately owned, including haemophilus influenza and Hepatitis C. And we’ve already mentioned that tests for the BRCA genes for breast cancer cost $3,000. Oh, one more thing: if you undergo the test, the company that owns the patent on the gene can keep your tissue and do research on it without asking your permission. Don’t like it? Too bad.

The plain truth is that gene patents aren’t benign and never will be. When SARS was spreading across the globe, medical researchers hesitated to study it — because of patent concerns. There is no clearer indication that gene patents block innovation, inhibit research and put us all at risk.

Even your doctor can’t get relevant information. An asthma medication only works in certain patients. Yet its manufacturer has squelched efforts by others to develop genetic tests that would determine on whom it will and will not work. Such commercial considerations interfere with a great dream. For years we’ve been promised the coming era of personalized medicine — medicine suited to our particular body makeup. Gene patents destroy that dream.

Fortunately, two congressmen want to make the full benefit of the decoded genome available to us all. Last Friday, Xavier Becerra, a Democrat of California, and Dave Weldon, a Republican of Florida, sponsored the Genomic Research and Accessibility Act, to ban the practice of patenting genes found in nature. Mr. Becerra has been careful to say the bill does not hamper invention, but rather promotes it. He’s right. This bill will fuel innovation, and return our common genetic heritage to us. It deserves our support.

Michael Crichton is the author, most recently, of the novel “Next.”

Discuss This Article

Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company

###

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

February 13:


1633 : Galileo in Rome for Inquisition

On this day in 1633, Italian philosopher, astronomer and mathematician
Galileo Galilei arrives in Rome to face charges of heresy for
advocating Copernican theory, which holds that the Earth revolves
around the Sun. Galileo officially faced the Roman Inquisition in
April of that same year and agreed to plead guilty in exchange for a
lighter sentence. Put under house arrest indefinitely by Pope Urban
VIII, Galileo spent the rest of his days at his villa in Arcetri, near
Florence, before dying on January 8, 1642.

Galileo, the son of a musician, was born February 15, 1564, in Pisa,
Italy. He entered the University of Pisa planning to study medicine,
but shifted his focus to philosophy and mathematics. In 1589, he
became a professor at Pisa for several years, during which time he
demonstrated that the speed of a falling object is not proportional to
its weight, as Aristotle had believed. According to some reports,
Galileo conducted his research by dropping objects of different
weights from the Leaning Tower of Pisa. From 1592 to 1630, Galileo was
a math professor at the University of Padua, where he developed a
telescope that enabled him to observe lunar mountains and craters, the
four largest satellites of Jupiter and the phases of Jupiter. He also
discovered that the Milky Way was made up of stars. Following the
publication of his research in 1610, Galileo gained acclaim and was
appointed court mathematician at Florence.

Galileo's research led him to become an advocate of the work of the
Polish astronomer Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1573). However, the
Copernican theory of a sun-centered solar system conflicted with the
teachings of the powerful Roman Catholic Church, which essentially
ruled Italy at the time. Church teachings contended that Earth, not
the sun, was at the center of the universe. In 1633, Galileo was
brought before the Roman Inquisition, a judicial system established by
the papacy in 1542 to regulate church doctrine. This included the
banning of books that conflicted with church teachings. The Roman
Inquisition had its roots in the Inquisition of the Middle Ages, the
purpose of which was to seek out and prosecute heretics, considered
enemies of the state.

Today, Galileo is recognized for making important contributions to the
study of motion and astronomy. His work influenced later scientists
such as the English mathematician and physicist Sir Isaac Newton, who
developed the law of universal gravitation. In 1992, the Vatican
formally acknowledged its mistake in condemning Galileo.

history.com/tdih.do

Jim Crow Remembered


By William Fisher
t r u t h o u t | Columnist

Monday 12 February 2007

Bob Herbert of the New York Times has written a couple of gut-wrenching columns recently about Gary Tyler, a 16-year-old black youth who in 1974 was accused of murdering a 13-year-old white boy outside the high school they attended in Destrehan, Louisiana.

Herbert recounts how "the boy was shot to death in the midst of turmoil over school integration, which the local whites were resisting violently. The case against young Tyler - who was on a bus with other black students that was attacked by about 200 whites - was built on bogus evidence and coerced testimony. But that was enough to get him convicted by an all-white jury and sentenced to die in the electric chair. His life was spared when the Louisiana death penalty was ruled unconstitutional, but he is serving out a life sentence with no chance of parole in the state penitentiary at Angola."

Herbert writes that "his mother's sharpest memory of the day Gary was arrested was of sitting in a room at a sheriff's station, listening to deputies in the next room savagely beating her son."

After I got my outrage under control, I remembered scenes from 20 years earlier, when I was a cub reporter for a newspaper in Central Florida - then known as the state's Bible Belt.

One of my beats was what my managing editor called C&C - cops and courts. They gave me the grand title of Bureau Chief and sent me twenty miles away to the county seat. There, covering the local police, the county sheriff and the county court offered an eye-opening - and terrifying - glimpse into the abyss of the Jim Crow South. For a young Yankee reporter from New York, it was a never-to-be-forgotten education.

Saturday nights were always the busiest for this fledgling journalist. That's when a couple of dozen sheriff's deputies got into their patrol cars and headed for "colored town" - the county seat's ghetto where the dirt-poor African-Americans lived.

They swept in like the 101st airborne, arresting virtually anything that moved. Men and women - and the occasional child - caught up in the sweep were hustled into waiting paddy wagons and dispatched back to the sheriff's station. There, they were put behind bars and charged with a variety of heinous crimes - loitering was the most common. If they could post a $25 cash bond, they got out of jail. If not, they stayed locked up.

The sheriff and his deputies much preferred getting the cash, because back in those days they were paid on the "fee system," i.e., their salaries were substantially composed of a percentage of the fines they collected from the "nigras."

The later it got, the more arrests were made. It was Saturday night in "colored town." People drank. Some got into fights. Occasionally there were knifings. The suspects in these crimes were, like their earlier neighbors, hustled off to jail.

For them, there were no $25 bonds. They were quickly put into tiny cells, where most of them remained through their arraignments and until their trials - sometimes for many months. Bail was an unmentionable.

Likewise, legal aid, as we now understand it, was non-existent. The town's lawyers were ordered by the local bar association and the judge to represent the accused on a rotating pro-bono basis. And since they weren't about to give up their own Saturday nights, they rarely appeared until Monday morning. By that time, many of the often-illiterate suspects had placed their "mark" on confessions, largely obtained through empty promises of freedom and/or brutal beatings. The sheriff and his deputies were particularly fond of arresting couples, and then sexually abusing a wife to extract a confession from her husband.

Customarily, the next time I saw these people was when they came before the county judge for trial. Their lawyers were often unaware of the charges, since they hadn't bothered to read the court papers and police reports. Evidence of coerced confessions was routinely excluded, usually without the slightest hint of an objection from the defense lawyers. Juries were, predictably, all-white and all-male. Some of the attorneys appointed to defend the suspects showed up in court drunk, or with Saturday night hangovers. Many literally slept through the trials.

The next stop for most of these convicted felons was the state prison at Raiford, then widely acknowledged to be one of the more notoriously cruel and overcrowded penal institutions in the country. There were few appeals; appeals cost money.

That was justice in Central Florida in the 1950s, and things only got worse for black citizens after the civil rights movement started to gather steam.

Things didn't get much better for me either. In addition to writing stories for the paper that paid my salary - which, to the paper's great credit, often got page one, above-the-fold treatment - I started filing articles for the Baltimore Afro-American, one of the oldest black newspapers in the country. They paid me five cents a word. I wrote about what I was seeing on the C&C beat. They also published photos that I shot with my ancient Speed Graphic camera.

Somehow, that information got back to the sheriff, who one morning appeared in my office and, in his laconic Southern drawl, let me know that hanging around his sleepy cow-town could be damaging to my health. Before long, my editors, concerned for my well-being, called me back to main office.

With the arrival of Disney, lots of Northern retirees, Supreme Court decisions, and dramatic demographic shifts, Central Florida gradually changed. The county sheriff's department now boasts of its diversity, and I doubt there are any more Saturday Night Massacres these days.

Which is not to say that racial discrimination has gone away. Doubtless poor African-Americans still get arrested, still get represented by incompetent lawyers, still get convicted at far higher rates than white defendants.

But if racial bias in Central Florida hasn't gone away, it's certainly become more subtle. If you're an African-American, you might be concerned about whether your polling place is going to have enough voting machines. And you're probably less worried about getting shipped off to jail than about getting a business loan from a bank or a mortgage to buy property in a white neighborhood.

I guess that's progress. Especially if one looks back less than a generation. Which is probably a worthwhile thing to do during Black History Month. And every other month.


William Fisher has managed economic development programs in the Middle East and in many other parts of the world for the US State Department and USAID for the past thirty years. He began his work life as a journalist for newspapers and for the Associated Press in Florida. Go to The World According to Bill Fisher for more.

-------

Edwards Steps out Front on Health Care

By Dean Baker
t r u t h o u t | Columnist

Monday 12 February 2007

For the people who will vote in the Democratic primaries next year, the Iraq War will rightly be the central issue. On this topic, it is worth noting that we already have a president who can't admit that he made a mistake. But, after Iraq, health care will almost certainly stand out as the most important issue.

John Edwards moved the health-care debate forward last week when he outlined a plan that could provide universal coverage at an affordable price. The key points are fairly straightforward. The plan would require that employers either directly provide insurance for their workers or pay a fee to help cover their insurance. The plan would also set up regional insurance markets that would be open to everyone not covered by an employer-based plan. These markets would include a government-run plan modeled on Medicare.

The first part, a requirement that employers either buy insurance for their workers or pay a fee, provides the financing for universal coverage. The money from the fees could be used to supplement Medicaid and the State Child Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) in order to make insurance affordable for low- and moderate-income workers and their families.

The second part, the regional insurance pools, would be the key to controlling costs. These pools would offer insurance to all at a single price, not discriminating based on pre-existing health conditions. This means that everyone could be covered.

The regional insurance pools would also provide the uninsured and employers the option of buying into a government-run, Medicare-type plan. This is important. The current system of competing private insurers is incredibly inefficient. Insurers make money by trying to make sure that they do not cover people who will get sick. They also make money by trying to avoid paying claims. They also have large costs associated with sales and marketing, plus high salaries paid to top executives and dividends paid to shareholders. As a result, the administrative costs of private insurers are more than 16 percent of what they pay out in claims. By contrast, Medicare's administrative costs are just two percent of what it pays out.

In addition to the savings from a more efficient system, Medicare is also far better able to control costs than private insurers. Because of its size, it can effectively dictate prices to providers on a take-it-or-leave-it basis. (Almost all providers take it.) Cost control is absolutely essential. Current projections imply that average health-care costs for a family of four will exceed $50,000 a year (in 2007 dollars) in two decades. If health-care costs actually follow this projected path, there is no way that most families will be able to afford insurance, and there is no way that the government will be able to provide large enough subsidies to make up the gap. Basically, anyone who is not serious about controlling health-care costs is not serious about providing universal coverage. It's that simple.

Finally, it is also important to note that the Edwards plan would be a great boon for small business. Currently, small businesses (most of whom provide insurance to their workers), must deal with a set of confusing rules on deductibles, co-pays, and caps to determine which policy is best for their workers. They also run the risk that their insurer can jack up their premiums by double-digit amounts, at any time. Under Edwards's plan, small businesses could buy into the Medicare-type system and never worry again about any extraordinary price increases or radical changes in coverage. For small-business owners who would rather than spend their time running their business than dealing with the fine print of insurance policies, this would be a huge gift.

The Edwards plan should only be the beginning of the debate over health care in this election cycle. Other candidates will presumably put forward their own proposals. (Representative Dennis Kucinich has already endorsed a universal Medicare plan.)

While no one expects a finely detailed plan, it is reasonable to ask that the candidates produce some meat on this issue, rather than just a vague commitment to universal health-care coverage. The last time a Democratic president was elected based on such a vague commitment, he produced a hopelessly complex plan that proved to be such a political disaster that it knocked health-care reform off the agenda for a dozen years. We can't afford to see a repeat of this disaster.

Dean Baker is the co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR). He is the author of The Conservative Nanny State: How the Wealthy Use the Government to Stay Rich and Get Richer (www.conservativenannystate.org). He also has a blog, "Beat the Press," where he discusses the media's coverage of economic issues. You can find it at the American Prospect's web site.

-------

Dixie Chicks get last laugh on Bush

Posted by Evan Derkacz at 7:43 AM on February 12, 2007.

5-for-5 on Grammys.

dixie

Share and save this post:
Digg iconDelicious iconReddit iconFark iconYahoo! iconNewsvine! icon

Got a tip for a post?:
Email us | Anonymous form

Get PEEK in your
mailbox!

Ever since the Dixie Chicks' Natalie Maines dissed Bush at a UK performance in 2003 ("we're ashamed the president of the United States is from Texas" VIDEO), they've been shunned by country radio, the chief vehicle for popularity and sales in the music industry.

Bush himself said that "they shouldn't have their feelings hurt because people don't wanna buy their record."

No matter.

At last night's Grammy Awards, the Chicks won Best Album for "Taking the Long Way," which includes "Not Ready to Make Nice" a song about the fallout from the Bush criticism.

It won best song and record of the year.

When the album won best "Country" album of the year as well Maines reportedly said: "A lot of people just turned their TVs off right now."

My only quibble is that they didn't mention Iran.

Digg!

Tagged as: dixie chicks, bush, iraq

Evan Derkacz is an AlterNet editor. He writes and edits PEEK, the blog of blogs.

Nygaard Notes #362

Nygaard Notes
Independent Periodic News and Analysis
Number 362, February 12, 2007

On the Web at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/

******

This Week: The National Memory System

1. “Quote” of the Week
2. E. Howard Hunt and the National Memory System
3. Subverting Democracy, In His Own Words

******


Greetings,

I never tire of reminding people that we can learn a lot from some of the smallest news items, the ones found in the most unlikely of places. This week I discuss the layers of meaning and perspective that was presented in the obituary of a long-time government functionary who passed away a couple of weeks ago. I think you’ll be surprised to see what can be learned from this sort of thing. And, when I say “learned,” I am not talking about what can be learned about the person who died. I’m talking about what can be learned about the cultural and intellectual systems in the United States, as expressed through our ideological institutions. In this case, the media.

Speaking of the smallest news items, I’m feeling the urge to do “A Stroll Through the News With Nygaard.” For those who are new to the Notes, a “Stroll” is where I devote an entire issue of the Notes to a bunch of tiny tidbits of news items, pointing out the lessons and, often, the absurdities that can often be found in the nooks and crannies of the Mainstream Corporate For-Profit Agenda-Setting Bound Media (as I like to call it). These “strolls” are fun, and they also have the salutary effect of allowing me to clear my files of the zillion clippings that seem to accumulate as the weeks go by. I think we’re about due...

Strolling on by, I remain yours truly,

Nygaard

******

1.
“Quote” of the Week

Here’s the headline from an Associated Press report, published in my local daily newspaper on February 8, 2007:

“Guantanamo Prisoners Weren't Beaten, U.S. Says; An Army Investigation into Guards’ Alleged Bragging about Abusing Detainees Found No Evidence it Occurred.”

And here is a patched-together “quote” drawn from the first six paragraphs of this story:

“Col. Richard Bassett, the chief [Army] investigator, recommended no disciplinary action against the Navy guards... who had ... described beating detainees as common practice. ... Bassett interviewed no detainees, said Jose Ruiz, a command spokesman. “He talked to all the parties he felt he needed [to talk to]...”

So, which is more amazing: That these people actually say such things to the media? Or that the media refrains from ridiculing them? Hmmm....

******

2.
E. Howard Hunt and the National Memory System

A man named E. Howard Hunt died on January 23rd. Does the name ring a bell? He is famous (infamous?) for his role in the Watergate burglaries that brought an end to the presidency of Richard Nixon in 1974. Note that I say that this is what he is famous for. It is not, however, the most important thing to know about this man. The London Guardian led off their obituary of Hunt with these words: “The infamous part that the espionage agent E Howard Hunt played in the 1972 Watergate burglary—which eventually brought down President Nixon—earned him 33 months in prison. Yet Hunt, who has died aged 88, spent a career in clandestine activities so nefarious that he was lucky not to have spent much longer behind bars.”

“Lucky?” I don’t think Hunt was “lucky” at all. It’s far more serious than that. Let’s have a look at how he is remembered in the “National Memory System” and the political/intellectual culture it serves.

National Public Radio ran an obituary for Hunt on the 23rd, and it began with these words:

“E. Howard Hunt, one of the key figures who organized the Watergate break in, has died at the age of 88. He was a long time CIA operative. He helped plan both a coup in Guatemala in 1954 and later the Bay of Pigs invasion of Cuba. Howard Hunt served 33 months in prison after he pleaded guilty to conspiracy for his role in the Watergate burglary.”

And that’s the last we hear from NPR about either Guatemala or Cuba, or any of the rest of Hunt’s long career in the CIA. NPR chose instead to devote its entire segment to an interview with reporter Bob Woodward, who “broke the Watergate story in the Washington Post” in 1973, and that’s all they talked about: Watergate. So, we see what’s important—and not important—to NPR.

The New York Times did a little better in their lengthy obituary the next day. They say of Hunt that “His field was political warfare: dirty tricks, sabotage and propaganda.” And, although most of their story was also about Watergate, they did devote one full paragraph to Guatemala. Here it is:

“In 1954, Mr. Hunt helped plan the covert operation that overthrew the elected president of Guatemala, Jacobo Arbenz. ‘'What we wanted to do was to have a terror campaign,’ Mr. Hunt said in a CNN documentary on the cold war, ‘to terrify Arbenz particularly, to terrify his troops.’ Though the operation succeeded, it ushered in 40 years of military repression in Guatemala.”

Two sentences later the Times adds that “Not until 1960 was Mr. Hunt involved in an operation that changed history.”

What Lessons Can Be Learned from Such Obituaries?

Remember that this obituary was being written in the winter of 2007, at a time when the United States is officially engaged in a “War Against Terror (a WAT?!),” and is supposedly trying to “spread democracy” around the world. The conventional thinking has it that this is what the U.S., as a Beacon of Democracy, has always done. Yet when a prominent government official dies, the fact that he was engaged in an official U.S. terror campaign for the purpose of overthrowing a democratically-elected government—and one that in fact “succeeded”—merits a single paragraph in the nation’s newspaper of record. Indeed, it is implied that such behavior did not even “change history.”

The operation that DID “change history,” according to the Times, was the secret campaign, ordered by Presidents Eisenhower and Kennedy, “to alter or abolish the revolutionary government of Fidel Castro in Cuba.” The Times tells us that “Mr. Hunt's assignment was to create a provisional Cuban government that would be ready to take power once the CIA’s cadre of Cuban shock troops invaded the island.” This was the infamous Bay of Pigs operation (Code Name: “Operation Zapata”), which used the same cast of (U.S.) characters as the Guatemala campaign from six years earlier. The Guatemala campaign was codenamed “PB Success,” and Zapata was expected to meet with the same “success.” It did not, of course, with the result that, as the Times put it, the careers of Hunt and the others “who planned and executed the Bay of Pigs debacle in April 1961 were damaged or destroyed, as was the CIA's reputation for derring-do.”

The Oxford English Dictionary defines “derring-do” as “daring action or feats; heroic courage.” Now, if it is true that the CIA’s reputation among the general population in 1960 was for “derring-do,” rather than for terror and subversion of democracy, that tells us quite a lot about our political and intellectual (and media) culture. Does it not?

It also tells us a lot that E. Howard Hunt was tried and convicted—and spent 33 months in federal prison—for burglary, conspiracy and wiretapping aimed at the Democratic National Committee, yet received no prison time, was never charged, in fact received no negative consequences whatsoever, for his well-documented roles in various campaigns of terror and subversion of democracy. The lesson: Violations against the property of powerful people in the United States have consequences, while much more serious violations against the lives (and governments!) of less-powerful people in other countries do not.

Here’s another, related lesson: Terror campaigns that overthrow democracies—and usher in 40 years of unimaginable human suffering—do not “change history.” But an operation that does not “succeed” in overthrowing anybody, but that damages the careers of powerful government officials and/or damages the (bizarre and distorted) reputation of the agency that runs the campaigns that overthrow those democracies? Now, THAT changes “history.”

Now, here’s your Lesson #3: Citizens in the U.S. must not be allowed to know much about covert operations and the casts of characters that carry them out. Why not? Because if we did, we might begin to see patterns in our government’s behavior over time, and might begin to understand a little better what is really involved in constructing and maintaining a Global Empire. The targets of these “covert” operations certainly know what is involved. Indeed, the combination of their knowledge of U.S. behavior and the ignorance of it in our own country goes a long way in explaining the bewilderment revealed in the oft-posed question that came to the fore on September 11, 2001: “Why do they hate us?”

Due to its power to reach and inform millions of us every day, the mass media has the effect of functioning as a doctrinal system. That is, a system that creates and/or maintains a certain ideology while delegitimizing others. A tiny part of our doctrinal system is what I call the “National Memory System”—that is, the part of the mass-communication system that functions to tell the general population what is memorable and what is forgettable in our history. The obituaries of E. Howard Hunt and others can be analyzed to see how the system works.

Why do we care how it works? Well, some important questions come to mind: Who are the E. Howard Hunts of today, the men and women who are carrying out the “dirty tricks, sabotage and propaganda” that violate the values of most of the good people in whose name they are supposedly being carried out? Which journalists are following the covert operatives of today? Which news organizations are publishing the details of empire? These journalistic efforts—or the lack of them—will dictate how today’s events are remembered—or not—in the obituaries of tomorrow. And, more importantly, they affect our ability to understand what is going on and to hold our leaders accountable for their actions today.

“Late in life,” the Times tells us, Mr. Hunt “said he had no regrets, beyond the Bay of Pigs.” Which is partly why the London Guardian calls him “lucky.” But it’s not luck. Our job is to see if we can create a culture where the E. Howard Hunts of the world not only feel regrets for their careers of terror and democracy-destruction, but are brought to justice for them.

******

3.
Subverting Democracy, In His Own Words

Here are the words of E. Howard Hunt, speaking to the Senate committee investigating the Watergate affair in 1973, when he faced a provisional prison sentence of 35 years:

“I am crushed by the failure of my government to protect me and my family as in the past it has always done for its clandestine agents. I cannot escape feeling that the country I have served for my entire life and which directed me to carry out the Watergate entry is punishing me for doing the very things it trained and directed me to do.”

Hmmm... what, exactly, was he “trained and directed” to do? Here are a few quotations from Mr. Hunt himself,

Speaking about “PB Success,” the U.S. campaign to overthrow the democratically-elected government of Guatemala, Mr. Hunt told an interviewer from the National Security Archive in 1999, “I was in charge of the political and the psychological warfare aspects [for this operation].” He went on to say,

“... we [the C.I.A] had these black flights coming in to Opa-Locka airport here in Miami, practically around the clock, bringing in people for training. And we had to establish in Honduras a very powerful radio station of our own, a transmitter that would override the beam of the Guatemalan national radio, so that... as in World War II, where we did the Funkspiel so often—this was an idea borrowed from World War II: you just override the other guy's transmitter and feed false information to the public. So that was done.”

“Sort of a Prisoner of Ours” Ha Ha

“...the co-operation of the Guatemalan clergy was arranged through Cardinal Spellman in New York, and I had taken upon myself to meet with the Cardinal. I had a letter of introduction from a prominent Washington figure, and I didn't tell him, I asked him what assistance he might be able to be in terms of getting co-operation from the Guatemalan clergy. I knew, of course, that in 1948 or thereabouts, the Catholic Church had been very helpful in arranging a subvention to the Christian Democrats in Italy and turning back the communist electoral threat there. So I wasn't at all bashful about approaching Spel, and he was a rather roly-poly placid individual, but a man of great mentality, and he said in effect, ‘You've told me what the problem is—I'll deal with it.’ And that was it. And soon we were writing scripts or leaflets for the Guatemalan clergy, the Catholic clergy, and this information was going out in the pastorals across the country, and in radio broadcasts.”

The NSA interviewer asked Hunt, “What part did the American ambassador, Purefoy, play in this business?” To which Hunt replied: “Well, Purefoy was very, very helpful. He was sort of a prisoner (Laughs) of ours, of CIA and of the Department of State. He owed his ambassadorship to Eisenhower, and he understood that co-operation with us was part of the deal, and so he bent over backward to do everything he could.”

How did Hunt get involved in the Bay of Pigs? Here’s his version:

“So I was yanked back [from another assignment] and told: ‘What we're doing is reassembling the PB Success team’—that is, the Guatemala operational team—‘to take care of Castro, as we did before. ... My role was very similar to what it had been in the Guatemalan project...”

“President Idigros Fuentes of Guatemala was good enough to give our Cuban exiles two training areas in his country, one in the mountains, and then at (Retardo Lejo) we had an unused airstrip that he gave over to us, which we put into first-class condition for our fighter aircraft and our supply aircraft, and we trained Cuban paratroopers there.”

So, just to summarize: In this single interview, Hunt reveals: Complicity by the Catholic Church hierarchy in subversion of democracy; Involvement of a U.S. ambassador in subversion of democracy, and; How a previous subversion (Guatemala) was made use of in an attempt at a later subversion (Cuba). That last revelation illustrates a sort of “domino theory” that is quite different from the one I was taught in high school. That theory said that if one land in a region came under the influence of Communists, then more would follow in a “domino effect.” Nobody told me my own government was expert at the game of (secret) dominoes.

**********

If you have received this issue of Nygaard Notes from a friend, or by accident, or through some other bizarre quirk of inexplicable fate which leaves you with no useful return address, be aware that you can receive your own free subscription by asking for it in an E-mail sent to Nygaard Notes at Or visit the Nygaard Notes website at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/

I would like to continue to provide this service for free. You could help by making a voluntary contribution (anything you can afford, whether $5.00 or $500.00) You can donate online by going to the Nygaard Notes website at http://www.nygaardnotes.org/ Then just get out your credit card and follow the instructions. Of course, you can always just send a good old check through the mail. Make checks payable to “Nygaard Notes” and send to: Nygaard Notes, P.O. Box 14354, Minneapolis, MN 55414. Thank you!

--
Jeff Nygaard
National Writers Union
Twin Cities Local #13 UAW
Nygaard Notes
http://www.nygaardnotes.org

ECOLOGY

ExxonMobil's War on Science

ExxonMobil's War on Science

With an elaborate network of phony think tanks and slick public relations firms, ExxonMobil has become today's Big Tobacco, defrauding the public and waging a war on science.

The Most Important Thing You Can Do To Stop Global Warming

The Most Important Thing You Can Do To Stop Global Warming

Environmentalist Bill McKibben explains that forcing Congress to take action on climate change is the top priority. Fortunately, he has a plan.

Alpha Females

Alpha Females

You know climate concern has gone mainstream when sororities get on board.

Biodiesel: The Fuel That Doesn't Kill Us

Biodiesel: The Fuel That Doesn't Kill Us

Annie Nelson, wife of Willie Nelson, speaks about community-based biodiesel production as a way of restoring dignity to family farmers, the environment, the economy and national security.

Apple Computers: Fun for You, Toxic for the Environment

Apple Computers: Fun for You, Toxic for the Environment

Apple positions itself as the technological haven for the hip, the progressive and the revolutionary. But when it comes to the environment, Apple is quite out of touch.

Global Warming?


Who's Funding Global Warming?

Who's Funding Global Warming?
By Tara Lohan, AlterNet
Find out which banks are part of the problem, and which are part of the solution, in the fight against global climate change. Read more »

The Road Map to Despotism

Published on Monday, February 12, 2007 by truthdig
The Road Map to Despotism
by Chris Hedges

Editor’s note: Despite spending an estimated $80 million, the government was unable to prove that Dr. Sami Al-Arian was a terrorist, yet he remains in prison and his sentence will likely be extended. Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Chris Hedges warns that the abusive imprisonment of this nonviolent Palestinian dissenter does not bode well for the rest of us.

Professor Sami Al-Arian, whose persecution and show trial are parts of a long string of egregious acts of injustice perpetrated by the Bush administration, has been on a hunger strike since Jan. 22 to protest the prolongation of his imprisonment.

Al-Arian’s travels through the halls of American justice, and now the subterranean corridors of the nation’s Stygian prison system, reads like a bad rip-off of Kafka. Al-Arian was acquitted on eight of the 17 counts against him by a Florida jury, which deadlocked on the rest. He agreed to plead guilty to one of the remaining charges four months later in exchange for being released and deported. The judge gave Al-Arian as much prison time as possible under a plea deal—57 months at his sentencing. He was set to be released this April, something that now appears unlikely.

The trial was a stinging rebuke to the Bush administration’s drive to turn the American judicial system into kangaroo courts. Over the six-month trial a parade of 80 witnesses, including 21 from Israel, attempted to brand the Florida professor as a terrorist. The government submitted thousands of documents, phone interceptions and physical surveillance culled from 12 years of investigations. The trial cost taxpayers an estimated $80 million. The 94 charges against Al-Arian and his co-defendants resulted in no convictions. But because Al-Arian has twice refused to testify before a grand jury in Virginia in a case involving a Muslim think tank, he has now been charged with contempt of court. The date of his release could be extended by as much as 18 months.

Al-Arian, who is a diabetic, began a hunger strike in response.

“I believe that freedom and human dignity are more precious than life itself,” he said in a telephone interview from Northern Neck Regional Jail in Warsaw, Va. “In, essence I am taking a principled stand that I am willing to endure whatever it takes to win my freedom.

“I am still OK,” he said. “I have lost 26 pounds by today. It’s definitely not easy, but I am determined to continue. It’s not a decision you make haphazardly or something that you take lightly. In the end, you have to make difficult decisions because of the larger cause. I drink four large cups of water a day, about 12 ounces each.”

Dr. Al-Arian said he will remain on a hunger strike until the government ends its campaign against him and allows him to return to his wife and children.

The case and continued harassment sets a dangerous precedent for American Muslims, who since 9/11 have been monitored, detained and deported in large numbers. But it bodes ill for the rest of us as well. The new legislation suspending habeas corpus and creating the possibility of legally stripping U.S. citizens of their right to a fair and timely trial is a taste of what awaits us all should we enter a period of instability or national crisis. In many ways the assault against Al-Arian is an assault against the judicial system that lies like a barrier between us and despotism.

“Much of the government’s evidence against me were speeches I gave, lectures I presented, articles I wrote, magazines I edited, books I owned, conferences I convened, rallies I attended, interviews I conducted, news I heard and websites no one accessed,” he said. “It was reminiscent of the thought crime of Orwell’s ‘Nineteen Eighty-Four.’ The scary part was not that these were offered into evidence, but that a federal judge admitted them. That’s why I am so proud of the jury, who acted as the free people that they were and saw through Big Brother’s tactics.

“I’ve been to nine prisons in nine months,” he explained. “I spent the first 23 months in Coleman Federal Penitentiary, where the conditions were Guantanamo-plus, that is they were like those of the detainees in Guantanamo Bay ‘plus’ one phone call a month and visits with my family behind glass. I was in a nine-foot-by-eight-foot cell, where I was held under 23-hour lockdown. During the first few months, they wouldn’t even allow me to exercise unless I was strip-searched, which I refused to submit to, so I was inside 24 hours. During the first month, I was allowed only one 15-minute phone call, and for six months after that I was not allowed to make any calls.

“I was shackled and handcuffed every single time I left my cell for any reason,” he said. “When I needed to take my legal papers for meetings with my attorney, the guards would not carry them for me, even though they did for other prisoners. Though I was shackled, they forced me to carry them on my back, as I was bent over. I had to walk like that for half a mile. I should also mention the use of fire alarms in trying to disrupt life. In the Special Housing Unit [SHU], a punitive section of the prison where I was the only pretrial detainee, alarms and emergency sirens would go off 15 to 20 times every single day, at 12 a.m., 2 p.m., any time of the day. It was a deafening noise that would continue for five to 10 minutes. It was clearly deliberate. In the SHU, commissary was almost nonexistent. All they offered was potato chips, whereas in the general compound everything was available. The SHU was designed for disciplinary purposes, not for housing a pretrial detainee.

“Not only did they place me in the SHU, but they imposed additional restrictions on me,” he went on. “For instance, everybody else was granted contact visits, while I had to see my family behind glass. They also insisted on strip-searching me before and after these behind-the-glass visits. In May 2003, my wife drove two hours to see me, but they denied her the visit when I would not submit to a strip search.”

Al-Arian is a Palestinian. The injustice meted out to him in America is writ large in the Middle East. He has no passport, no home, no country. He must live on the charity of others, stateless, as most Palestinians are, and without the rights of the citizens around him. He once thought America would be his home. He was, before this charade, in the process of gaining citizenship. All this is over. In George Bush’s America there is no place for activists or dissidents. And when they finish with those on the margins of our society they will turn, if we let them, on the rest of us.

Discuss This Article

Copyright © 2007 Truthdig, L.L.C.

Repeal the Military Commissions Act and Restore the Most American Human Right

Published on Monday, February 12, 2007 by CommonDreams.org
Repeal the Military Commissions Act and Restore the Most American Human Right
by Thom Hartmann
"The power of the executive to cast a man into prison without formulating any charge known to the law, and particularly to deny him the judgment of his peers, is in the highest degree odious, and the foundation of all totalitarian government whether Nazi or Communist."
-- Winston Churchill

The oldest human right defined in the history of English-speaking civilization is the right to challenge governmental power of arrest and detention through the use of habeas corpus laws. Habeas corpus is roughly Latin for "hold the body," and is used in law to mean that a government must either charge a person with a crime and allow them due process, or let them go free.

Last autumn the House and Senate passed, and the President signed into law The United States Military Commissions Act of 2006, which explicitly strips both aliens and Americans of the right of habeas corpus, the right of recourse to the courts (as provided in the Fifth through Eighth Amendments to the Constitution), and denies appeal through mechanisms of the Geneva Conventions to those designated to lose these rights by the President.

As the most conspicuous part of a series of laws which have fundamentally changed the nature of this nation, moving us from a democratic republic to a state under the rule of a "unitary" President, the Military Commissions Act should be immediately reversed. When a demi-tyrant like Vladimir Putin begins lecturing the United States, as he did just a few days ago, on how our various behaviors over the past five years have "nothing in common with democracy," we should pay attention.

This attack on eight centuries of English law is no small thing. While the Republican's (and 13 Democrats in the Senate) purported intent was to deny Guantanamo Bay Concentration Camp detainees the right to see a civilian judge or jury, it could just as easily extend to you and me. (Already two American citizens have been arbitrarily stripped of their habeas corpus rights by the Bush administration - Jose Padilla and Yasser Hamdi - and there may be others.)

Section 9, Clause 2, of Article I of the United States Constitution says: "The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it."

Alberto Gonzales testified on January 18th before Congress that "there is no express grant of habeas in the Constitution. There is [only] a prohibition against taking it away."

While there are many countries in the world where all power and all rights are reserved to the government, and then doled out to the people by constitutional, legislative, or executive decree, the first three words of our Constitution clearly state who in this country holds all the power and all the rights: "We the People."

Our Constitution does not grant us rights, because "We" already hold all rights. Instead, it defines the boundaries of our government, and identifies what privileges "We the People" will grant to that government.

When Gonzales suggested we have no habeas corpus rights because the Constitution doesn't grant them, his testimony betrayed a breathtaking ignorance of the history and meaning of the United States Constitution. And, because his thinking probably reflects that of his superior, George W. Bush, Gonzales' testimony demonstrates the urgency with which Congress must act to repeal the many laws, signing statements, and executive orders that have been issued by this administration.

But particularly, and first, with regard to habeas corpus.

Abraham Lincoln was the first president (on March 3, 1863) to suspend habeas corpus so he could imprison those he considered a threat until the war was over. Congress invoked this power again during Reconstruction when President Grant requested The Ku Klux Klan Act in 1871 to put down a rebellion in South Carolina. Those are the only two fully legal suspensions of habeas corpus in the history of the United States (and Lincoln's is still being debated).

The United States hasn't suffered a "Rebellion" or an "Invasion" since Lincoln's and Grant's administrations. There are no foreign armies on our soil, seizing our cities. No states or municipalities are seriously talking about secession. Yet the Attorney General says we have no rights to habeas corpus, and the Military Commissions Act now backs him up.

The modern institution of civil and human rights, and particularly the writ of habeas corpus, began in June of 1215 when King John was forced by the feudal lords to sign the Magna Carta at Runnymede. Although that document mostly protected "freemen" - what were then known as feudal lords or barons, and today known as CEOs and millionaires - rather than the average person, it initiated a series of events that echo to this day.

Two of the most critical parts of the Magna Carta were articles 38 and 39, which established the foundation for what is now known as "habeas corpus" laws, as well as the Fourth through Eighth Amendments of our Constitution and hundreds of other federal and state due process provisions.

Articles 38 and 39 of the Magna Carta said:

"38 In future no official shall place a man on trial upon his own unsupported statement, without producing credible witnesses to the truth of it.

"39 No free man shall be seized or imprisoned, or stripped of his rights or possessions, or outlawed or exiled, or deprived of his standing in any other way, nor will we proceed with force against him, or send others to do so, except by the lawful judgment of his equals or by the law of the land."

This was radical stuff, and over the next four hundred years average people increasingly wanted for themselves these same protections from the abuse of the power of government or great wealth. But from 1215 to 1628, outside of the privileges enjoyed by the feudal lords, the average person could be arrested and imprisoned at the whim of the king with no recourse to the courts.

Then, in 1627, King Charles I overstepped, and the people snapped. Charles I threw into jail five knights in a tax disagreement, and the knights sued the King, asserting their habeas corpus right to be free or on bail unless convicted of a crime.

King Charles I, in response, invoked his right to simply imprison anybody he wanted (other than the rich), anytime he wanted, as he said, "per speciale Mandatum Domini Regis."

This is essentially the same argument that George W. Bush makes today for why he has the right to detain both citizens and non-citizens solely on his own say-so: because he's in charge. And it's an argument now supported by the Military Commissions Act.

But just as George's Act is meeting resistance, Charles' decree wasn't well received. The result of his overt assault on the rights of citizens led to a sort of revolt in the British Parliament, producing the 1628 "Petition of Right" law, an early version of our Fourth through Eighth Amendments, which restated Articles 38 and 39 of the Magna Carta and added that "writs of habeas corpus, [are] there to undergo and receive [only] as the court should order." It was later strengthened with the "Habeas Corpus Act of 1640" and a second "Habeas Corpus Act of 1679."

Thus, the right to suspend habeas corpus no longer was held by the King. It was exercised solely by the people's (elected and hereditary) representatives in the Parliament.

The third George to govern the United Kingdom confronted this in 1815 when he came into possession of Napoleon Bonaparte. British laws were so explicit that everybody was entitled to habeas corpus - even people who were not British citizens - that when Napoleon surrendered on the deck of the British flagship Bellerophon after the battle of Waterloo in 1815, the British Parliament had to pass a law ("An Act For The More Effectually Detaining In Custody Napoleon Bonaparte") to suspend habeas corpus so King George III could legally continue to hold him prisoner (and then legally exile him to a British fortification on a distant island).

Now, the Military Commissions Act and Alberto Gonzales say that George W. Bush may similarly detain people or exile them to concentration camps on distant islands. Except these people are not Napoleon Bonaparte. "They" could even be you or me.

The Founders must be turning in their graves. As Alexander Hamilton - arguably the most conservative of the Founders - wrote in Federalist 84:

"The establishment of the writ of habeas corpus ... are perhaps greater securities to liberty and republicanism than any it [the Constitution] contains. ...[T]he practice of arbitrary imprisonments have been, in all ages, the favorite and most formidable instruments of tyranny. The observations of the judicious [British 18th century legal scholar] Blackstone, in reference to the latter, are well worthy of recital:

"'To bereave a man of life,' says he, 'or by violence to confiscate his estate, without accusation or trial, would be so gross and notorious an act of despotism, as must at once convey the alarm of tyranny throughout the whole nation; but confinement of the person, by secretly hurrying him to jail, where his sufferings are unknown or forgotten, is a less public, a less striking, and therefore A MORE DANGEROUS ENGINE of arbitrary government.''' [Capitals all Hamilton's from the original.]

The question, ultimately, is whether our nation will continue to stand for the values upon which it was founded.

Early American conservatives suggested that democracy was so ultimately weak it couldn't withstand the assault of newspaper editors and citizens who spoke out against it, or terrorists from the Islamic Barbary Coast, leading John Adams to pass America's first Military Commissions Act-like laws, the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798. President Thomas Jefferson rebuked those who wanted America ruled by an iron-handed presidency that could - as Adams had - throw people in jail for "crimes" such as speaking political opinion, or without constitutional due process.

"I know, indeed," Jefferson said in his first inaugural address on March 4, 1801, "that some honest men fear that a republican government cannot be strong; that this government is not strong enough.

But, Jefferson said, our nation was "the world's best hope," and because of our strong commitment to rights like habeas corpus, "the strongest government on earth."

The sum of this, Jefferson said, was found in "freedom of person under the protection of the habeas corpus; and trial by juries impartially selected. These principles form the bright constellation which has gone before us, and guided our steps through an age of revolution and reformation.

"The wisdom of our sages and the blood of our heroes have been devoted to their attainment. They should be the creed of our political faith, the text of civil instruction, the touchstone by which to try the services of those we trust; and should we wander from them in moments of error or alarm, let us hasten to retrace our steps and to regain the road which alone leads to peace, liberty, and safety."

When I was working in Russia some years ago, a friend in Kaliningrad told me a perhaps apocryphal story about Nikita Khrushchev, who, following Stalin's death, gave a speech to the Politburo denouncing Stalin's policies of arbitrarily arresting people and throwing them into prisons or mental institutions without the rights of habeas corpus. A few minutes into Khrushchev's diatribe, somebody shouted out, "Why didn't you challenge him then, the way you are now?"

The room fell silent, as Khrushchev angrily swept the audience with his glare. "Who said that?" he asked in a reasoned voice. Silence.

"Who said that?" Khrushchev demanded, leaning forward. Silence.

Pounding his fist on the podium to accent each word, he screamed, "Who - said - that?" Still no answer.

Finally, after a long and strained silence, the elected politicians in the room fearful to even cough, a corner of Khrushchev's mouth lifted into a smile.

"Now you know," he said with a chuckle, "why I did not speak up against Stalin when I sat where you now sit."

The question for our day is who will speak up against Stalinist policies in America? Who will speak against the man who punishes reporters and news organizations by cutting off their access; who punishes politicians by targeting them in their home districts; who punishes truth-tellers in the Executive branch by character assassination that even extends to destroying their spouse's careers? And why is our press doing such a pathetic job that in all probability 95 percent of Americans don't even know that our Attorney General says we have no rights to habeas corpus?

As Alexander Hamilton wrote in Federalist Number 8:

"The violent destruction of life and property incident to war; the continual effort and alarm attendant on a state of continual danger, will compel nations the most attached to liberty, to resort for repose and security to institutions which have a tendency to destroy their civil and political rights. To be more safe, they, at length, become willing to run the risk of being less free."

We must not make the mistake that Jefferson and Hamilton warned us against. We must not remain silent, like Khrushchev's people did. We must speak out.

Contact your U.S. Senators and members of the House of Representatives (the Capitol's phone number is 202 225-3121) and tell them to stop this assault on eight hundred years of legal precedent by repealing the Military Commissions Act and thus restore the most fundamentally American human right of habeas corpus.

Thom Hartmann is a three-time Project Censored Award-winning, New York Times best-selling author of nineteen books and, for the past four years, the host of a nationally syndicated noon-3 PM ET daily progressive talk show which will, starting on February 19th, replace the Al Franken show on Air America Radio radio stations from coast-to-coast and on Sirius Satellite Radio. His website is at www.thomhartmann.com His most recent books are "What Would Jefferson Do? A Return To Democracy" and Screwed: The Undeclared War Against the Middle Class and What We Can Do About It.

Discuss This Article

###

The Peak Oil Crisis: Connecting the Dots

By Tom Whipple
The Falls Church News-Press

Thursday 08 February 2007

In the months after 9/11 there was much discussion about the American government's failure to "connect the dots." Hints and clues that Al Qaida was about to launch airborne suicide attacks inside the US abounded but nobody put the bits and pieces together into a convincing warning.

Such it may be with peak oil. There are trend lines and clues from across the earth pointing to serious troubles just ahead, but once again they are not generally perceived as making a "convincing case," especially when nobody really wants to contemplate the conclusion.

The "dots" of peak oil cluster into four groups. First, there are the depletion vs. new discovery dots. Every active oil field on earth is giving up some share of the 85 million barrels we burn up each day. New wells are constantly being drilled into existing oil fields in an effort to maintain production as the oil from the field is used up.

As fields mature and new wells are not enough to maintain production, output starts to drop. To offset the loss and maintain or increase our 85 million barrels a day, new fields must be opened and start producing. This balance between old fields drying up and new fields starting up is the heart of the peak oil story. When there is not enough production from new fields or other "unconventional" sources of oil substitutes to offset the decline, it is all over - world production has peaked.

For the last couple of years, new production and depletion have been running just about neck and neck, with production from new fields just offsetting the declines in production and cutbacks from geopolitical factors such as insurgencies and other political disputes. Some knowledgeable observers, after noting the pace at which in production is falling particularly from the North Sea and Mexico's Cantarell fields, believe that new production going on stream during 2007 will not be enough to maintain the production level we have seen during the last two years.

These observers note the cost of extracting oil from new, mostly offshore, fields has been increasing rapidly and that many projects have been slipping due to the unavailability of skilled personnel and equipment necessary to bring them on stream as rapidly as planned.

It should be noted that we don't yet have returns in from the giant Saudi oil fields. Saudi production has dropped about 1 million barrels a day in the past year. The Saudis maintain they are simply cutting production due to a glut of oil and falling prices. Many outside observers, however, are suspicious that there may be more to the story. Various techniques of assessing the course of Saudi oil production suggest these giant fields, some of which have been in production for 60 years, are ready to go into rapid decline. If this is happening, the Saudis sure aren't going to tell us.

Just to be safe, the Saudi dot should probably be flashing amber just as the North Sea and Mexican dots are already flashing bright red.

The next cluster of dots are the one's for the world's oil exporters. Some of these countries are fine, upstanding places like Canada, Norway, and the UK that will keep sending us oil until they run out of exportable surpluses. Unfortunately, for the UK this is already the case. Even America's best friend to the north, Canada, only has a few years before its citizens start to question selling of so much of its oil to the US.

Most large oil exporters are monuments to political instability. Iraq and Nigeria are currently in death spirals that could easily lead to serious reductions in their oil exports during the next year or so. The political leadership of Iran and Venezuela at the moment seems to be doing their best to get bombed by somebody or other. At least they are ideologically screwing up their domestic petroleum industries to the point where their ability to export current quantities of oil has a very short half-life.

Then we have the global warming dots: meltings, droughts, famines, hurricanes, and you name it. While the US, at the minute, seems inclined not to do much about this until Wall Street actually goes under water, a critical mass of public opinion seems to be forming. Short of imposing a 50 mph speed limit, and rationing or taxing the dickens out of fossil fuels, there does not seem to be much the US can do about greenhouse emissions in the short run.

Any serious, rapid, governmental action to cut emissions will of course have a serious impact on the last set of dots: the global economy. Here the question is easy. Do economic hard times come before or after peak oil? It should be obvious to everyone by now that if you take away a share of the world's oil and gas consumption, you are going to have some really serious economic problems. You can pick your own word to describe this phenomenon depending on how bad you think it is going to be - Recession? Depression? Collapse? Armageddon?

The key question is whether the economic troubles come before or after oil, for one reason or another, becomes very expensive and scarce. Many observers think there are serious economic troubles just ahead stemming from negative savings in the US, the housing bubble, collapse of Detroit, balance of payments, value of the dollar, or any number of other factors.

Where does this leave us? To anyone who cares to look, the dots are already connected and they spell big, big trouble just ahead. The dots are flashing bright red. The alarm bells are sounding. The klaxons are blaring. But few are noticing. As a nation, we are so engrossed with Wal-Mart's latest sales figures, interest rates, and surging in the streets of Baghdad, that we have failed to notice the cliff just ahead. Someday, the historians will say "on this one, connecting the dots didn't make any difference after all."

-------

Opposition to Unions Overheats

By Al Lewis
The Denver Post

Saturday 10 February 2007

Say the word, "union," and you might as well add "communist," "mobster" and "bureaucracy."

It's a lot like the word "abortion," says Ray Hogler, a management professor at Colorado State University.

"It's all politics, it's all heat, it's all debate, it's all acrimony," said Hogler, who has studied unions for the past 30 years.

On Friday, Democratic Gov. Bill Ritter vetoed a bill that would have lowered a hurdle for unions in Colorado. Ritter said he agreed with House Bill 1072. He just didn't like the way it was forced through the Democratic-controlled legislature.

"It caused ... overheated partisan rhetoric," he said. "A lot of Coloradans turned the volume completely off."

Some say signing this bill would have been like hanging a "closed" sign over the state's economic development office.

"There will be companies that (wouldn't) come here because of this," Aurora's eco-devo diva Wendy Mitchell told me.

Companies are already not coming, said Tom Clark of the Metro Denver Economic Development Corp. "This is not theory," he said. "We've been fielding phone calls from companies who say they are now looking at taking their expansions out of state."

One of the first questions on any relocating or expanding company's checklist is, "Are you a right-to-work state?"

There are 22 such states where workers cannot be forced to pay union dues or agency fees. There are 27 other states that allow unions to negotiate with management for the right to establish all-union shops where everyone pays union dues or agency fees.

Colorado is the only state in the middle. It allows unions to pursue all-union shops after an initial simple-majority vote by employees and a second super-majority vote. HB 1072 would have eliminated that second vote.

"Capital flees risk," said Clark. "And, like it or not, unions are viewed as an uncontrollable risk to capital."

Clark grew up in a union family. When he worked as a schoolteacher in Minnesota in the 1970s, he was president of a local collective bargaining unit. But unions are not what Clark's economic development prospects want to talk about.

"There's a huge surplus of highly trained union autoworkers in Michigan right now," Clark said. "Why aren't the foreign companies that are building auto plants in this country going to Detroit? They're going to Mississippi. That ought to tell you something."

It tells you that multinational companies want cheap labor, said Hogler, the management professor. Even eco-devo folks like Clark pride themselves on the highest-paying jobs they can attract.

"You don't create a good business climate by reducing wages," Hogler said. "We're not Mississippi and we're not Alabama, and I don't think we ought to be trying to compete with them."

Still, fewer than 10 percent of Colorado's workers belong to unions, and most employers like it that way.

Companies often respond to union campaigns with intimidation, said Teamster Ted Textor. Just talking about a union can mean reduced hours, undesirable assignments or termination. HB 1072 wouldn't have changed that.

"It's symbolic, but substantively, it hardly changes anything," said Textor, secretary-treasurer of Local 537. Employers "will probably be firing people and surveilling them more than ever."

Ritter, once a union man himself, says companies such as Qwest and Xcel depend on unions as partners.

"A lot of folks have that mindset that these interests (labor and management) are polarized and will remain that way," he said. "I don't think they have to be."

We live in an age when even our Republican president complains about CEO pay, and our Federal Reserve chairman warns about widening economic inequality. Once stalwart companies are ditching pension plans. Middle-class jobs are disappearing. And health care benefits?

Well, last week Wal-Mart CEO Lee Scott joined Andy Stern, president of the Service Employees International Union, in a campaign called "Better Health Care Together."

"Government alone won't and can't solve this crisis," said Scott. "We have to work together - business, labor, government and our communities."

Imagine that. The Wal-Mart CEO and the union president, in the same room, and it's not a courtroom.

-------

$25 Million Offered in Climate Challenge

By Kevin Sullivan
The Washington Post

Saturday 10 February 2007

Tycoon hopes to spur milestone research.

London - British billionaire entrepreneur Richard Branson, with former vice president Al Gore at his side, offered a $25 million prize Friday to anyone who can come up with a way to blunt global climate change by removing at least a billion tons of carbon dioxide a year from the Earth's atmosphere.

Branson, saying that the "survival of our species" is imperiled by current environmental trends, said the prize was similar to cash inducements that led to some of history's most notable achievements in navigation, exploration and industry. A competition launched in the 17th century, he said, resulted in the creation of a method to accurately estimate longitude.

"I believe in our resourcefulness and in our capacity to invent solutions to the problems we have ourselves created," said Branson, who has pledged to invest $3 billion in profits from his transportation companies, including Virgin Atlantic Airlines and Virgin Trains, to fighting global warming.

"We are now facing a planetary emergency," said Gore, whose documentary film, "An Inconvenient Truth," has helped him become one of the world's leading voices on climate change issues.

The former vice president will serve as a judge in the contest, known as the Virgin Earth Challenge. He said he hoped the contest would spur scientific innovation without distracting from more practical steps people can take to battle global warming, from using energy-efficient light bulbs to pressuring politicians to confront "the crisis of our time."

"It's a challenge to the moral imagination of humankind," Gore said at a packed news conference, which several noted climate scientists and authors attended. Others provided videotaped endorsements or appeared by live video link.

Gore and Branson said that although scientists are working on technologies to capture carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases at power plants and other industrial sources, no one has developed a strategy to remove gases already released into the atmosphere. Those gases are contributing to a dramatic increase in global temperatures that could have catastrophic results in the coming decades, they said.

The winner of the contest must devise a plan to remove greenhouse gases from the atmosphere without creating adverse effects. The first $5 million would be paid upfront, and the remainder of the money would be paid only after the program had worked successfully for 10 years.

"We're nowhere" on technologies to reduce the amount of carbon dioxide in the air, Gore said. But he said he hoped innovators might be spurred not simply by the cash prize but also by a passion for working on what he called "a moral issue."

Other judges in the competition are James E. Hansen, director of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies; British environmentalists and authors James Lovelock and Crispin Tickell; and Australian conservationist and author Tim Flannery.

Gore, Branson and the other panelists referred repeatedly to a study released last week by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, made up of hundreds of scientists from 113 countries, that concluded that human activity is warming the planet at a potentially disastrous and irreversible rate.

Gore dismissed critics who say the potential effects of climate change have been exaggerated. He said the overwhelming scientific evidence is that "the planet has a fever." He likened the situation to parents told by a doctor that their child needs medical care; those parents shouldn't listen to "some science fiction expert who tells you it isn't real - you listen to the doctor."

Gore said he believed public interest in climate change was growing in the United States. But asked whether he thought Americans were ready for a presidential campaign in which global warming was the central issue, he said, "We're not there, yet."

Branson and Gore said they hoped to ask the governments of the United States, Britain and other countries to add to the prize money, or even match the $25 million pledged by Branson. "I don't have much influence with this administration," Gore joked.

Gore, who barely lost the 2000 presidential election to President Bush, has experienced a resurgence in popularity among many Democrats and is still viewed as a potential dark horse candidate in 2008. On Friday, he said he would not categorically rule out another run for public office, but he said he "can't foresee" any circumstances that would lead him to enter the race.

"I'm involved in a different kind of campaign," Gore said.

Details on the $25 million competition can be found at http://www.virginearth.com.

-------